Contracts 1 Benchmark Quizzes

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/40

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

41 Terms

1
New cards

A man purchased an antique 1956 sports car, and was restoring it himself. It needed a great deal of mechanical work. The man's friend came by one day while the man was working on the car. The man was trying to loosen a bolt on the engine when something broke. The man looked at the car in dismay and said to his friend, "I paid $10,000 for this car, but | don't think I will ever be able to get it to run properly." Then he laughed and said, "I am so thirsty, I would trade this car to you for the can of soda you are drinking." The friend laughed too and said, "It's a deal." The friend handed the man the can of soda, and the man took a drink from the soda. The man then said, "I was joking, of course." The friend insists that the parties have a contract for the purchase and sale of the sports car in return for the can of soda. Is the friend correct?

(a) yes, because the friend formed a unilateral contract when she gave the man the soda

(b) yes, because the friend formed a bilateral contract when she said "its a deal"

( c) no, because a reasonable person would understand that the man was joking

(d) No, because the subjective intent of the offeror controls whether an offer has been made

(C) No, because a reasonable person would understand that the man was joking.

<p>(C) No, because a reasonable person would understand that the man was joking.</p>
2
New cards

A miner owns a silver mine. It is uncertain how much silver is contained in the mine, but the miner honestly thinks there could be as much as $60 million in silver. The miner borrows $500,000 from an investor to purchase equipment necessary to mine the silver. In a detailed and signed writing, the miner promises to pay the investor $20 million in return for his investment once the silver has been mined and sold. Is the $500,000 investment consideration for the future promise of $20 million?

(A)Yes, because the investor's risk in losing the investment justifies receiving a greater reward

(B)Yes, but the court should limit the return by determining the fair market return that an investment in a speculative silver mine should yield

(C)No, because the disparity between the $500,000 investment and the $20 million payment renders the consideration nominal

(A)Yes, because the investor's risk in losing the investment justifies receiving a greater reward

<p>(A)Yes, because the investor's risk in losing the investment justifies receiving a greater reward </p>
3
New cards

A hotel is building a luxury hotel where the plans include an elaborate outdoor garden. The hotel engaged in a long negotiation with a landscaper to design and construct the garden according to a detailed list of written specitications by a certain date. In return for designing and constructing the garden, the hotel will pay the landscaper $500,000. The specifications list 100 different varieties of flowers to be planted. One of the 100 different varieties of flowers was for roses, however, the entry did not specify what color the roses should be. The number of rose bushes to be included occupies roughly the same amount of space as the other types of flowers. The hotel and landscaper sign the written agreement. Betore construction begins, the hotel repudiates the contract. The landscaper brings a breach of contract claim. At trial, the hotel asserts as a defense that no contract ever formed because of the lack of certainty as to the color of the roses.

Which of the following is the most likely result?

(A)The hotel wins, because to be enforceable, a contract must provide explicit detail on every duty.

(B)The hotel wins, because the missing color term means that a court could not determine whether there was a breach.

(C)The landscaper wins, because uncertainty as to incidental matters is unlikely to be fatal to the formation of the contract.

(D)The landscaper wins, because color should always be left to the discretion of the designer.

(C)The landscaper wins, because uncertainty as to incidental matters is unlikely to be fatal to the formation of the contract.

<p>(C)The landscaper wins, because uncertainty as to incidental matters is unlikely to be fatal to the formation of the contract.</p>
4
New cards

An owner wants to build his dream house according to a set of plans designed in a particular architectural style called mid-century modern. The design of the house was considered to be a work of art in and of itself. While interviewing builders, the owner expresses how important it is that the construction be perfect. The owner enters into a contract with a builder to construct the house. Under the terms of the contract, the builder has ten months to complete the house, and would be paid progress payments while the structure was being built. The final payment of $100,000 would only be paid upon a condition that "the owner is honestly satisfied with the artistic merit of the construction of the completed building." The builder completed the house in nine months making sure that he followed the architectural plans. The owner inspected the work and expressed honest dissatisfaction with the artistic merit of the construction of the completed building. The owner demanded that certain parts of the house be redone or the builder would not be paid the final installment. The builder brought in experts in mid-century modern design who stated that the house substantially conformed to the style; however, the owner still insisted that certain work be redone. The builder refuses to redo the work and sues for breach of contract.

Has the owner breached the contract with the builder by refusing to remit the final payment?

(A)Yes, because the builder completed the building within the ten-month time period

(B)Yes, because the satisfaction condition should be waived since the owner was presumptively unreasonable

(C)No, because the builder is bound by the owner's good faith opinion

(D)No, because the builder did not follow the architectural specifications

(C)No, because the builder is bound by the owner's good faith opinion

<p>(C)No, because the builder is bound by the owner's good faith opinion</p>
5
New cards

A client enters into a signed and written agreement with a lawyer in which the lawyer promises to represent the client in a divorce proceeding in return for the client's promise to make one payment of $3,000 to be due when the divorce is granted. The agreement-drafted by the lawyer-provides that the lawyer will make all of necessary court appearances, file all necessary paperwork, and otherwise do all of the legal work necessary until the court grants the divorce. The $3,000 is the lawyer's normal rate for the average divorce. The lawyer, however, miscalculated how much time it would take for this particular divorce. The fair market value of the legal services that the lawyer provided was $20,000. When the court grants the divorce, the client presents the lawyer with a check for $3,000

Will the lawyer be successful if he refuses the $3,000 check as full payment and instead sues the client for the fair market value of $20,000?

(A)No, because there was a fully negotiated express contract between the lawyer and the client

(B)Yes, because it would he rendered be inequitable for the lawyer to receive less than the full value of the services

(C)No, unless the lawyer provides sufficient proof that his services would be valued at $20,000

(D)Yes, because there is gross disparity in the consideration

(A)No, because there was a fully negotiated express contract between the lawyer and the client

<p>(A)No, because there was a fully negotiated express contract between the lawyer and the client</p>
6
New cards

A high-end furniture maker uses a particular type of wood called "curly maple" to make its furniture. To make sure that it has a sufficient supply of curly maple wood, the furniture maker enters into a contract with a lumber company. The contract provides that the furniture maker will purchase and the lumber company will sell all of the curly maple that the lumber company produces for five years at a specific price. For the first two years, the lumber company produces 100,000 board feet of curly maple a year, which the furniture company purchases. For the third year, the lumber company thinks that it can produce up to 200,000 board feet of curly maple.

Which the following best describes the rights and duties of the parties?

(A)The lumber company is not required to sell any of its curly maple wood to the furniture maker if there are large variations in the quantity that it produces.

(B)The lumber company must sell at least 100,000 board feet of curly maple wood to the furniture maker and may sell anything in excess to another buyer.

(C)The lumber furniture company must sell its curly maple wood exclusively to the furniture maker and the maker must purchase curly maple exclusively from lumber company.

(D) The furniture maker is not obligated to purchase a quantity that is unreasonably disproportionate from the previous output of 100,000 board feet.

(D) The furniture maker is not obligated to purchase a quantity that is unreasonably disproportionate from the previous output of 100,000 board feet.

<p>(D) The furniture maker is not obligated to purchase a quantity that is unreasonably disproportionate from the previous output of 100,000 board feet.</p>
7
New cards

An uncle wants to make a binding promise to give his niece a gift of his $100,000 grandfather clock when she turns 30 in two years. The uncle discusses the matter with the niece and they agree to make the promise look as it the niece has purchased the clock. The uncle provides the niece with a signed writing that states, "In consideration of $10 to be paid by my niece, I promise that when my niece reaches her thirtieth birthday I will convey to her my grandfather clock." Later, the uncle decides not to convey the grandfather clock to the niece.

If the niece sues for breach of contract, what is the likely result?

(A)The uncle will win, because the consideration promised by the niece was the pretense of a bargain.

(B)The uncle will win, because his subsequent refusal to perform makes his original promise illusory.

(C)The niece will win, because the promise is evidenced by a bargained-for exchange.

(D)The niece will win, because courts generally will not inquire into the adequacy of consideration.

(A)The uncle will win, because the consideration promised by the niece was the pretense of a bargain.

<p>(A)The uncle will win, because the consideration promised by the niece was the pretense of a bargain.</p>
8
New cards

Over the last thirty years, a farmer and a distributor have entered into many contracts for the sale of the farmer's crops to the distributor. Typically, the contract price was explicitly stated in the written agreement and had been whatever the market price was for the particular crop on the date of contract formation. This year, the farmer and the distributor entered into a written contract for the sale of 1,000 bushels of corn; however, the written agreement did not contain a price. Additionally, the agreement did not include the time for delivery.

Assume that the parties had a dispute and one of the parties attempted the missing terms. Which of the following statements is most accurate to avoid enforcement because of as to whether the court would imply the missing terms?

(A)The court would imply both a reasonable time for delivery and a reasonable price.

(B)The court would imply a reasonable time for delivery but would not imply a reasonable price.

(C)The court would not imply a reasonable time for delivery and would not imply a reasonable price.

(D)The court would not imply a reasonable time for delivery but would imply a reasonable price.

(A)The court would imply both a reasonable time for delivery and a reasonable price.

<p>(A)The court would imply both a reasonable time for delivery and a reasonable price.</p>
9
New cards

A seller owns two bicycles-an old bicycle worth about $75 and a new bicycle worth $200. The seller wants to sell the old bike and keep the new bike. On a public street, the seller is seated on the new bike, to which he has attached a sign, "My bicycle for sale, $75." Walking on the street, a buyer approaches the seller, who says, "As the sign says, my bicycle is for sale; $75 takes it." The buyer believes that the seller is offering for sale the very bicycle on which the seller sits. The buyer takes $75 trom his pocket and says, "I'll take it." The buyer hands the seller the $75 and says, "So, would you give it over to me please? I'll ride it away now." The seller responds, "Oh, no. I was referring not to this bicycle but to an older bicycle I have sitting in my garage."

The parties have contracted for the sale of:

(A)the old bike sitting in the seller's garage.

(B)the new bike on which the seller is seated.

(C)no bicycle, because there was not a meeting of the minds between the two parties.

(D)no bicycle, because $75 would be considered too little money for a bicycle worth $200.

(B)the new bike on which the seller is seated.

<p>(B)the new bike on which the seller is seated.</p>
10
New cards

A farmer decides to retire from farming. An employee who had worked for the farmer for ten years, is interested in purchasing the farmer's tractor. The tractor is valued at $26,000, which is about the same amount as the employee earned in one year. The farmer intends to give the employee a bonus for the past year. After some discussion between the two parties, the farmer provides the employee with a signed writing that states, "In consideration of his long time employment, I promise to give my tractor to the employee. the farmer, however, later refuses to transfer title of the tractor to the employee.

If the employee attempts to sue for breach of contract, which of the following is the most likely result?

(A)The farmer wins, because there was no consideration for the bonus.

(B)The farmer wins, because the fair market value of the tractor is greater than the reasonable bonus for an employee.

(C)The employee wins, because courts do not inquire into the adequacy of consideration.

(A)The farmer wins, because there was no consideration for the bonus.

<p>(A)The farmer wins, because there was no consideration for the bonus.</p>
11
New cards

A major league baseball team ran advertisements in the local media in order to increase ticket sales. The promotion stated, "Anyone who attends Saturday's baseball game wearing our team's jersey gets one free hot dog."

Is the team's advertisement for a free hot dog an offer?

(A)No, because advertisements are generally not considered offers

(B)No, because the advertisement does not identify an offeree

(C)Yes, because the advertisement invites acceptance by a promise

(D)Yes, because the advertisement invites acceptance by performance

(D)Yes, because the advertisement invites acceptance by performance

<p>(D)Yes, because the advertisement invites acceptance by performance</p>
12
New cards

On March 1, a homeowner contacts a swimming pool installer and expresses interest in having him install a swimming pool in her backyard. On March 3, the installer responds with a signed written offer to build the pool. In the offer the installer specifies price, timetable, and all other relevant details. As for scheduling, the offer provides that the installer will begin work on April 1 and complete it by April 15. He writes, "I have only those 15 days in which to install your pool, and I can only install one pool at a time. I am full with commitments before and after that period. You have one week in which to respond." On March 4, the homeowner learns from her neighbor that her neighbor and the installer have formed a contract for the installation of a swimming pool on the neighbor's property. The installer is to begin the neighbor's job on April 1 and finish by April 15. Immediately on that same day, March 4, the homeowner sends a signed email to the installer, stating, "I accept your March 3 offer." In response the installer advises the homeowner that his offer is no longer open-that he has committed April 1-April 15 to building another party's swimming pool. The homeowner maintains that the installer is in breach of contract-that he made her an offer on March 3, gave her one week in which to accept, and that within one week she accepted.

Has the installer breached a contract with the homeowner?

(A)Yes, because the homeowner accepted the offer before the installer attempted to revoke it

(B)Yes, because any revocation has to be heard directly from the offeror to be effective

(C)No, because the homeowner lost her power to accept the installer's offer on March 4 when the neighbor spoke with the homeowner

(D)No, because the power of acceptance of an offer typically terminates at the end of a conversation

(C)No, because the homeowner lost her power to accept the installer's offer on March 4 when the neighbor spoke with the homeowner

<p>(C)No, because the homeowner lost her power to accept the installer's offer on March 4 when the neighbor spoke with the homeowner</p>
13
New cards

A nephew inherited a large collection of antique jewelry from his aunt. The nephew wished to sell most of the collection. A jewelry dealer who was familiar with the collection asked if the nephew would sell the entire collection to him. On November 5, the nephew sent the dealer a signed letter stating, "I offer to sell you portions of my aunt's collection of antique jewelry as listed below for $300,000 to be paid by certified check at closing. This offer terminates if your acceptance is not received by November 15." The nephew's letter then listed the items the nephew wanted to include in the sale and the time and place of closing. The dealer received the nephew's letter on November 10. On November 11, the dealer telephoned the nephew and said, "I would like to keep your offer of November 5 open, but I want to inquire whether it was possible to include one or two items that are not listed in your letter. I am willing to pay an additional price." The nephew declined but stated that he hoped the dealer would still accept the nephew's offer. On November 15, the dealer mailed a signed letter that stated, "I accept your November 5 offer to sell the Jewelry listed for $300,000 according to the terms and conditions of the offer." On November 20, the nephew received the dealer’s November 15 letter.

Which of the following most accurately reflects the relationship of the parties on November 20?

(A)The dealer's letter of November 15 formed a contract since acceptance is effective on dispatch.

(B)The dealer's letter of November 15 could not form a contract because the terms of the nephew's

November 5 offer were not certain and definite.

(C)The dealer's letter of November 15 failed to form a contract because the dealer lost the power of

acceptance when the dealer made a counteroffer during the November 11 telephone call.

(D)The dealer's letter of November 15 can be reasonably construed to be an offer to purchase the collection of jewelry listed in the nephew's November 5 letter, and the nephew had the power to accept that offer but failed to do so.

(D)The dealer's letter of November 15 can be reasonably construed to be an offer to purchase the collection of jewelry listed in the nephew's November 5 letter, and the nephew had the power to accept that offer but failed to do so.

<p>(D)The dealer's letter of November 15 can be reasonably construed to be an offer to purchase the collection of jewelry listed in the nephew's November 5 letter, and the nephew had the power to accept that offer but failed to do so.</p>
14
New cards

A cleaning company ran advertisements in the local media stating, "We will clean any space that is 2,000 square feet or less for $250 no matter how dirty it is. Call now to accept this offer." The advertisement provided contact information for the cleaning company. An office building owner's property has several floors and each floor measured exactly 2,000 square feet. The property owner called the cleaning company phone number but got voicemail. The property owner left the following message, "I accept your offer. If you can start cleaning tonight by 9:00pm and finish by tomorrow morning at 7:00am, I will pay you $300 per floor to clean each of the floors in my building." The property owner provided the necessary details such as the building address and combination needed to unlock the doors. The property owner then ended the voicemail saying, "You need not call back. Just show up and start working. I will pay." The cleaning company received the voicemail and went to the property owner's building that evening before 9:00pm, unlocked the doors, and started cleaning the first floor. The property owner, who was working late, saw the cleaning company and said, "Stop. I changed my mind. I don't want you to clean my building" The cleaning company stopped working and later brought a breach of contract suit against the property owner.

Who will prevail in the lawsuit?

(A)The cleaning company, because the property owner accepted the cleaning company's offer by leaving a voicemail

(B)The cleaning company, because the property owner's offer provides for acceptance by performance

(C)the property owner, because the cleaning company never called back to accept the property owner's offer

(D)The property owner, because the property owner revoked before the cleaning company promised to clean the building

(B)The cleaning company, because the property owner's offer provides for acceptance by performance

<p>(B)The cleaning company, because the property owner's offer provides for acceptance by performance</p>
15
New cards

A hiring manager for a restaurant hires a part time server during shifts when the restaurant anticipates it will have increased business. For the past two years this has happened 35 times. Each time the manager calls the server, he either speaks to him or leaves as a voicemail saying something similar to the following: "We could use you on Saturday night from 5:00 to midnight. If you want to work, show up betore 5:00, work the shift, and we will pay you $6.00 an hour plus a proportionate share of tips that night." The server, when he is able, arrives at the restaurant and either starts working or stops by the manager's office to say he is reporting for work. On February 12, the manager calls and leaves a message for the server on his voicemail making the same offer for Valentine's Day. The server never calls the manager back. The server shows up on Valentine's Day and works from 5:00 to midnight. The manager has the night off so does not see the server at work. A few days later the server calls the manager to ask when he can pick up his pay and share of the tips. Usually, the manager pays the server a few days later after they have calculated his share of the tips. The manager says "Oh, I never heard back from you after I left my message, so I called another server who worked that night. We didn't really need you as a result, so l am not paying." The server did see the other server working that night but thought nothing of it as she sometimes works there on other occasions when he was also working. If the server sues for his hourly fees and proportionate share of tips, is a court likely to find that a contract has been formed?

(A)Yes, the manager made a unilateral offer and the server effectively accepted by rendering the required performance

(B)Yes, the manager made an offer and due to their course of dealing, silence operates as acceptance.

(C)No, the server's acceptance is nullified since the offeree must notify the offeror of acceptance even if earlier silence is effective.

(D)No, since the manager was not present to reject the proffered services on Valentine's Day, the server's silence does not operate as acceptance.

(A)Yes, the manager made a unilateral offer and the server effectively accepted by rendering the required performance

<p>(A)Yes, the manager made a unilateral offer and the server effectively accepted by rendering the required performance</p>
16
New cards

A professor is teaching in France for the current academic year. His house back in the U.S. is vacant. While he is away, he thinks it is a good time to have his house repainted. He emails a painter that has done work around the neighborhood. The email states: "I promise to pay you when I return from France $5,000 if you paint the exterior of my house at 123 Main Street." The professor provides all the relevant information to the painter about the specific paint type, color, and finish for the job. The painter paints the house over the next few days. Since she knows the professor will not be back for a few weeks she decides to wait until the professor returns to seek payment. The professor's neighbor emails a picture of the painted house to the professor with the message: "I saw the neighborhood painter here. The new paint looks great!" The professor sends an email to the painter after receiving the neighbor's message that states: "I changed my mind. Forget about painting the house." Is a court likely to require the professor to pay the painter the $5,000?

(A)Yes, once a requested performance is completed the contractual price is always due whether or not the professor ever receives notice of performance.

(B)Yes, notwithstanding the fact that the painter never notified the professor of her acceptance, the professor learned of the performance by the painter before attempting to revoke the offer.

(C)No, the professor revoked the offer prior to the painter's communicating acceptance.

(D)No, the painter did not exercise reasonable diligence in professor.

(B)Yes, notwithstanding the fact that the painter never notified the professor of her acceptance, the professor learned of the performance by the painter before attempting to revoke the offer.

<p>(B)Yes, notwithstanding the fact that the painter never notified the professor of her acceptance, the professor learned of the performance by the painter before attempting to revoke the offer.</p>
17
New cards

A builder is in the business of constructing modest homes. An owner owns a piece of property on which he wants to build a house. At the request of the owner, the builder prepares an offer to build a house on the property in return for $100,000. The offer provides all of the key specifications needed to build the house. In reviewing the offer, the owner says to the builder, "I would like to keep your offer under advisement. Would you consider making the following modifications for the same price?" The owner then added dozens of changes to the specifications. The builder realized that the owner would be difficult to work with and that the builder might lose money on this deal. After the owner added yet another proposed modification, the builder reached across the table, took the copy of his original offer from the owner, and tore it up in front of the owner. The builder said, "I don't think I can do this." The owner replied, " accept your offer." Which of the following best expresses the legal relationship between the parties?

A)The owner's request for changes to the specification was a counteroffer that destroyed the owner's power of acceptance as to the builder's offer.

(B)The builder's statement of uncertainty and ripping up of the offer was, in effect, a revocation of the builder's offer.

(C) The owner formed a contract with the builder according to the terms of the builder's original offer.

(D) The owner formed a contract with the builder that incorporates the owner's proposed terms.

(B)The builder's statement of uncertainty and ripping up of the offer was, in effect, a revocation of the builder's offer.

<p>(B)The builder's statement of uncertainty and ripping up of the offer was, in effect, a revocation of the builder's offer.</p>
18
New cards

A landscaper sent a letter to a tree nursery on August 1 stating, "I need to purchase 100 evergreen trees. Are you able to deliver this many trees and how much would it cost?" The landscaper included details about the specific type of evergreen tree and the size required. The landscaper also signed the letter. The nursery replied to the landscaper with a signed letter dated August 5 that stated, "we can provide you with 100 evergreen trees for immediate delivery according to your specifications for the price of $500, which is $5 per tree. This price is good for six months." The landscaper received the letter on August 10. Which of the following is the best description of the legal effect of the nursery's letter?

(A)The nursery's letter is an offer, but only if the landscaper accepts it within six months.

(B)The nursery did not make an offer because the term concerning the six-month period is over the three-month limit under the UCC's Merchant's Firm Offer provision.

(C)The nursery only gave a price quotation, which is not an offer

(D) The nursery made an offer on August 10.

(D) The nursery made an offer on August 10.

<p>(D) The nursery made an offer on August 10.</p>
19
New cards

On May 31, a seller sends a written and signed offer in the mail to sell a property that the seller owns to a buyer for $100,000. The offer contains all of the relevant details needed for a sale of property. The buyer receives the ofter on June 1. On the same day, the buyer mails to the seller a written and signed acceptance of the seller's otter. On June 2, the buyer changes his mind and sends a second signed letter by overnight mail to the seller rejecting the offer. On June 3, the seller receives the buyer's rejection letter. On June 4, the seller receives the buyer's acceptance letter.

Which of the following is the most accurate statement of the legal rights of the parties?

(A)No contract formed, because the seller received the rejection before the acceptance.

(B)No contract formed, because the buyer's power of acceptance was terminated by the subsequent rejection.

(C) A contract formed on June 1.

(D) A contract formed on June 4 since rejections are not effective until there is confirmation.

(C) A contract formed on June 1.

<p>(C) A contract formed on June 1.</p>
20
New cards

A customer orders an espresso machine on a retailer’s website. Above the “Place Order” button the page states: “This purchase is subject to our Terms of Sale, which will be included with your order.” The machine arrives with a printed copy of the Terms of Sale and a notice that she may return the machine within 30 days for a full refund if she does not agree to them. One term requires any lawsuit against the retailer to be filed in Delaware. She does not read the terms and keeps the machine. Eight months later, she sues the retailer in Tennessee. Is she bound by the Delaware term?

(A)

Yes. She had notice of the terms, was told how to reject them, and manifested her assent by keeping the machine past 30 days.


(B)

Yes. A buyer is bound by any terms a seller includes with a product.


(C)

No. She never signed, clicked, or otherwise affirmatively agreed to the terms, so she did not manifest assent.


(D)

No. A term the buyer has not read is not part of the contract.


(A)

Yes. She had notice of the terms, was told how to reject them, and manifested her assent by keeping the machine past 30 days.

Rationale: A standard-form term binds a party who had reasonable notice of it and manifested assent to it. Notice: the website said before she ordered that terms would follow, the terms arrived with the machine, and the notice told her how to reject them. Manifestation of assent: she was told that keeping the machine past 30 days meant she agreed, and she kept it. Answer A is correct. Answer B drops the notice requirement; terms placed in a box with no advance warning and no way to reject them do not bind the buyer. Answer C is incorrect because assent need not be a signature or a click; conduct the buyer has been told will count as agreement, here keeping the product past the return period, is a manifestation of assent. Answer D is incorrect because a buyer who has the terms in hand and a way to reject them is bound whether or not she reads them.

21
New cards

A contractor and a homeowner agree orally that the contractor will build a swimming pool on homeowner’s land for $90,000. The homeowner also inquires how much it would cost to construct a cabana behind the pool, and a cement walkway leading from the pool to the cabana. The contractor says it will cost an additional $15,000. The homeowner decides not to build the cabana and walkway. The parties draft a contract that is exhaustively detailed, complete with a merger clause, for the construction of the swimming pool. Right after the parties sign the agreement, the homeowner says, "I changed my mind. I would like you to build the cabana and walkway; I'll pay the $15,000." The contractor agrees to do the additional work for $15,000. The contractor builds the swimming pool, whereupon the homeowner pays him $90,000. The homeowner then asks the contractor to build the cabana and walkway. The contractor refuses, and the homeowner sues the contractor for breach of contract. At trial, the homeowner wants to testify to the parties' oral agreement concerning the cabana and walkway. The contractor objects, citing the parol evidence rule.

How should the court rule on the issue of whether the homeowner can testify about the oral agreement?

(A)

Allow the testimony on the basis that it is a collateral contract with a separate consideration.


(B)

Allow the testimony only if the homeowner plans to testify that the contractor defrauded her.


(C)

Allow the testimony because it relates to events subsequent to the signing of the pool contract.


(D)

The court should not allow the testimony.


(C)

Allow the testimony because it relates to events subsequent to the signing of the pool contract.


Rationale:

Issue: This problem tests one of the exceptions to the parol evidence rule: subsequent contracts.

Rule: The parol evidence rule provides that when the parties to a contract have expressed their agreement in a writing that they intend to be a total integration of their agreement, then evidence of prior or contemporaneous agreements that supplement or contradict the writing is inadmissible. If the writing is only a partial integration of the agreement, then the writing cannot be contradicted but can be supplemented by evidence of consistent additional terms.

Analysis: The parol evidence rule concerns evidence of prior or contemporaneous agreements. Here, the oral agreement to build the walkway and cabana occurred after the written agreement to build the pool had been signed. Since the oral agreement was not prior or contemporaneous with the written agreement, the parol evidence rule does not apply. Choice C is correct.

Choice A suggests an exception to the parol evidence rule (a collateral contract for a separate consideration) that would apply if these parties had agreed on the cabana before adopting their writing. Since the parol evidence rule does not apply to exclude subsequent terms, there is no need to invoke the exception to the rule. Although it is true that the walkway/cabana agreement is a separate contract with a separate consideration, the answer choice is not the best rationale for the admission of the evidence.

Choice B suggests another exception—,testimony of fraud—that would apply if the parol evidence were at issue. However, the parol evidence rule is not applicable here since the oral agreement was a subsequent agreement. In addition, the answer states that the homeowner should be allowed to testify only if she was introducing evidence of fraud. That is clearly not the case.

Choice D has the wrong result for the reasons already stated.


22
New cards

A marketing consultant signs an agreement with a company that reads: “Consultant shall receive ten percent of the sales price for each unit of the product sold during the term of this Agreement.” At the end of the term the Company pays the consultant ten percent of its profit on each unit after deducting its costs. The consultant sues for ten percent of the price each unit sold for. The Company offers testimony from its negotiator that both sides used the phrase “sales price” during negotiations to mean the Company’s profit on each unit after costs. Which of the following is correct?

(A)

If the court follows the plain-meaning approach, it admits the negotiator’s testimony and lets the jury decide what “sales price” means, because the parties disagree about it.


(B)

If the court follows the plain-meaning approach, it decides as a matter of law that “sales price” is unambiguous and does not consider the negotiator’s testimony.


(C)

If the court follows the contextualist approach, the jury decides whether “sales price” is ambiguous.


(D)

If the court follows the contextualist approach, it construes “sales price” against the consultant, because the consultant’s reading gives it the larger payment.


(B)

If the court follows the plain-meaning approach, it decides as a matter of law that “sales price” is unambiguous and does not consider the negotiator’s testimony.

Rationale: Under the plain-meaning approach, whether a contract term is ambiguous is a question of law the court decides from the writing itself, read as a whole. A term is not ambiguous because the parties disagree about it; it is ambiguous only if its words are reasonably susceptible to more than one meaning. “Sales price” has one ordinary meaning, the price a unit sold for, and the agreement says that, not “profit” or “sales price less costs.” The term is unambiguous, so the court interprets it as a matter of law, does not consider extrinsic evidence of a different meaning, and the meaning of the term does not go to the jury. Answer B is correct.

Answer A is incorrect because a disagreement between the parties does not make a term ambiguous, and a plain-meaning court does not look outside the writing to find an ambiguity. Answer C is incorrect because under the contextualist approach the court considers the extrinsic evidence, but whether the term is ambiguous remains a question of law for the court; the jury receives the term only if the court first finds it ambiguous. Answer D is incorrect for two reasons. A court does not construe a term against a party simply because that party benefits from it; construction against the drafter is a last resort used only after a term is found ambiguous and the other sources of meaning fail. Further, nothing in the facts indicates the consultant drafted the agreement.

23
New cards

A person enters into a contract with a dog breeder to purchase a watchdog for $1,000. When the breeder delivers a bulldog to perform the contract, the person objects claiming a Doberman was indicated by “watchdog.” The court concludes after examining the contract that it is a fully integrated agreement. The court also finds the term ‘watchdog’ ambiguous. Will the person be able to introduce evidence that at the time of contracting they discussed a Doberman, not a bulldog, is a "watchdog?"

(A)

No, the parol evidence rule prohibits introduction of evidence of the contemporaneous or prior agreement because the court found their contract to be fully integrated.


(B)

No, the agreement about breed of dog is not a collateral agreement and therefore an exception to the parol evidence rule is not available.


(C)

Yes, the evidence would be introduced to resolve the ambiguous term “watchdog.”


(D)

Yes, contracts for the sale of a dog are covered by the Uniform Commercial Code and it does not include a parol evidence rule.


(C)

Yes, the evidence would be introduced to resolve the ambiguous term “watchdog.”

Rationale:

The parol evidence rule excludes all prior or contemporaneous evidence that would contradict or supplement the totally integrated agreement. As the court finds their contract to be fully integrated the rule could be applicable unless an exception exists. Answer A correctly summarizes the rule but does not take account of exceptions and is therefore incorrect. The collateral agreement exception allows introduction of evidence of a separate, collateral, agreement entered into contemporaneously with the integrated contract. There does not appear to be a separate agreement in addition to the one concerning the purchase of the dog. Answer B is incorrect. The Uniform Commercial Code does contain a parol evidence rule that is generally similar to that under the common law. Answer D is incorrect. Answer C correctly states that the evidence would be introduced to resolve the ambiguous term “watchdog.”


24
New cards

A seller sells fan blades. The buyer manufactures fans at two different factories in the same industrial area in the city. For years, the buyer has purchased fan blades from the seller for the fans he manufactures. Each of the buyer's signed purchase orders and each of the seller's signed sales confirmations names the place of delivery as "the buyer's factory" without specifying which location. The seller's truck drivers have always made delivery to the buyer's first factory, and the buyer has accepted every delivery without objection. On January 2, by signed writing, the buyer and the seller form a single contract under which the seller is to make twelve deliveries of 10,000 fan blades each, one such delivery on the fifteenth day of each month January to December. On January 10, the seller hires a new truck driver.

On January 15, with 10,000 fan blades loaded on her truck, the driver reads the seller's delivery order which, as always, calls for delivery at "the buyer's factory." She delivers the fan blades to the buyer's second factory. The buyer accepts and pays for the delivery. The driver also makes deliveries to that same factory on the fifteenth days of February, March, and April. The buyer has found it more convenient that the blades be delivered to the second factory location, and instructs her employees not to accept deliveries at the other location. On May 15, the driver is absent from work. One of the seller's other truck drivers loads his truck with 10,000 fan blades destined for the buyer’s factory, reads the delivery order, and sets out.

In order that the other driver conform to the contract between the buyer and the seller, where should he deliver the blades?

(A)

The second factory because contract modifications under the UCC need no additional consideration


(B)

The first factory because an ambiguity must always be construed against the drafter


(C)

The second factory because course of performance overrides course of dealing


(D)

The first factory because it had been the seller’s custom to make deliveries there under previous contracts


(C)

The second factory because course of performance overrides course of dealing


Rationale:

Issue: The problem tests on the rules surrounding contract interpretation under the UCC Article 2 when the express language is ambiguous.

Rule: UCC § 1-303 provides that the parties’ course of performance, course of dealing, and usage of trade may be used to give meaning to the terms of the contract. The phrases "usage of trade," "course of dealing," and "course of performance" concern the interpretation of contractual terms. "Usage of trade" refers to those meanings commonly understood within a given industry. With respect to a term that appears in any given contract, “course of dealing” refers to meanings on which two parties have agreed, implicitly, through their behavior in relation to contracts they have formed in the past. “Course of performance" refers to meanings on which two parties have agreed, implicitly, through their behavior in relation to a single contract that calls for multiple occasions of performance. The express terms of an agreement and any applicable course of performance, course of dealing, or usage of trade must be construed whenever reasonable as consistent with each other. If such a construction is unreasonable: (1) express terms prevail over course of performance, course of dealing, and usage of trade; (2) course of performance prevails over course of dealing and usage of trade; and (3) course of dealing prevails over usage of trade.

Analysis: For all contracts these parties formed prior to the January 2 contract, the seller's drivers have delivered fan blades to the first factory. The buyer accepted them without objection, and paid the relevant charges. Hence, between these parties, the “course of dealing” calls for delivery to the first factory.

In January, these parties formed a single contract that called for multiple (monthly) deliveries of fan blades. The seller (through their new driver) made the first four deliveries to the second factory. The buyer knew of this change in the traditional delivery location and accepted the delivery at the second factory location. Hence, with respect to this contract, the “course of performance” requires delivery at the second factory.

Under UCC § 1-303 if for any contract, there is conflict among usage of trade, course of dealing, and course of performance, the UCC provides that course of performance supersedes course of dealing, and that course of dealing supersedes usage of trade. Here, between the seller and the buyer, course of dealing calls for deliveries at the first factory, and course of performance requires deliveries at the second factory. An interpretation using course of performance "prevails" over an interpretation using course of dealing. Therefore, Choice C is correct.

Choice A is misleading in that it suggests that there was a contract modification in which consideration played a role. The January 2 contract was not a modification of an existing contract. It was a new contract that had an ambiguity in it. Nor was there any modification of the January 2 contract when the seller delivered. Therefore, Choice A is incorrect.

Choice B refers a common law interpretation rule called “interpretation against the drafter.” This is a poor answer choice for a couple of reasons. First, the rule in the answer is overstated as being absolute. A more accurate statement of the rule would be that courts may interpret ambiguous terms most strongly against the party who caused the ambiguity to exist. However, interpretation against the drafter is a “last resort” tool of interpretation that is only used when other tools of interpretation fail. Second, the UCC provides a method to resolve the ambiguity without this rule. It is true that the buyer put “the buyer’s Factory” on the purchase order and thus introduced the ambiguity; therefore, one might argue that the seller could deliver the products to either location. However, the UCC provides explicit interpretation rules under UCC § 1-303 to resolve the ambiguity. For these reasons, Choice B is not the best answer.

Choice D speaks to the the seller’s customary performance in previous contracts. Since the custom related to previous contracts, this interpretation relies on course of dealing as a tool for interpreting the intent of the parties. However, as noted above, course of performance prevails over course of dealing. Therefore, Choice D is also incorrect.


25
New cards

A state highway commission entered a contract with a road construction company in which the company would build a highway in six months in return for a $25 million payment from the state. The written contract was 91 pages long, with a highly detailed description of reciprocal rights and duties. The contract included a clause that read: "Entire Agreement: This writing embodies the parties' complete and final agreement on its subject matter." Before signing the agreement, the parties orally agreed that if the company finished the project one month early, the state would pay the company a bonus of $1.5 million. Both parties signed the agreement, but the writing was not modified to include the bonus term.

The company completed its work one month ahead of schedule and submitted to the state a demand for the $25 million fee plus the $1.5 million bonus. The state paid the $25 million fee but refused to pay a bonus, on the ground that the contract did not provide for it, the company sued the state for breach of contract. At trial the company tried to introduce testimony of the oral agreement.

If the court refused to admit the company’s evidence of the oral agreement, what did the court most likely conclude with respect to the parties' contract?

(A)

Their writing constituted a total integration.


(B)

Their writing constituted only a partial integration.


(C)

The bonus agreement contradicted the terms of their writing.


(D)

The bonus agreement was "collateral" to the agreement set forth in the writing.


(A)

Their writing constituted a total integration.

Rationale:


Issue: This problem tests on the parol evidence rule and requires students to identify the level of integration given a certain set of facts.

Rule: With regard to the parol evidence rule, a given contractual writing might constitute a (1) "total integration," (2) a "partial integration," or (3) no integration at all. Each designation has implications for the rule's operation as to what type of evidence (of prior or contemporaneous agreements outside of the writing) is allowed to be introduced. A total integration excludes all such evidence that supplements or contradicts the writing. However, a partial integration allows supplemental evidence of consistent additional terms and only excludes evidence that contradicts the writing. If there is no integration, then evidence that either supplements or contradicts is allowed to be introduced. There are many exceptions to the parol evidence rule that are not relevant here.

Analysis: In order to exclude the evidence, the court most likely found that the writing was totally integrated. The writing has indicia of a totally integrated agreement; the contract is lengthy (91 pages), exhaustively detailed, and contains a merger clause, which is a provision by which the writing characterizes itself as a complete and final expression of the parties' agreement. The writing is silent on whether the company is entitled to a bonus; therefore, the oral agreement to give the company a bonus for finishing a month early is a consistent additional term. The call of the question assumes the evidence is going to be excluded. The only way that a consistent additional term is excluded is if there is a total integration. If the court found that the writing was partially integrated, then the court would have to allow supplementary evidence to be introduced. However, the court refused to admit the evidence, so it could not have found the writing to be partially integrated. Choice A the correct answer.

Since the writing is totally integrated, Choice B is incorrect.

Choice C is not the best answer. It is possible that a court might find that the bonus agreement conflicts with the main payment term since both have to do with compensation. However, such an analysis is ambiguous at best—a matter of interpretation by a judge. A more precise analysis of conflicting term would be where a particular term has two different values. Here, however, the terms don’t conflict in any precise way.

Choice D suggests an exception to the parol evidence rule—a collateral contract with a separate consideration. However, that exception is not relevant since a finding that the oral term fit that criteria would actually allow the introduction of the evidence, and, here, the evidence was excluded.


26
New cards

A tenant and a landlord enter a written agreement for the rental of an office building for one year starting January 1 and ending December 31. The lease was highly negotiated and both parties were active in drafting provisions. The lease provides the tenant with an option to renew the lease provided that the tenant must give the landlord written notice to renew by “midnight November 1.” At noon on November 1, the tenant provides the landlord with written notice to renew the lease. However, the landlord refuses to accept the notice stating that the meaning of “midnight” is the start of the day—not the end of the day. The literal and accurate dictionary definition of “midnight” is the start of the day. However, in common usage a large majority of people treat “midnight” as the end of the day even though they are technically wrong. Assume that the tenant brings a breach of contract suit against the landlord. The court makes a finding that “midnight” is an ambiguous term. Which of the following is the best and most accurate statement of the approach that a modern jurisdiction would take in interpreting the meaning of the word “midnight” in these circumstances?

(A)

The court would first try to determine the intent of the parties as to what they meant by “midnight.”


(B)

A court must use the dictionary definition of “midnight” since the dictionary definition always represents the objective meaning.


(C)

A court would be bound to use the customary meaning of “midnight” given that the majority of people interpret the word differently than the dictionary definition.


(D)

Given the two reasonable interpretations of the meaning of midnight, the court would split the difference and find that “noon” on November 1 was a reasonable time by which the tenant should have exercised the option.


(A)

The court would first try to determine the intent of the parties as to what they meant by “midnight.”

Rationale:


The correct answer is A.

The question asks for the best and most accurate statement of the approach a modern jurisdiction would take in resolving the issue.

Answers B and C are both too absolute. Be cautious when you see the words “must” and “are bound to use” since each suggests that there are no exceptions. We know that a dictionary definition is very good proof of the objective meaning of an ambiguous term, but it is not the absolute answer. It is just a starting point. Additionally, the colloquial usage may not control if there is an official definition. Answers B and C might be approaches that are used, but neither is the best and most accurate statement.

Answer D seems attractive as it attempts to find a reasonable middle ground. While this might be done in negotiations, it does not invoke any rule of interpretation; consequently, it is also not a good answer.

Answer A is the only answer that invokes a rule that a court is bound to use. The guiding principle of all interpretation problems is to first determine the intent of the parties. That is the definitive starting point for an interpretation problem and therefore Answer A is the best answer.


27
New cards

A restaurant has a contract with a food supplier to supply its restaurant with meat. The five-year contract was signed three years ago. The supplier promises to sell meat ordered by the restaurant and the restaurant promises to pay the current published price of the supplier at the time of order for all meat ordered. Over three years, the restaurant has placed 58 orders for a specific cut of prime grade beef. On 33 occasions when it was not possible to fulfill the quantity of the restaurant’s order for prime grade beef, the supplier substituted with a lower quality choice grade of beef. Upon delivery, the supplier substituted the original invoice listing prime grade beef with a new invoice reflecting the lower choice grade of beef and the lower price per pound. On each of these occasions, the restaurant accepted the choice grade meat and paid the invoice without any objection or complaint. The contract, which is a final, fully integrated agreement between the supplier and the restaurant, says nothing about the ability of the supplier to make any substitutions. Last week the restaurant’s new chef complained to the restaurant owner about a shipment of choice grade beef when he had ordered prime grade. He refused to cook with “that lousy inferior meat.” The restaurant owner called her contact at the supplier and said they needed to take away the meat they delivered as it did not comply with the contract since the restaurant had ordered prime grade. The supplier responded that their contract allowed them to substitute choice grade as long as they charged accordingly. The owner responded, “Where does it say that in the contract?” Did the supplier breach the contract by delivering the choice grade meat?

(A)

Yes, a contract only contains the express provisions included in the agreement and since the written contract does not provide for substitutions, the supplier breached the obligation to deliver the meat ordered.


(B)

Yes, the facts do not establish a course of dealing that allows substitutions of the type made by the supplier.


(C)

No, the usage of trade established between the supplier and the restaurant supplements the agreement to include the right to make this type of substitution.


(D)

No, the extensive occasions of performance are sufficient to establish a course of performance that supplements the agreement to include the right to make this type of substitution.


(D)

No, the extensive occasions of performance are sufficient to establish a course of performance that supplements the agreement to include the right to make this type of substitution.


Rationale:

This contract is one for the sale of goods so the Uniform Commercial Code, Article 2, applies. UCC §2-202 states, “Terms . . . which are otherwise set forth in a writing intended by the parties as a final expression of their agreement . . . may be explained or supplemented (a) by course of performance, course of dealing, or usage of trade (Section 1-303) . . . .” Therefore, answer A is incorrect as it claims that written terms may never be supplemented and is inconsistent with UCC §2-202. The question tests understanding of the terms usage of trade, course of dealing, and course of performance. The facts in the question give rise to a course of performance because the contract “involves repeated occasions for performance.” (UCC §1-303). On 33 (out of 58) occasions in which the restaurant ordered prime grade beef, the supplier substituted choice grade. Since the restaurant had “knowledge of the nature of the performance and opportunity for objection to it” and never objected to the substitution of choice grade, the facts appear to establish a course of performance that choice grade meat may be substituted for prime grade when ordered. There is no bright line rule for how many occasions of performance must arise to establish a course of performance. In the famous case Nanakuli Paving & Rock Co. v. Shell Oil Co., 664 F.2d 772 (9th Cir. 1981) the court found two occasions to be sufficient. In the problem more than half of the orders placed involved this course of performance, and therefore there is likely sufficient evidence of a course of performance. Answer D is correct. The facts make no reference to a “sequence of conduct concerning previous transactions between the parties to a particular transaction” and thus there is no course of dealing between the two (UCC §1-303). A course of dealing involves a history of entering into similar contracts with the same parties, whereas a course of performance involves repeated occasions to perform under the same contract. In the question the supplier and the restaurant are said to have entered into only one five-year contract. Answer B correctly states that there are not sufficient facts to establish such a course of dealing but wrongly concludes that the supplier is in breach. Even if there is no course of dealing a course of performance may exist. The question refers to no “practice or method of dealing having such regularity of observance” in the trade of wholesale food supply and thus the facts do not raise an issue of a usage of trade (UCC §1-303), and therefore answer C is incorrect.


28
New cards

A woman lost an expensive gold watch. She placed an ad in the local newspaper that read: “Reward of $400 offered to the person that finds and returns to me my gold watch inscribed with my initials and the date engraved.” A man had recently hosted a party in his apartment which the woman attended. When dusting an end table, he found a gold watch lying behind a large lamp. He immediately recognized it as the woman’s because of the inscriptions of the date and initials he had seen previously. He does not read the local paper and did not see the above quoted ad that appeared in it the day prior to his finding the watch. On his way to return the watch he encountered his friend. Upon mentioning to his friend that he was returning the woman’s watch that he had just found, the friend pulled out the prior day’s paper and showed the man the ad. The man exclaimed with joy, “That is great as I could really use the reward.” When he returned the watch, he told the woman about his encounter with his friend and learning of the reward. She replied that since he did not know about the reward when he found the watch, he did not accept her reward offer. She refuses to pay him the reward. If the man were to sue the woman for the reward, what would be the likely outcome?

(A)

The court will find no contract was formed because the offer was not communicated to the man at the time he began performance.


(B)

The court will find no contract was formed because advertisements are not offers.


(C)

The court will likely find a contract was formed because the man learned of the offer before completing the requested performance.


(D)

The court will likely find a contract was formed because offers for unilateral contracts are formed once performance is begun and the man began performance by finding the watch.


(C)

The court will likely find a contract was formed because the man learned of the offer before completing the requested performance.


Rationale:

This question involves an offer for a unilateral contact in which one party (the woman) promises something (the reward) in exchange for performance (finding and returning the watch). This type of offer is often called a reward offer. An offer requires: (1) a manifestation of present intent to enter a bargain; (2) that it be stated in certain and definite terms; (3) that it be communicated to an identified person or persons; (4) that an offeree be able to reasonably understand that a contract would result if accepted. Typically, advertisements are not offers, but if the advertisement meets all of the criteria for an offer it can be found to be an offer. Reward offers are a type of advertisement that courts typically find to be offers because they are capable of acceptance only by those who perform the act meriting the reward. Answer B is therefore not a good choice because it too definitively states that advertisements are not offers. An offer of a unilateral contract is formed by the completion of the requested performance. The offer must be communicated to the offeree to be accepted. The Restatement (Second) of Contracts §45 provides for the creation of an option contract so that an offeror cannot revoke an offer of a unilateral contract after an offeree has begun performance so that the offeree has the opportunity to complete performance and accept the offer. It is true that an option contract may have been formed under §45 when the man began performance but he did not accept the offer until he returned it to the woman. Answer D is therefore not the best choice. Restatement §51 states that “Unless the offeror manifests a contrary intention, an offeree who learns of an offer after he has rendered part of the performance requested by the offer may accept by completing the requested performance.” This section makes clear that a reward offer can be accepted so long as the offeree learns of the requested performance before completing that performance. The man clearly learned of the reward before he completed the two-part performance requested in the ad: (1) find the watch and (2) return it to the woman at her home. The man accepted the offer once he returned the watch with knowledge of the offer. Answer C is correct and answer B incorrectly states that the man must know of the offer when beginning performance.


29
New cards

An owner offers to sell her vacation home to a buyer. The offer is sent in the form of a contract to purchase real estate that includes all material terms and is signed by the owner. Upon receipt, the buyer signs the contract and deposits it in the US mail addressed to the owner at the address listed in the contract. The next morning the buyer has second thoughts and takes a copy of the contract he had made before signing it and changes the purchase price by reducing it by 15%. He then signs this new version and brings it to the FedEx store and sends it to the owner via overnight delivery. The next day the owner receives the second copy (with the reduced purchase price) and the day after that she receives the first copy the buyer sent in the mail. She notes the postmark on the mailed copy is a day prior to the date the FedEx package was sent. The owner calls the buyer and said she is holding him to the original contract and price, and he must perform. At this point does a contract exist between owner and buyer for the purchase of the vacation home at the original price?

(A)

Yes, once an offered contract is signed the acceptance is effective.


(B)

Yes, the acceptance was effective prior to the counteroffer and thus the contract was formed before the counteroffer became effective.


(C)

No, because an acceptance is not effective until the offeror receives it, and the owner received the counteroffer first.


(D)

No, because the owner received the counteroffer before the acceptance, the counteroffer acted as a rejection and since the owner never accepted the counteroffer no contract was formed.


(B)

Yes, the acceptance was effective prior to the counteroffer and thus the contract was formed before the counteroffer became effective.


Rationale:

This question tests the operation of the so-called mailbox rule on counteroffers and acceptances. Restatement (Second) of Contracts §63(a) makes clear that unless the offer stated otherwise, “an acceptance made in a manner and by a medium invited by an offer is operative and completes the manifestation of mutual assent as soon as put out of the offeree’s possession.” Since the owner sent the offer by mail, an acceptance sent by mail is effective since Restatement §65 makes clear that unless specified otherwise in the offer, using the same mode to transmit the acceptance as used by the offeror is a reasonable method of acceptance. Although Restatement §40 makes clear a counteroffer or rejection is effective once received by the offeror, a counteroffer cannot be effective if a contract has already been accepted. Thus, answer B is correct since the parties formed a binding contract as soon as the buyer put the acceptance in the U.S. mail. Mere signature on an acceptance is not sufficient as an acceptance unless the offer makes clear such an act will constitute acceptance in and of itself. Absent such specification execution must be followed by delivery or communication of the acceptance. Answer A is therefore incorrect. Answer C misstates the rule. Under §63(a) an acceptance sent by mail is effective on dispatch, not on receipt, so the order in which the owner received the two documents does not matter. Although counteroffers are effective upon receipt, they are only effective if the offer has not been accepted. Since the offer was accepted upon mailing the acceptance, answer D is incorrect.


30
New cards
31
New cards

A hiring manager for a restaurant hires a part time server during shifts when the restaurant anticipates it will have increased business. For the past two years this has happened 35 times. Each time the manager calls the server, he either speaks to him or leaves as a voicemail saying something similar to the following: “We could use you on Saturday night from 5:00 to midnight. If you want to work, show up before 5:00, work the shift, and we will pay you $6.00 an hour plus a proportionate share of tips that night.” The server, when he is able, arrives at the restaurant and either starts working or stops by the manager's office to say he is reporting for work. On February 12, the manager calls and leaves a message for the server on his voicemail making the same offer for Valentine’s Day. The server never calls the manager back. The server shows up on Valentine’s Day and works from 5:00 to midnight. The manager has the night off so does not see the server at work. A few days later the server calls the manager to ask when he can pick up his pay and share of the tips. Usually, the manager pays the server a few days later after they have calculated his share of the tips. The manager says “Oh, I never heard back from you after I left my message, so I called another server who worked that night. We didn’t really need you as a result, so I am not paying.” The server did see the other server working that night but thought nothing of it as she sometimes works there on other occasions when he was also working. If the server sues for his hourly fees and proportionate share of tips, is a court likely to find that a contract has been formed?

(A)

Yes, the manager made a unilateral offer and the server effectively accepted by rendering the required performance


(B)

Yes, the manager made an offer and due to their course of dealing, silence operates as acceptance.


(C)

No, the server's acceptance is nullified since the offeree must notify the offeror of acceptance even if earlier silence is effective.


(D)

No, since the manager was not present to reject the proffered services on Valentine’s Day, the server’s silence does not operate as acceptance.


(A)

Yes, the manager made a unilateral offer and the server effectively accepted by rendering the required performance


Rationale:

This question tests the ability to distinguish acceptance by silence (Restatement (Second) of Contracts §69) and Acceptance by Performance (Restatement §50). Restatement §30 makes clear an offeror can invite acceptance either by “an affirmative answer in words” or “by performing . . . a specified act,” Restatement §32 makes clear the required “act” can be performance of the terms of the offered contract. The common law called such an offer an offer of a “unilateral” contract although the Restatement does not use this terminology. Under the facts of this problem, the manager is making a unilateral offer and asks for acceptance by performance (working as a server on Valentine’s Day from 5:00 p.m. until midnight). The server either did not have a duty to notify the manager of his acceptance by performance because the manager did not require notification of acceptance when making the offer (Restatement §54(1)) or the server's call a few days later constituted “reasonable diligence to notify” the manager of acceptance by performance (Restatement §54(2)(a)). Answer A is therefore correct. Although Restatement §69(1)(b) makes clear a course of dealing between parties can create a situation in which silence can constitute acceptance, as already noted, this offer did not invite acceptance by silence but acceptance by performance. The past dealings do not demonstrate a history of accepting by silence but by performance so Answer B is incorrect. Although Restatement §54 specifies instances in which notice of acceptance is required, as noted previously the server did give notice within a reasonable time. Having the ability to reject proffered services is relevant sometimes to silence constituting acceptance, in this case when performance was the invited method of acceptance, the ability to reject services is not relevant and therefore Answer D is incorrect.


32
New cards

A niece is enrolled to start college in the fall. Her aunt tells her, “I promise to give you $30,000 in December to help pay your tuition.” During the fall, the niece travels to Europe, where she stays at expensive hotels, eats at expensive restaurants, and spends her nights dancing at clubs. The niece charges $20,000 on her credit cards for the trip, expecting to pay them off in December when her aunt gives her the money she promised. When the niece returns home, the aunt refuses to pay the niece the $30,000. The niece sues her aunt for the $30,000 that was promised.

Will the niece recover any amount from the aunt?

(A)

Yes, for $30,000, the amount the aunt promised


(B)

Yes, but for only $20,000, the amount the niece relied to her detriment on the aunt’s promise


(C)

Yes, because the niece’s trip to Europe was consideration for the aunt’s promise


(D)

No, because the niece’s actions were not reasonably foreseeable


(D)

No, because the niece’s actions were not reasonably foreseeable


Rationale:

Issue: Can the niece enforce the promise through the doctrine of promissory estoppel?

Rule: Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 90(1) provides that “A promise which the promisor should reasonably expect to induce action or forbearance on the part of the promisee or a third person and which does induce such action or forbearance is binding if injustice can be avoided only by enforcement of the promise. The remedy granted for breach may be limited as justice requires.”

Analysis: Under these facts, the aunt has made a gratuitous promise to the niece. Since there is no consideration for the promise to pay the niece $30,000, the aunt is not legally bound to perform her promise unless the doctrine of promissory estoppel creates liability. However, promissory estoppel is not established under these facts. Although the niece took action in reliance on the aunt’s promise, the action was not reasonably foreseeable to the aunt. The aunt promised the niece $30,000 to help the niece pay tuition for college. However, the niece instead charged a lavish European vacation to her credit cards. Because the niece’s actions were not foreseeable, Choice D is the best answer.

Choices A and B are both incorrect because there is no basis for liability under promissory estoppel. The action was not reasonably foreseeable; therefore, no amount of recovery is justified.

Choice C is incorrect since the aunt did not request that the niece take a trip to Europe; therefore there was no bargain and the trip was not consideration for the aunt’s promise.


33
New cards

After working at the company for 25 years, an employee was told by his employer, “Because you have been such a loyal employee for many years, the company promises that you will be provided with a monthly pension of $4,000 for the remainder of your life.”

The employee then retired and the company began making monthly payments. After five years, the company stopped making the monthly payments to the employee. What would be the employee’s best legal theory of recovery if he sues the company for not making the payments:

(A)

The company breached an express unilateral contract that formed by the employee’s retirement.


(B)

The company was unjustly enriched by the employee by his many years of service.


(C)

The employee relied to his detriment on the company’s promise of a pension by retiring.


(D)

The company’s promise of a monthly pension of $4,000 for life lacks consideration.


(C)

The employee relied to his detriment on the company’s promise of a pension by retiring.


Rationale:

Answer C is the best answer.

This is an issue-spotting question that is based on promissory estoppel.

Restatement (Second) of Contracts §90(1) provides: “A promise which the promisor should reasonably expect to induce action or forbearance on the part of the promisee or a third person and which does induce such action or forbearance is binding if injustice can be avoided only by enforcement of the promise. The remedy granted for breach may be limited as justice requires.”

The promise of the pension is based on past consideration. Since the pension was not bargained for, the best argument for the employee would be Answer C, promissory estoppel—i.e., that the employee relied to his detriment by taking the action of retiring because of the promise and it was reasonably foreseeable to the company that he would do so.

Answer A is incorrect since there was no consideration. The company did not request that the employee retire; therefore, the employee’s retirement is not the sort of performance that would form a unilateral contract.

Answer B is incorrect since the employee did not confer a benefit on the company that was unjust—i.e., the employee was paid for the work that he did.

Answer D is not an argument in the employee’s favor. It just describes the reason the promise is not enforceable as a contract.


34
New cards

In January, a seller advertised on the Internet that he had a car for sale. The buyer was working overseas but planned to return home in February and would need a car. The buyer read the seller’s ad, and the buyer and the seller came to an agreement where the buyer would pay for the car and the seller would transfer title to the car immediately. The seller planned to park the car in front of the seller’s house until the buyer could pick it up in February. After the sale was completed, the buyer expressed concern that the car might be harmed being parked on the street. The seller promised the buyer to insure the car until February. However, the seller did not obtain insurance on the car. The buyer could have insured the car but did not since the seller had agreed to do so. In late January, a hit and run driver ran into the parked car thereby destroying it. If either the seller or the buyer had insured the car, then the insurance would have paid out for the value of the car.

What is the likely outcome if the buyer sues the seller for damages?

(A)

The seller will prevail, because the seller’s promise was gratuitous.


(B)

The seller will prevail, because the buyer did not take any affirmative action to his detriment.


(C)

The buyer will prevail, since there was a bargained-for exchange.


(D)

The buyer will prevail, since the buyer reasonably relied to his detriment.


(D)

The buyer will prevail, since the buyer reasonably relied to his detriment.


Rationale:

Issue: This problem tests on the doctrine of promissory estoppel.

Rule: Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 90(1) provides that “A promise which the promisor should reasonably expect to induce action or forbearance on the part of the promisee or a third person and which does induce such action or forbearance is binding if injustice can be avoided only by enforcement of the promise. The remedy granted for breach may be limited as justice requires.”

Analysis: After the sale was completed, the seller made a promise to insure the car until the buyer could return to pick it up. Since this promise was made after the transaction was complete, there is no consideration for the promise. The buyer’s promise to pay for the car is not consideration for the seller’s promise to insure the car, and the buyer made no other promise in exchange for the promise to insure; consequently, the seller’s promise to insure is gratuitous.

However, the buyer can assert the doctrine of promissory estoppel since the seller’s promise induced forbearance on the part of the buyer. The buyer did not purchase insurance because the seller had promised to do so. The seller should have reasonably expected the buyer to not get insurance once the seller promised to do so. The buyer has suffered a detriment since the seller did not fulfill his promise, and the car was destroyed. Choice D is correct.

Although Choice A has a correct statement (i.e., that the promise was gratuitous) the conclusion is incorrect since the buyer has recourse through a theory of promissory estoppel.

Choice B is incorrect. The answer suggests that the buyer must act to detriment to assert a claim of promissory estoppel. However, under Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 90(1), the promise can induce either action or forbearance. Here, there was forbearance—i.e., the promisee did not act as a result of the promise.

Choice C is incorrect because there was no bargain. The seller’s promise to insure was gratuitous.


35
New cards

A buyer enters into a written contract with a horse breeder to purchase an Arabian horse for $10,000. When the breeder delivers a Russian Arabian, the buyer objects claiming a Crabbet Arabian was indicated by “Arabian.“ The court concludes after examining the contract that it is a fully integrated agreement. The court also finds the term ‘Arabian’ ambiguous. Will the buyer be able to introduce evidence that at the time of contracting they discussed a Russian, not a Crabbet, type of Arabian as evidence that they mean a Russian Arabian?

(A)

No, the parol evidence rule prohibits introduction of evidence of the contemporaneous or prior agreement because the court found their contract to be fully integrated.


(B)

No, the agreement about breed of horse is not a collateral agreement and therefore an exception to the parol evidence rule is not available.


(C)

Yes, the evidence would be introduced to resolve the ambiguous term “Arabian.“


(D)

Yes, contracts for the sale of a horse are covered by the Uniform Commercial Code and it does not include a parol evidence rule.


(C)

Yes, the evidence would be introduced to resolve the ambiguous term “Arabian.“


Rationale:

The parol evidence rule excludes all prior or contemporaneous evidence that would contradict or supplement the totally integrated agreement. As the court finds their contract to be fully integrated the rule could be applicable unless an exception exists. Answer A correctly summarizes the rule but does not take account of exceptions and is therefore incorrect. The collateral agreement exception allows introduction of evidence of a separate, collateral, agreement entered into contemporaneously with the integrated contract. There does not appear to be a separate agreement in addition to the one concerning the purchase of the horse. Answer B is incorrect. The Uniform Commercial Code does contain a parol evidence rule that is generally similar to that under the common law. Answer D is incorrect. Answer C correctly states that the evidence would be introduced to resolve the ambiguous term “Arabian.“


36
New cards

A restaurant leases space in a shopping center under a five-year lease. The lease states that the landlord may terminate the lease “for any reason on 90 days’ written notice.” In year three, a national restaurant chain offers the landlord higher rent for the same space. The landlord gives the restaurant 90 days’ written notice of termination and then leases the space to the chain. The restaurant sues the landlord for breach of the implied duty of good faith and fair dealing. Will the restaurant prevail?

(A)

Yes, because terminating the lease deprived the restaurant of the benefit of its five-year lease.


(B)

No, because the lease expressly allowed termination for any reason, and the landlord used that right as the lease allowed.


(C)

Yes, because every contract includes a duty of good faith and fair dealing that the parties cannot disclaim.


(D)

Yes, because the landlord terminated the lease to obtain higher rent, which is the kind of opportunistic conduct the duty prohibits.


(B)

No, because the lease expressly allowed termination for any reason, and the landlord used that right as the lease allowed.


Rationale:

Every contract includes an implied duty of good faith and fair dealing in its performance, and the parties cannot disclaim it. But the duty cannot contradict what the contract expressly provides. The lease gave the landlord the right to terminate for any reason on 90 days’ written notice. The landlord gave the required notice and terminated for a reason the lease allowed. Choosing to terminate in order to obtain higher rent is not arbitrary; it is the kind of decision the termination clause gave the landlord the right to make. The restaurant did not have a right to five years no matter what; it had a right to five years subject to the termination clause. A court will not rewrite the parties’ termination clause because the result is hard on the restaurant. Answer B is correct.


37
New cards

A lumber supplier and a home builder sign a contract for lumber, to be delivered “on or about the first of each month.” For the first eight months, the supplier delivers between the 5th and the 10th, and the builder accepts every delivery without objection. In month nine, the builder rejects a delivery made on the 8th as late. Evidence shows that in the regional lumber trade, “on or about” means within three days. What will the court most likely rely on to interpret “on or about the first of each month”?

(A)

The trade usage, because it shows what the phrase means in the lumber industry.


(B)

The dictionary meaning of “about,” because the phrase has a plain meaning.


(C)

The express term, because the contract requires delivery on the first of each month.


(D)

The parties’ course of performance, because it shows what these parties meant by the term under this contract.


(D)

The parties’ course of performance, because it shows what these parties meant by the term under this contract.


Rationale:

The contract does not require delivery on the first of each month. It requires delivery “on or about” the first. That is a flexible term: it allows some leeway around the first but does not say how much, so the words alone do not tell the court how late a delivery may be. When a term leaves room like this, the court looks at how the parties themselves performed under the contract. A course of performance outweighs trade usage because it shows what these particular parties meant by their words in this contract. For eight months, the supplier delivered between the 5th and the 10th, and the builder accepted every delivery without objection. That conduct shows the parties understood “on or about the first” to include delivery by the 10th. The trade’s three-day meaning and the dictionary’s meaning of “about” give way to what the parties’ own performance shows. Answer D is correct.


38
New cards

By signed writing, a seller and buyer agree that the buyer will pay the seller a nonrefundable $1,000, and the seller, for two months, will hold open an offer to sell her a parcel of real property for the price of $1 million, which is the fair market value of the property. The buyer then pays the seller $1,000. One month later, the buyer tells the seller that the buyer wants to accept the offer and purchase the land. The buyer tenders a cashier's check for $1 million in accordance with the terms of the offer, but the seller refuses to convey title to the property.

Is the seller in breach of contract?

(A)

Yes, because the seller sold the buyer an enforceable option to purchase the real estate


(B)

Yes, because an option for the sale of real estate requires no consideration


(C)

No, because the consideration from the buyer for the option is presumptively inadequate


(D)

No, because the seller fails to provide consideration for the option


(A)

Yes, because the seller sold the buyer an enforceable option to purchase the real estate

Rationale:


Issue: This problem tests the enforceability of option agreements.

Rules:

An offer is generally freely revocable at any time before it has been accepted if the offeree receives notice of the revocation. However, an offer may be made irrevocable for the time stated under a valid option contract. “An option contract is a promise which meets the requirements for the formation of a contract and limits the promisor's power to revoke an offer.”

Analysis: Two parties form an "option contract” if one of them (the "optionee") gives some value in exchange for which the other ("optionor") agrees, for some stated period, to hold open an offer. (Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 25). The optionor is the offeror of the underlying offer being held open. The optionee is the offeree of the underlying offer. Here, the seller and the buyer have formed a contract, under which the buyer has purchased the seller's irrevocable offer. Each must abide by his/her contractual obligation. The buyer must pay $1,000 (as she does), and the seller gives up the power to revoke the offer for two months. The seller must sell the buyer the real estate (for $1 million) if, within two months, the buyer “exercises the option”—i.e., accepts the underlying offer by tendering the $1 million. One month later, the buyer does exercise the option, but the seller refuses to sell it. The seller is in breach of the option contract, and so is in breach of the underlying contract to sell the property.

Choice B has the correct result—that a contract formed for the purchase of the property, and the seller breached it—but the wrong reasoning. Under the common law, an option for real estate does require consideration. In some situations under the UCC Article 2, an offer from a merchant for the sale of goods may be held open without consideration; however, this contract is for the sale of real property, not goods. Similarly, Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 87(1) provides that an offer may be binding as an option contract if it is made in a certain manner, but those requirements are not met.

Choice C incorrectly applies the adequacy of consideration rules to the wrong contract. There are two contracts (the option contract and the sales contract) and there are two sets of consideration. In the option contract, the $1,000 is given for the firm option; in the sales contract, the $1 million is given for the property. Neither the $1,000 nor $1 million is nominal in the context of the correct contractual exchange. Although the property is worth $1 million, the $1,000 is not nominal because it is only purchasing time to keep the offer open. There is nothing in the facts suggesting that the $1,000 represents the pretense of a bargain. Furthermore, many courts give some leeway in terms of consideration for option agreements. Nominal consideration under an option agreement could be sufficient if the underlying contract is fair. (See Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 87.) Under these facts, the $1,000 is not nominal. Furthermore, the underlying contract of $1 million for the property is a fair price. For these reasons, Choice C is incorrect.

Choice D is wrong because the option does exact consideration from the seller. In return for the $1,000 the seller promises to not revoke the offer for two months. That promise curtails the seller’s right to revoke an offer and is therefore consideration for the promise. Choice A is correct.


39
New cards

For years, the City had wanted to build a park in its center. On October 1, a prominent restaurateur sends the following signed letter to the City.

“I have lived in the City all of my life and want to provide the City with an opportunity to purchase property for a park at a very good price. To show my civic spirit and because I love this town, I offer to sell the property my restaurant is located on to the City for $30,000—a price that is well below the fair market value. This offer is open until November 1.”

The restaurant property has a fair market value of $100,000. The City received the letter the following day. On October 15, the restaurateur dies. Under her will, her son inherits all her property. The son is also the executor of the restaurateur’s estate. The City knows that the son is not as civic minded as the restaurateur and will want to keep the restaurant property. The City then sends an acceptance of the restaurateur’s offer to her address with a copy to the son as executor of her estate.

When the son received the City’s acceptance, he wrote back stating that as executor of his mother’s estate, he would not sell the restaurant property for any less than the fair market value of $100,000. The City brings a breach of contract claim. What is the likely decision of the court and rationale?

(A)

The son prevails as executor of the restaurateur’s estate because there was no consideration to keep the offer open.


(B)

The son prevails as executor of the restaurateur’s estate because the offer terminated when the restaurateur died.


(C)

The City prevails because the offer was made irrevocable through promissory estoppel.


(D)

The City prevails because they accepted before the attempted revocation.


(B)

The son prevails as executor of the restaurateur’s estate because the offer terminated when the restaurateur died.


Rationale:

Answer B is correct.

This problem tests on the issue of termination of the power of acceptance by the death of the offeror. Under these facts, the restaurateur has made an offer to the City to sell her property. The restaurateur states that the offer will be open until November 1. An offer is effective when the offeree receives it, so the offer became effective on October 2. The City took no immediate action on the letter. When the restaurateur died on October 15, the City’s power of acceptance was terminated. (See Restatement (Second) of Contracts §48.) For this reason, Answer B is correct.

Answer A has the right conclusion and correctly states the facts; however, the rationale is not the principal reason that the offer was terminated. It should be noted that if the restaurateur’s letter had been an option contract with consideration, then her death would not have terminated the City’s power of acceptance. (See Restatement (Second) of Contracts §37.) That rule is not relevant since there is no consideration to hold her offer open. Even so, the lack of consideration is not the reason that the offer was terminated. As stated above, the restaurateur’s death terminated the offer.

Answer C is incorrect since nothing in the facts suggests that the City relied to its detriment on the restaurateur’s promise to keep the offer open until November 1. While the City has always wanted a park in the City center, it took no action or forbearance of action based on the offer letter. They were apparently just contemplating the transaction when the restaurateur died.

Answer D is also incorrect. It is true that the City tried to accept the offer stated in the October 1 letter before the son refused to sell at the price stated. However, the City’s purported acceptance was ineffective since the October 1 offer terminated when the restaurateur died, as explained above. Consequently, the City’s purported acceptance is really an offer. The son’s response is a rejection of the City’s offer and he proposes a counteroffer. For these reasons, Answer D is incorrect.


40
New cards

While a homeowner is away for the summer, her next-door neighbor notices that the paint on the homeowner’s fence is peeling. Without contacting the homeowner, the neighbor hires a painter to repaint the fence for $1,500. When the homeowner returns, the neighbor asks her to pay the $1,500, and she refuses. The neighbor sues the homeowner for unjust enrichment, seeking the reasonable value of the work. Will the neighbor recover?

(A)

No, because the neighbor conferred the benefit without a request when there was no emergency and the homeowner could have been asked.


(B)

Yes, because the homeowner received a benefit, and keeping it without paying would unjustly enrich her.


(C)

Yes, because the neighbor relied to her detriment by paying the painter.


(D)

No, because the homeowner never promised to pay for the work.


(A)

No, because the neighbor conferred the benefit without a request when there was no emergency and the homeowner could have been asked.


Rationale:

Quasi-contract allows a party to recover the reasonable value of a benefit when it would be unjust for the recipient to keep the benefit without paying for it. Quasi-contract does not require a promise to pay; the law imposes the obligation to prevent unjust enrichment. But enrichment is not unjust when the benefit was forced on the recipient. Nothing prevented the neighbor from contacting the homeowner, and peeling paint did not require immediate action. A person who confers a benefit without being asked, when the owner could have been asked, is an officious intermeddler and cannot recover. The homeowner had the right to decide whether to have her fence painted, and at what price. Answer A is correct.


41
New cards

A shopping mall developer entered into a one-year, $15 million contract with a construction company to build a new shopping mall on land owned by the developer. The written contract was 125 pages long, with a highly detailed description of reciprocal rights and duties. The contract included a clause that read: "Entire Agreement: This writing embodies the complete and final agreement of the parties as to its subject matter." Before signing the agreement, the parties orally agreed that if the construction company finished the project two months early, the developer would pay them a bonus of $1 million. Both parties signed the agreement, but the writing was not modified to include the bonus term. The company completed its work two months ahead of schedule and submitted to the developer a demand for the $15 million fee plus the $1 million bonus. The developer paid the $15 million fee but refused to pay a bonus, on the ground that the contract did not provide for it, the company sued the developer for breach of contract. At trial the company tried to introduce testimony of the oral agreement. If the court refused to admit the company‘s evidence of the oral agreement, what did the court most likely conclude with respect to the parties' contract?

(A)

Their writing constituted a total integration.


(B)

Their writing constituted only a partial integration.


(C)

The bonus agreement contradicted the terms of their writing.


(D)

The bonus agreement was "collateral" to the agreement set forth in the writing.


(A)

Their writing constituted a total integration.


Rationale:

Issue: This problem tests on the parol evidence rule and requires students to identify the level of integration given a certain set of facts.

Rule: With regard to the parol evidence rule, a given contractual writing might constitute a (1) "total integration," (2) a "partial integration," or (3) no integration at all. Each designation has implications for the rule's operation as to what type of evidence (of prior or contemporaneous agreements outside of the writing) is allowed to be introduced. A total integration excludes all such evidence that supplements or contradicts the writing. However, a partial integration allows supplemental evidence of consistent additional terms and only excludes evidence that contradicts the writing. If there is no integration, then evidence that either supplements or contradicts is allowed to be introduced. There are many exceptions to the parol evidence rule that are not relevant here.

Analysis: In order to exclude the evidence, the court most likely found that the writing was totally integrated. The writing has indicia of a totally integrated agreement; the contract is lengthy (125 pages), exhaustively detailed, and contains a merger clause, which is a provision by which the writing characterizes itself as a complete and final expression of the parties' agreement. The writing is silent on whether the company is entitled to a bonus; therefore, the oral agreement to give the company a bonus for finishing early is a consistent additional term. The call of the question assumes the evidence is going to be excluded. The only way that a consistent additional term is excluded is if there is a total integration. If the court found that the writing was partially integrated, then the court would have to allow supplementary evidence to be introduced. However, the court refused to admit the evidence, so it could not have found the writing to be partially integrated. Choice A is the correct answer. Since the writing is totally integrated, Choice B is incorrect. Choice C is not the best answer. It is possible that a court might find that the bonus agreement conflicts with the main payment term since both have to do with compensation. However, such an analysis is ambiguous at best as a matter of interpretation by a judge. A more precise analysis of conflicting term would be where a particular term has two different values. Here, however, the terms don’t conflict in any precise way. Choice D suggests an exception to the parol evidence rule a collateral contract with a separate consideration. However, that exception is not applicable because the bonus term is not a collateral agreement with its own separate consideration. The oral agreement is merely a supplemental conditional payment term of the main contract.