1/91
Looks like no tags are added yet.
personal jurisdiction
is it fair to make this person come here
specific jurisdiction: can hear cases based on D specific contact to the state
general jurisdiction: can hear cases based on where D is at home
specific jurisdiction
Does d have minimum contacts or purposely availed in state?
intentional (deliberate adds, office, negoaitions)
D must intentionally target state to gain benefit and that action caused harm (International Shoe)
cannot be merely foreseeable, Volkswagen
D must create connection in forum state (Walden V Fior)
size
can be as small as one customer if relationship is continuous (mcgee)
arise of
issue must arise out of or relate to D contacts with state–doesnt have to directly cause issue (Ford Motor co)
contract
Contract alone does not prove min contacts but D rather the activities done in state
(Burger King V Rudezewicz)
did D travel to state, preformed duties in sate, long relationship, virtually enter state
Purposely availed: D could have benefited form states laws/protections
Just need to prove could have used state law/protection for benefit not that they actually used it (Hanson V Denkla)
Does P have tag jurisdiction?
tag jurisdiction
specific jurisdiction P and D contact to state
P does not need to live there, just that harm was sustained there ( Keeton V Hustler Magazine)
Physical presence of D is not required to fulfill min contact as long as harm affected someone in said state (Clader v jones)
“Did x shoot Tortious arrows in another state”
Specific intent and foreign commerce
harder to prove
Foreign manufacturers not subject to PJ in a state merely bc product ends up there through stream of commerce–
D must deliberately target state (min contact/purposely availment)
(Ashai metal)(J. McIntyre)
General Jurisdiction
Court power to hear any cases related to D for any dispute as long as D is “at home” in state not where harm occurs
at home: affiliations with state are continuous and systematic
LLC vs corp
1. corporation
owned by shareholders which promote capitalism by investing money, but cannot be sued for more than the money they invested
Parent and subsidiary~
are connected but have different shareholder, board of officers, CEO, and employees so both entities cannot be sued for same issue–can only be sued where
each company is treated as an independent legal "person" capable of suing, being sued, and incurring liability on its own
2. LLC
More popular business structure that gives owns lawsuit protection of a cooperation and flexible management of partnership
Members own LLC
“at home” for people vs corps
human
state they call home
corp
State it was incorporated and principle place of business (PPB) (Daimler AG v Bauman)
PPB: “never center” where high level officers direct, control, and cooperate corporations activities
Doesn't matter if have continuous/systematic activities in other states (BNSF railway v tyrrell)
General Jurisdiction: foreign subsidiary
Subsidiary and parents are separate so cannot sue under general jurisdiction over foreign subsidiaries just bc have American parent (Goodyear) bc Have separate boards officers and shareholders for this reason
unless subsidiary engages in such continuous and systematic activities as to render it essentially at home in the forum state (Goodyear)
consent for personal jurisdiction
Agree to be sued in state without needing min contact/personal availment
WHATEVER YOU ARE SIGNED YOU ARE STUCK WITH –(unless tricked
Similar to general jurisdiction in that you could be sued for anything
consent my appearance
D consents to pj by voluntarily appearing/participating in the case without properly objecting to pj
Special appearance
appear in court solely to challenge PJ without agreeing to legal authority over them
Consent by registration:
state can require a company to consent to personal jurisdiction as a condition of registering to do business in the state (Mallory v. Norfolk Southern Railway Co )
anyone harmed by the company can bring issue to the consent by registration state regardless if harm did not arise there, D has no reverent contacts to state, D is not at home,
contact by registration will be enforced regardless of parties sophistication (Carnival Cruise Lines, Inc. v. Shute)
objection of personal jurisdiction
D must object to PJ at the beginning of the case.
If D does not object and proceeds with the case, D waives the right to challenge PJ later.
(Baldwin v. Iowa State Traveling Men's Association)
direct attack on jurisdiction
12(b) motion to dimes
collateral attacks of jurisdiction COME BACK TO
never appear in court and ignore suit → goes into default judgment →P tries to collect → file a motion in the enforcement court (or a separate lawsuit) asking the court to declare the original judgment void
risky bc if court decided original court had jurisdiction its a default judgement—meaning waived rights to defend and must pay
if win the default judgement is wiped out and P and must start lawsuit over again in proper court
or exceptional circumstance where on appeal it was blatant that the court should have never decided the previous issue (Klab)
Quasi in rem
Court uses D's property located in the state as the basis for jurisdiction over D.
property gives the plaintiff a practical way to get something from a defendant who is outside the state, even when the lawsuit isn't about that property.
lawsuit does not have to be about property, uses D property to resolve legal dispute against the specific person
property used a basis for jurisdiction
if P wins recovery is limited to value of property
min contact
need to prove D has connection to forum state, property alone is not min contact ((Shaffer v. Heitner)
ex. D owns home in PA, lives thee part time, rents to PA tenants, conduct business involving property
not an ex. D lives in CA and has a random bank account in PA that contains money, D have never been to PA or any other conecction
Transient Presence in Forum— Tag Jurisdiction
court gets jurisdiction over D when voluntarily physically present in state and is personally served with process—exception to min contacts (Burnham v. Superior Court)
Subject Matter Jurisdiction
does court have authority to hear certain type of legal dispute?
Exclusive vs concurrent jurisdiction
Exclusive jurisdiction: one court system has legal authority to hear case
Concurrent Jurisdiction: both fed and state courts have legal authority to hear same case
P can chose where to file
federal jurisdiction must still exist
unless congress make fed jurisdiction exclusive it is generally concurrent ((Mims v. Arrow Financial Services, LLC)
Ways to get into fed court
diversity
fed question
supplemental
diversity for federal court jurisdiction (SMJ)
Amount in controversy: Total amount being sued must exceed 75,000
aggregated claims meet monetary threshold (A.F.A. Tours, Inc. v. Whitchurch )
Can also aggregate punitive damages
complete diversity: P and D cant be citizen of same state
induvial:
where domiciled: physical presence + intent to remain (mas v perry)
corps
state of incorporation AND PPB (nerve center)
LLC
Citizen is based on each of individual members
Collusive joinder: cannot fraudulently add/remove parties just to create diversity (Kramer v. Caribbean Mills, Inc. )
federal question for federal court jurisdiction (SMJ)
issue arise under—gravamen— is based of federal law, constitution, treaty
1. well pleaded complaint
Fed question must appear on the face of P complaint , and cannot be raised by D in defense ( Louisville & Nashville Railroad co V Mottley)
no implied federal question–have to be outright (Merrell Dow Pharm., Inc. v. Thompson)
2. fed issue must be real and substantial
Parties have to disagree about meaning/application of fed law not just facts (Grable & Sons Metal Products, Inc. v. Darue Eng’g & Manuf. (2005)
state law claims can qualify for fed when fed law created the cause of action or depends on substantial fed question (Empire Healthchoice Assurance, Inc. v. McVeigh (2006)
Federal statue motion does not automatically mean federal question (gunn v milton)
3. quiet title
Quiet title lawsuit: used to clear up claims on title of property to establish owner
Ex. Grable & Sons Metal Products, Inc. v. Darue Eng’g & Manuf
Issue can from federal govt entity
4. hypothical questions do not count
issue needs to be part of case (gunn v Milton)
supplemental for federal court jurisdiction (SMJ)
tagging on case/party to federal question or diversity case
claims (fed question)
Other claim must “arise out of same common nucleus of operative fact” (United Mine Workers of America v. Gibbs (1966)
Involves same event
parties (diversity)
D CAN bring new party to the suit if D2 actions arise under same incident (share nucleus) even if messes up diversity (Own Equipment v Kroger)
P CANT add additional parties if they mess up diversity and claim is based on diversity
SMJ for state courts: General vs limited jurisdiction
general: state courts can generally hear most types of cases unless federal law makes jurisdiction exclusive
limited: Topics only state can hear–
Divorce and probate are only state
supremacy clause
ederal law is supreme of land
State cant ignore or refus to apply federal law just bc dont agree with it (Howlett v Rose)
removal (from state to fed)
only D can remove ((Shamrock Oil & Gas Corp. v. Sheets (1941)) (Home Depot v. Jackson (2019)
Must be filed within 30 days of receiving
only done if fed court have have had original SMJ
so need diversity or fed question
diversity removal rule
D cannot remove diversify case if D is a citizen of the state where the case was filed
good faith test
court believes that P excess of 75 is correct
When removal is based on diversity, D can rely on the allegations when they have a reasonable/good-faith basis for the amount claimed (Dart Cherokee)
Changes to complaint and how effect removal
If D properly removes a case because P's complaint contains a federal claim, but P later amends the complaint to remove ALL federal claims, the federal court loses federal-question jurisdiction and must remand the remaining state-law claims to state court (Royal Canin v. Wullschleger)
direct vs collateral SMJ challenge * come back to
1. Direct challenge: objection raised during original case or direct appellate review
Ex. capron
2. Collateral challenge: attacks final judgment though new legal action
Hard to do can exception when blatantly clear the first case did not have subject matter J
when is SMJ determined?
Time lawsuit is filed is when look at state citizenship
Cannot give shares to someone for the sake of keep diversity (Grupo Dataflux v. Atlas Global Group, L.P. (2004) but CAN dismiss a person with the same citizenship as D (Caterpillar, Inc. v. Lewis (1996))
Drop of party need to be done before trailcitizenship is measured when lawsuit begins
Jurisdictional vs claim processing rule
jurisdiction rule
determines if court has authority
cannot be waived
if violated court lack jurisdiction
ex. amount in controversey
claim processing rule
procedural requirement for moving forward case
can be waived
ex. time limit to file answer to lawsuit
RDA vs REA
1. Rules of decision act
Requires federal courts to apply state substantive law when there is no controlling federal law.
Outcome determinative
Comes from Erie v. Tompkins. Goal: federal courts should generally apply the same substantive law that a state court would apply.
2. Rule of enabling act
Procedural rules
Allows fed court to apply federal procedural law
Fed court sitting in diversity—when to use state rule
apply state law when issue is substantive (Erie)
and no direct conflict with FRCP
when is issue substantive?
when its outcome determinative—significantly changed outcome (Byrd v. Blue Ridge Electric
ex.
1. State statute of limitations ( Ragan v. Merchants Transfer & Warehouse Co.)
2. Who can bring a lawsuit (Woods v. Interstate Realty Co. (1949)
If state bars plaintiff from suing in state court so does fed
3. Reviewing excessness of jury verdict– (damage awards) (Gasperini v. Center for Humanities, Inc.)
“shocks the conscious rule"- standard used by judges to evaluate in jury award excessive damages
4. Conflict of laws rules–apply forum state law conflict of law rule–the state its sittingin (Klaxon)
when is issue procedural?
1. Discovery (Sibbach v. Wilson & Co.)
2. Service of process (Hanna v. Plumer)--enforced by (Burlington Northern R. Co. v. Woods)
3. pleadings (Berk v. Choy)
4. Enforcing Forum selection clause (Stewart Organization, Inc. v. Ricoh Corp)
5. Damages available in class action suits (Shady Grove Orthopedic Associates v. Allstate Ins. Co.)
6. Overwhelming federal interest (Byrd V Blue ridge rual elecntic cooperative)
Fed Court sitting in diversity—when to use FRCP
Use FRCP whenever state and valid federal law (is not silent) are in direct conflict (address same issue and both cant be used)—regardless if substantive or procedural (Berk v. Choy)
Fed court sitting in diversity—which law to chose when two state laws are in conflict
apply forum state law conflict of law rule–the state its sittingin (Klaxon)
Choice-of-law rules (also known as conflict-of-laws rules) are the legal principles that courts use to determine which jurisdiction’s laws apply to a lawsuit when the case involves more than one state or country.
Fed court sitting in diversity—when judicial common law conflicting with state law
use state law (erie)
predicting law (under federal diversity cases deciding state law claim)
Sometimes issue involves law that has not been established by state supreme court
Supreme court has to guess what state supreme court would say
Pull out crystal ball and try to see what you think state supreme court would think about this issue
ways to predict law
Dicda–not a ruling just gratuitous words in opinion
Words
Part of opinion that explain the ideas but dont have to follow it
Look at this to try to guess holding
Restatement
Certification–asking state supreme court what they would do
when to use federal common law (every federal issue)
There is a strong federal interest, AND
Uniform federal law is necessary, AND
There is no federal statute that already resolves the issue.
ex. Clearfield trust v united states, Boyle v United Technologies
which law should state court deciding federal claim (reverse Erie) use?
state courts to apply federal substantive a when they hear cases based on federal rights or admiralty claim
the court may not apply state law to limit the scope of federal rights. (Dice v Arkon)
state courts cannot use strict procedural rules that interferes with core of federal right/alter outcome of case state MUST apply federal law instead (Brown v Western Railway of alabama)
Venue
proper geographic court/district for lawsuit
not jurisdiction, figured out after jurisdiction
federal venue
§1391 (b)
(b)(1): where d resides
district in which any defendant resides, if all defendants are residents of the State in which the district is located
(b)(2): substantial part of events
events or omissions give rise to claim
Can have multiple districts where important actions of suit happened (Bates v. C & S Adjusters, Inc. (2d Cir. 1992)
(b)(3): any district where any D is subject to PJ
Only go to b(3) if you don’t have b(1) or b(2)-- do NOT just get to chose b(3)
types of venue transfer
improper venue
plaintiff files a case in a court that completely lacks proper venue
the court can dismiss it
OR transfer to proper court if (where it could have been brought originally—pj & SMJ) in the interest of justice
Goldlawr holds that a court lacking personal jurisdiction can transfer a case—but it does not allow a case to be transferred to a court that lacks personal jurisdiction.
proper venue
Forum non Conveniens
more convenient/apprioate court
improper venue Transfer
p or d moving case to another federal district bc its current venue is improper
done when:
could have originally filed lawsuit there ( (Hoffman v. Blaski (1960) or parties consented and
another proper venue is more convenient or in the interest of justice
consider convinces of parties, witnesses, interest of justice
can transfer even if court doesn’t have Personal jurisdiction over d Goldlawr, Inc. v. Heiman (1962)
*root and branch rule
Root and branch rule for Transfer
law that would have applied in the original court travels with the transfer case ( ferrens v. John Deere Co. (1990
including statue of limitation (ferrens v. John Deere Co. (1990)
“whole case gets pulled out by the roots”
Multidistrict Litigation (MDL)
combined similar cases for pretrial proceedings
cases remain separate lawsuits but grouped together for pre tail phase—discovery (execon, Inc. v. Milberg Weiss Bershad Hynes & Lerach)
NOT a class action
Bellwether trials
judge chose few representative cases to go to trail—helps parties decide if case will win
Forum non Conveniens
court have jurisdiction and proper venue, but another court is much more appropriate and convenient ((Gulf Oil Corp. v. Gilbert)
convinces is not based on if rules are better
ex. (Piper Aircraft Co. v. Reyno)
Judge dismisses case
Can dismiss without prejudice –so can file in more appropriate venue (cannot transfer that is differnt thing)
reasnaoble notice
if d is reasonably ascertainable must have reasonably calculated notice Mullane V Central Hanover bank)
Reasonably ascertainable: D can be found though reasonable diligence
Reasonably calculated: using method of notice that sensible person would expect to successfully reach D
Reasonable notice for all entities (human, copr, bank)
. Reasonable notice does not mean D has received it
As long as P used reasonably calculated method (Dusenbery v. United States)
improper service
legal papers are delivered in manner that breaks local, state, federal rules
Can’t use fraudulent means to service or trick someone in jurisdiction (Tickle)
Reasonably calculated methods
snail mail is reasonably ascertainable
P can name someone related to/known as service of agent for D if D consent to arraignment in contact (National Equip. Rental, Ltd. v. Szukhent)
“Stuck with what you sign”
nOT reasonably calculated methods
Legal newspapers do not count as reasonable notice (Mennonite Board of Missions v. Adams)
When p knows there is a problem with the method of service that outside control of D cannot rely on this as fair notice (Greene v. Lindsey)
returned mail as unclaimed that is not reasonably calculated notice (Jones v. Flowers)
Mullane rule
cannot take property/rights away without reasonable notice and hance for D to respond
Mullane v Central Hanover Bank
If statues says needs personal service then do that (Grabble and sons)
Etiquette
P cannot use fraudulent means to lure person into jurisdiction and serve them
Can “smoke people out” or trickery when already in jurisdiction
Immunity
legal shield that protects certain people from being served with a lawsuit when they enter a state solely to participate in an ongoing court case
P, D, lawyers, witness are protected
Does not fulfill tag jurisdiction
Does not extend to people voluntarily going to state
4d: waiver of service
Wavier: no longer have to personal serve people if D will accept service and waiver requirements
Pressure on D to waiver bc will have to pay Ps feeds for service
4h: serving entity
well integrated into the organization who holds substantial responsibility
1. Officer
2. Managing agent
3. Authorized agent
Ins. Co. of N.A. v. S/S Hellenic Challenger
Default Judgment
Default judgment: P is automatic winner bc D failed to respond
Before trial
Strategies to object to PJ and avoid default judgment
1. Ghost them (collateral Attack)
Ignore suit and let it go to default judgment and wait for P to being judgment to home state to get money
D now speaks up and say didnt have PJ–works bc D never made appearance to consset to PJ
2. Special Appearance
appear in court solely to challenge PJ without consenting to courts general jurisdiction
Judge can say I do then D is stuck
pleadings must be what to survive 12(b)(6)
short and plain—Who, what, where, when, why and plausibility standard
plausibility standard
complaint does not need detailed factual allegations but it must contain enough factual allegations to state claim that is plausible on its face–not just conceivable (Twombly)(Iqbal)
Only need to provide factual basis for claim (Johnson v. City of Shelby, Miss.)
Don't need to prove legal theory
Don't even need specific facts in claim (Erickson v. Pardus)–just something to show its plausible
Alternative and inconsistent pleading
an plead alternative and inconsistent pleadings in cause of claim
Can plead two different stories, doesn't mean they can use second version against you
Do it bc going to anticipate the first one wont pass
Heighten pleading standard for fraud and mistake claims (FRCP 9)
if pleading fraud–the fraud must be explained in detail have to plead in court (Kearns v. Ford Motor Co)
Need particularity– who what where when why different then needing to make it plausible claim under rule 8(b)
Private securities litigation reform act (FRCP 10(b)(5))
Law requires public trading companies to be honest and make discolors to certain entities to can inform people about honest risk of investing
when pleading fraud the facts have to be more than plausible but show actual fraud (Tellabs, Inc. v. Makor Issues & Rights, Ltd.)
Pleading damages: general vs specific (p)
General/direct: damages that naturally and ordinary result from wrongful act
Does not need to be specifically stated in pleading
Specific/consequential: additional losses that result from the injury or breach but do not necessarily occur in every case
Ex. hit by car had to go to the hospital did not get to submit plea sued for malpractice–the mal pratice is the special
Must be clearly/specifically stated Rule 9(g) in pleading
(Ziervogel v. Royal Packing Co. (Mo. Ct. App. 1949)
Punitive damages: just need to prove more than negligence
Does not need to be specifically stated in pleading
Prayer for relief (p)
Complaint must contain P specific remedies , damages for the relief sought 8(a)(3)
Judgment cannot exceed or differ for what was demanded in pleadings 54(c)d
pre answer motions—pleading stage motions (d)
Motion for more definite answer: Asking court to order P to clarify a complaint that is too vague or ambiguous to answer
12(e)
Motion to strike: Procedural request asking court to remove parts of pleading that are irrelevant, blasphemy, material from pleading
12(f)
Answering the complaint (d)
Admits: says facts are true
Denies:
Specific: defines certain parts of paragraphs
General: denies every thing in the complaint
If not denied then its admitted automatically
Insufficient information: lack enough info to admit or deny allegations
Affirmative defenses (rule8)
Admits allegation of complaints but challenges P right to being the action by introducing new facts to negate claim
Need to explicitly put it in answer the affirmative defense (8(c)) (Ingraham v. United States (5th Cir. 1987)
Ex. consent, statute of limitations
The reply (P)
Pleading filed by P in response to D answer
Not normally required
Required under rule 7
Required for counterclaims–p must answer counter claim or if court demands it
Motion for judgment on the pleading
Have to make a response or will be poured out
D must properly admit or deny allegations (Kegerise v. Susquehanna Township School Dist. (M.D. Pa. 2016))
Amendments to pleading
: Adding things that already existed
Parties can change or add to pleading during litigation rule 15 Beeck v. Aquaslide ‘N’ Dive Corp. (8th Cir. 1977)
As long as reasonable when you filed it and then after discovery you find new info its understandable why new facts would happen
why amend pleadings
1. An unpleaded issue that the other party gave consent to/didn't deny is treated as though it was in the original pleading Moore v. Moore (D.C. 1978)
3. a party may amend pleading if court allows it or opposite party gives consent Beeck v. Aquaslide ‘N’ Dive Corp. (8th Cir. 1977)
2. Statute of limitations
Allows amended pleading to be treated as thought was filed on the date of the original pleading when:
claim or defense is added and arises under same conduct, transaction, or occurrence as original pleading Schiavone v. Fortune (1986)
ex. correcting facts and adding facts
When served the wrong person and the correct D knew about it Krupski v. Costa Crociere S.P.A. (2010)
supplemental pleadings
adding things that happened after filing complaint
Amends new things have happened since to claim and be allowed to add them
ex. new wrongful acts and new damages
Frivolous pleadings
Lawyers and parties are assumed to be truth and do the diligence to make sure claims are true rule 11, 23.1 Hadges v. Yonkers Racing Corp. (2d Cir. 1995)
Must verify there is factual and legal basis, if not have to pay for other sides attorney fees and other sanctions rule 11
types of frivolous pleadings
Factual frivolousness: no factual support, facts are impossible, nonsensical, contradictory
Legal frivolousness: no recognizable legal basis for claim
Rule 12(b)(6) Motion to dismiss
request by D to judge to throw out lawsuit before trial
writ (pre judgment remedies)
freeze the assets before they can D get rid of them or spend them and final judgment though ex parte
Way to prevent people from being “judgment proof”-- can get property before hidden
writ for repo cases
Security interest: unti l pay off and receive lean you don't own item
Ex. buy car with a mortgage these are security interest for seller–lean on property until you pay full price
Default on loan and get sued by seller and ask judge ex parte to get remedies and product in good conation–mena tot project for
Mathews v. Eldridge
writ for repo cases non repo
Sue you for tort has nothing to do with property–i want to freeze property bc i think i win cases and i need damages paid for by you property
Doesn’t have any investment in product but using it for solve remedies
joinder
Combining multiple claims, cause of action, or parties into single lawsuit
Allow joinder bc want to avoid multiplicity–we don't want to have multiple lawsuits about the same basic thing
joinders must have Rule 17
Real party and interests: Person who actually suffered harm or owns the rights must be the one to bring the suit
Ellis Canning Co.
Standing: Person challenging it has standing to complain about it
Stake in the case Sprint communications Co.
Entities can sell claims to the assigned person and be sued as them
Capacity: person has Capacity to sue or be sued, of age and mentally cable
Guardians can stand in the shoes of people who cant
Work product protection (discovery)
lets you keep your lawsuit materials and legal strategies secret from the other side during discovery, unless you give up that right or the other side proves they absolutely need it
how to overcome work product protections
showing substantial need to ensure visual evidence has not been edited and cannot find equivalent evidence anywhere else (DiMichel V. South Buffalo Ry. Co.)
Parties have to be under oath viewing evidence/deciding the truthfulness of the evidence
motion of summary judgment (after discovery)
asking judge to rule in favor of one party without holding full trial–
judge must view evidence in “light most favorable to non-moving party” and decide if reasonable rational jury could favor in non-moving party (rational fact finder test)
not deciding facts but deciding if jury could side with non moving party
Cannot grant motion of summary judgment based on evidence/facts that are mere assumptions (Alderman V Baltimore & Ohio R. Co)
Contemporaneous Object Rule
counsel must object to judges decision introduction of evidence, or instructions at the exact moment and explain why (Alexander V. Kramer Bros. Freight Line, Inc)
cant go to appeals to ty to reserves burden when it could have already been done in lower court
USE IT OR LOSE IT
Plain error appellate review
allows an appeals court to fix a massive, obvious mistake made during a trial, even though the losing side's lawyer completely forgot to object to it at the time. (Alexander V. Kramer Bros. Freight Line, Inc)
general verdict for vs special verdict form
General verdict form: directly choosing winner, asking who wins and how much they win–jury doesn't need to explain reasoning
Special verdict form: indirectly choosing winner, step by step checklist of factual questions yes/no, then judge uses answers to calculate who wins
Judge can take back special verdict and ask jury for general verdict if questions on special verdict were too confusing (Diniero v. United States Line Co )
Allen charge
: judge putting pressure on deadlock jurors, who are deadlock over long period of time, to go back in and reconsider positions–listen to the majority
jury deliberation rules
Jurors only discuss common knowledge and use life experience to judge evidence/witnesses if it was present in court. (Head V Hargrave)
Jurors cannot use personal experience to invent new facts that were not presented or bring outside facts (Texas Employers’s Ins. Ass’n V. Price)
Jury verdict cannot be reversed when it is based on an inference that is supported by substance evidence and is not completely unreasonable (Lavender V Kurn)
Res Judicata
parties cannot reopen or relitigate same dispute
Parties cannot attack final judgment over lack of jurisdiction if didnt