1/27
midterm on November 5th
Describe briefly what De Interpretatione was about and what specific parts of speech was included.
Written by Aristotle, focuses on the theory of language.
Outlined specific terminology of sentences
Affirmations and denials
Universals and particulars
Contrary and contradictory statements
Aristotle’s Terminology: Names
a spoken sound significant by convention (significant because it is agreed-upon), when broken down into syllables, names have no significance.
Aristotle’s Terminology: Sentences
a spoken sound that carries an idea and has meaning
when broken down, into words for example, the separate parts still carry meaning
it expresses a concept or idea but does not make a statement about whether something is true or false
needs to have a subject and a predicate
Aristotle’s Terminology: Statements
not every sentence is a statement, but every statement is a sentence
statements include whether there is truth or falsity (that’s why not every sentence is a statement)
Aristotle’s Terminology: Affirmation
to affirm is to combine a predicate and a subject
ex. Socrates is white
Aristotle’s Terminology: Denial/Negation
to separate a predicate from a subject
ex. Socrates is not white
Aristotle’s Terminology: Contradictory Opposites
an affirmation and it’s negation where one is universal and the other in non-universal
if one is true, the other is false, and vice versa
ex. All trees are green” and “some trees are green
Aristotle’s Terminology: Contrary opposites
an affirmation and its negation where both are universal
can’t both be true at the same time, though its possible for them both to be false
ex. “All trees are green” and “No trees are green”
What can’t be true or false statements? (IQEP)
Imperatives: Help!
Questions: Why are you on your phone?
Expressive acts: Oh, how romantic
Performative Acts: I hereby declare you husband and wife
What is logic?
concerned with the truth or falsity of one sentence and how it is related to the truth and or falsity of other sentences
What are syllogisms?
basic forms of logical argument, formed with two premises and a conclusion
Briefly describe what is the Turing test.
designed by Alan Turing to assess a machine’s ability to think by imitating dialogue
An interrogator asks a computer (A or B) and a human (A or B) questions and examines the written responses. The interrogator tries to identify the machine and the machine passes if the evaluator cannot reliably tell them apart.
results depend not on how correctly the machine answers, but rather how closely the machine’s answers can resemble those of a human
Describe some advantages of the Turing test.
it is a definite experiment that could be carried out in practice
it isolates the intellectual aspects of a person (i.e. what we might call thinking)
we could test all possible intellectual abilities in this way, the question and answer method seems to be suitable for introducing almost any mode of thinking that we want to include
What was the theological objection to the Turing Test and what was Turing’s Reply?
thinking was an exclusive function to humans souls which God gave to humans beings but not to animals or machines
reply: we would just be instruments of God’s will if we created thinking machines
What was the heads-in-the-sands objection to the Turing Test and what was Turing’s reply?
the thought that the consequences of machines thinking would be too dreadful
reply: this argument is rarely said openly, and he doesn’t think this argument is sufficient substantial to require refutation. consolation would be appropriate instead.
What was the mathematical objection to the Turing Test and his response
for any given digital computer, there will always be some question which it will be unable to answer
reply: humans are likely subject to the exact same logical limits as machines
What was the consciousness objection to the Turing Test and his response
a machine and follow rules and produce language without truly feeling or being aware of its thoughts like a human can
reply: turing doesn’t dismiss this argument and suggests that in order to really know what a machine thinks, you have to be inside of the machine yourself.
Briefly describe the Chinese room thought experiment and who thought of it
Searle thought of it
a person is in a closed room which has a slot for a piece of paper that is written in Chinese to be passed back and forth. the person cannot read Chinese but they can follow a giant rule book that tell the person what to write down in Chinese.
by using the rules, the person can imitate someone who can read and write Chinese characters
What was the first objection to the Chinese room and Searle’s reply
The systems objection: even though the individual person in the room does not understand the story, the individual is rather part of a whole system that understands the story. understanding is not merely being ascribed to just the individual person but part of the whole system he is a part of.
reply: if the person internalized all the elements and memorized all the rules. that doesn’t mean the person still understands Chinese.
What was the second objection to the Chinese room and Searle’s reply
The robot objection: if you place a computer inside a robotic body equipped with cameras, microphones and other technology, the machine can interact directly with the physical environment, allowing the robot to link words or symbols to real-world objects and actions.
reply: he expanded the thought experiment and asked up to imagine that the person inside the room still follows the rules. because the person inside still doesn’t understand what the symbols mean as they are just following a manual, Searle argued that adding a mechanical body and cameras doesn’t create genuine consciousness or understanding.
What was the final objection to the Chinese room thought experiment and Searle’s response.
The brain simulator objection: if a computer program did not just mimic general rules but actually simulated the sequence of neuron firings in a native Chinese speaker’s brain, the system would genuinely understand Chinese.
reply: the water pipe analogy - imagine the person inside the room was operating a massive elaborate system of water pipes instead of a book where the pipes are supposed to represent every single neuron and synapse of a Chinese speaker’s brain. the person moving the vales or the network of water pipes still does not understand Chinese.
What was Descartes Philosophy?
his views on the nature of the mind, certainty, and the external world
What was Meditation I about (simple phrase)
explains his method of skeptical doubt and his desire for reliable knowledge
What was Meditation II about (simple phrase)
explains how he can be certain of his own existence and the contents of his mind
What is Descarte’s position on the nature of knowledge called and what is it about?
foundationalism: the idea that our knowledge of reality in general is ultimately based upon our knowledge of a few basic underlying facts
What does Descartes say about empirical knowledge (such as knowledge gained from the 5 senses) and priori knowledge (knowledge obtained by reason such as mathematical truths) in Meditation I
Empirical knowledge is less reliable since the senses can deceive us. Priori knowledge is more reliable but can still be incorrect
What does Descartes say in Meditation II about essential and inessential properties?
Essential properties are identified by reason, inessential properties are identified by the senses.
What are Descartes two big claims in Meditation II
He can be certain of his own existence
His own essential property is that he is a thinking being