Torts I Key Cases (Chapters 1–5)

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/25

flashcard set

Earn XP

Description and Tags

A 26-card vocabulary review covering key cases, fact cues, and legal rules from Chapters 1 through 5 of Torts I.

26 Terms

1
New cards

Brown v. Kendall

For accidental injury from a lawful act (such as separating fighting dogs with a stick and accidentally striking a bystander), the plaintiff must establish the defendant’s lack of ordinary care.

2
New cards

Spano v. Perini Corp.

Blasting carries strict liability for resulting damage (such as garage damage caused by vibrations) even without proof of negligence or a physical invasion by debris.

3
New cards

Garratt v. Dailey

Knowledge that contact is substantially certain can establish battery intent (such as when a child moves a chair just before a woman sits and falls); actual knowledge must be determined.

4
New cards

Talmage v. Smith

Intent to cause tortious contact can transfer from the intended target to the person actually struck (such as when an object thrown at one boy strikes another).

5
New cards

Fisher v. Carrousel Motor Hotel

Offensive contact with an object closely connected to the plaintiff’s person (such as offensively snatching a plate from a guest’s hand) can constitute battery.

6
New cards

Western Union Telegraph Co. v. Hill

Apparent present ability to carry out threatened contact matters to whether apprehension of imminent contact is reasonable (such as reaching across a counter while threatening to touch a woman).

7
New cards

Parvi v. City of Kingston

Later amnesia does not defeat proof that the plaintiff was aware of confinement while it occurred.

8
New cards

State Rubbish Collectors Ass'n v. Siliznoff

Intentional infliction of severe emotional distress can support liability without an assault or bodily injury (such as when collectors use coercive threats of violence to demand payment).

9
New cards

Katko v. Briney

A landowner cannot use force likely to cause death or serious bodily harm solely to protect property (such as using a spring gun inside an unoccupied farmhouse).

10
New cards

Bonkowski v. Arlan's Department Store

Recognized an investigative privilege to stop a suspected shoplifter in the immediate vicinity based on reasonable suspicion, manner, and duration; resolved on insufficient evidence of intent to confine.

11
New cards

Surocco v. Geary

Public necessity can completely privilege destruction reasonably necessary to prevent a public calamity (such as destroying a house as a firebreak to stop a spreading fire).

12
New cards

Vincent v. Lake Erie Transportation Co.

Private necessity can privilege staying moored to a dock during a storm while requiring compensation for the actual damage caused.

13
New cards

United States v. Carroll Towing Co.

Learned Hand’s breach calculation compares the burden of precaution with the probability and gravity of loss; if B<P×LB < P \times L, omitting the precaution can be negligent.

14
New cards

Vaughan v. Menlove

Reasonable care is measured objectively against ordinary prudence; the defendant’s personal best judgment does not set the standard.

15
New cards

Robinson v. Lindsay

A child engaging in an inherently dangerous activity characteristically undertaken by adults (such as operating a powerful snowmobile) is held to an adult standard of care.

16
New cards

Breunig v. American Family Insurance Co.

A narrow exception exists for sudden mental incapacity without forewarning, but evidence of earlier warning or notice supports liability.

17
New cards

Trimarco v. Klein

Safety custom (such as using safety glazing in bathtub enclosures) is relevant evidence of reasonable care, but does not conclusively establish breach.

18
New cards

Hodges v. Carter

An attorney who exercises ordinary skill and care and uses best judgment is generally not liable for an honest error on a genuinely unsettled legal question.

19
New cards

Moore v. The Regents of the University of California

A physician must disclose personal research and financial interests that may affect medical judgment, but excised cells cannot support a claim for conversion.

20
New cards

Martin v. Herzog

An unexcused statutory violation can establish negligence under the per se approach, provided the violation contributed causally to the injury.

21
New cards

Byrne v. Boadle

Res ipsa loquitur allows the event itself (such as a barrel of flour falling from a warehouse) to support an inference of negligence when it ordinarily would not occur without negligence and circumstances point to the defendant.

22
New cards

Perkins v. Texas & New Orleans R. Co.

Factual causation requires evidence that reasonable care probably would have changed the outcome; proof of excessive train speed alone is insufficient.

23
New cards

Hill v. Edmonds

Separate negligent acts can both be factual causes when they combine to produce an injury (such as an unlit truck struck by a careless driver) and removing either would have prevented it.

24
New cards

Anderson v. Minneapolis, St. P. & S. St. M. Ry.

Each independently sufficient cause can count as a factual cause when multiple causes merge (such as two merging fires that each could have destroyed property independently).

25
New cards

Doull v. Foster

But-for is the ordinary factual-causation test; independently sufficient causes call for a distinct instruction rather than a substantial-factor test.

26
New cards

Summers v. Tice

Alternative liability shifts the burden of proof to each negligent defendant to show he did not cause the injury when two defendants act negligently and the injuring actor is uncertain.