1/203
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Define state (weber's definition)
a human community that successfully claims the monopoly of the legitimate use of physical force within given territory
Hobbes on state emergence
argued in leviathan that life without some sort of gov would be dominated by fear and violence, describing life in a stateless society as 'solitary , poor, nasty, brutish and short'
Hobbes quote
a stateless society is 'solitary , poor, nasty, brutish and short'
locke on state emergence
tates emerged to protect natural rights such as property
Rousseau on state
political authority developed and emerged through 'general will'
zomia eg
mountain pops purposely avoided centralised state control
why could states emerge?
economic equality and surplus production which required systems of extraction of control
marx n engles on agriculture surplus
enabled existed of private property, creating classes and diff institutions to protect elite interests
how did early mesopotamia emerge?
around grain storage, taxation and irrigaton management
ancient egypty…
centralised administratiin to coordinate nile irrigations and labour systems
ancient chinas hydraulic management…
strengethned political centralisation and elite control
warring states period china
created intense military competition between rival chinese states - surplus production along yellow river caused taxable wealth which allowed rulers to support large armies and pops
Define legitimacy (weber)
refers to the belief that authority is rightful and deserves obedience
how does british monarchy retain legitimacy
through tradition and historical continuty, supporting webers idea that repeated cultural acceptance
what happened to post war germany
through tradition and historical continuty, supporting webers idea that repeated cultural acceptance
hobbes on individuals and state
individuals obey states because security is preferable to chaos, implying legitimacy can derive from the states ability to prevent disorder
how do rulers maintain authority according to machieavelli?
rulers maintain authority through strength and political control rather than moral approval
what is arab spring?
set of protests in middle eastern countries advocating for democracy
how do states have legitimacy according to gramci?
states maintain legitimacy by shaping cultural values so authority appears natural and beneficial than imposed
Define state (weber)
the institution claiming a monopoly on the legitimate use of force within a territory
hobbes on life without state?
the institution claiming a monopoly on the legitimate use of force within a territory
locke argues states are..
necessary to protect natural rights such as property and liberty
somalia after 1991 eg
after collapse of the regime, the absence of a strong central state led to a civil war and fragmented authority
pinochets chile
state used disappearances, torture and censorship to suppress political opposition after the military coup
stop n search
black britons more targeted under policing powers
what is the state according to marx?
state reflects the interests of the ruling class because political institutions are shaped by underlying economic power
miners strike 1984-5
thatchers gov deployed mass policing and legal restrictions against striking miners
colonial india under raj
colonial state extracted resources while suppressing nationalist resistance through likes like ROWLATT ACTS
weber on state
all states rely on coercion but legitimacy determines whether authority Is accepted as rightful
michael mann on state
state has both 'despotic' and 'infastructural' dimensions, meaning states can dominate and also prodvide welfare for society
according to michael mann the state has..
both 'despotic' and 'infastructural' dimensions
'despotic' and 'infastructural' dimensions meaning…
states can dominate and also provide welfare for society
south african apartheid
the state did provide some functional benefits such as mainatined infrastructure or economic organisation but racial segregation and censorship persisted
foucault on state
modern states maintain power not simply through violence but through surveillance and discipline
althusser on state
argues institutions such as schools, media and religion function as 'ideological state apparatuses
althussers main idea
'ideological state apparatuses’
'ideological state apparatuses’ meaning..
produce obedience and dominant social values
chinese social credit system
digital monitoring and behavioural scoring to regulate citizens behavior
libya after gaddafi
collapse of central authority led to militia conflict and fragmented governance
kropotkin rejected
HOBBESIAN assumptions about human nature
why did kropotkin reject hobbesian assumptions about human nature
cooperation was evolutionarily beneficial
revolutionary catalonia
during spanish civil war, anarchist groups collectivised factories, farms and transport systems without traditional central state
somali clan politics after 1991
collapse of somali state produced warlordism and fragmented clan authority rather than self governance
yugoslavia after 1990 collapse
weakening of federal authority led to ethnic conflict and competing nationalist militias
haiti in 2020s
weak state authority enabled gang control over large areas of society
tsarist russia
state violently suppressed labour movement and heavy censorship
cointelpro usa
FBI surveilled and disrupted civil rights and socialist organisation during cold war
russian oligarchs after 1990s collapse
allowed private elites to dominate key industries and political influence
nozick on states
even minimal societies naturally generate protective associations which evolve into larger states
gramsci emphasises
legitimacy and consent as limits on state domination
rojava northern syria
kurdish led autonomous regions use decentralised coucils, local democracy and communcal defence structures
hobbes on state authority
states possess supreme authority bc only sovereign power can prevent disorder and enforce obedience
medieval europe
authority fragmented between monarchs, lord and church
english civil war
conflict between parliament + crown on who possessed sovereign authority
catholic church medieval europe
popes can excommunicate ruler and influence political legitimacy across kingdoms
east india company
controlled territory, taxation anf military forces in india during 18th century
classical liberals like locke arged
individuals should process legal rights and protecion from arbitrary authority
modern liberals like rawls arg
accepted limited reditribution but still prioritsed fair opportunity over complete economic equality
us civil rights act 1964
end of segregation for black americans
marx on capatalist societies
create class domination bc economic inequality allows for the bourgeoisie to control labour and politics
trade unions
socialist and lab movements historically fought for minimum wages, workplace rights and collective bargaining
soviet economic stagnation
central planning in USSR produced inefficiency, shortages and weak innovation
SCHUMPETER arged
modern democracy functions less thru rational public and more thru elite competition for votes shaped by propaganda and mass persuasion
plato criticised..
democracy for allowing rule by uninformed masses rather than knowledgeable elites
weimar germany
democratic instability and economic crisis contribute to extremist electoral success during the 1930
roussau on authority
legitimate authority must reflect the 'general will' of the people
citizens united v fec 2010
ruling expanded corporate political spending in US elections
linz on authoritarian regimes
autho regimes survive thru coercion and limited political pluralism
eqypt post 2013
the general removed president thru military intervention and later consolidated autho rule
bueno de mesquita
selectorate theory shows how leaders survive by rewarding key elites than broader pops
russian oligarchs networks
regime depends on loyal business elites connected to state resources and energy industries
wagner group rebellions
exposed tensions between russias military and elite structures and internal elite conflict
SCHMITT on gov
claimed states sometimes require exceptional powers during criss bc legal contrictions legal restrictions may prevent effective action
us patriot act
expanded surveilance and security powers after 9/11
freedom of info act 2005
more freedom for gov to look at private info on citizens
2008 crisis bank that was saved by gov
UK GOV - spent billions rescuing banks such as lloyds banking group
lock + montesquieu on separation of powers
liberty requires separation of powers so no instit becomes politically dominant
non state actors are
lobbying, protest and media scrutiny
us debt ceiling crisis
repeated stand offs between congress and president threatened economic stability
turkey after 2016 coup attempt
expanded pres power while purging oppo figures and civil servants
hong kong protests 2019-20
bejing imposed law to weaken protest movements
chernobyl
soviet secrecy delayed accurate reporting
tocqueville on tyranny of maj
democratic societies risk social conformity because majs possess both political and cultural dominance
john mill on tyranny of maj
warned public opinion itself can become oppressive if dissenting minorities are silenced
jim crow laws usa
southern state govs used democratic majs to enforce racial segregation
california proposition 8 2008
aj vote temporarily banned same sex marriage in california
james madison on tyranny of maj
arged factions are inevitable to democracy meaning instits should prevent any majs from dominating completely
brown v board of education 1954
ruled segregaion unconstitutional
kirchheimer on turnout
argued parties became 'catch all parties' seeking broad electoral appeal
dalton on low turnot
partisan dealignment weakened long term voter attachment to parties
third way poltiics
tony blair + clinton accepted market oriented economic policies while moderating trad left wing positions
peter mair on turnout and parties
parties become detached from society and integrated into state itself
bernard mann on turnout + parties
democracies shifted from 'party democracy' to 'audience democracy' where voters repond more to personalites and media performance
mp expenses scandal 2009
public anger over parliamentary expenses damaged trust in mainstream parties
obama 2008 campaign
utilised digital campeigning to connect to young voters
intersectionality crenshaw meaning
describes how overlapping identities produce distinct forms of discrimination and exclusion
intersectionality developed from
black feminist theory
degraffenreid v general motors 1976
black women argued GMS hiring policies discriminated specifically against them, court rejected bc it treated race and gender seperately
black women in politics
faced exclusion both within feminist movements and civil rights movements
labour racism
minority MPs within major parties reported exclusion despite formal commitments to diversity