1/20
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What are the two key questions to ask when evaluating any given argument?
Are the premises actually true?
(or, at minimum, would it be rational to accept them, in light of our evidence?)
IF the premises were true, would the conclusion have to be true as well? (or how well is the conclusion supported?)
(or, at minimum, would the truth of the premises make the conclusions truth probable?)
If the argument dosen’t pass both of these, you reject it, rejecting it docent mean disproving or disagreeing with its conclusion necessarily, you’re just finding the ones that have the rationally strongest arguments.
When is an argument deductively valid?
Goal: Prove/guarantee that the conclusion is true
Premise: Elvis was the first U.S. president
Premise: Elvis was 12 ft. tall.
Conclusion: The first U.S. president was 12 ft. tall.
VALID because if the premises are true, the conclusion must be true
Validity has nothing to do with if the premises, or conclusion are ACTUALLY true
only about the relationship between them.
In this imaginary world, must the conclusion be true? If yes, than the argument is valid.
SOUND when it is valid, and all of the premises are true (Elvis argument is unsound)
Valid when: If the premises are true, the conclusion must be true. (Invalid when the conclusion could possibly be false, while the premises are true.)
Inductive Strength (strong vrs weak)
Goal: Show that the conclusion is probably true (not guaranteeing)
Premise: there’s a lot of smoke coming from a house
Premise: there’s a firetruck pulling up to it.
Conclusion: that house is probably on fire
STRONG: if the premises are true, the conclusion is probably true
But the conclusion still isn’t guaranteed, what if the smoke is coming from a burn pile in the backyard?
Also in imaginary worlds, if the premises make sense in an imaginary world they are strong
COGENT: Strong, and all of its premises are true
Not made up worlds, so not cogent if false premises.
What is cosmological fine-tuning?
The observation that the fundamental physical constants and laws of our universe fall within an extremely narrow, life-permitting range (cosmological constant, gravitational constant)
Pretty much the fine tuning of the universe is exactly perfect
The values oof these constants and quantities fall into an extremely narrow life permitting range of values
if you were to alter these at all, the balance would be destroyed and life could not exist in the universe
Some contemporary thinkers hold that such ‘fine-tuning’ is good evidence that this
universe was intelligently designed. How do they argue for that claim?
P1) The universe is fine-tuned for life
Around 24 fundamental physical constants have exactly the right values for life to exist
Even the smallest changes would make it so that life couldn't exist
P2) The odds that a random or unplanned process would produce a fine-tuned universe are astronomically low
P3) The odds that a supernatural intelligence would design a fine-tuned universe are comparatively high in opposition to it being a purely random or unplanned process
What scientific theory presents a serious problem for the fine-tuning argument? If that theory were true, how or why would that count against the argument?
The Multiverse Theory suggests that this universe is one of many
SO if this theory is true, it would prove P2 - “The odds that a random or unplanned process would produce a fine-tuned universe are astronomically low” false, because the probability that such a multiverse would contain at least one fine-tuned universe is quite high
Perhaps P2 is the best reason to support the argument, but there are several reasons to suspect that its false
True or false: If an event takes place that had an incredibly low probability of coming
about by chance, then that event is more likely to have been brought about by design.
FALSE
A low probability of something occurring by chance dosent automatically establish that it was designed
Emily and Nancy example - Who made the pattern?
The pattern itself might be very improbable if produced randomly
But that alone docent tell us who made it
Once we know about the potential creators, we can compare the probabilities
Emilys interests and abilities make her more likely than Nancy
In order to know how likely (or unlikely) it is that a supernatural intelligence would
create a fine-tuned universe, what other sorts of things would we have to know
already? And why would we need to know those sorts of things?
What?
What supernatural intelligences are like - goals, intentions, tendencies
How likely a supernatural intelligence is to create a universe at all
How likely such an intelligence would be able to create a universe with the particular conditions necessary for life
Other possible universes that such an intelligence could have created
Why?
Depends on comparing probabilities
If were claiming that a fine-tuned universe is more likely if a supernatural intelligence exists, we need some basis for what a supernatural intelligence would be likely to do
Simply saying “God could create a fine-tuned universe” docent tell us that God would probably create one
Possibility isn’t probability. Knowing that god could create a fine-tuned universe docent tell us how likely God would be to do so.
True or false: The fact that {God is typically thought of as a being who would be willing
and able to create a universe like ours} counts in favor of the fine-tuning argument.
True
God is understood as both powerful enough to create a universe like our and willing to create such a universe
Fine tuned universe is something we would expect if God from exists
Only counts as evidence if we have some reason to think god would actually be likely to create such a universe
Being able vrs would do it
The ‘basic background’ for the ontological argument, as described in lecture, is the way
in which the God of traditional theism is traditionally conceived or defined. What is that
traditional conception/definition?
God is the greatest possible being - unsurpassably perfect being - a being than which nothing greater can be conceived
In other words, God is perfect in every way and possesses all the greatest possible qualities
This definition is the starting point for the ontological argument, which argues that such a being must exist
God is
-Omnipotent (all-powerful)
-Omniscient (all-knowing)
-Omnibenevolent (perfectly good)
-Absolutely Independent
-And unlimited (etc?)
What is the ‘basic claim’ made by the ontological argument, as formulated in lecture?
It is self-contradictory (both can’t be true at the same time opposes each other) to deny that the greatest possible being actually exists (i.e., the concept of god, by itself, entails the existence of god)
God Is defined as the greatest possible being - nothing greater could exist
If God existed only as an idea and not in reality, then we could imagine something greater: that same being actually existing
So, the argument says, denying that God exists contradicts the very definition of God.
What is the ‘classical’ argument (namely, Anselm’s argument) for that claim? (No need
to exactly reproduce the version presented in lecture, but do your best to clearly explain
the basic content and logic of the argument.)
P1) God is the greatest possible being that can be conceived
P2) God exists as a concept in our minds (we can know he exists we understand)
P3) A being that exists both in reality and in ur minds is greater than one that exists only in our minds
P4) So, if God only is a concept in out minds, we can conceive of a being greater (one that exists in reality)
P5) Impossible of conceiving anything greater than God because God is already supposed to be the greatest possible being
Therefore, God exists in reality, cannot be merely an idea
Ex:
P4 : If god is just an idea, nothing more (P), then we can conceive of something greater than god (Q)
P5: Not Q
—-------------------------------
Conclusion → Not P
Anselm’s colleague Gaunilo argued that Anselm’s line of thinking led to absurd
consequences. How did Gaunilo go about trying to prove that point?
Gaunilo used a style of argument called reductio absurdum
Using Anselm’s logic, you can prove crazy things that are not true
Given the existence of an idea, it doesn’t follow that a thing corresponding to that idea really exists (you can’t just think everything exists because they are the ‘greatest possible’ x, y, z)
Ex: the greatest possible island
Some philosophers think Anselm’s argument fails because (on their view) the traditional
concept of God is not coherent. On what grounds do they make that latter claim?
“that than which nothing greater can be conceived”
The traditional god has properties that cannot all consistently belong to the same being
If there’s no coherent being that possesses all of these properties, Anselm’s definition of God docent successfully describe a possible being
His argument can’t establish that such a being exists
Ex: can omniscience, omnipotence, perfect goodness, and necessary existence all be combined?
Ex: omniscience and human free will. If God infallibly knows everything that will happen, do humans actually have the ability to act freely?
Evil
Something that is seriousy bad or undesirable, including suffering and wrongdoing.
Moral Evil
Results from the actions or choices of moral agents
Ex: murder, torture, abuse, war
Moral evil is caused by agent’s choices
Natural Evil
Results from natural processes rather than someone’s morally wrong choice
Ex: earthquakes, hurricanes, diseases, birth defects, natural disasters
Caused by nature
Necessary Evil
Evil that cannot be avoided if some greater good is to exist
The evil is necessary for the greater good
The concept becomes important when asking whether God could have created a world with less evil
Supreme Good
The highest/greatest possible good
Ultimate goal or highest value in life that all other actions and desires aim to achieve
Best possible world
The possible world containing the greatest overall amount/value of good, given the relevant constraints.
This becomes important because of the question: if an omnipotent and perfectly good God created the world, would God have to create the best possible world?
What is the logical argument from evil? (simplified rendition)
If god exists, god is omnipotent (unlimited power), omniscient (all knowing), and perfectly good
If god is omnipotent, god has the power to prevent evil
If god is omniscient, god knows that evil exists,
If god is perfectly good, god would want to prevent evil
evil exists
therefore, god can’t exist because the existence of evil contradicts the traditional concept of god
God and evil can’t logically coexist