PHIL 1100 - Fallacies

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/31

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

32 Terms

1
New cards

The fallacy of composition

“The atoms that make up the human body are invisivle. Therefore, the human body is invisible.”


2
New cards

The genetic fallacy

  • Holding that a claim is false solely because of it’s origin OR refusing to take an argument seriously because of its origin

  • EX: “We should reject that proposal for solving the current welfare mess. It comes straight from the Conservative Party”


3
New cards

Appeal to the person (Ad hominem)

  • Holding that a claim is false solely because of WHO is making it OR refusing to take an argument seriously because of who is making it

EX: “We should reject everything that Newton said about physics. After all, he believed in astrology”


4
New cards

Tu Quoque (You’re another/special case of ad hominem)

  • Rejecting a claim that someone makes (a claim how people have to act) because the person does not practice what they preach

  • Not the other person committing the fallacy but yourself for rejecting the claim because they dont practice what they preach

EX: “You shouldnt smoke cigarettes they’re bad for you.” → “Why should i listen to you? You smoke a pack a day”


5
New cards

The fallacy of composition

  • Arguing that what is true of the parts of something must be true of the whole thing

  • Looks at every member of the category in premise then makes conclusion

EX: “The atoms that make up the human body are invisible. Therefore, the human body is invisible.”


6
New cards

Fallacy of division

  • Arguing that what is true of the whole must be true of the parts

  • Opposite of the fallacy of composition

EX: “This boat floats. Thus, each of its metal planks must individually float.”


7
New cards

The burden of proof

  • Obligation to give evidence/reasons to support your view

  • Anyone who makes a claim has burden of proof

  • Anyone who does not have burden of proof = agnostic/no view


8
New cards

Burden of proof fallacy #1A - Appeal to ignorance

  • Claiming that just because a view has not been proven false, it is therefore true OR claiming that just because a view has not been proven to be true, it is false

EX: “You cannot prove that it is false that we are in the Matrix. Thus, we are in the matrix.”


9
New cards

Burden of proof fallacy #1B - Appeal to ignorance (Supernatural variation)

  • Claiming that because a naturalistic (scientific) explanation cannot yet explain something, it follows that the real explanation msut be magical/supernatural instead


10
New cards

Burden of proof fallacy #2 - Ignoring Sagan’s Maxim

  • “Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.”


11
New cards

Burden of proof fallacy #3 - Forgetting that negative claims need justification

  • “I believe that there are no ghosts. I don’t have to offer any justification for that view.”


12
New cards

Appeal to popularity - Argumentum ad populum

  • Arguing that a claim must be true merely because a substantial number of people believe it.

  • Everyone believes X, so X is likely to be true'

EX: “Surveys say about 89% of people believe ghosts. So, ghosts have a 89% chance of existing”


13
New cards

Appeal to common practice

  • Arguing that you have to do something just because most other people do. (Argue that something is morally right just because most other people do it)

EX: “Eating meat can’t be wrong. Most people are not vegetarians”


14
New cards

Appeal to tradition

  • Arguing that a claim must be true (or a practice) because it is part of tradition

EX: “The seal hunt is part of traditional cultural practices, so it’s okay”


15
New cards

Appeal to nature

  • The view that somrthing is goof or true ebcause it is natural, or false/wrong because it’s unnatural

EX: Computers, glasses, snake venom, heroin


16
New cards

Appeal to consequence

  • Arguing that a statement must be false because if it were true that would be bad.

EX: “It can’t be the case that men tend to have a natural biological advantage over women in most sports, because if it were that would be sort of unfair.”


17
New cards

Appeal to consequence of belief

  • Arguing that a statement must be false because beliving in it would lead to bad things.

EX: "Reincarnation isn't real, because I wouldn't want to come back as something else."


18
New cards

Equivocation

  • The use of a word in two different senses in an argument

EX: P1: Man is the only rational animal

P2: No woman is a man

C: Therefore, no woman is rational


19
New cards

Selective Normative Concept Creep

  • When a term has a traditional use (refers to something bad) then the word is expanded to refer to something good/better


20
New cards

“Suddenly don’t understand words” fallacy

  • Not understanding words to avoid arguments

EX: “Do you believe in God?” “What do you mean ‘do’, what do you mean ‘you’, what do you mean by ‘God’?”


21
New cards

Nirvana fallacy

  • Arguing that because something is imperfect, it has to be rejected

EX: Dumping everyone you date, because nobody is perfect.

OR argument that police should be abolished because of it’s flaws


22
New cards

Base rate fallacy

  • Calculating the likelihood of a phenomenon by looking only at the reliability of the evidence while ignoring the prevalence of that phenomenon



23
New cards

Appeal to emotion

  • Trying to persuade someone of a conclusion by arousing their feelings rather than presenting proper reasons

EX: “Please hire me for this position. I’m the best person for the job, and if I don’t get the job my wife will leave me, I have to pay for surgery.”


24
New cards

Red herring

  • Deliberately raising an irrelevant issue during an argument (in an attempt to change the subject and evade criticism)

EX: “You never wash the dishes” → “Well you never pick up you dirty clothes from the floor”


25
New cards

Straw man

  • Distorting, weakening, or oversimplifying someone’s position so that it can be more easily attacked or refuted

EX: "I think we should increase financial support for single mothers during their child's first year so they can afford medical care.”

→

"So you believe we should hand out free taxpayer money to encourage people to become single mothers and live off the state."


26
New cards

Begging the question

  • Attempt to establish the conclusion of an argument by using that conclusion as a premise. (Disguised version of the conclusion as a premise)

  • Will have a missing premise and will be the question begging premise


27
New cards

False dilemma T1

  • Presenting 2 choices as though they are exhaustive when in reality they are not (in reality you can pick neither)

  • A or B but you can pick neither

  • Manipulation

EX: “You’re either with America, or you’re with the terrorists”


28
New cards

False dilemma T2

  • Presenting 2 choices as though they are exclusive when in reality they are not (you can have both)

  • A or B but you can have both

EX: “Lassie is either a dog or a mammal. Which one is it?”


29
New cards

Slippery slope

  • Arguing w/o good reason that taking a particular step will inevitably lead to a further undesireable step

EX: “Marijuana is a gateway drug”


30
New cards

No true scotsman fallacy

  • Redefining a term (to narrow its reach) to evade counterexamples

EX: Fred: Every Canadian plays hocket

Bill: I’m Canadian and I don’t, so that’s false

Fred: No, my claim is true because I mean every TRUE Canadian


31
New cards

Appeal to authority

  • When you appeal to somebody’s expertise, but the person you are appealing to is not a qualified expert

EX: Listening to celebrities


32
New cards