1/46
Looks like no tags are added yet.
how were crowds viewed historically?
seen as “mad mobs” - Le Bon
“an individual in a crowd is a grain of sand amid other grains of sand. which the wind stirs up at will”
no personal responsibility
what are some types of crowds?
sports crowds
large cultural events
emergencies
collective action (riots)
online posting
what is submergence?
individuals in the crowd lose their sense of personal identity, along with control and responsibility of their actions
what is suggestion?
crowd members become susceptible to any passing idea or emotion
Le Bon believed these come from the ‘radical unconscious’ - primitive substrate of our mind
(cognitive aspect)
what is contagion?
these ideas and emotions sweep through the crowd - making crowd behaviour primitive and meaningless
(emotional aspect)
what are some criticisms of the “irrational crowd” theory?
decontextualised
assumes the individual self is unitary
denies voice to crowd (don’t actually listen to concern)
justifies repression (suggests all crowds are inherently dangerous so methods may lead to self-fulfilling prophecy of the police)
what was the “group fallacy”?
all port suggested individualistic approach
“there is not psychology of groups which is not essentially a psychology of individuals”
“the individual in the crowd behaves just as he would be alone”
what is deindividuation? (Festinger et al, 1952)
the loss of self-awareness and evaluation apprehension under condtions of anonymity
what are the consequences of deindividuation?
no personal responsibility
negative behaviour (aggression or loafing)
what is the social identity model of deindividuation effects?
anonymity increases self-categorisation (depersonalisation)
cognitive shift from personal characteristics to group membership
not loosing responsibility but adhering to self norms
from individual to collective goals
group norms act as moderators - depending on norm you get different outcomes
what increases deindividuation?
costumes / uniform
code names
what was Johnson and Downing study?
N = 60 women
2 × 2 between-subjects experimental design
IV deindividuation - identifiable or unidentifiable
IV cues - costume resembling the KKK or nurses uniform
findings:
KKK = more shocks, nurses = lead shocks
anonymity alone did not increase aggression
anonymity strengthens adherence to group norms
what is emergent norm theory? (Turner & Killian, 1972)
crowd formation - no history or tradition
uncertainty - look at how to behave
milling - search for information and observe others
keynoting - influential individuals emerge and model behaviour
norm enforcement - descriptive anf injunctive norms
norm enforcement - approval/disapproval and self-policing
social identity model of a crowd
personal identity becomes less salient and a context-relevant social identity is made salient
may be based on shared experiences or grievances
how is behaviour shifted in a crowd?
control of behaviour is governed by understanding and values that define the salient social identity
collective goals rather than individual self-interest
how does crowds cause empowerment?
enables collective action
the experience of collective action can also provide participants with a sense of power and collective efficacy (these are dynamic social factors)
what is an example of social identity model of crowd behaviour?
St Paul’s riot - Bristol
shared identity = shared experiences of what it mean to be a St Pauls resident (exploited, poor and targeted by police)
crowd action reflects shared norms - only attack police, financial institutions and shops owned by outsiders
what is the elaborated social identity model of crowds?
variations and subgroups lead to different rather than united collective behaviour
shared identity as “collective movement”
what are the temporal dynamics?
salience changes in response to situation
outgroup behaviour can shape in-group norms about a situation
why are there variations of social identity in a crowd?
may not have unified entities - people may have different and varied understanding of who ‘we’ are in a crowd event
how does variation change?
temporal dynamics - as confrontation with police develops, a sense of shared identity develops - unifying crowd members
what changes perceptions of social relations?
differences in self understanding
differences in power
self-fulfilling prophecy
what are consequences of escalation?
radical individuals become more prototypical
radicalisation - non-agonistic crowd members become radical
change in group norms of what is acceptable
change in boundaries
collective empowerment
what is the definition of crowds?
temporary gatherings of people that can be spontaneous or in response to an organised event
identity salience in a crowd is highly fluid
what is the definition of social movements?
exist beyond crowd events
can be a reason for crowds
they have explicit goal of achieving social change
membership precedes the crowd event
what is collective action?
any action that individuals undertake as group members to pursue group goals such as social change
why do social movements emerge?
relative deprivation theory (Runyiman, 1966)
realistic group conflict theory (Sherif, 1966)
what is relative deprivation theory (Runyiman, 1966)
social comparison and unequal access leads to:
deprivation - notion that one is worse than the others
gratification - feeling better off than others
what are the types of deprivation and gratification?
absolute - in real terms irrespective of who one compares with
relative - in relation to a particular comparison
egoistic - individual comparison to others
fraternal - group-based comparison
relative privilege - group-based advantages in society
what are the consequences of relative deprivation theory?
egoistic deprivation - frustration and stress
fraternalistic deprivation - collective action motivation (looking at the injustice as a group rather than on the individual level)
what is realistic group conflict theory? (Sherif, 1966)
conflict between groups due to conflicting goals or competition over scare resources between these groups
what are negative interdependent goals?
win-lose
intergroup hostility
what are positively interdependent goals?
win-win
superordinate goals
what are the outcomes of negatively interdependent goals?
stereotyping and prejudice
social distancing between members of different groups
intragroup solidarity, identification with the group and self-glorification
leadership changes towards more aggressive leaders
why do people not participate? (5 theories)
system justification theory (Jost & Banaji, 1994)
social movement mobilisation (Klandermans, 1997)
intergroup emotions theory (Smith, 1993)
extended social identity model of collective action (Van Zomeren et al, 2018)
encapsulation model of social identity in collective action (Thomas et al, 2009)
what is system justification theory? (Jost & Banaji, 1994)
people have a psychological motivation to defend, bolster and justify the existing social systems (even when disadvantageous)
what are epistemic needs?
the need for certainty and understanding - status quo
what are existential needs?
the need to manage threat and distress
what are relational needs?
the need to coordinate with others and maintain social harmony
what are the 4 components of social movement mobilisation? (Kladermans, 1997)
mobilisation potential - sympathiser due to fraternalistic deprivation, perception of negatively interdependent goals
target of mobilisation attempts - understand what is possible to be done and how you can help
motivation to participate - perceived value of any possible outcome of collective action and likelihood it can be achieved
opportunity and capability - overcoming obstacles to participation
sympathisers → targeted → motivated → participant
what is intergroup emotions theory? (Smith, 1993)
based on social identity approach
group-based appraisals of events shape group-based emotions
what are the emotions within intergroup emotions theory?
anger - appraisal of in-group injustice with group-based efficacy → collective action
fear - appraisal of injustice without group-based efficacy → withdrawal or avoidance
hope - appraisal of group-based efficacy in relation to a group-based goal → sustain participation in collective action (resilience)
pride - appraisal of group-based goal achievement and attribution to group efficacy (strengthens group solidarity)
what is extended social identity model of collective action? (Van Zomeren et al, 2018)
integration of 2 pathways within a social identity framework:
group-based emotions path
instrumental (efficacy) path
both explain collective action together
group membership and identitifaction are preconditions for moral beliefs
identities become policised when group morality is violated

encapsulation model of social identity in collective action (Thomas et al, 2009)
perceptions of injustice can create the basis for a new or politicised group membership
the realisation that systemic injustice cannot be overcome though individual effort
collective effort is the most viable path so increases self-categorisation and social identification
what is normative collective action? (Becker & Tausch, 2015)
socially approved and lawful actions
usually aims to create change while working within social norms
predicted by anger
what is non-normative collective action?
actions that challenge social norms
moderate = disruptive
extreme = violence
associated with contempt
how does group efficacy increase participation?
people feel their collective efforts can bring about social change