Judicial Decision Making, Legitimacy, Diversity, and Juries

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/42

flashcard set

Earn XP

Description and Tags

Comprehensive vocabulary flashcards covering judicial decision-making models, statutory and constitutional interpretation, stare decisis, institutional legitimacy, judicial diversity theories, sentencing research, and jury selection procedures.

43 Terms

1
New cards

Legal Model

A theoretical account of judicial decision-making positing that rulings are substantially driven by case facts neutrally applied to existing legal doctrine—including statutory and constitutional text, drafters' intent, and binding precedent.

2
New cards

Textualism

An interpretive methodology directing judges to interpret statutes and constitutional provisions according to the ordinary, plain meaning of the words at the time of enactment, strictly avoiding extratextual legislative history or evolving policy preferences.

3
New cards

FCC v. AT&T Inc. (2011)

A Supreme Court case illustrating the limits of hyper-literal textualism; the Court held that while corporations are defined as 'persons' under the statute, the ordinary meaning of the adjective 'personal' in the Freedom of Information Act's 'personal privacy' exemption applies solely to individual human beings.

4
New cards

Intentionalism

An interpretive method that looks beyond the literal text of a law to uncover and enforce the underlying goals and understandings of the drafters by consulting historical records such as convention debates, committee reports, and floor speeches.

5
New cards

Collective-Intent Problem

A methodological complication for intentionalism stemming from the fact that legislatures and ratifying conventions are multi-member bodies whose individual members often vote for the same statutory text for disparate, conflicting, or contradictory reasons.

6
New cards

Stare Decisis

A legal principle meaning 'to stand by things decided,' establishing that prior judicial rulings govern future analogous cases to foster legal stability, predictability, and institutional legitimacy.

7
New cards

Vertical Stare Decisis

The doctrine strictly compelling lower trial and appellate courts to follow the binding precedent established by superior courts within their direct judicial hierarchy.

8
New cards

Horizontal (Peer) Stare Decisis

The practice where an appellate court or peer panels defer to their own past decisions for consistency, though peer circuits view other circuits' rulings as persuasive rather than strictly binding.

9
New cards

Distinguishing Precedent

A judicial treatment of precedent wherein a court determines that the material facts or legal questions in the current dispute differ from those of an earlier case, rendering the prior rule inapplicable without questioning its underlying validity.

10
New cards

Limiting Precedent

A treatment of precedent where a court restricts the scope of an existing ruling so that it applies only to a narrowly circumscribed set of factual circumstances, reducing its future doctrinal reach.

11
New cards

Ignoring Precedent

A treatment of precedent in which a court silently bypasses or declines to cite a potentially relevant prior decision, effectively allowing the precedent to weaken through disuse.

12
New cards

Overruling Precedent

The explicit judicial repudiation of an earlier decision as wrongly decided, stripping it of all legal force and binding authority (e.g., Brown v. Board of Education or Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization).

13
New cards

Extending Precedent

A treatment of precedent whereby a court applies and expands the legal rationale of an established decision to govern new factual situations, groups, or legal issues not present in the original case.

14
New cards

Attitudinal Model

A judicial behavior model developed by Jeffrey Segal and Harold Spaeth arguing that Supreme Court justices decide cases based primarily on their personal policy preferences and sincere ideological attitudes, using legal doctrine largely as post-hoc justification.

15
New cards

Spatial Model (Fourth Amendment Application)

A spatial framework arraying Fourth Amendment search-and-seizure disputes along a continuum of police intrusiveness; a justice votes to uphold a search if its level of intrusion falls to the left of their personal ideological threshold (ideal point) and votes to strike it down if it falls to the right.

16
New cards

Strategic Model

A model formulated by Lee Epstein and Jack Knight positing that judges are goal-directed policy seekers who cannot act solely on personal ideology; they must act strategically by anticipating the preferences and anticipated reactions of colleagues, external elected branches, and institutional rules.

17
New cards

Craig v. Boren (1976)

A Supreme Court case concerning gender-differentiated alcohol purchase ages in Oklahoma, illustrating intra-court strategic bargaining: Justice William Brennan compromised his sincere preference for strict scrutiny to formulate intermediate scrutiny, securing a majority coalition.

18
New cards

Intermediate (Heightened) Scrutiny

The middle-tier equal protection standard crafted by Justice Brennan in Craig v. Boren (1976) to evaluate sex-based classifications, strategically adopted to unite moderate justices into a binding majority.

19
New cards

Logrolling

Implicit or explicit reciprocity or vote-trading across issues or cases among judges on a multi-member court, used to secure majority coalitions and accommodate colleagues' core concerns.

20
New cards

Federalist No. 78

Alexander Hamilton's foundational essay describing the federal judiciary as the 'least dangerous branch' possessing 'neither FORCE nor WILL, but merely judgment,' rendering it vulnerable and dependent upon the executive branch for the enforcement of its decrees.

21
New cards

Specific Support

Short-term public performance satisfaction with the Supreme Court, measured by approval or disapproval of particular rulings or current judicial handling of major controversies.

22
New cards

Diffuse Support

Long-term institutional legitimacy characterized as a durable 'reservoir of goodwill' and institutional commitment to the Supreme Court that persists even when individuals strongly disagree with specific decisions.

23
New cards

Positivity Theory

A theory holding that public exposure to judicial proceedings and authoritative legal symbols (such as robes, marble columns, and legal rhetoric) reinforces perceptions of judicial impartiality, insulating the Court's diffuse legitimacy from short-term policy controversies.

24
New cards

Descriptive Representation

A concept of representation focused on whether the demographic profile of the judiciary mirrors the demographic makeup of the public (such as gender and race), designed primarily to enhance public trust and institutional legitimacy.

25
New cards

Substantive Representation

A concept of representation focused on whether the demographic diversity of the bench alters judicial outputs, substantive doctrine, and case outcomes through the distinct perspectives, experiences, or advocacy of diverse judges.

26
New cards

Panel (Collegial) Effects

The phenomenon observed on multi-judge appellate courts where the presence of a judge with a specific demographic or experiential trait causes peer judges on the same panel to alter their voting behavior or rationale.

27
New cards

Different Voice Theory

A judicial theory derived from Carol Gilligan's psychological research positing that female judges bring a distinct, empathetic, care- and context-oriented moral framework to the bench, predicting individual gender differences across diverse areas of law.

28
New cards

Representational Theory (Judicial Diversity)

A judicial theory derived from Hanna Pitkin's work asserting that female judges function as active advocates for women's collective interests, predicting pro-plaintiff individual gender effects specifically on gender-salient disputes such as abortion and sex discrimination.

29
New cards

Informational Theory (Judicial Diversity)

A theory positing that female judges contribute unique, credible professional and lived insights regarding gender bias that educate and persuade male colleagues, producing both individual effects and panel effects in workplace discrimination cases.

30
New cards

Organizational Theory (Judicial Diversity)

A theory maintaining that shared legal education, standardized professional training, and uniform institutional role constraints override personal demographic attributes, predicting no significant gender differences in judicial voting.

31
New cards

Public Defender Background Effect

The empirical finding by Allison Harris and Maya Sen demonstrating that federal district judges with prior career experience as public defenders sentence criminal defendants to prison less frequently (an average drop of up to 2.5%2.5\%) and assign post-trial sentences roughly 16 months16\text{ months} shorter than peers.

32
New cards

Venire

The master panel or pool of citizens summoned from the local community (predominantly using voter registration rolls and driver's license lists) from which a petit jury is selected for trial.

33
New cards

Petit Jury

The smaller trial jury (typically comprising 6 to 12 jurors) selected from the broader venire to hear evidence, deliberate, and return a verdict in a civil or criminal proceeding.

34
New cards

Voir Dire

The preliminary questioning process conducted by judges and attorneys to examine prospective jurors in the venire, balancing the institutional goal of impartiality against the adversarial goal of seating a favorable panel.

35
New cards

Scientific Jury Selection

The systematic use of social science methodologies—such as community focus groups, mock juries, and attitude-based questionnaires—by specialized trial consultants to identify prospective juror biases and advise on strikes.

36
New cards

Challenge for Cause

An unlimited procedural challenge allowing an attorney to request the dismissal of a prospective juror who demonstrates actual bias, financial or personal conflicts of interest, or an inability to follow the law, requiring judicial approval.

37
New cards

Peremptory Challenge

A limited statutory right granted to attorneys to strike a prospective juror without offering an explanation or obtaining judicial approval, bounded constitutionally by prohibitions against race- or gender-based exclusions.

38
New cards

Batson Challenge

A three-step procedural objection alleging discriminatory use of peremptory strikes: (1) establishing a prima facie inference of discrimination, (2) providing a facially race- or gender-neutral explanation, and (3) a judicial ruling on whether the explanation was pretextual.

39
New cards

Swain v. Alabama (1965)

A Supreme Court ruling upholding an all-white jury despite significant underrepresentation of Black residents in the venire, setting an almost insurmountable requirement that defendants prove systematic multi-case racial exclusion to invalidate peremptory strikes.

40
New cards

Batson v. Kentucky (1986)

The landmark Supreme Court ruling that overruled Swain v. Alabama, holding that the Equal Protection Clause allows criminal defendants to establish purposeful racial discrimination based solely on peremptory strikes conducted in their own trial.

41
New cards

Taylor v. Louisiana (1975)

A Supreme Court decision overturning Hoyt v. Florida and establishing under the Sixth Amendment that jury venires must be selected from a pool representing a fair cross-section of the community, invalidating opt-in jury systems for women.

42
New cards

Duren v. Missouri (1979)

A Supreme Court decision invalidating Missouri's automatic opt-out exemption from jury service for women, cementing mandatory gender neutrality in venire compilation under the Sixth Amendment fair cross-section requirement.

43
New cards

J.E.B. v. Alabama ex rel. T.B. (1994)

A Supreme Court ruling extending the Equal Protection principles of Batson v. Kentucky to prohibit state litigants and attorneys from exercising peremptory strikes on the basis of gender.