1/153
Looks like no tags are added yet.
How does this module differ from biomedical science modules that focus mainly on pathology?
A lot of your modules in biomedical science are focused on pathology and of the mechanisms of disease, very much the bio part of medicine. But this will focus more on the medicine part of biomedicine, and we'll be taking a more public health perspective of medicine, and so there'll be a lot of public health, but there'll be also some opportunities to gain clinical skills.
Why does the lecture emphasise understanding public health administration for students interested in applying for medicine?
When you apply for medicine, of course, you've got to have a good understanding of the way public health is run and administered in the UK, you've got to have a good understanding of the public health challenges facing the NHS, and you've also got to have a good grasp of where the future is, and also how the UK health system compares to other health systems around the world.
When was the NHS established, and what made its founding radical?
Established in 1948 the UK National Health Service was the first western country and that with the largest population to offer free healthcare at the point of use to all it’s people. But when it was established in 1948, it was a radical idea, this concept that there is a national health service which is administered, run and funded by public money, taxpayers' money, essentially.
What were the post-war circumstances that helped create the political case for a national health service?
After the war, things had changed a bit. So the UK was running out of money, people were quite poor, standards of living had dropped, something else radical needed to change, and Clement Attlee's government, socialist government, back in those days, was radically transformative.
What beliefs shaped Clement Attlee’s approach to welfare and the NHS?
Attlee’s socialist views were shaped by his experiences. Believed that a rich country had a duty to provide for the poorest. Concept of society and welfare was paramount in Attlee’s post-war cabinet.
What wider programme did Attlee’s government plan alongside nationalising health?
Amongst nationalizing Health, Attlee’s government also planned to nationalize other industries and create a welfare state. They also help put money into schools, education, and then nationalise all the major services, and they remained under government control up until the Thatcher era.
What was the Beveridge Report, who produced it, and what problem did it address?
Much of this plan built upon ‘the Beveridge report (1942)’ from economist William Beveridge. And this is a senior silver servant who was asked to report on the state of Britain's social structures and the support it gives to the poorest in society. That report revealed that Britain needed to do something drastic to help people, particularly after the negative impact of the war and the immediate aftermath of the war.
What were Beveridge’s ‘five giants’?
His vision was to battle against what he called the five giants; idleness, ignorance, disease, squalor and want.
How did the Beveridge Report and the wartime Government White Paper shape the NHS agenda?
Beveridge Report and a Government White Paper from previous Coalition Government set the agenda which the government put into action. The Beveridge report built on this concept and it was actually the government, the white paper, which is a bill proposed during the coalition government during the war which actually set sowed the seeds for this radical agenda.
Which three post-war governments were described in the lecture as radically transformative?
Clement Attlee, Margaret Thatcher and Tony Blair. Those three main governments radically transformed not only the health systems, but also the financial system, the financial structure and how these different departments and services are funded fundamentally.
How did the lecture contrast the general approaches of Conservative and Labour governments to public spending?
Conservatives didn't really do much for the health service and actually part of what the Conservatives stand for is spending less and taxing less. But the Labour governments, I do. generally more tax and spend. Raised taxes, spend more on public services, spend more on investment.
What was healthcare provision like before the NHS?
Before that, there were private practices, they were making a lot of money, and there was a large range in the care you could receive. So if you live in one part of the country, you could receive quite good care. There might be a lot of doctors per patient in other parts of the country where people don't want to live. Where doctors don't want to live, you'll have the opposite.
What national changes did the NHS introduce compared with the pre-NHS system?
This was the first time in which there was a national level of service, a national level of oversight, and the whole medical establishment came together under one umbrella.
Why did the British Medical Association oppose the establishment of the NHS?
As you would expect where you have private practice, very wealthy doctors, very influential doctors, pretty much being able to run their practices how they wanted to. They obviously didn't want government oversight of their operations. that was a not very popular initiative. So the British Medical Association, of course, were against it from the start and they threatened to bypass the whole thing.
What were the major financial and political problems facing the NHS at its outset?
By 1948, Britain was bankrupt. The Marshall Plan helped to provide financial stability. Attlee had a difficult job to convince Parliament to pass the necessary Bills. Bevan had a harder task to convince the Medical Establishment. Government faced structural and logistical challenges from the outset.
What was the Marshall Plan and how did it support the establishment of the NHS?
The Marshall Plan was a massive amount of money essentially from the US government. Most of the Marshall Plan was a grant, actually. Britain received the largest payment of any other country from the Marshall Plan. Not technically because that money didn't go directly into the establishment of the NHS, but what it did was it created the financial stability to fund the NHS.
Was the Marshall Plan money technically paid directly into the NHS?
Not technically because that money didn't go directly into the establishment of the NHS, but what it did was it created the financial stability to fund the NHS. And so the NHS would not have been funded, if not for that massive amount of money from America.
What scale of Marshall Plan support did the lecturer describe in today’s money?
People think it was a loan, but actually it's essentially about 35 billion pounds in today's money, which is pretty much a blank check. Only a small minority of that money was a loan.
What political and logistical hurdles did Attlee’s government have to overcome?
Clement Attlee's government had to convince the US that this money was going to be well spent and that Britain needed this money. Attlee had to convince Parliament to pass the bill and that wasn't easy either. So a lot of logistical hurdles had to be overcome in order for this bill to be passed for the doctors to come on board and also for the money to be provided.
How did Aneurin ‘Nye’ Bevan secure support from the medical establishment?
Health Minister Aneurin ‘Nye’ Bevan convinced the broad medical establishment including doctors, dentists, nurses, pharmacists and opticians to come together to form a nationwide health organization. A lot of money was needed to convince doctors to sign up for it. them a lot of money and you also have to be able to give them financial concessions, which wasn't on the plate initially, but it turned out because the BMA were being so vehemently against it, they had to do something.
What did Bevan mean by the reported phrase ‘we stuffed their mouths with gold’?
He said, we stuffed their mouse with gold. So, you know, he's making no secret of the fact that they had to pump in a lot of money in order to get doctors on site.
How close to the NHS launch were doctors still threatening to boycott it?
So right up until, I think, a few days before, the NHS was due to come about. Doctors were threatening to boycott the whole thing.
Who was the first patient treated by the NHS, and what were the circumstances?
First patient treated in NHS hospital was 13-year-old Sylvia Diggory in Trafford General Hospital in Manchester on 5th July 1948. Sylvia Diggery, she was a 13-year-old girl who had acute nephritis. And she was quite sick, actually. So she was very ill for several months in hospital. thankfully she pulled through her she lived quite a long life.
How large was the NHS described as being when it was founded?
At the time the NHS came about in 1948 it was the second largest employer in the whole world apart from the Chinese army so only the Chinese army was larger. It's right up there with a big multi-national companies such as Walmart.
Who has ultimate oversight of the NHS, and who is responsible for its funding?
The NHS is publicly funded and therefore administrative responsibility comes from the UK Government. The UK government is responsible for NHS funding. It technically falls under the jurisdiction and oversight of Parliament and the government.
What is the formal title of the Health Secretary, and what are their main responsibilities?
Secretary of State for Health & Social Care is responsible for policy setting, and oversight of delivery and performance. Not only are they responsible for the NHS, the Health Secretary is responsible for the whole healthcare in the UK, so they run the Health Department.
What is the NHS Chief Executive Officer responsible for?
NHS has a Chief Executive Officer who is in charge of operational management, answers to the Health Secretary. But the NHS also has a chief executive officer who is responsible for day-to-day operations within the NHS.
What is the role of the Chief Medical Officer in the government’s health structure?
Chief Medical Officer is the senior-most medical advisor to Health Secretary. He is the government's chief advisor and he is the person responsible for public health in the UK.
What distinction does the lecture make between the NHS and the Department of Health and Social Care?
NHS is a separate entity to the Department of Health & Social Care and it’s Board function as an independent organization in terms of day-to-day operations. The important thing to note about the NHS is that it's run as a arm's length body within the Department of Health. So while it falls under the Department of Health and is ultimately under the control of the Health Secretary, it does function as a fairly autonomous entity in its own right.
What is an arm’s-length body in the context described by the lecture?
The NHS is run as a arm's length body within the Department of Health. So while it falls under the Department of Health and is ultimately under the control of the Health Secretary, it does function as a fairly autonomous entity in its own right.
Who was identified as the Chief Medical Officer, and what example of their public role was given?
Professor Chris Whitty, who was the chief medical officer during the pandemic. We saw him on TV quite a lot during that time.
What is the role of the Permanent Secretary within the Department of Health and Social Care?
They have senior civil servants who are responsible for leading that department. They advise government on policy, on progress, on issues relating to operational delivery and management. But they are not responsible for setting the policy. Of course, that comes from politicians, that comes from parliament, that comes from senior ministers.
How does the lecture distinguish civil servants from senior clinicians and medical professionals?
He's not a civil servant and nobody who works for either the NHS or the Department of Health as a senior doctor or a senior scientist is a civil servant. Clinicians and medical professionals are not civil servants.
Who sets policy: the civil service or elected political leadership?
They advise government on policy, on progress, on issues relating to operational delivery and management. But they are not responsible for setting the policy. Of course, that comes from politicians, that comes from parliament, that comes from senior ministers.
What major administrative restructuring of the NHS in England was described in the lecture?
NHS previously operated with autonomy. This is changing in restructuring with NHS being integrated into DHSC with more accountability and operational oversight. NHS England is being abolished.
Does abolishing NHS England mean that the National Health Service itself is being abolished?
So we're not abolishing the National Health Service, but what we are abolishing is the administrative body that runs it. The NHS, as our body, is still going to be there.
What changes are expected from bringing NHS administration under the Department of Health and Social Care?
The UK government is taking on more of the ownership and the accountability and responsibility of running the NHS. There's perhaps a less autonomy, there's perhaps more government interference but it's good in that there's more direct accountability to the government and then therefore to Parliament.
What potential advantages and disadvantages of the NHS restructuring were identified?
It's bad in the sense that there's perhaps a less autonomy, there's perhaps more government interference but it's good in that there's more direct accountability to the government and then therefore to Parliament. There's going to be more accountability coming from the government and therefore more government oversight.
Why does the lecture say the restructuring does not apply in the same way to Scotland?
Health as a concept is devolved to the regions. And so Scotland has full autonomy to administer health in its own jurisdiction. So the UK government has no ability to interfere there. And Scotland has chose to keep the NHS as an arm's the length body within the department.
What is the difference between the administrative body and the clinical workforce under the restructuring?
The clinicians and medical professionals will still not be civil servants. Their salary will still come from the NHS. The NHS, as our body, is still going to be there. So we're not abolishing the National Health Service, but what we are abolishing is the administrative body that runs it.
Who were named as the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care and the NHS Chief Executive in the lecture slides?
Yvette Cooper — Secretary of State for Health & Social Care. James Mackey — Chief Executive, NHS England.
What is the NHS Mandate and how often is it published?
Currently, the NHS mandate dictates what the government wants to do with the NHS for that year. So every year, the government publishes this NHS mandate. This is where the goals and plans are established.
What are the principal sources and route of UK healthcare funding described in the lecture?
Taxpayer money. Budget of Department of Health & Social Care. Funds come from government and the NHS budget is dependent on public money.
What does the Department of Health and Social Care need to monitor in relation to commissioned services?
The other key thing that the Department of Health needs to do is monitor how services are commissioned and monitor the cost-effectiveness of that process. So this is done at a national level.
When did the concept of commissioning NHS services begin, and how has it developed?
Concept of commissioning began in 1990s. This concept of commissioning began in the 90s, but it really reached a peak in the last few years.
What does commissioning of NHS services involve?
Assessing needs, setting priorities, planning services, procuring services, monitoring quality.
Why was commissioning introduced as a separation between purchasing and delivery?
They provide a separation from the commissioning of services from the purchasing of services and the delivery of those services. Before you had commissioning what you had was the primary care practices essentially purchasing and delivering their own services.
What problem could arise when the same primary care practice purchases and delivers its own services?
Before you had commissioning what you had was the primary care practices essentially purchasing and delivering their own services so you can imagine the financial wastage there was in that person It's like marking your own homework.
How does separating commissioning from service delivery create an internal market?
You have a separation between the commissioning and the delivery of the services. It creates an internal market, and there's no monopoly on services.
What outcomes is commissioning intended to promote?
Promote efficiency, responsiveness and innovation. And ultimately, people want a good value for money, don't they, for using the NHS and the government wants there to be a good cost-effectiveness of this approach.
What are Integrated Care Systems and how do they support regional planning?
The way integrated care systems work is that they bring together a lot of stakeholders, so local authorities, regional groups, local governments and various regulatory bodies, and they work together in order to establish a plan for commission.
What is the main benefit of Integrated Care Boards identified in the PowerPoint?
Main benefit of ICBs is a joined-up approach to delivering medicine and avoidance of a fragmented process.
How does a joined-up commissioning approach differ from the previous fragmented approach?
This takes a more joined-up approach and there's a plan for commissioning for that for that region for that community which is which is much more joined up and less fragmented before that it was much more fragmented and because primary care practices were commissioning and running and delivering services at the same time there was not only a more fragmented approach but there was also infighting within these systems.
Which services and facilities are commissioned within the NHS structure described?
Hospitals, GP practices, ambulance services, specialist clinics, walk-in centres. But also there things like hospital security, IT support, infrastructure services. So there's a whole host of various services that are commissioned by these integrated care groups.
What is the Care Quality Commission and what does it oversee?
Care Quality Commission (CQC) oversees and regulates all the service provision. Responsibility for standards of care of services and oversees ICBs and their service provision.
What is the formal organisational status of the Care Quality Commission?
CQC is a non-departmental body of the Department of Health & Social Care.
How is the Care Quality Commission organised?
Operate with a Board and a Chief Executive.
Does the Care Quality Commission directly manage NHS Trusts and Integrated Care Boards?
Do not directly interfere with how NHS Trusts and ICBs are run but make recommendations to the Department for Health & Social Care.
What happens when the Care Quality Commission identifies a problem with commissioning?
If they discover a problem with the commissioning process, they report to the Department of Health and then things are altered, modified in that process hopefully to then improve the commissioning process for the next year.
What is the limit of the CQC’s direct power described by the lecturer?
What the Care Quality Commission can't do is make a phone call and say this problem was found, rectify this now. All they can do is make recommendations. And it's up to the Department of Health fundamentally as to whether those changes are indeed made.
How does accountability ultimately extend from the CQC to Parliament?
The Care Quality Commission is answerable to the Department of Health. Anything that is answerable to the UK government department is also answerable to Parliament. Parliament is the ultimate body with which the government needs to answer to.
What parliamentary mechanism may be used when a major public-health problem occurs?
There's parliamentary select committees such as we saw with COVID. Something goes wrong in terms of public health. there can be a parliamentary inquiry to get to the bottom of the problem, and to help people accountable.
What pressures have increased the use of private providers within the NHS?
There was quite a considerable rise in waiting lists. The waiting lists have risen. The government in the last few years has then turned to the private sector to try to plug some of these gaps.
What trend in hip operations and private hospitals was highlighted?
More hip operations being performed than ever before. What you can see is that more of the operations are being performed by the private sector. A large chunk of that are privately funded within a private hospital, but a good amount of it are publicly funded within a private hospital.
What proportion of planned NHS operations were reported as being performed by private hospitals?
Private hospitals are performing 10% of all planned NHS operations.
Why do some people view increased private-sector involvement as undermining the NHS?
Many see this increasing prominence of the private sector as undermining the NHS. What people are concerned about is that there's a greater influence of the private sector within the NHS and also it means that public money is going into private practice technically.
What is the government’s stated short-term argument for using private-sector capacity?
Government’s view is that in the short term, reliance on private sector boosts capacity and service provision to those most in need.
What workforce concerns have been raised by public-sector workers?
Public sector workers have complained of real-term pay cuts to staff.
What was the resident doctor dispute about, and what outcome was reported?
BMA agreed a deal with government this summer bringing a a long running dispute and strike by resident ‘Junior’ Doctors to an end. They were striking because of their conditions in pay. So it's both conditions and pay, which were the centre of this dispute.
What financial cost was associated with settling the resident doctor pay dispute?
Cost to the government for settling pay strikes expected to be £200m despite financial challenges facing sector. This year, there is a good pay rise, not 22%, but it's above the rate of inflation. And the cost to resolve this dispute was about 200 million pounds.
Why might resolving industrial disputes be less costly than allowing them to continue?
The cost of cancelling operations, the cost of rescheduling operations, the cost of turning people away and then treating them later when they've got an even more severe version of that disorder or disease, that cost would be probably double that even more.
How can industrial action create additional costs beyond the pay settlement?
Administrative cost of strikes and other industrial action. The cost of cancelling operations, the cost of rescheduling operations, the cost of turning people away and then treating them later when they've got an even more severe version of that disorder or disease.
What infrastructure problems are affecting NHS hospitals and equipment?
Many hospitals and equipment are in disrepair. Adds to delays, inefficiencies and is a danger to patients.
What did the lecture report about the NHS maintenance backlog?
This table shows you the repair job backlog that is inherent in all our hospitals, all our major hospitals. So 2015, you can see there was quite a big maintenance backlog, so into the easily approaching 6 billion. But you can see that's basically doubled now. You know, and this is 2023, so that's even higher now.
Why is the maintenance backlog a patient-safety concern?
The risk of not maintaining these services, not maintaining these hospitals is very problematic. The risk is extremely high. So, you know, the vast majority of that matter's backlog is either high or significant, has a significant risk on how the NHS is able to essentially operate, which is very worrying.
What working-condition concerns were raised by resident doctors in addition to pay?
A lot of them are saying that they're operating without the tools with which they can actually perform to the best of their ability. And so it's both conditions and pay, which were the centre of this dispute.
How did the lecture describe the relationship between public spending and NHS staff retention?
If you invest in the infrastructure, doctors feel that they can do their job, they can execute their skills, well, that might help with morale. Also pay. If pay and conditions are good, you might be able to retain more of these important medical stuff.
What did the lecture’s workforce comparison indicate about the UK?
The UK is in that quadrant where you don't want to be. It's got a shortage of doctors and a shortage of nurses. The UK is one of very few countries in that position where I think we're finding hard to retain nurses, and we're finding hard to retain doctors.
Which country was used as a contrast to the UK in the doctor and nurse workforce comparison?
Compare that to Germany, which is in the opposite quadrant, a lot of doctors and a lot of nurses.
What broad factors did the lecture identify as influencing NHS waiting lists and spending over time?
A lot of the problems in the NHS can be put down to differences in policy between the two major parties. Labour Party, tax and spend, raise taxes, spend money, put money into public services. Conservative Party reduced taxes, but put less money into public services.
What pattern in UK public-health spending was associated with the Tony Blair government?
Under Tony Blair, you can see public health spending rose dramatically. By the end of Blair's time in government, the UK was actually spending a lot more than other developed countries as a percentage of GDP.
How did the lecture describe public spending during the David Cameron austerity period?
What we see under the David Cameron years of austerities that then public has sort of flatlined. But a lot of the shortfalls we see today might have their origins in that David Cameron era of austerity sadly.
What happened to healthcare spending during the COVID-19 period?
There was this sudden increase with COVID that in 2020, every country was putting money, more money into public health and healthcare spending.
How did the lecture characterise the US healthcare system in relation to universal coverage?
It's actually one of the few developed countries, probably the only developed country, which doesn't have a universal healthcare system which is free at the point of use. So the US has a system based on essentially insurance.
What proportion of Americans were described in the PowerPoint as lacking any health coverage?
More than 10% of Americans are without any health coverage.
What is the Veterans Affairs healthcare system and how did it originate?
At the end of the Civil War, Abraham Lincoln’s government created a nationally-funded and integrated healthcare system for veterans. Evolved into the VA Medical health system.
Which groups did the lecture describe as benefiting from the Veterans Affairs system?
The VA system, which essentially gives the most vulnerable people who have been impacted by war, and essentially all veterans on either side of that conflict, gave them free healthcare. It's a system that rewards those who fought in the military and rewards people who have received honours, and it rewards people who have been severely injured in conflict.
How did Franklin D. Roosevelt’s wartime wage policy contribute to employer-provided health insurance?
During the war when he basically froze pay, not only for government workers, but also for the private sector. So employers weren't allowed to put up pay for their employees. And that was to control inflation. The one thing that they could do was give them perks and one of those perks was private medical insurance.
Why did employers use medical insurance as a recruitment benefit during wage controls?
You can't promise them good salaries because salaries were stagnated as a matter of law. The one thing that they could do was give them perks and one of those perks was private medical insurance.
What proportion of the US population had private medical insurance by 1946 according to the PowerPoint?
30% private medical insurance coverage by 1946.
What structural problem did the lecture identify in the US private insurance market?
Today relatively few insurance firms comprise the vast majority of insurance coverage. Little scope for competition and cost-effectiveness.
How did the lecturer describe the influence of powerful healthcare and insurance companies in the USA?
There are very powerful healthcare companies and very powerful private health insurance companies. which have a monopoly on the system, and they have the lobbyists, they get tax breaks, they get government tax money as well, and the system is not designed for cost effectiveness.
How is US healthcare coverage commonly linked to employment?
Most Americans covered by employer insurance systems. Most large employers legally obliged to offer medical insurance.
What role does government taxation play in the US healthcare system described in the slides?
Government taxes fund private insurance companies and big Health companies. Healthcare coverage dependent on private insurance.
What were Medicare and Medicaid, and when were they introduced?
Medicare and Medicaid in 1965 greatly expanded health coverage for poorer families or those with chronic conditions. Lyndon B. Johnson in 1964, 1965, instituted Medicare and Medicaid.
Who was Medicare intended to support, according to the lecture?
Medicare is therefore the elderly, people are retired.
Who was Medicaid intended to support, according to the lecture?
Medicaid is there for people who are from a low socioeconomic background.
Why were Medicare and Medicaid significant for vulnerable groups?
Medicare and Medicaid were two social medicine initiatives which allowed the poorest people and the people who were not benefiting from private health insurance to be able to get treatment. So that provided a lifeline for the first time, or publicly funded access to health care for those vulnerable people.
Why did the lecture identify the US federal system as a barrier to healthcare reform?
The thing about America is that they have a constitution, and this constitution is a constant battle between federal government and states, and the states want their power, the government want to do their thing, but the states have a lot of power and influence, and they have a lot of rights, and this constitution actually enables those rights to be preserved to a large extent.
What was the Affordable Care Act and when was it enacted?
Affordable Care Act (2010) known as ‘Obamacare’. Healthcare reform was a major topic in the 2008 US Presidential Election.