1/30
Looks like no tags are added yet.
US Policing before the 1960s
Policing both on the local and federal level were relatively undeveloped institutions in the US until the early 20th century
• There had been no serious attacks on the 4th amendment
• Civil rights movement brings federal policing into conflict with local police departments in the South
• Western Europe and the US had broadly similar patterns of crime and incarceration
Watts Riots of 1965
the spark for real change in US cultural attitude about police and race generally, its in the wake of these riots that the US started to see crime as an big problem again
long tension between African-Americans and LAPD that creates these huge riots (34 dead, 1000 injured, 40 million in property losses) - its one of the first major riots to be seen on TV nationwide.
Daryl Gates came up with SWAT team concept after these riots
crime in the the 60s
the crime rates were actually rising and they are able to present this as related to poltiical stuff and all the issues Webb was trying to alert people of (also nixon) but its quite possible it was more related to the baby boom generation coming to be of the age group that commits the most crime (young adults) - demographic bump
Nixon and the 1968 election
1966 to 1969, US support for death penalty rises from 42% to 51%
• Nixon runs and wins on a law and order campaign and he’s really beating the drum of the issue of crime and this public opinion shift towards it is reflected in the death penalty stats
• against “lawlessness” of civil rights activists, anti-war protestors, and ethnic minorities - he is making a war on all these groups of misfits and running on the power of silent majority of regular law abiding citizens who he is protecting from all those outsiders. he is also reducing the legitimacy of all these opposing groups and what they advocate for
starting the war on drugs
Nixon really didn’t care about weed but he saw it as a chance to revive public enemy language and by hyping drug problems into a national crisis they knew congress would let them do what they wanted.
was able to createa brilliant coalition of people they could lump together as threat to the public: weed/drug users, black ppl, anti-war coalition, ethnic minoritties, left wing ppl
created the ODALE later renamed the DEA
responsible for a huge jump in weed arrests that then stayed relatively stable before dramatically increasing again around 1980
DEA/ODALE
ODALE (Office of Drug Abuse and Law Enforcement) was founded in 1971
The “office was strongly a political thing. They were trying to prove that the number one problem was drugs, as Nixon said, and were under pressure to produce.”
start of SWAT teams in drug raids
its renamed to DEA (Drug Enforcement Agency) in 73
the 70s - lost opportunities& waining of Nixon’s war
the launching of the war on drugs and start of police militarization + birth of weed eradication initiatives targeting northern california
tho in 70s particularly after watergate there was a feeling that perhaps nixon overreacted and there was moves to decriminalize weed and repeal the aggressive raids sicne there was reaction against SAWt Teams (also law on no-knock raid was repealed 64-31 in the Senate 1974)
It was calmer in the carter administration(76-80) cus he didn’t pursue war on drugs and there was development of community policing model in a few places
Reagan: anti-drug crusader
tho nixon had some focus on weed he was looking more at heroin and hard drugs
Reagan (and his aids) switched the focus to weed in the early 80s with the birth fo the “gateway” hypothesis which was a cornerstone of his drug policy
Carlton Turner became “Drug Czar”-– “We have to create a generation of drug-free Americans to purge society.”
also the start of DARE program
1982 Crime Bill passes 95-1 that allows for the military and police to work together on drug interdictions and allowed for asset forfeiture
gateway hypothesis
idea of weed not as a super bad drug itself but as a gateway to other drugs. used a (now contested) study to say people who did weed would start other drugs
random note there was a huge cocaine problem in middle class homes in the 80s
key developments in the 80s
Rise of asset forfeiture and thus the possibility of making the war on drugs pay.
• Proliferation of SWAT teams (both from Watts riots and growth of mass shooter phenomenon)
• Creation of the DARE program (1983) by Daryl Gates (LAPD chief)
• “Bryne grants” part of 1988 crime bill that funneled billions of federal dollars into local drug war initiatives
• Rise of mandatory minimum sentences
• 1988 election and the infamous Willie Horton ad.
broken windows article
the broken windows article from 1982 is famous and reflects the philosophy that came to dominate american police - it was the best social scientific theory to that point to explain why police should behave as they do + goes with the zero tolerance drug mentality
it essentially says that community level crime and disorder are linked - if one window is broken and not fixed, soon the rest of that house will be broken too since it shows the inhabitant doesn’t care, this can lead to breakdown of community controls. This “untended” behavior creates perceived rise in crime which creates real rise in crime because people feel they can get away with more.
perceived lack or order/community control → more fear → more disorderliness → more crime
more cops on the streets maintaining neighborhood standards→perceived safety
they say in the article that it improves public perception and feelings of safety though it doesn’t decrease crime at all
issues with policing based on neighborhood norms
they say not to go based just on rules but enforce neighborhood norms of what is acceptable in that community
they say though that police may then be making judgements about what is okay and what to enforce rather than a judge. Also how do you make sure an officer is enforcing is valid and based on law not personal bias or bigotry - its hard to reconcile due process with fair trial
big suggestion of broken windows theory
the key is for police to look for and identify neighborhoods starting to have broken windows adn fix it before it gets worse
the key is for police to recognize order maintenance in precarious situations as vital to their job along with criminal investigations
they should focus on crime fighting in the worst areas but return to the idea that they protect community along with individual needs
its a big call to addressing crime at the community level rather than jsut the individual
Issues of broken windows theory
enforcement and ability to enforce this is really arbitrary
also implies that having police will make people feel safe but not everyone views authority and police as food - if you feel save or surveilled by polcie presence also is very variable based on race
article says that people feel safer running into police but these seems naive and the whole thing is based on really limited data/sample size - like really minimal empirical support
the article itself acknowledges that this method DOESN’T reduce crime
Crack Cocaine epidemic
some of the features of thsi drug that made it so explosive and addictive are what led to gang violence aorund it. there were wars over territory
explosions of violence in urban areas and skyrocketed homicide rate
led to a number of draconian and extreme policies that now even the most supportive politicians have rolled back on.
100-1 crack to cocaine ratio for sentencing which treated cracka s fundamentally different from cocaine and had a huge racial component (primarily tar
1994 crime bill
Joe Biden introduces the VAWA (Violence Against Women Act) in 1990 and it’s incorporated into the Bill Clinton’s 1994 crime bill to receive huge bipartisan support (part of clinton’s strategy of triangulation)
Elements of the Bill:
• 1) Introduced Federal assault weapons ban
• 2) New categories of crimes (hate, gang, sex)
• 3) Established registry for sex offenders
• 4) Expanded federal death penalty
• 5) Three-strikes provision (commit 3, even small, crimes and you have a minimum sentence)
seen as starting along the line the mass incarceration step to worsenign mass surveillance
Ways the crime bill impacted prison population
there was now a whole new class of offenders from having made doemstiv violence a crime (it wasn’t before)
mandatory long term sentences
giving judge no room for less harsh sentences after 3 strikes even fi the crime is petty
this bit followed people for life since then they were excluded from services and infrastructure (job or food of housing services)
Rudy Giuliani and Broken windows
he praised this theory and the idea that we shouldn’t be too busy to pay attention to the street level issues becuase they underlie the issues you have in yoru society
also showed it worked with dropping crime rates in NYC in the 1990s in his farewell address in 2001
Stop and Frisk
Broken Windows sought to arrest people for misdemeanors
• Stop and Frisk was designed to prevent potential misdemeanors - police picked people(often racially profiled) on the street for things as little and subjective as “furtive movement” and stopped them. they often aggressively out them down and searched them (usually for drugs and weapons)
• Hundreds of thousands of stops per year that yielded very low hit rates for contraband or weapons. not nealry enough to justify the practice
• 2013 Federal District Court finds that NYPD’s Stop and Frisk is unconstitutional on grounds of racial profiling
Bur unfortunately it was seen in cases like Eric Garner (2014 taken into custudy where he died cus he was selling loose cigarettes) showed it didn’t stop then
4th amendment to the constitution
“The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.”
Erosion of the 4th Amendment: Carroll doctrine 1925
1925 Carroll v. US—established an automobile exception to the fourth amendment [a vehicle could be searched if there was probable cause that evidence was present and there were exigent circumstances to believe the car would be removed—the Carroll doctrine]
during prohibition and officers orgnized a liquor purchase from Carroll, then they spotted him driving on highway and pulled him over (went across state lines?)
Supreme court found that cars aren’t like little houses and so when necessary they msut be dreated as different - they upheld the arrest since they said that “where it is not practical to secure a warrant, because the vehicle can be quickly moved out of the locality or jurisdiction in which the warrant must be sought.”
this was early case whose consequences would be felt later
Erosion of 4th amendment: Ker Vs California 1963
couple arrested after officers from the LA sheriff’s department observed a person suspected of selling illegal drugs and in searching for the suspect, the officers entered into Ker’s apartment without a warrant and saw marijuana in a brick-like package.
precedent: Police are exempted from knock and announce if they believe evidence might be destroyed and if they had probable cause - **it was a 5-4 decision tho so rly close call**
• Dissent: Ker decision does “obvious violence to the presumption of innocence” and argued that “innocent civilians should not suffer the shock, fright, or embarrassment attendant upon an unannounced police intrusion.”
• Set the legal foundations for “no-knock raids” - what SWAT ended up doing
erosion fo 4th amendment: Terry v Ohio 1968
Terry went back and forth past a store a few times (called casing - reminiscent of he walked by night) and an officer saw this and arrested him on the basis that he thought the man was armed (he found a concealed weapon)- argued with his experience and the situation he was allowed to exceed the judge, warrant, & proper process
Ruling: Police can perform a search for weapons without a warrant and without probably cause when the officer reasonably believes that person may be armed and dangerous.
dissent “We hold today that the police have greater authority to make a seizure and conduct a search than a judge has to authorize such an action… To give the police greater power than a magistrate is to take a long step down the totalitarian path.”
• “Terry Stops” precursor to Stop and Frisk and Pretext Stops (of cars later)
1914 Weeks v US (Warrantless Searches)
Fremont Weeks arrested for using the mail to transport lottery tickets
Weeks’ neighbor allows officers into Weeks home and seized his personal papers
Unanimous decision of Supreme Court that since there was no warrant for the items, the search was illegal under the 4th Amendment and papers should have been excluded as evidence
Established precedent that evidence obtained in unlawful search cannot be used
YAY
1961 Mapps v Ohio (weeks case applied to states
its often the case that something is ruled and sets a precident at the federal level then tis reaffirmed at the state level
Police conducted a warrantless search of Mapps’ home during a search for a bombing suspect
Police found pornographic materials in his apartment that were prohibited under Ohio Law
Established at state level the “exclusionary rule” from Weeks (that evidence obtained unlawfully cannot be used)
Miranda v Arizona 1965
Ernesto Miranda arrested in house and brought to police station where he was questioned about a kidnapping and rape. Police extracted a confession from him after two hours but failed to inform him of his 5th amendment rights (“right to remain silent…”)
• Miranda one of four cases claiming that the right to protection against self-incrimination extends to police interrogation.
• Ruling that required a suspect to be reminded of his rights (“Mirandized”) before questioning. to this point there was no rule about telling people their rights - close case and trouble fr dragnet
dissent argued majority opinion overly constrained police officers’ ability to execute their duties.and Nixon+ plice officers reacted to the “liberal court” that made this decision
Tennessee v Garner (use of deadly force) 1985
fifteen-year-old boy was shot and killed by police feeling a burglary scene.
Officer claimed he was acting under a Tennessee state statute authorizing deadly force “if, after notice of the intention to arrest the defendant, he either flee or forcibly resist, the officer may use all the necessary means to effect the arrest.”
• Court finds that deadly use of force in this case violated the 4th amendment. & the statute itself was unconstitutional
• Ruling that officer can’t use deadly force to prevent escape unless there’s "probably cause that the suspect is poses a threat of death or serious physical injury to the officer or others.”
Dissent argued police need to make spur of the moment decisions in the public interest
Graham v Connor 1989
Dethorne Graham goes to convenience store to get juice to counter insulin reaction cus of diabetes. a police officer observes him wobbling in checkout line and assumed he is drunk or high.
In the process of arresting him (holdup, is seeing a little high rly grounds for arrest?) he uses a lot of force and breaks Graham’s foot +leaves him with hearing problems (WTF happened)
US supreme court hears case cus theres no est. standard for use of force cases and found that use of force was reasonable since the reasonableness of a call must been seen from the POV of a reasonable officer on the scene not with hindsight
precedent that “reasonableness” can refer back to a local department’s own use of force standards which makes the definition relaly vague
Florida v Bostick (just say no?) 1991
During a drug sweep of a bus in Florida (common practice to stop buses and search everyone), the officers do not inform individuals that they are free to remain silent, to not answer questions, and to decline a search of their bag.
• Police find drugs in Bostick’s duffle bag.
• Florida Supreme Court finds the police violated Bostick’s 4th Amendment rights.
• But the Supreme Court overturns with the argument that “reasonable people” know they do not legally have to answer questions in such circumstances. - such bullshit honestly
Whren v Ohio (1996)
A search of a car with a busted taillight led to a drug seizure. and Whren argued that if cops follow you for long enough they will find some pretext to pull you over and they shouldn’t be able to do this endlessly. they should have limited power to make “pretext stops” using minor traffic violations to look for drugs or weapons
Supreme Court decided that “any traffic offense committed by a driver was a legitimate basis for a legal stop.”
many cases such as this end up having to do with race at their root - racial bias
McClesky v Kemp (racial bias) 1987
Ruling: Racial bias could not be challenged under the 14th Amendment (equal protection clause) without clear evidence of conscious discriminatory intent.
Case involved a death penalty case of black man who killed white officer. The Baldus study found overwhelming statistical evidence of racial bias in Georgian death penalty cases. (also entirely white courts tha seemed statisically impossible
The court ruled that statistical evidence not the same as existence of conscious racial bias.
Dissent argued that the case “closed the courthouse door to claims of racial bias in sentencing