1/4
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Theology and ideology
Pre Reformation Cathos
Centred in Rome under papal supremacy which taught salvation required the 7 sacraments like mass and confession.
1500s criticism targeted political corruption and mechanical rituals
Martin Luthers Protest
Argued salvation by faith alone rejecting good works and papal authority,
Preached the spiritual equality of protests and laity
Counter Reformation
Launched at council of Trent to reassert papal authority and deploy missionary orders like the jesuits to reconvert Europe
John Calvin & Predestination
Based in Geneva ,Calvin taught predestination and the idea that God has already chosen the elect for salvation and unregenerate for damnation
Theological differences dictated how society and authority was ordered. The Counter Reformation created a militant Catholic resurgence that fueled Anglo-Protestant paranoia regarding plots and invasions. Calvinist predestination did not breed passive fatalism but produced more intensive moral activism as living a godly life was viewed as outward proof of being among the elect.
Patrick Collinson emphasises the Calvinist predestination actually formed the consensus theology of the mainstream elizabthean and Jacobean church meaning holding Calvinist doctrine didn’t automatically make someone a radical.
Catholic vs Protestant worship
Catholicism
Richly decorated statues , stained glass and images of saints to inspire reverence
Priests wore ornate vestements and services were conducted in Latin
High altar separated from the congregation by a rood screen to emphasise hierarchy and priestly mediation
Protestant
Pulpit placed prominently for preaching alongside an accessible communion table
Plain whitewashed walls with the 10 commandments and English prayers
Ministers wore plain robes standing near the people to read and preach from an English bible
Visual church Lyon’s were direct reflection of political authority. When Charles I and Lauf forced communion tables east as railed in altars , puritans saw it as a deliberate reversal of the reformation and stepping stone toward catholic absolutism
Tudor Pendulum and Elizabethan Compromise
Henry VII broke with Rome via the Act of Supremacy without radically altering catho doctrine, Edward Vi enacted radical ProtReformation and Mary I restored papal authority married Phillip of Spain and burned nearly 300 Prots.
Elizabeth I’s settlement engineered a political compromise/ middle way that was Calvinist in doctrine but catholic style ceremonies and bishops so the crown could control the church hierarchy.
Puritans and Presbs viewed the church as half reformed and sought further purification from within while presbs demanded abolition of bishops in favor of elected lay elders. Lizzy blocked parliamentary reforms in the 1570s and used her bishops to suppress puritan meetings.
Prevented immediate religious civil war in England and preserved royal supremacy
Freezing reform midway left James an unresolved ideological time bomb, bishops linked the church directly to the monarch ‘’no bishop , no king’’ any presb attack on church hierarchy was simultaneously an attack on royal authority.
Religious Geography
England & Wales
Officially Anglican - Calvinist doctrine with traditional liturgy and bishops. Contained persistent catholic minority of recusants and vocal puritan wing pushing for further reform.
Scotland
Lowlands dominated by strictly Calvinist anti bishop Presbyterian Kirk by john Knox
Highlands remained heavily catholic among the clans
Ireland
Volatile colonial powder keg
Vast majority of native Irish remained fiercely catholic looking to priests as commiunoity leaders after the death of Gaelic chieftains
Meanwhile the crown imposed an Anglican Church of Ireland in Dublin and planted miltant Scottish/anglo presbs in Ulster
L5 Threadables
The "No Bishop, No King" Constitutional Lock: Because Elizabeth I and James I relied on episcopacy (bishops) to enforce royal supremacy over the Church, religious disputes automatically became constitutional battles. When Puritans and Presbyterians attacked bishops in the 1630s–40s, the Crown viewed it as an attack on monarchy itself. media-48267325-DF7C-… +1
2. The Long Shadow of "Popery" (1603–1688): The anti-Catholic paranoia forged during Mary I’s burnings and the 1570 Counter-Reformation created a permanent ideological trigger in English politics. Whether it was Charles I’s French Catholic queen (Henrietta Maria) and Laudian rituals in the 1630s, Charles II’s Secret Treaty of Dover (1670), or James II’s open Catholicism during the Exclusion Crisis (1679–81), the fear of "Popery and arbitrary government" consistently united Parliament against the Stuart kings. IMG_8267.heic +1
3. The Three Kingdoms Domino Effect: The incompatible religious map of 1603 directly explains why Stuart rule collapsed twice—first in 1637–42 (when imposing Anglicanism on Presbyterian Scotland sparked the Bishops' Wars and the Irish Rebellion), and again in 1688 (when James II used Ireland and Scotland as testing grounds for Catholic toleration, terrifying English Protestants into inviting William of Orange).