1/31
Looks like no tags are added yet.
The fallacy of composition
“The atoms that make up the human body are invisivle. Therefore, the human body is invisible.”
The genetic fallacy
Holding that a claim is false solely because of it’s origin OR refusing to take an argument seriously because of its origin
EX: “We should reject that proposal for solving the current welfare mess. It comes straight from the Conservative Party”
Appeal to the person (Ad hominem)
Holding that a claim is false solely because of WHO is making it OR refusing to take an argument seriously because of who is making it
EX: “We should reject everything that Newton said about physics. After all, he believed in astrology”
Tu Quoque (You’re another/special case of ad hominem)
Rejecting a claim that someone makes (a claim how people have to act) because the person does not practice what they preach
Not the other person committing the fallacy but yourself for rejecting the claim because they dont practice what they preach
EX: “You shouldnt smoke cigarettes they’re bad for you.” → “Why should i listen to you? You smoke a pack a day”
The fallacy of composition
Arguing that what is true of the parts of something must be true of the whole thing
Looks at every member of the category in premise then makes conclusion
EX: “The atoms that make up the human body are invisible. Therefore, the human body is invisible.”
Fallacy of division
Arguing that what is true of the whole must be true of the parts
Opposite of the fallacy of composition
EX: “This boat floats. Thus, each of its metal planks must individually float.”
The burden of proof
Obligation to give evidence/reasons to support your view
Anyone who makes a claim has burden of proof
Anyone who does not have burden of proof = agnostic/no view
Burden of proof fallacy #1A - Appeal to ignorance
Claiming that just because a view has not been proven false, it is therefore true OR claiming that just because a view has not been proven to be true, it is false
EX: “You cannot prove that it is false that we are in the Matrix. Thus, we are in the matrix.”
Burden of proof fallacy #1B - Appeal to ignorance (Supernatural variation)
Claiming that because a naturalistic (scientific) explanation cannot yet explain something, it follows that the real explanation msut be magical/supernatural instead
Burden of proof fallacy #2 - Ignoring Sagan’s Maxim
“Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.”
Burden of proof fallacy #3 - Forgetting that negative claims need justification
“I believe that there are no ghosts. I don’t have to offer any justification for that view.”
Appeal to popularity - Argumentum ad populum
Arguing that a claim must be true merely because a substantial number of people believe it.
Everyone believes X, so X is likely to be true'
EX: “Surveys say about 89% of people believe ghosts. So, ghosts have a 89% chance of existing”
Appeal to common practice
Arguing that you have to do something just because most other people do. (Argue that something is morally right just because most other people do it)
EX: “Eating meat can’t be wrong. Most people are not vegetarians”
Appeal to tradition
Arguing that a claim must be true (or a practice) because it is part of tradition
EX: “The seal hunt is part of traditional cultural practices, so it’s okay”
Appeal to nature
The view that somrthing is goof or true ebcause it is natural, or false/wrong because it’s unnatural
EX: Computers, glasses, snake venom, heroin
Appeal to consequence
Arguing that a statement must be false because if it were true that would be bad.
EX: “It can’t be the case that men tend to have a natural biological advantage over women in most sports, because if it were that would be sort of unfair.”
Appeal to consequence of belief
Arguing that a statement must be false because beliving in it would lead to bad things.
EX: "Reincarnation isn't real, because I wouldn't want to come back as something else."
Equivocation
The use of a word in two different senses in an argument
EX: P1: Man is the only rational animal
P2: No woman is a man
C: Therefore, no woman is rational
Selective Normative Concept Creep
When a term has a traditional use (refers to something bad) then the word is expanded to refer to something good/better
“Suddenly don’t understand words” fallacy
Not understanding words to avoid arguments
EX: “Do you believe in God?” “What do you mean ‘do’, what do you mean ‘you’, what do you mean by ‘God’?”
Nirvana fallacy
Arguing that because something is imperfect, it has to be rejected
EX: Dumping everyone you date, because nobody is perfect.
OR argument that police should be abolished because of it’s flaws
Base rate fallacy
Calculating the likelihood of a phenomenon by looking only at the reliability of the evidence while ignoring the prevalence of that phenomenon
Appeal to emotion
Trying to persuade someone of a conclusion by arousing their feelings rather than presenting proper reasons
EX: “Please hire me for this position. I’m the best person for the job, and if I don’t get the job my wife will leave me, I have to pay for surgery.”
Red herring
Deliberately raising an irrelevant issue during an argument (in an attempt to change the subject and evade criticism)
EX: “You never wash the dishes” → “Well you never pick up you dirty clothes from the floor”
Straw man
Distorting, weakening, or oversimplifying someone’s position so that it can be more easily attacked or refuted
EX: "I think we should increase financial support for single mothers during their child's first year so they can afford medical care.”
→
"So you believe we should hand out free taxpayer money to encourage people to become single mothers and live off the state."
Begging the question
Attempt to establish the conclusion of an argument by using that conclusion as a premise. (Disguised version of the conclusion as a premise)
Will have a missing premise and will be the question begging premise
False dilemma T1
Presenting 2 choices as though they are exhaustive when in reality they are not (in reality you can pick neither)
A or B but you can pick neither
Manipulation
EX: “You’re either with America, or you’re with the terrorists”
False dilemma T2
Presenting 2 choices as though they are exclusive when in reality they are not (you can have both)
A or B but you can have both
EX: “Lassie is either a dog or a mammal. Which one is it?”
Slippery slope
Arguing w/o good reason that taking a particular step will inevitably lead to a further undesireable step
EX: “Marijuana is a gateway drug”
No true scotsman fallacy
Redefining a term (to narrow its reach) to evade counterexamples
EX: Fred: Every Canadian plays hocket
Bill: I’m Canadian and I don’t, so that’s false
Fred: No, my claim is true because I mean every TRUE Canadian
Appeal to authority
When you appeal to somebody’s expertise, but the person you are appealing to is not a qualified expert
EX: Listening to celebrities