1/32
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Central argument
-Culture is one of the most important concepts in the social sciences, but it is also one of the most difficult to define
-The problem is not simply that scholars have failed to find the correct definition, the authors argue that the disagreements reflect genuine differences in what scholars want to investigate
-Definitions of culture reveal the assumptions, priorities, and methods of the people using them
How have different scholars refered to culture
-A complete way of life
-Artistic and intellectual refinement
-Shared values and beliefs
-Patterns of behavior
-Systems of symbols
-Knowledge transmitted between generations
-Membership in a social group
-Processes of meaning-making
-Relations of power and inequality
-An unstable collection of competing identities and practices
Culture as an empty sign
-The word culture is a signifier whose relationship to its signified, what it represents, continually changes
-It is an empty vessel that people fill with meaning, it is not literally meaningless, because its possible meanings have developed historically and are socially recognizable
-Culture is a moving target because actual cultures continually change and the academic concept of culture also changes
Historical origins of culture
-The word originated in the Latin colere, meaning to till or cultivate the ground
-Its early meanings were connected to agriculture and the cultivation of land
-Just as people could cultivate soil, they could supposedly cultivate the mind, taste, morality, or spirit
3 broad historical meanings
-Culture as cultivation and refinement
-Culture as artistic production
-Culture as a way of life
Culture as cultivation and refinement
-Culture referred to a process of intellectual, spiritual, and aesthetic development
-A cultured person was educated, refined, and familiar with what society considered its greatest intellectual and artistic achievements
-This definition tends to be hierarchical. Some people are judged to possess more culture than others, while certain works of art or forms of knowledge are treated as culturally superior
What is culture connected to in the culture as cultivation and refinement meaning
-Education
-Personal refinement
-Literature
-Fine art
-Music
-Theater
-Intellectual achievement
Culture as artistic production
-Identifies culture with artistic and intellectual activities themselves
-Under this definition, culture consists of literature, music, painting, sculpture, theater, and other creative practices
-This use remains common in government, journalism, and everyday language
Culture as a way of life
-Refers to the characteristic way of life of a particular group --> all human groups possess culture, rather than some individuals possessing more culture than others
-This definition challenges the idea that one civilization could be measured as more cultured than another
-The shift from singular "culture" to plural "cultures" was therefore intellectually and politically important, it encouraged scholars to understand groups on their own terms
Practices within culture in the culture as a way of life meaning
-Beliefs
-Values
-Customs
-Language
-Knowledge
-Food
-Clothing
-Social expectations
-Family structures
-Rituals
-Technologies
-Everyday behavior
Society, culture, and civilization
-Society refers to people and the social relationships connecting them
-Culture refers to the meanings, practices, beliefs, and products created within those relationships
-Civilization can refer either to technologically and politically complex societies or to their scientific and technical achievements
Classifications of definitions of culture according to Kroeber and Kluckhohn
-Enumerative-descriptive: the elements culture contains
-Historical: traditions transmitted across generations
-Normative: values and rules that guide behavior
-Psychological: learning, habits, adaptation, and problem-solving
-Structural: the organization and relationships among cultural elements
-Genetic: how culture originates through ideas, symbols, and artifacts
The Kroeber and Kluckhohn's classification
-These categories show that scholars were not necessarily describing completely different objects, they often emphasized different aspects of culture
-They attempted to combine these elements into a comprehensive definition: they describe culture as explicit and implicit patterns of behavior that are learned and transmitted through symbols
-These patterns include historically developed ideas and values, appear in artifacts, result from human action, and influence future action
How does the classification present culture
-Learned rather than biologically inherited
-Shared among group members
-Historically transmitted
-Organized into patterns
-Expressed through symbols
-Connected to values
-Visible in behavior and artifacts
-Both produced by action and capable of shaping action
Structural definitions
-Structural approaches treat culture as an organized system: cultural elements do not exist separately, they form patterns
-This system might consist of behaviors, beliefs and values, knowledge, symbols, social rules, artifacts, and relationships among these elements
-The main question is: What is culture made of, and how are its elements organized?
-The difficulty is that scholars disagree about what belongs within the system
Functional definitions
-Functional approaches emphasize what culture does
-Culture may help people adapt to their environment, meet physical and social needs, solve recurring problems, coordinate group life, maintain social order, communicate, connect individuals to society, and preserve the group across generations
-The main question is: What purpose does culture serve?
-These perspectives are often combined --> culture is understood as a learned and organized system of meanings, values, practices, and behaviors that helps a group maintain itself and respond to its environment
Objective culture
-Objective culture includes things that can be observed or physically encountered:
--Tools
--Roads
--Buildings
--Technologies
--Clothing
--Art
--Food
--Written documents
--Ritual behavior
Subjective culture
-Subjective culture includes internal or symbolic frameworks:
--Beliefs
--Values
--Assumptions
--Categories
--Knowledge
--Expectations
--Interpretations
--Systems of meaning
Problems with summary definitions
-Comprehensive definitions are appealing because they create the impression of clarity, however the authors argue that they often create new problems
--A definition focused only on knowledge might exclude actions with no obvious symbolic intention
--A definition focused on meaning could overlook physical objects or material conditions
--A definition tied to nations might ignore major differences within national borders
-Summary definitions risk creating an image of cultures as internally uniform, clearly bounded and unchanging --> oversimplification
3 major contemporary turns
-Interpretive turn
-Intergroup turn
-Critical or cultural-studies turn
Interpretive turn
-Associated with Geertz, who defines culture as the webs of significance human beings create and inhabit
-Traditional definitions often describe culture as a completed system of beliefs or behaviors, interpretive approaches instead emphasize the process through which people continually create and recreate meaning
-Culture is not simply something people possess, it is something they produce through communication and interpretation
Relationship between culture and communication in the interpretive turn
-A traditional approach says culture influences how people communicate
-An interpretive approach adds that communication continually creates culture
-This creates a circular relationship, where cultural meanings lead to communication and action, which create the reproduction or change which change the cultural meanings
-Any description of a culture is only a temporary snapshot
Ways in how any description of a culture oversimplifies
-Essentializing: treating one description as the culture's complete essence
-Reifying: treating a changing process as a fixed and permanent object
Intergroup turn
-The intergroup perspective defines culture through membership and identification rather than primarily through national or geographical boundaries
-This approach is closely connected to social identity theory, which argues that people possess both personal identities and group-based identities
-A situation becomes "cultural" when it activates group-based categories and identities
-The intergroup approach is valuable because it recognizes that culture is not always connected to nationality
What does the intergroup turn ask
-How do people identify with groups?
-How do groups define their members?
-How are people categorized by others?
-How do groups distinguish themselves from outsiders?
-When does group identity influence behavior?
-How do groups compete for positive recognition?
What does social identity theory propose
-People seek a positive social identity
-They develop this identity partly by comparing their own group with relevant outside groups
-If their group identity appears negative, they may leave the group, join another group, or attempt to improve the group's status
Critical turn
-Critical theory and cultural studies shift attention from what culture is to whose interests it serves
-Earlier approaches often presented culture as a shared system producing social unity
-Critical approaches emphasize that members of a society do not possess equal power to define shared meanings
What do groups struggle over
-Which identities are considered normal
-Which histories are remembered
-Whose art counts as legitimate culture
-How minorities are represented
-What information appears in the media
-Which behaviors receive approval
-Who controls cultural institutions
-Who has access to material and symbolic resources
Culture as a site of contestation
-It is where meanings are produced, challenged, imposed, and resisted
-Ideology is central to this approach, which refers to frameworks through which groups interpret and represent social reality
-These frameworks may support existing hierarchies by making unequal arrangements seem natural or inevitable
Postmodern challenge
-Postmodern thought questions whether any culture possesses a stable essence or clear boundary
-Scholars examine the tensions and differences within cultures
-They are especially interested in people who exist between established categories, such as migrants
-They also emphasize reflexivity: scholars must recognize that they are not neutral observers
What do postmodern approaches emphasize
-Fragmentation
-Contradiction
-Hybridity
-Multiple perspectives
-Marginalized voices
-Unstable meanings
-Cultural borderlands
-The researcher's influence on the description
Ethical and political importance of definitions
-How scholars define culture affects how they represent people --> it is not only an academic choice
-Describing a culture as internally uniform may silence minority perspectives
-Defining it according to national boundaries may ignore migration and hybridity
-Treating culture as fixed encourages stereotyping
-Presenting one group's values as universal can marginalize other groups
What should scholars ask
-What does this definition include?
-What does it exclude?
-Which discipline produced it?
-What research questions does it support?
-Whose experiences does it represent?
-Which power relations does it conceal?
-What political or ethical consequences might follow from using it?