1/25
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Define genetic explanation of crime
any explanation of human behaviour that involves genetic structures. Genes consist of DNA which produces ‘instructions’ for physical features which might affect psychological features (i.e crime)
What are candidate genes?
specific genes believed to increase the likelihood of criminal or violent behaviour
What candidate genes are involved in crime?
researcher analysed genetics of 800 Finnish offenders and found 2 genes that are associated with violent crime - MAOA gene, CDH13 gene. Within the sample, both genes were 13 time more likely to have a history of violent behaviour
What is the MAOA gene?
one that regulates serotonin and has been linked to aggression
What is the CDH13 gene?
one linked to substance abuse and ADHD
What were the concordance rates in twin studies for criminality?
35% for MZ twins and 13% for DZ twins suggesting that genetic factors play a role in offending behaviour
Why are adoption studies useful in genetic research?
they separate genetic influences from environmental influences
What did Crowe find about adopted children with a biological criminal parent compared to one without a criminal biological parent?
adopted children who had a biological parent with a criminal record had a 50% risk of having a criminal record by the age of 18 whereas adopted children without a criminal biological parent had just a 5% risk
What does the diathesis-stress model suggest about crime?
crime results from a genetic predisposition (diathesis) triggered by environmental stressors
Define neural explanation of crime
any explanation of human behaviour that involves function (or dysfunction) of the brain. This includes activity of brain structures such as the PFC and neurotransmitters such as serotonin and dopamine
What disorder is commonly studied in neural explanations of crime?
antisocial personality disorder (APD)
What are key characteristics of APD?
lack of empathy, lack of remorse
What is the role of the prefrontal cortex?
regulates emotional behaviour and decision-making
What did Raine at al find about grey matter in the prefrontal cortex?
individuals with APD had 11% less grey matter compared to people without APD
How does reduced grey matter in the PFC relate to crime?
it may impair emotional regulation and reduce feelings of guilt
What are mirror neurons?
neurons that fire when we perform an action and when we observe someone else performing the same action
How are mirror neurons linked to empathy?
they activate when observing others’ emotions, allowing us to feel empathy
What does the ‘neural switch’ theory suggest about offenders with APD?
they are not incapable of empathy, but their empathy can be turned on and off
Why is it a weakness that twin studies used to support genetic explanations can’t fully separate nature from nurture?
as this issue undermines the internal validity of twin studies and mean they cannot provide definitive evidence for a genetic basis of criminal behaviour
Give an example of this weakness
for example, identical twins, who share 100% of their DNA are usually raised in the same household, attend the same schools, and experience very similar parenting styles. This shared environment can inflate concordance rates, making it appear as though criminality is genetically driven when environmental factors may be responsible
How is the fact that the research into the biological explanation does not support a fully genetic basis for criminality a weakness?
as the evidence suggests that both genetics and environment are important when explaining crime, not just genetics as the theory suggests
Give an example of this weakness
for example, research was conducted with 13,000 Danish adoptees. It was found that having no biological or adoptive criminal parents gives a 13.5% chance of them having a criminal record. Having one biological criminal parent gives a 20% chance of them having a criminal record and having both biological and adoptive parents give a 24.5% chance of them having a criminal record
How is the fact that no cause and effect can be established in Raine’s findings on reduced grey matter in the prefrontal cortex of individuals with antisocial personality disorder a weakness?
as it is impossible to draw firm casual conclusions. As a result, the internal validity of neural explanations of offending is weakened, and caution is needed when interpreting brain-based evidence as deterministic proof of criminality
Give an example of this weakness
for example, although Raine reported that people with APD show around 11% less PFC grey matter, this correlation does not demonstrate whether the brain abnormality causes antisocial behaviour or whether years of antisocial, aggressive, or criminal behaviour lead to changes in the brain (plasticity)
How is the fact that the neural explanation is reductionist a limitation? (+counter/development)
because criminal behaviour is complex and influenced by social factors such as upbringing and poor influence, which are ignored when behaviour is reduced to brain structure alone
C: however, identifying neural mechanisms may help develop targeted interventions
Give an example of this limitation
for instance, it explains offending behaviour in terms of mirror neuron dysfunction, suggesting that reduced empathy leads to increased criminal behaviour