1/7
Looks like no tags are added yet.
A01-Milgrims variation
conducted several variations of his experiment, to investigate the factors most likely to affect obedience
A01-Proximity
Baseline Study: Teacher and learner were in separate rooms (could hear, not see). Obedience was highest.
Proximity Variation: Teacher and learner were in the same room. Obedience dropped to 40%.
Touch Proximity Variation: Teacher had to force the learner's hand onto a shock plate. Obedience dropped to 30%.
Key Conclusion: Greater physical distance makes it easier to ignore the harm caused, which increases obedience. Closer distance makes the consequences real, which reduces obedience
A01-Location
In Milgram’s original study, the locations was the prestigious Yale University. When Milgram moved his study to a run-down office block, obedience fell to 47.5%.
This is because the university environment gave Milgram's study legitimacy and authority. Participants were more obedient in this location because they perceived that the experimenter shared this legitimacy and that obedience was expected
A01-Uniform
The role of the experimenter was taken over by an ‘ordinary member of the public’ (a confederate) in everyday clothes rather than a lab coat. The obedience rate dropped to 20%, the lowest of these variations.
This is because uniforms ‘encourage’ obedience, as they are widely recognised as symbols of authority.
A03-Research Support
Point: One strength of situational variables as an explanation for obedience is that there is strong supporting research showing the impact of uniform.
Evidence: For example, Bickman (1974) conducted a field experiment in New York where male actors dressed as either a security guard, a milkman, or a civilian in ordinary clothes gave instructions to members of the public (such as picking up a bag or giving money for a parking meter). He found that the guard was obeyed 76% of the time, compared to 47% for the milkman and only 30% for the civilian.
Explanation: This supports the theory because it demonstrates that wearing a uniform gives an individual perceived authority, significantly increasing the likelihood that others will obey them in a real-life setting. Furthermore, because it was a field experiment, the findings have high ecological validity and can be generalised to everyday behaviour.
Link: This therefore increases the credibility and validity of situational variables as an accurate explanation of obedience.
A03-Cultural Replications
Point: One limitation of Milgram's research into obedience is that there is a lack of cultural replications, meaning the findings may not apply universally.
Evidence: For example, Smith and Bond (1997) found that out of the replications conducted between 1968 and 1985, only two took place in non-Western cultures (India and Jordan), while the majority were conducted in Western, individualist countries culturally similar to the US, such as Spain, Australia, and Scotland (and Meeus and Raaijmakers' 1986 study in the Netherlands).
Explain: This is a limitation because assuming that findings from individualist cultures apply equally to collectivist cultures takes an ethnocentric approach and ignores how cultural norms influence obedience.
Link: Therefore, Milgram's theory of obedience is limited in its external validity, as it is culturally biased and cannot be generalised to all populations worldwide.
A03-Demand Characteristics
Point: One limitation of Milgram’s research into obedience is that the participants' behaviour may have been influenced by demand characteristics rather than true obedience to authority.
Evidence: For example, Perry (2013) found that only about half of the participants actually believed the electric shocks were real, and most of those who did believe were disobedient. Furthermore, Perry et al. (2020) cited testimony from one of Milgram's assistants, Taketo Murata, who reported that participants who 'not fully believed' the setup administered more shocks than those who 'fully believed', suggesting they were simply 'play-acting'.
Explain: This is a limitation because Milgram’s study may not have genuinely measured obedience in all cases, but instead measured how participants responded to the artificial cues of being studied.
Link: This therefore means that Milgram's situational explanation of obedience is less credible, as the results lack internal validity and may not be an accurate explanation of real-life obedience
A03-Dangers of Situational Variables
Point: A limitation of situational explanations of obedience is that they can be used as an excuse for harmful and unacceptable behaviour.
Evidence: For example, David Mandel (1998) argued that situational explanations offer an 'alibi' for evil actions, noting that many Nazis on trial for war crimes defended themselves by claiming they were simply following orders.
Explanation: Mandel suggested it is offensive to claim individuals were merely victims of circumstance, as this absolves them of personal responsibility for their contributions to the Holocaust, trivialises genocide, and minimises the suffering of the victims.
Link: This therefore means that while situational variables remain a credible explanation for obedience, the theory is socially sensitive and must be treated with caution so it is not used to justify destructive behaviour.