1/5
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Vicarious liability gives the C a just and practical remedy
C (victim) is the truly innocent party so deserves a remedy. The employer is more likely to have the financial means to pay the remedy and will have insurance (compulsory). Justifies cases like Limpus or Rose (employee acting against instruction)
Increased insurance premiums may act as a deterrent to poor employment practice.
However, in Barry, the SC makes it clear having ‘deeper pockets’ is not justification for extending VL.
The employer benefits from the work and so should take responsibility
Employer has control over selection and practices, so a wrongdoing by a person they integrated into their business and committed in their course of work, should leave the employer at some fault.
It will encourage employers to ensure employees carry out work safely.
Especially liable if their instructions led to a tort (Mattis).
Rules on VL achieve social justice
Organisations that have failed to guard against SAers working for them have been held accountable, even well after the abuse (Lister, Catholic child Welfare).
Also been used to counter institutional racism (Jones).
Also effective at raising standards of hygiene, safety and service to the benefit of society.
VL is unfair
It imposes liability on a supposedly innocent party for something they haven’t personally done and which they may not be at fault for. Strict liability is inconsistent with the fault principle in law as it targets the employer simply because they are able to bear the financial loss. The tort will occur before the employer finds out and is able to discipline, making it difficult to avoid liability.
Modern working practices mean employers can’t supervise workers closely. And still may be fixed with liability even though they have expressly prohibited the unsafe practice (Limpus)
The scope of liability has also broadened by changes to the law relating to the loan or sharing of employees, meaning more than one employer can be liable for 1 tort (viasystems). This is unfair as it may leave an employer with little control or supervision with the financial burden.
The rules on whether an employee is working ‘in the course of employment’ may lead to inconsistent outcomes
It is difficult to justify the difference between Rose and Beans. Making it hard for employers to create clear rules for workers and leaves them vulnerable.
Inconsistent decisions with road incidents. (Hilton Smith)
Is the law too favourable for the claimant?
Traditional tests of employment have proved too narrow and courts now adopt a more flexible approach to finding an employment relationship. This may be viewed as creating uncertainty as it stretches the boundaries. (Barclays shuts down this argument somewhat)
The development of the close connection test has broadened the scope of vicarious liability significantly and most controversially in cases involving criminal conduct. Employer used to only be liable if the employment itself involved a risk that a crime could be committed. Mohamud signalled an expansion of this law.
However recent cases like Morrisons have sought to place limits by saying that it’s not enough that the tortfeasor of was able to commit the tort because of their employment.