1/36
Digital Consumer Rights & Digital Citizenship, Week 12
What are the 4 steps of consumer rights (roadmap)?
rights: do they work in practice, digital inclusion
control: who controls what we paid for (ownership/repair)
fairness: are the market rules fair? platform/market power
voice: who shapes the rules? digital citizenship, collective
What did the traditional consumer protection revolve around?
physical products, clear jurisdiction + direct relationship with seller (doesn’t work with digital markets)
What are the new risks for consumers in digital markets?
intangible products: unclear ownership, product can be removed without notice
cross-border transactions: jurisdiction + language barriers (purchases overseas)
information asymmetry: legal terms cannot be fully read/understood (would take 200h a year to read all the terms)
platform power: one access point controls consumer options
benefit: easier comparison of products, product becomes more competitive
disadvantages: unfair search systems
What are some of the 11 needs of the UN guideline for consumer protection? Name 3!
protection from health & safety hazards; for vulnerable consumers and e-commerce users
promote sustainable consumption patterns + consumer economic interests (honest pricing, protections against fraud)
access to adequate informed choices (full info is not needed → information overload)
What is the problem with the UN guidelines for consumer protection?
not legally binding (=soft law), it’s just a guideline
needs vs. rights: needs imply voluntary action vs. rights demand action + accountability
framing protection as needs can weaken consumer rights in the marketplace
What are the core principles of the OECD E-commerce recommendation? (Don’t learn in detail)
actions pre-purchase process: transparent protection, fair advertising/business practices, online disclosures
payment process: confirmation + payment process
after purchase process: resolution
whole life cycle of the process: privacy + security, education + digital competency
What are the digital consumer rights in Korea? (THEORY)
clear disclosure of seller info
7-day cancellation right without valid reasons
dispute (Streit schlichten) mediation (korea consumer agency)
measures in specific domains (dark patterns regulations -> very strict)
What do these rights look like in practice? (PRACTICE)
digital consumer rights are not equally exercised (information is not enough anymore), enforcement challenges:
multiple jurisdictions & foreign platforms (e.g. Amazon)
automated support (redirected to other areas (click 7 for this service -> while calling), AI chatbots) -> limited human assistance
time-costly complaint processes -> abandonement
english-dominant legal & refund procedures
What are some common barriers to digital inclusion?
complex interfaces + procedures, language barriers, device & connectivity, expensive devices/services
What are some concrete laws for digital inclusion in Korea?
Act on prohibition of discrimination against people with disabilites: ensures digital service (websites/apps/kiosks) accessibility → enlarged font/screen size
KWCAG 2.2: how to make 1. a reality (technical guideline for accessible interfaces)
Digital Inclusion act: inclusion plans, impact assessment (ensuring inclusion!)
Digital government strategy (not a law but an approach): digital-first public services, can exclude people!
What are some implications for disadvantaged people (elderly/disabled people) when it comes to digital access?
cognitive & physical limitations: having a hard time using mobile-only services
high fraud exposure: phishing/SMS scams
dependence on caregivers for digital access: less autonomy
banks/government services are increasingly on apps only -> there is a risk of service denial for older consumers
What do international frameworks suggest that platforms should do/implement?
ensure inclusive design from the start
clear, multilingual information
offer alternatives for essential services (offline human support channels instead of just digital support)
do accessibility disclosre + audits (see if guidelines are followed)
strengthen redress rights (wiedergutmachen)
meeting accessibility standards should be the default
Whose job is accountability for digital inclusion?
government: ensures digital access in essential services + enforces compliance + penalties (Strafen)
platforms: meet accessibility standards (default), provide multilingual/offline human assistance
civil society organizations: monitor/report violations of digital inclusion, support consumer advocacy + legal action
What is a digital good?
intangible items accessed through digital platforms (streaming/download music/movies, e-books, in-game items) -> consumers buy access more and more (not ownership)
Do consumers think they usually buy owen
Consumers think they are buying ownership/permanent access, but usually they only have temporary licenses and conditional access (can be removed under the service terms of the platform -> resale, lending + inheritance is limited by license terms)
ownership gets weaker and weaker nowadays (purchases cannot be modified/preserved)
What is de-listing?
removed music from streaming libraries (rights expiration), shut-down video game servers make purchased items/games disappear -> often limited refunds
How do platforms try to control the ownership more?
DRM: you can’t move downloaded songs to other computers
automatic updates can remove bought items
mandatory cloud connection to access goods
platform lock-in (ecosystem dependency)
What are the legal rules for ownership/access to digital goods in Korea?
ownership + access: you usually get contractual access to purchased goods rather than ownership
withdrawal/refunds: 7-day withdrawal right (often only for content that hasn’t been used/provided yet)
fairness/remedies: unfair terms can be challenged
Compared to Korea, what legal rules exist for the EU and the U.S.? (NOT THAT IMPORTANT)
EU: digital content must work as promised (incl. updates), otherwise trader must fix it/price reduction/contract termination possible
USA: first-sale-doctrine (consumers cant sell bought products to other people), platforms are often favored over consumers in court cases
What are some policy proposals from “stop destroying videogames” advocates?
transparent disclosure of what’s being sold
right to back-up/transfer content (controversial bc people can transfer content to other people unlimited)
minimum availability period for digital purchases (conflicts with cost-benefit analysis from producer)
compensation/refund when content is removed (however, sometimes producers/platform owners maybe dont have the licenses to continue the server)
What are some implications for inequality in this regard (videogames and refunds)?
price-sensitive users struggle with raised switching costs (platform lock-in), places with worse enforcement get worse refunds
Who controls what consumers paid for (digital content vs. physical products)? What is the shared logic behind it?
Digital content (ownership): control through license terms, DRM, de-listing, service shutdown
Physical products (repair): control through software locks, parts restrictions, cloud dependency
shared logic: access depends on provider terms + technical design, consumers with fewer alternatives are hit the hardest
What is the right to repair? Why is it important?
legislative movement that consumers + independent repair businesses have the necessary resources to fix their own products (access to spare parts, repair info + tools, advocated legal permission to circumvent repair-related software restrictions)
important today: more connected devices (more failures), software expiration (artificial obsolescence), repairs blocked by software locks
What is planned obsolescence?
designing a product to have a shorter useful life, forcing consumers to purchase replacements sooner than necessary (e.g. through software updates making performance worse)
What are some problems and challenges with repairability?
DRM & software locks
warranty void stickers (if you break the seal your warranty will be gone)
repair monopolies & high costs (Samsung repair is so expensive but sometimes it’s the only option as it’s the only place that will repair your specific piece)
lack of interoperability
What are some actions for repairability that are already being taken?
grassroot repair ecosystem (unofficial)
open-source repair manuals (e.g. on reddit people upload user-made manuals for repair → how to fix the screen yourself)
advocacy coalitions
What are arguments FOR repair?
consumer & economic justice
manufacturer-authorized repairs are expensive
low-income consumers are forced to replace repairable devices, limiting access to essential technology
environmental sustainability
e-waste, producing new electronics consumes a lot of resources and contains toxic materials that pollute land + water when improperly disposed of
repairability is necessary for circular economy (Kreislaufwirtschaft)
What are arguments AGAINST repair?
consumer repairs can be done incorrectly (only authorized technicians can guarantee the use of parts and procedures is safe + good)-> safety hazards -> manufactuer could be liable
open acess to software + internal mechanisms can make devices more vulnerable to hacking, open access to parts + designs could make people steal trade secrets
Compare the legal + regulatory landscape for repairability in EU, Korea and US/Canada!
EU Right to Repair: repair duty for listed products, spare parts, information access
US/Canada: differs from state to state
Korea: Circular Economy Transition Act (not a right but an obligation to make efforts)
What is the definition of digital marketplaces?
multi-sided platforms where platforms operators govern consumer-seller interactions
What do dominant platform act as?
market gatekeepers (decide entry + exit)
search arbiters (authority, decides product visibility)
data holders: prefers those with more profitable data
private regulators: platform policies with limited oversight/accountability
What are some access barriers in digital markets?
payment system exclusion
device ecosystem lock-in
identity verification problems
participation gap for low-income and older adults
regional market segmentation (unavailable in your country -> content inequality)
delayed product rollouts by market size (USA and Europe as first markets rather than Asia)
How is platform fairness enforced now and how should it be enforced?
Today: act after the harm (ex-post) -> unfair contract terms, self-preferencing (the own products are pushed more on the platform e.g. Amazon than othes)
Missing: rules set in advance (ex-ante) -> no dedicated platform law (like EU Digital Markets Act)
What does citizenship encompass?
status of full membership in a community with equal rights (civil + social) + duties (social responsibility, community engagement)
What is digital citizenship?
capacity to shape, not just use, digital systems -> competent + positive engagement and active participation in digital technologies and communities
How has the role of the consumer evolved in the digital marketplace?
from passive user (not questioning social media algorithm, only information receiver)
to economic actor (filing complaints, rights-holder in transactions)
to civic participant (voice in platform governance + policy)
How can citizens participate in digital governance?
critical engagement: questioning platform rules + policies, seeking transparency
collective participation: civic tech platforms, public consultations on digital policy
accountability & solidarity: reporting harms via formal channels, support for frameworks that strengthen citizen voice