1/7
Taken from week 3 lecture notes.
Degree of annexation in Re de Falbe 1901 and Berkley v Poulett [1977] 1 EGLR 86
Re de Falbe 1901 saw tapestries fixed to the wall by being stretched over wooden strips which were nailed to the walls, and be questioned who owned them. Ruled as chattels, since this was the usual display of tapestries, so could not be a fixture.
Berkley v Poulett [1977] 1 EGLR 86 saw court introduce the additional evidential presumption of chattels being easily removed from the land without causing damage.
Elitestone Ltd v Morris [1997] 1 WLR 687 (HL)
A township of wooden chalets built up over time (once holiday cottages), rested on their own weight, and their freehold was sold. Nobody had expressly stated whether the chalets were temporary or not, but could not be removed without being destroyed - found to be fixtures of the land.
Chelsea Yacht & Boat Co Ltd v Pope [2000] 1 WLR 1941 (CA)
Court of Appeal said boats are designed to float away, so the land underneath is not attached to a boat - it is not a part of the land, and the 1977 Act does not apply.
Mew v Tristmire Ltd [2012] 1 WLR 852 (CA)
Former military landing craft rested on a wooden bay and water depending on the tide and was increasingly difficult to remove, due to the boat being in such a state that it would fall apart and sink if removed from the pier. They once could have sailed away, as they were only joined by a rope, and the change in circumstances does not change this - it could have sailed away once upon a time. The deterioration does not change the fact the boats were not a part of the land.
This questions Elitestone, since the chalets could have been moved - different set of rules.
LB of Tower Hamlets v LB of Bromley [2015] EWHC 1954 (Ch)
A dispute of two London Boroughs over the ‘old Flow’ statue. One owned the land, and the other put the statue there. She rested on her own weight and had been moved before, but was considered heavy enough to be ruled a fixture.
Object of annexation and Melluish v BMI (No 3) Ltd [1996] AC 454 (HL)
This questions the reason for the object existing / being attached.
Melluish v BMI (No 3) Ltd [1996] AC 454 (HL) - The central heating system was not being included as part of the house for tax purposes, and installer retains the title. This failed, since the object was attached in such a way that it had become part of the property (fixture). For such agreements between parties to be valid, the object must be highlighted as being temporary.
Botham v TSB Bank plc [1996] 73 P & CR D1
Botham had a luxury flat, which the mortgage failed on and TSB tried to repossess the flat. Courts had to categorise many items to decide what the bank could retain in the property. Considerations included whether items were ornamental or functional, whether they were fitted into the flat, whether included by the original builder or later additions (built for purpose), if items could be removed, or belonged to the landowner.
Lost and found items, Parker v British Airways Board [1982] QB 1004 (CA), and Waverley Borough Council v Fletcher [1996] QB 334 (CA)
Lost items will be returned if the true owners can be found, but this is usually not the case.
Parker v British Airways Board [1982] QB 1004 (CA) saw P find a bracelet in the first-class lounge for BA, and handed it in for the true owners to be found - but requested it be returned to him if they could not be located. BA sold the bracelet, and P wanted compensation. Exercise of control over the land meant that first-class passengers were not monitored once in the lounge, and so P was entitled to what he found there.
Waverley Borough Council v Fletcher [1996] QB 334 (CA) saw a metal detectorist dig 9 inches down in a public park owned by the council to find a valuable lost brooch. F did not have permission to begin digging the park up, since the land had to be intervened to find the brooch - wrongdoing may affect this, since he did not have permission to be digging in the park to begin with. The council were entitled, not F.