1/18
Looks like no tags are added yet.
what is the main argument?
modern advertising makes masculinity look more flexible, humorous, and accepting. however these changes don’t necessarily challenge traditional gender hierarchies or eliminate male privilege
what is hegemonic masculinity?
the culturally dominant and celebrated ideal of masculinity, linked to power and dominance
what is symbolic distance?
men distance themselves from traditional or hegemonic masculinity
what is strategic borrowing?
Dominant men borrow cultural styles or traits associated with marginalized groups.
what is identity tourism?
temporarily adopting another group’s cultural traits without changing the inequalities they experience
How can borrowing reinforce group boundaries?
Men adopt traits from other groups while structural inequalities remain.
What does the Old Spice campaign illustrate?
that exaggerated, humorous masculinity can still celebrate male power and dominance.
How does the Yoplait advertisement illustrate hybrid masculinity?
A rugged, masculine man eats feminine-coded yogurt without losing his masculine status.
How does the Kraft salad dressing campaign use satire?
It presents a hypermasculine man preparing food in a sexualized, humorous way.
Why has consumption become a new rite of passage to manhood?
Traditional markers like marriage, children, and breadwinning jobs are less accessible to younger men.
what leads to transformations in femininity?
anxiety about what masculinity actually is tends to follow transformations in femininity
when women enter into historically masculine arenas, they shift the boundaries of femininity
do satirical ads challenge hegemonic masculinity?
no but they mock masculine stereotypes but can still celebrate male power and dominance
what are hybrid masculinities?
the way privileged men selectively adopt styles, behaviours, emotional expressions or identity elements from marginalized masculinities and femininities
what do hybrid masculinities do?
they produce symbolic distance between men and hegemonic forms of masculinity
they involve men strategically borrowing elements from disadvantaged groups
they fortify boundaries between groups in ways that obscure the inequalities defining the boundaries
they can lead to sexual objectification disempowering women on a larger scale
how do hybrid masculinities make inequalities hard to identify?
They create the appearance of social change by allowing dominant men to adopt traits associated with marginalized groups or distance themselves from traditional masculinity.
what is satire masculinity used for?
to sell men on products they avoid in fear of what it might say about their gender and sexual identities,
it offers viewers the appearance of something progressive by mocking configurations of masculinity that sustained feminist criticism → they offer a playful, ironic masculinity
how does reading 23 connect to the other readings?
The Pink Dragon is Female: Both show how products reinforce gender expectations.
Gender and Health Revisited: Masculine expectations can discourage men from showing vulnerability or seeking help.
Health Care Disparities among LGBT Youth: Traditional gender norms can marginalize people who do not conform.
Domestic Violence at the Crossroads: Dominant masculinity can reinforce male power and control.
Tough Guise 2: Both examine how media teaches men that masculinity means strength, dominance and aggression.
Killing Us Softly 4: Both show how advertising uses gender stereotypes to sell products; one focuses on masculinity, the other on representations of women.
Overall: Masculinity can appear more modern and flexible through advertising, but traditional male privilege and gender inequalities can remain.
what are the major concepts of this reading?
1. Hegemonic masculinity
The dominant, socially accepted idea of what a man should be.
Associated with strength, power, dominance and heterosexuality.
2. Hybrid masculinity
When socially dominant men adopt traits associated with marginalized groups or femininity.
Makes masculinity appear more flexible without necessarily changing male privilege.
3. Satirical masculinity
Using humour, exaggeration and jokes to portray traditional masculinity.
Example: Old Spice's exaggerated macho advertisements.
4. Symbolic distance
When men separate themselves from traditional forms of masculinity to appear more progressive.
Example: Men publicly distancing themselves from sexist behaviour.
5. Strategic borrowing
When dominant men borrow cultural styles or characteristics from marginalized groups.
They can adopt these traits while still benefiting from their social privilege.
6. Identity tourism
- Temporarily adopting another group's cultural identity or characteristics without experiencing the inequalities that group faces.
7. Masculinity crisis
The belief that traditional masculinity is being threatened.
Often emerges when women's roles and expectations change.
8. Consumption as a rite of passage to manhood
Buying products becomes a way for men to demonstrate masculinity.
Traditional milestones like marriage, children and breadwinning jobs are less accessible to younger men.
Example: Old Spice sells grooming products as a way to feel more masculine.