1/58
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Title VII, ADEA, and the ADA statutorily require there be an ______-______relationship (essentially asking, who has the ______ to control?)
Employee: someone who works for an employer
Employer: someone who has X number of employers
Respondent superior: the employer is vicariously liable for the acts of its agents
Employee v. independent contractor = the ability to ______ the ______ and the ______ of work
Independent contractors are not covered by Title VII, ADEA, and ADA
Title VII, ADEA, and the ADA statutorily require there be an employer-employee relationship (essentially asking, who has the right to control?)
Employee: someone who works for an employer
Employer: someone who has X number of employers
Respondent superior: the employer is vicariously liable for the acts of its agents
Employee v. independent contractor = the ability to control the manner and the means of work
Independent contractors are not covered by Title VII, ADEA, and ADA
Forced Arbitration and Class Waivers:
Employers can require employees to arbitrate disputes and agree to class waivers
EFASASHA: sexual ______ and sexual ______ claims are not subject to forced arbitration
Regardless: The ______ can still pursue the claim, even if the employee is bound by arbitration
Forced Arbitration and Class Waivers:
Employers can require employees to arbitrate disputes and agree to class waivers
EFASASHA: sexual harassment and sexual assault claims are not subject to forced arbitration
Regardless: The EEOC can still pursue the claim, even if the employee is bound by arbitration
Individual disparate treatment: an employer ______ treats an individual employee differently ______ ______ a protected class.
perpetrator based theory
______ damages + ______ damages available
______ relief available (backpay, front pay, reinstatement, injunction)
Individual disparate treatment: an employer intentionally treats an individual employee differently because of a protected class.
perpetrator based theory
compensatory damages + putative damages available
equitable relief available (backpay, front pay, reinstatement, injunction)
McDonnell Douglas: Establishes a three step structure-
The plaintiff must establish a prima facie case of discrimination, which creates a “______ " that the employer ______
Once the prima facie case is established, the employer has the burden of ______ into evidence (burden of ______ ) a legitimate non-discriminatory reason for the alleged discriminatory decision
______ that burden destroys the ______ , but the plaintiff has the ______ to prove that the supposed reason was really a ______ for an underlying discriminatory ______ (burden of ______ )
The McDonnell Douglas formula does not require ______ proof of discrimination
McDonnell Douglas: Establishes a three step structure-
The plaintiff must establish a prima facie case of discrimination, which creates a “presumption" that the employer discriminated
Once the prima facie case is established, the employer has the burden of putting into evidence (burden of production) a legitimate non-discriminatory reason for the alleged discriminatory decision
Carrying that burden destroys the presumption, but the plaintiff has the opportunity to prove that the supposed reason was really a pretext for an underlying discriminatory motivation (burden of persuasion)
The McDonnell Douglas formula does not require direct proof of discrimination
Prima facie case of discrimination: The plaintiff must show –
That she was a ______ of the protected group;
That she was ______ for the position;
That she experienced ______ employment ______ ; and
That such action occurred under ______ giving rise to an ______ of discrimination
"Inference of discrimination: = McDonnell Douglas framework
Prima facie case of discrimination: The plaintiff must show –
That she was a member of the protected group;
That she was qualified for the position;
That she experienced adverse employment action; and
That such action occurred under circumstances giving rise to an inference of discrimination
"Inference of discrimination: = McDonnell Douglas framework
Proving pretext:
Statistical evidence (w/employer's general policy) ______ tiebreaker
An employer's failure to follow procedures can have ______ value depending on how uncommon or great the ______ from established
______ can help provide evidence that the different treatment was ______ ______ the protected class characteristic.
______ : a ______ ______ person outside of the plaintiff's protected class (another race or sex)
Proving pretext:
Statistical evidence (w/employer's general policy) IF tiebreaker
An employer's failure to follow procedures can have probative value depending on how uncommon or great the deviation from established policy
Comparators can help provide evidence that the different treatment was because of the protected class characteristic.
Comparator: a similarly situated person outside of the plaintiff's protected class (another race or sex
Disproving pretext: Honest Belief Rule
Honest Belief Rule: The issue is not whether the employer's asserted reason was ______ true, but whether the employer ______ ______ the reason was ______ when it took the challenged ______ .
An employer may ______ the honest belief rule for taking a ______ during the employee’s opportunity to prove ______ !
HOWEVER:
A ______ LNDR by part of the employer is not indicative of discrimination, but raises the possibility thus permitting the ______ of ______ (to be made by the factfinder)
The ______ reasonable the mistake, the more likely the ______ of ______
Disproving pretext: Honest Belief Rule
Honest Belief Rule: The issue is not whether the employer's asserted reason was actually true, but whether the employer honestly believed the reason was true when it took the challenged action.
An employer may invoke the honest belief rule for taking a LNDR during the employee’s opportunity to prove pretext!
HOWEVER:
A mistaken LNDR by part of the employer is not indicative of discrimination, but raises the possibility thus permitting the inference of discrimination (to be made by the factfinder)
The less reasonable the mistake, the more likely the inference of discrimination
Stray remarks (i.e. "too damn old” and “must've come over on the mayflower") are ______ of discrimination, with ______ ______ varying depending on:
Whether it was said by the ______ ______ ;
How ______ to the decision it was uttered; AND
How ______ it evidences bias
Stray remarks (i.e. "too damn old” and “must've come over on the mayflower") are probative of discrimination, with probative strength varying depending on:
Whether it was said by the decision maker;
How close to the decision it was uttered; AND
How clearly it evidences bias
______ jurors can differ when making the ultimate decision regarding whether the plaintiff’s finding of ______ is ______ to prove their protected class was a but-for cause of the employer’s discrimination
Reasonable jurors can differ when making the ultimate decision regarding whether the plaintiff’s finding of pretext is sufficient to prove their protected class was a but-for cause of the employer’s discrimination
When determining whether an employer may be held liable for employment discrimination, do not stop the analysis at the ______ of the ______ decision maker.
______ the decision-making process ______ to determine whether a biased actor influenced the result
Cat’s paw theory: Regardless of whether the ______ decision maker is not personally ______ , an employer may still be liable if a biased ______’s conduct was a ______ cause of the firing.
When determining whether an employer may be held liable for employment discrimination, do not stop the analysis at the identity of the final decision maker.
Trace the decision-making process backward to determine whether a biased actor influenced the result
Cat’s paw theory: Regardless of whether the ultimate decision maker is not personally biased, an employer may still be liable if a biased supervisor’s conduct was a proximate cause of the firing.
To make out a Title VII employment discrimination claim, a transferee must show ______ harm respecting an ______ term or condition of employment.
○ Easier to prove "some harm" when there is a financial/monetary harm
To make out a Title VII employment discrimination claim, a transferee must show some harm respecting an identifiable term or condition of employment.
○ Easier to prove "some harm" when there is a financial/monetary harm
Constructive Discharge: If an employee ______ resigns because of the employer's conduct.
Equivalent to ______ discharge (by employer) and ______ under the antidiscrimination statues
Plaintiff has a ______ burden to establish constructive discharge: (1) must establish an ______ working environment and (2) must prove that the “working conditions became so ______ that a ______ person in the employee’s position would have felt ______ to resign
Constructive Discharge: If an employee voluntarily resigns because of the employer's conduct
Equivalent to formal discharge (by employer) and actionable under the antidiscrimination statues
Plaintiff has a high burden to establish constructive discharge: (1) must establish an abusive working environment and (2) must prove that the “working conditions became so intolerable that a reasonable person in the employee’s position would have felt compelled to resign
Price Waterhouse v. Hopkins (female associate is not promoted to partner (Title VII)
IMPORTANCE: Under Title VII claims, where both ______ and ______ (mixed-motive) reasons ______ the employer's decision, the employer could only ______ a finding of liability by proving by a ______ of the ______ that it would have made the ______ decision even if it had ______ allowed the protected class to play such a role.
Defendant (employer) now has a burden of ______
O’Connor’s concurrence AND holding: (1) plaintiff must prove prima facie case by a "______ factor" and need "______ evidence" and (2) must show presence of "______ evidence" to shift the burden of ______ to employer
Price Waterhouse v. Hopkins (female associate is not promoted to partner (Title VII)
IMPORTANCE: Under Title VII claims, where both legitimate and illegitimate (mixed-motive) reasons motivated the employer's decision, the employer could only avoid a finding of liability by proving by a preponderance of the evidence that it would have made the same decision even if it had not allowed the protected class to play such a role.
Defendant (employer) now has a burden of persuasion
O’Connor’s concurrence AND holding: (1) plaintiff must prove prima facie case by a "substantial factor" and need "direct evidence" and (2) must show presence of "direct evidence" to shift the burden of persuasion to employer
Title VII (1991) adopts the motivating-factor standard for liability but permits a same-decision defense that limits ______ , NOT ______ .
Essentially: employers are able to ______ the ______ off by saying that it would have still had the same ______ regardless of the discrimination
Title VII (1991) adopts the motivating-factor standard for liability but permits a same-decision defense that limits remedies, NOT liability.
Essentially: employers are able to cut the remedy off by saying that it would have still had the same result regardless of the discrimination
Desert Palace (Title VII mixed-motive suit)
IMPORTANCE: As Title VII (1991) remained ______ as to the type of evidence required in mixed-motive cases, a plaintiff must prove her case by a preponderance of the evidence using ______ OR ______ /______ (sufficient) evidence
Eliminates O’Connor’s ______ evidence requirement in Price Waterhouse
Desert Palace (Title VII mixed-motive suit)
IMPORTANCE: As Title VII (1991) remained silent as to the type of evidence required in mixed-motive cases, a plaintiff must prove her case by a preponderance of the evidence using DIRECT OR INDIRECT/CIRCUMSTAINTIAL (sufficient) evidence
Eliminates O’Connor’s direct evidence requirement in Price Waterhouse
Gross v. FBL Financial Services (ADEA mixed-motive suit?)
Title VII (1991)'s mixed-motive ______ does ______ APPLY for ______ claims
For ADEA claims, a plaintiff must prove by the preponderance of the evidence (direct or indirect evidence) that age was the ______ -______ cause.
Plaintiff retains a burden of ______
Employer does not have a shifting burden of ______
Gross v. FBL Financial Services (ADEA mixed-motive suit?)
Title VII (1991)'s mixed-motive instruction does NOT APPLY for ADEA claims
For ADEA claims, a plaintiff must prove by the preponderance of the evidence (direct or indirect evidence) that age was the but-for cause.
Plaintiff retains a burden of persuasion
Employer does not have a shifting burden of persuasion
Comcast Corp v. Nat'L Ass'n of African American-Owned Media (Section 1981) discriminatory access to certain media markets)
IMPORTANCE: Mixed-motive claim (and motivating factor test) is ______ available under Section ______ ; but-for causation required.
Comcast Corp v. Nat'L Ass'n of African American-Owned Media (Section 1981) discriminatory access to certain media markets)
IMPORTANCE: Mixed-motive claim (and motivating factor test) is not available under Section 1981; but-for causation required.
After-Acquired Evidence Rule: Limits backpay to ______ of ______ - adverse employment action
After-Acquired Evidence Rule: Limits backpay to discovery of misconduct - adverse employment action
Same actor ______ : courts will sometimes dismiss a plaintiff's case if the same actor ______ and ______ the plaintiff, as evidence that if the adverse employment outcome was truly because of discrimination -> the actor would not have ______ the plaintiff
Same actor inference: courts will sometimes dismiss a plaintiff's case if the same actor hired and fired the plaintiff, as evidence that if the adverse employment outcome was truly because of discrimination -> the actor would not have hired the plaintiff
Systemic disparate treatment discrimination: ______ /______ -based discrimination ______ ______ a protected class
Perpetrator based theory of discrimination
Differences between damages?
Intentional disparate treatment = ______ and ______ damages
Disparate impact = economic damages
______ can also be litigated under systemic disparate treatment
Systemic disparate treatment discrimination: group/class-based discrimination because of a protected class characteristic
Perpetrator based theory of discrimination
Differences between damages?
Intentional disparate treatment = compensatory and punitive damages
Disparate impact = economic damages
ADEA can also be litigated under systemic disparate treatment
Methods to prove a systemic disparate treatment claim:
______ discriminatory policy: the employer has a policy which discriminates on its face
______ and ______ of discrimination: a pattern and practice of discrimination which demonstrates that the employer ______ ______ from the ______
Methods to prove a systemic disparate treatment claim:
Facially discriminatory policy: the employer has a policy which discriminates on its face
Pattern and practice of discrimination: a pattern and practice of discrimination which demonstrates that the employer statistically deviates from the norm
Under a pattern and practice of discrimination claim, the plaintiff must establish by a ______ of the evidence that [protected class] discrimination was the employer's ______ operating ______ .
Under a pattern and practice of discrimination claim, the plaintiff must establish by a preponderance of the evidence that [protected class] discrimination was the employer's standard operating structure.
Inexorable zero: the complete ______ of a protected group (like a specific race or gender) from a company's ______ or a specific job category
Inexorable zero: the complete absence of a protected group (like a specific race or gender) from a company's workforce or a specific job category
For elements to start a class action:
______ questions of ______ and ______ to the class
______ protected by ______ who protect the class
______ members of the class
______ claims and ______ of the parties
For elements to start a class action:
Common questions of law and fact to the class
Adequately protected by attorneys who protect the class
Numerous members of the class
Typical claims and defenses of the parties
Three defenses to systemic disparate treatment cases:
Challenge the ______ basis on which the plaintiff's case is ______
Often results in a battle of the ______
Available for when a pattern and practice that demonstrates statistically that the employer deviates from the norm
Challenge the ______ of discriminatory ______ the statistics ______
Available for when a pattern and practice that demonstrates statistically that the employer deviates from the norm
______ the discrimination but assert a recognized defense (______ )
BFOQ defense is the ONLY available defense for a formal policy
Three defenses to systemic disparate treatment cases:
Challenge the factual basis on which the plaintiff's case is predicated
Often results in a battle of the experts
Available for when a pattern and practice that demonstrates statistically that the employer deviates from the norm
Challenge the inference of discriminatory intent the statistics raise
Available for when a pattern and practice that demonstrates statistically that the employer deviates from the norm
Admit the discrimination but assert a recognized defense (BFOQ)
BFOQ defense is the ONLY available defense for a formal policy
Bona fide occupational qualification (BFOQ): an employer may ______ discriminate upon a protected class it is a bona fide occupational qualification ______ necessary to the normal ______ of that particular ______ or ______
Regarding religion, sex, national origin, and age discrimination (NOT ______ )
Affirmative action is ______ a BFOQ
Bona fide occupational qualification (BFOQ): an employer may intentionally discriminate upon a protected class it is a bona fide occupational qualification reasonably necessary to the normal operation of that particular business or enterprise
Regarding religion, sex, national origin, and age discrimination (NOT race)
Affirmative action is NOT a BFOQ
Three categories of BFOQ:
Employer demonstrates that ______ ______in the ______ class can perform the job
Employer demonstrates that it is ______ to determine who can perform the job (Criwell, Johnson Controls)
BFOQ is ______ necessary to the ______ of their business (to the normal ______ of that particular business or enterprise)
BFOQ CANNOT be customer preferences (Air line case)
Three categories of BFOQ:
Employer demonstrates that no one in the protected class can perform the job
Employer demonstrates that it is impractical to determine who can perform the job (Criwell, Johnson Controls)
BFOQ is reasonably necessary to the essence of their business (to the normal operation of that particular business or enterprise)
BFOQ CANNOT be customer preferences (Airline case)
Analytic Framework for individual disparate treatment claim + affirmative action defense:
Plaintiff must demonstrate a prima facie case of discrimination
Burden of articulating a LNDR shifts to the defendant (may rely on an affirmative action plan)
Employer does ______ need to demonstrate the elements of a valid affirmative action plan (below)
A ______ affirmative action plan is NOT necessary; plan may be ______ (i.e. common knowledge among the decision makers that they want to hire more of a certain protected class)
Burden shifts back to plaintiff to prove that the employer’s justification (the valid affirmative action plan) is, in fact, ______ valid
Here: Plaintiff would demonstrate that the defendant’s affirmative action plan does not meet the ______ test
Analytic Framework for individual disparate treatment claim + affirmative action defense:
Plaintiff must demonstrate a prima facie case of discrimination
Burden of articulating a LNDR shifts to the defendant (may rely on an affirmative action plan)
Employer does NOT need to demonstrate the elements of a valid affirmative action plan (below)
A FORMAL affirmative action plan is NOT necessary; plan may be INFORMAL (i.e. common knowledge among the decision makers that they want to hire more of a certain protected class)
Burden shifts back to plaintiff to prove that the employer’s justification (the valid affirmative action plan) is, in fact, NOT valid
Here: Plaintiff would demonstrate that the defendant’s affirmative action plan does not meet the WEBER test
Established requirements for a valid affirmative action plan:
Purpose of the plan ______ the statute by aiming to break down old ______ of discrimination
Can be shown by a disparity in the employer’s work force and representation in “the area labor market or general population,” depending on whether “special expertise” is required
Does not ______ trammel the interests of the ______ employees; i.e. “narrowly tailored”
Can be demonstrated by an employer having no ______ or set-aside (no absolute entitlement for the protected class)
The plan is ______
Established requirements for a valid affirmative action plan:
Purpose of the plan mirrors the statute by aiming to break down old patterns of discrimination
Can be shown by a disparity in the employer’s work force and representation in “the area labor market or general population,” depending on whether “special expertise” is required
Does not unnecessarily trammel the interests of the majority employees; i.e. “narrowly tailored”
Can be demonstrated by an employer having no quota or set-aside (no absolute entitlement for the protected class)
The plan is temporary
To establish a prima facie case of systemic disparate impact discrimination, a plaintiff must show that the facially ______ policy in question causes a ______ ______ based upon a protected class.
Can be demonstrated by:
Relying on the general ______ demographic; ______ /______ workforce; or the ______ pool
What the court determines is a systemic disparity
May be 1% difference between the majority and minority (Jones)
When determining whether an employee should have been promoted, compare the input statistics for promotion
EEOC’s ______ rule or ______ rule
To establish a prima facie case of systemic disparate impact discrimination, a plaintiff must show that the facially neutral policy in question causes a disparate impact based upon a protected class.
Can be demonstrated by:
Relying on the general population demographic; eligible/qualified workforce; or the applicant pool
What the court determines is a systemic disparity
May be 1% difference between the majority and minority (Jones)
When determining whether an employee should have been promoted, compare the input statistics for promotion
EEOC’s 4/5ths rule or 80% rule
Once it is shown that the employment standards are ______ in ______ , the employer must meet the burden of ______ that (1) the practices that do cause an impact are justified as ______ related and ______ with business ______ ; or (2) those practices fall within the section ______(h) defenses:
Professionally developed ______ tests
Bona fide ______ system
Bona fide ______ system
Once it is shown that the employment standards are discriminatory in effect, the employer must meet the burden of persuasion that (1) the practices that do cause an impact are justified as job related and consistent with business necessity; or (2) those practices fall within the section 703(h) defenses:
Professionally developed ability tests
Bona fide seniority system
Bona fide merit system
If the employer proves that the challenged requirements are ______ -______ , the plaintiff may then show that other ______ devices without a similar ______ effect were also available.
If the employer proves that the challenged requirements are job-related, the plaintiff may then show that other selection devices without a similar discriminatory effect were also available.
EEOC 4/5th’s rule: the ______ rate should be within 4/5 (80%) or better in terms of ______ the ______ and ______ rates.
Falling below 4/5ths creates an ______ of discrimination, as the plaintiff has established a prima face case of systemic disparate impact discrimination.
EEOC 4/5th’s rule: the selection rate should be within 4/5 (80%) or better in terms of comparing the majority and minority rates.
Falling below 4/5ths creates an inference of discrimination, as the plaintiff has established a prima face case of systemic disparate impact discrimination.
Business necessity: An employment practice must be ______ to job ______ if it operates to exclude a protected class
"accurately, but not ______ , ascertains an applicant's ability to ______ successfully the job in question."
More ______ than systematic disparate treatment discrimination's BFOQ
Business necessity: An employment practice must be related to job performance, if it operates to exclude a protected class
"accurately, but not perfectly, ascertains an applicant's ability to perform successfully the job in question."
More broad than systematic disparate treatment discrimination's BFOQ
When bringing a systemic disparate treatment claim, the plaintiff must ______ to ______ business/employment ______ ; Can't rely on ______ ______ statistics.
BUT: If the plaintiff is ______ to determine the ______ employment practice, they may argue that the particular employment practice is ______ of ______ and thus rely on the ______ ______ statistics
employer may then ______ a plaintiff's prima facie case by demonstrating that the data the plaintiff relied on was ______ (battle of experts)
When bringing a systemic disparate treatment claim, the plaintiff must point to specific business/employment practice; Can't rely on bottom line statistics.
BUT: If the plaintiff is unable to determine the particular employment practice, they may argue that the particular employment practice is incapable of separation and thus rely on the bottom line statistics
employer may then undermine a plaintiff's prima facie case by demonstrating that the data the plaintiff relied on was flawed
______ claim applies under systemic disparate impact
BUT the business necessity (Title VII) defense is ______ available under ______ disparate impact claims, instead, an employer must demonstrate a ______ ______ other than ______ RFOA
ADEA applies under systemic disparate impact
BUT the business necessity (Title VII) defense is not available under ADEA disparate impact claims, instead, an employer must demonstrate a reasonable factor other than age RFOA
Damages: systemic disparate impact!
A plaintiff may ______ recover ______ damages, NOT legal ______ .
Legal remedies = ______ + cdamages (only available under disparate treatment claims)
Compensatory + punitive not available for disparate impact
______ , ______ , etc. = equitable remedy
Note about jury trials: ______ jury trials in disparate impact cases!
Damages: systemic disparate impact!
A plaintiff may only recover equitable damages, NOT legal remedies.
Legal remedies = compensatory + punitive damages (only available under disparate treatment claims)
Compensatory + punitive not available for disparate impact
Backpay, reinstatement, etc. = equitable remedy
Note about jury trials: NO jury trials in disparate impact cases!
Sexual Harassment
The harassment must be ______ OR ______ (fact-bound analysis);
The conduct must ______ be perceived as ______ or ______ ; and
The victim herself must ______ perceive the conduct to be ______ or ______
“______ ” conduct requirement
Sexual Harassment
The harassment must be severe OR pervasive (fact-bound analysis);
The conduct must reasonably be perceived as hostile or abusive; and
The victim herself must subjectively perceive the conduct to be abusive
“Unwelcome” conduct requirement
Quid-pro-quo sexual harassment: ______ sexual advances is an ______ or ______ "quid-pro-quo" for ______ , ______ , or ______ in a job
Quid-pro-quo sexual harassment: accepting sexual advances is an explicit or implicit "quid-pro-quo" for obtaining, retaining, or advancing in a job
Hostile work environment: The ______ of the workers create such a ______ environment in ______ and ______ of employment because of a ______ class
Hostile work environment: The acts of the workers create such a hostile environment in terms of dealing with the terms and condition of employment because of a protected class
With grooming code requirements, men and women can be treated ______ -> but it depends whether the burden ______ .
Better argument/alternative argument = frame claim as same sex claim and follow a gender non-conformity under Price Waterhouse
With grooming code requirements, men and women can be treated differently -> but it depends whether the burden unequal.
Better argument/alternative argument = frame claim as same sex claim and follow a gender non-conformity under Price Waterhouse
Under quid-pro-quo claims for sexual harassment, the employer is ______ liable for tangible employment action taken by a ______ .
Under quid-pro-quo claims for sexual harassment, the employer is vicariously liable for tangible employment action taken by a supervisor.
If the employer did ______ take tangible action (meaning a plaintiff brings a ______ work environment claim), the employer has ______ part defense:
Employer exercised ______ care to ______ and ______ promptly any sexually harassing behavior
Does the employer have a ______ + ______ sexual harassment policy that’s ______ AND ______ ?
Presence of harassment policy is not enough
Investigation was not prompt
No clear path for reporting
A rational jury could . . .
The plaintiff ______ failed to take ______ of any ______ or corrective opportunities
If the employer did not take tangible action (meaning a plaintiff brings a hostile work environment claim), the employer has two part defense:
Employer exercised reasonable care to prevent and correct promptly any sexually harassing behavior
Does the employer have a clear + effective sexual harassment policy that’s used AND works?
Presence of harassment policy is not enough
Investigation was not prompt
No clear path for reporting
A rational jury could . . .
The plaintiff unreasonably failed to take advantage of any preventative or corrective opportunities
Negligent Co-Worker Claims:
The plaintiff must show that the employer was negligent, meaning the employer must have known or should have known
Even for those outside the workplace (vendors, customers)
Negligent Co-Worker Claims:
The plaintiff must show that the employer was negligent, meaning the employer must have ______ or should have ______
Even for those ______ the workplace (vendors, customers)
Under Title VII, a plaintiff does not have to meet the EPA's requirement of "______ work" to bring a compensation claim
Can bring a sex-based pay discrimination claim under both EPA and Title VII
Under Title VII, a plaintiff does not have to meet the EPA's requirement of "equal work" to bring a compensation claim
Can bring a sex-based pay discrimination claim under both EPA and Title VII
FMLA grants employees with up to ______ weeks of ______ leave for the ______ or adoption of a new child, the employee's own ______ health condition, or the serious health condition of an employee's child, parent, or spouse.
Only applies to employers with ______ or more employees
FMLA grants employees with up to 12 weeks of unpaid leave for the birth or adoption of a new child, the employee's own serious health condition, or the serious health condition of an employee's child, parent, or spouse.
Only applies to employers with 50 or more employees
Pregnant Workers Fairness Act
Employers must provide ______ accommodations for a ______ employee's ______ pregnancy-related limitations unless doing so causes an ______ hardship.
______ claims only.
Covered employers: ______ + employees.
Pregnant Workers Fairness Act
Employers must provide reasonable accommodations for a qualified employee's known pregnancy-related limitations unless doing so causes an undue hardship.
Accommodation claims only.
Covered employers: 15+ employees.
Employers have a duty to ______ accommodate religious practices BUT an accommodation must not ______ an ______ hardship.
Reasonable accommodations may include adjusting work, wearing distinctive clothing, not shaving, displaying religious symbols, etc.
______ must demonstrate that the accommodation involves an undue hardship, meaning the employer incurs ______ increased ______ in relation to the ______ of its particular ______
______ effects on co-workers are not relevant to determining whether an accommodation involves an undue hardship
Must impact the employer's business to factor into undue hardship analysis!
Employers have a duty to reasonably accommodate religious practices BUT an accommodation must not involve an undue hardship.
Reasonable accommodations may include adjusting work, wearing distinctive clothing, not shaving, displaying religious symbols, etc.
Employer must demonstrate that the accommodation involves an undue hardship, meaning the employer incurs substantial increased costs in relation to the operation of its particular business
Adverse effects on co-workers are not relevant to determining whether an accommodation involves an undue hardship
Must impact the employer's business to factor into undue hardship analysis!
"National origin" discrimination does ______ include/prohibit alienage discrimination, meaning discrimination on the basis on (non) citizenship
Regarding national origin discrimination, the more highly correlated a trait is with a protected class, the more likely a court will view discrimination on the basis of that trait as discrimination on the basis of a protected class!
"National origin" discrimination does not include/prohibit alienage discrimination, meaning discrimination on the basis on (non) citizenship
Regarding national origin discrimination, the more highly correlated a trait is with a protected class, the more likely a court will view discrimination on the basis of that trait as discrimination on the basis of a protected class!
Section 1981: Includes national origin discrimination, as ______ at the time of enactment had a ______ meaning which included national origin
Prohibits ______ discrimination
Section 1981: Includes national origin discrimination, as race at the time of enactment had a broad meaning which included national origin
Prohibits alienage discrimination
Under the ADA, Covered entities may not discriminate against a ______ individual because of ______ in ______ , firing, ______ , training, or other ______ and ______ of employment.
Under the ADA, Covered entities may not discriminate against a qualified individual because of disability in hiring, firing, compensation, training, or other terms and conditions of employment.
Disability:
(A) a ______ or ______ impairment that ______ limits one or more major ______ ______ of such individual;
(B) a ______ of such an impairment; or
(C) being ______ as having such an impairment (that substantially limits one or more major life activities of such individual)
Disability:
(A) a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits one or more major life activities of such individual;
(B) a record of such an impairment; or
(C) being regarded as having such an impairment (that substantially limits one or more major life activities of such individual)
Qualified Individual (ADA): an individual who, with or without ______ accommodation, can perform the ______ ______ of the employment position.
Qualified Individual (ADA): an individual who, with or without reasonable accommodation, can perform the essential functions of the employment position
Undue hardship: an accommodation requiring ______ difficulty or ______ , which must be determined by ______ all relevant factors, including the ______ and ______ resources of the covered entity
An individual who is “regarded as” having a disability ______ bring a duty of reasonable accommodation claim
The employer must take ______ steps to allow disabled employees to perform their job.
Denial of accommodation can amount to ______ discharge
Undue hardship: an accommodation requiring significant difficulty or expense, which must be determined by considering all relevant factors, including the size and financial resources of the covered entity
An individual who is “regarded as” having a disability CANNOT bring a duty of reasonable accommodation claim
The employer must take affirmative steps to allow disabled employees to perform their job.
Denial of accommodation can amount to constructive discharge
Burdens of productions and proof:
______ bears the burden of demonstrating that they are an individual with a disability within the meaning of the ADA (i.e. Actual, "regarded as," and "record of")
______ bears the burden of proving that a reasonable accommodation is available
______ bears the burden of persuasion as to undue hardship
______ has an implied burden to prove that a job function is an essential (IAMS)
Burdens of productions and proof:
Plaintiff bears the burden of demonstrating that they are an individual with a disability within the meaning of the ADA (i.e. Actual, "regarded as," and "record of")
Plaintiff bears the burden of proving that a reasonable accommodation is available
Employer bears the burden of persuasion as to undue hardship
Employer has an implied burden to prove that a job function is an essential (IAMS)
Direct threat: a significant ______ to the ______ or ______ of others that cannot be ______ by a reasonable ______
Must be based on a reasonable ______ judgment that considers such factors as the duration of the risk, the nature and severity of the potential harm, the likelihood of the potential harm, and the imminence of the potential harm
______’s burden!
Direct threat: a significant risk to the health or safety of others that cannot be eliminated by a reasonable accommodation
Must be based on a reasonable medical judgment that considers such factors as the duration of the risk, the nature and severity of the potential harm, the likelihood of the potential harm, and the imminence of the potential harm
Employer’s burden!
A "qualified individual with a disability" does ______ include a person who is currently engaging in the ______ use of drugs
Currently participating in ______ (SAFE HARBOR): The individual is participating in a supervised rehabilitation program and is no longer illegally using drugs.
A "qualified individual with a disability" does NOT include a person who is currently engaging in the illegal use of drugs
Currently participating in rehabilitation (SAFE HARBOR): The individual is participating in a supervised rehabilitation program and is no longer illegally using drugs.
Protected relationships (people fired because of their relationship with a disabled individual)
To make out a case of associational discrimination under the ADA, the plaintiff must show that the individual with whom they have a relationship is ______ and that the employer was ______ of the third party's disability + fired
Not entitled to disability accommodation
Protected relationships (people fired because of their relationship with a disabled individual)
To make out a case of associational discrimination under the ADA, the plaintiff must show that the individual with whom they have a relationship is disabled and that the employer was aware of the third party's disability + fired
Not entitled to disability accommodation
Trait Discrimination: The more ______ ______ a trait is with a protected class, the more likely a court will view discrimination on the basis of that ______ as discrimination on the basis of a ______ ______ !
______ preference/policies are a type of trait discrimination
Trait Discrimination: The more highly correlated a trait is with a protected class, the more likely a court will view discrimination on the basis of that trait as discrimination on the basis of a protected class!