1/68
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Why do we work in teams?
to make better decisions 2. to share the workload
scores when working in teams
team score should be better than the average (value of diversity), but often at least one persons score is better than the group
group decision making process losses
power differences, indirect vs. direct communication styles, groupthink, satisficing, individuals trying to impress by taking risks, desire for closure
impact of power differences (formal and informal)
suppresses conflict
group think impact
desire for group harmony makes us agree quickly
satisficing
taking the first idea that sounds “good” enough
desire for closure impact
leads to voting vs. consensus where the whole group doesn’t agree
the problem with individual expertise in groups
it is a mystery to a group who their biggest expert is on a particular decision, and expert is usually someone else on the next decision (unknown and unreliable)
solution for individual expertise in groups
don’t hold back your expertise, but when an expert on a decision appears, put team success ahead of winning your POV
how do decision and task process losses occur
happen because of weak team norms, differing member motivation, and time pressure
what decision process loss examples
satisficing, groupthink, risky choices to impress
task process loss examples
crowding the task, miscommunication, handoffs, failing to rehearse, diverted attention
conditions for disaster in groups
individual factors, group composition, group dynamics, organizational factors
when does conflict potentially help
conflict during the creative phase of a project is positive
interdependence definition
the extent of and form in which parts of a system must rely on other parts for inputs to perform their tasks effectively
inputs
can be any combination of work product or information
decision interdependence
when decisions vary on path dependence, meaning the choices you have now depend on the choice you have made before
task interdependence
tasks may involve cases where what happens before (alongside or after) drives your ability to do your job effectively.
What do higher levels of interdependence require
higher levels of trust
coupling
the amount of slack, buffer, or give between two items in a system
complexity impact on coupling
the more complex the system, the looser the elements should be coupled to avoid accidents
what does loose project coupling entail
high personal independence, less learning from others, information sharing at junctions, less efficient, prone to duplication, has lots of slack, highly flexible and resilient, seen as “inefficient”
what does tight coupling entail
high team interdependence, more real-time learning, information sharing within a task, most efficient for “linear” systems, designed to reduce slack, not flexible, vulnerable to disruption, prone to critique only after an accident
what drives optimal coupling
the work drives the optimal coupling (EX: nuclear plants are highly complex and are tightly coupled, whereas universities are pretty complex, but loosely coupled)
accidents in complex, tightly coupled systems
these accidents tend to be rare, but also large and notable because demands are inconsistent. Because of complexity, they are best decentralized, but because of tight coupling, they are centralized (Fukushima)
how a team charter helps
specifies norms and roles in an organized way that still leaves room for flexibility
norms
habits that are common to the group that are connected to what they believe are effective functioning
norms examples
communication, performance expectations and goals, meeting structure, conflict management norms, appropriate disagreement
role
specific expertise areas and functional areas that members of the team fulfill and can be accountable for
role examples
subjects, tasks, subteams, project management, after action review coordination
reality of team conflict effectiveness
while it is often seen as a key input into team performance, there is little evidence that it helps
task conflict
conflict about how to do something, leads to higher decision making (moon), but can also lead to lower team effectiveness
process conflict
conflict about the system for a project, leads to lower “grades”
relationship conflict
conflict involving interpersonal affective reactions, leads to lower everything
stauts conflict
conflict over in-team roles and power levels, leads to lower everything
when does conflict hurt performance?
in individualistic culture, the negative relationship is weaker (conflict is not as detrimental), for larger team, negative relationship is strong, for coupled production and service work, negative relationship is strong
team effectivenes depends on what 3 things
learning, output, cohesion
learning in team effectiveness
was there improvement over multiple trials?
output in team effectiveness
did the team’s work meet the objective criteria of its stakeholders?
cohesion in team effectiveness
do the team members want to stay together as a team
effective teams
rate high on learning, output, and cohesion
how do the conflict types relate
the way we deal with task conflicts and process conflicts can lead to relationship and status conflicts, the way we work together to resolve conflicts can lead to greater trust and performance
what happens when task conflict is ignored
the harder the problems are to fix and the bigger the impact, leading to relationship and status conflict
trust definition
a willingness of a party to be vulnerable to the actions of another party based on the expectation that the other will perform a particular action important to the trustor, irrespective of the ability to monitor or control the other party
trust details
requires risk taking, can stop conflict from progressing, is specific (can differ from person to person and task to task)
why do we decide to trust another person?
based on individual differences, identity/similarity, and trust judgements
individual differences for trusting
everyone has a different trust propensity/ self orientation
identity/similarity in trust decisions
we are more likely to trust someone we perceive is similar to us
trust judgements in trust decisions
do I trust that they can do the job? are they reliable?
what three factors do we decide trust on
credibility, security, and reliability
importance of trust judgements based on identity
the information we select is filtered through a prism of identity, meaning if I feel a common group membership with you, I will mostly pick confirming information (benefit of the doubt)
social identity theory
we categorize ourselves based on the groups we believe we are a part of (in groups) and group that are different from us (outgroups)
cognitive trust
based on judgements of the others’ credibility or economic incentives (contracts/loans), less risk taken
affective (emotional trust)
based on deeper judgement of shared motives and security, starts as cognitive trust first, and as effective trust grows, we are more willing to take greater risks in relationships, builds from multiple interactions that create solidarity
trust in a group
you don’t want to be the team member who can’t be trusted and you also don’t want to be the team member who doesn’t trust their team
team output and individual output
most teams’ output doesn’t equal the sum of individuals’ ability or output, which is particularly true when outcomes are driven by the least effective teammate, as coupling increases, good processes lead to performance
how does conflict impact team efficiency?
conflict erodes trust, and the process was already as fast as its slowest member (process gets worse when coordination disappears), teams grows less efficient even if members exert more effort
cooperative rewards
lead to increased info sharing and greater cooperation
when should cooperative rewards be used
when teammates have to depend on each other to succeed
competitive rewards
lead to negative perceptions of others’ motives and lower views of team performance, group would should not have competitive reward systems for internal performance, important to match the reward system to the interdependence used
How are norms learned
through interactions between people that result in solving a common problem (environmental presents similar problems to people), and people more quickly recognize the problem and develop a shorter way of recognizing and responding
importance of language in norms
language drives the development of norms and culture, so that overtime, a set of assumptions (jargon) develops as mutual understanding between people is reached
how do groups learn and improve over time
through communication efficiency as shared understandings emerge
difficulty of switching team
different groups use different strategies to solve the same problem (noticeable learning challenge because once assumptions are learned, they filter our subsequent actions, and are hard to unlearn)
timing of learning norms when switching teams
it takes time to learn new culture and norms, but it rarely takes all the time it first took because existing task expertise reduces the disruption
what happens when you put enough people together and then give the process enough time
assumptions about solving common problems translates to cultural institutions and team norms, which arise to efficiently solve problems and institutionalize the strategies people use to succeed.
how does learning help beat task process losses
specialization/repetition, positive behavioral norms mean pride in team drives greater effort, work design/process engineering (designing processes to reduce steps and to put right people in right place), transactive memory
what is transactive memory
learning and remembering the cues and signals that team members send about task work and who does what step of the task at what time, leads to efficient task communication
what drives team effectiveness
shared norms/culture because effectiveness builds from norms and processes that create a shared identity, which creates a positive feedback loop as this leads to improved processes (particularly true as interdependence increases)