1/25
Vocabulary flashcards covering sports philosophy topics including equal opportunity, transgender athletes, Title IX, and the educational role of intercollegiate athletics.
Non-Discrimination
The principle that everyone should be treated fairly and decisions should be based on relevant abilities rather than irrelevant characteristics like sex.
Equal Chances
The principle that everyone should have the same probability or likelihood of succeeding, such as men and women having equally good chances of earning athletic scholarships.
Equal or Proportional Achievement
The principle that different demographic groups should achieve equal or proportional results, such as women receiving around 51% of awards if they represent 51% of the population.
Jane English's Proposal for Women's Sports
The recommendation to create and promote a greater variety of sports that reward different physical abilities and women's strengths to foster participation and achievement.
Basic Benefits
Non-exclusive goods in sports that many participants can experience simultaneously, such as health, fun, friendship, teamwork, and self-respect.
Scarce Benefits
Limited athletic goods that not everyone can obtain, such as championships, awards, fame, and recognition.
NCAA February 2025 Policy
The policy update establishing that athletes assigned female at birth may compete on women's teams, whereas athletes assigned male at birth may practice with women's teams but cannot compete on them.
Andie Taylor
A transgender runner who maintains that inclusion and fairness both matter and advocates using scientific evidence rather than assumptions to evaluate post-transition competitive advantages.
Potentially Fair Advantages
Athletic advantages that a sport is explicitly designed to reward or develop, including better technique, increased practice, superior strategy, and natural abilities.
Potentially Unfair Advantages
Athletic advantages prohibited by rules, that undermine the core purpose of a competitive category, or that introduce unacceptable safety risks.
Roslyn Kerr's Proposal
The proposal that athletic categories should be based on the specific physical traits that determine success in each individual sport rather than using sex to classify every athlete.
Competition-Relevant Traits
The primary physical attributes that dictate success in a specific sport, can be measured fairly, and improve competition when used to create categories.
Michael Burke's Critique
The perspective challenging the automatic exclusion of transgender women, asserting biological differences alone shouldn't decide eligibility and that fairness must encompass transgender athletes' rights.
Camp 1: Gender-Identity-Based Inclusion
The philosophical position holding that transgender women should generally compete in women's sports because they are women, prioritizing inclusion and gender identity.
Camp 2: Sex-Based Eligibility
The philosophical position holding that sports eligibility must be determined by biological sex in order to safeguard female athletes' competitive opportunities.
Camp 3: Sport-Specific Eligibility
The philosophical position holding that eligibility rules should depend on the particular sport, relying on scientific evidence and sport-relevant physical traits.
Title IX
A federal law that prohibits sex discrimination in federally funded education programs, including athletic departments.
Title IX Prong 1: Substantial Proportionality
The standard requiring that the percentage of male and female athletes at an institution be reasonably proportional to undergraduate enrollment numbers.
Title IX Prong 2: History of Expansion
The standard requiring an institution to show a history and continuing practice of expanding athletic opportunities for the underrepresented sex.
Title IX Prong 3: Full Accommodation
The standard requiring an institution to demonstrate that it fully accommodates the athletic interests and abilities of the underrepresented sex.
Three-Prong Test Compliance Rule
The regulatory rule stating that an educational institution only needs to satisfy one of the three prongs to fulfill the participation-opportunity test.
Lisa Niblock Case
A Title IX and sports fairness case study set at the University of Kentucky examining institutional compliance, disagreements, and athletic opportunity.
Sage Ohlensehle Case
A Title IX case study centered at the University of Iowa involving a member of the women's swimming and diving team regarding fairness and women's sports opportunities.
Standard View of College Athletics
The perspective that sports are extracurricular activities separate from the university's primary educational mission, which mainly takes place in classrooms.
Integrated View of College Athletics
Myles Brand's view that athletics is an integral component of higher education where coaches act as educators and sports teach leadership, discipline, teamwork, and perseverance.
Performing Arts Analogy
Myles Brand's comparison illustrating that both athletics and performing arts share practice, expert instruction, specialized skill development, and personal growth, justifying sports as educational.