1/7
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What are the characteristics of the ontological argument for the existence of God?
Deductibe
Analytic
A priori
What is Anselm’s argument for the existence of God?
P1: God = being TWNGBCBC
P2: Understand what it means to speak of P1
P3: We can conceive of being existing irl
P4: If we understand x, x exists in understanding
C: God = in understanding
P5: Suppose G exists in un, not irl
P6: If G exists in un alone, but can be conceived to exist irl, then that thing can be conceived to be greater than it actually is
P7: God can be conceived to be greater than he actually is
C: Being cannot be conceived to be greater than it is can be conceived to be greater than it is
C: Bc previous C = contradictory, G exists in irl
P8: Possible to conceive of something that cannot be thought of as not existing
P9: Something cannot be thought of to not > something that can be thought of to not exist
C: God’s existence in reality = necessary
What is Gaunilo’s parody argument?
P1: Lost Island = TTWNGICBC
P2: Lost Island exists in mind, but not in reality
P3: Existence in reality > existence in understanding alone
P4: Conceivable that Lost Island exists in reality
P5: It is conceivable that there is an island greater than lost island
C: Conceivable that there is an island greater than that island TWNGICBC
What is Anselm’s response to Gaunilo?
An island is a land mass surrounded by a body of water
God is the greatest conceivable being
What is Descartes’ argument for the existence of God?
P1: I have the innate idea of God
P2: The idea of God is the idea of a supremely perfect being
P3: A supremely perfect being does not lack any perfection
P4: Existence is a perfection
C: Therefore, God exists
What is Descartes’ argument for the inseparability of God and existence?
The property of a triangle’s angles adding up to 180 degrees cannot be separated from the concept of a triangle
The concept of God existing cannot be separated from the concept of God, as existence is a perfection
What is Hume’s response to Descartes’ argument?
P1: If something is demonstrable, it involves a contradiction
P2: Nothing that is distinctly conceivable implies a contradiction
P3: Whatever we conceive as existent, we can also conceive as non-existent
C: Therefore, there is no being whose non-existence implies a contradiction
What is Kant’s response to Descartes’ argument?
P1: If ‘God does not exist’ is a contradiction, then ‘God exists’ is an analytic truth
P2: If ‘God exists’ is an analytic truth, then ‘existence’ is part of the concept of God
P3: Existence is not a predicate, something that can be added on to another concept
C1: Therefore, ‘God exists’ is not an analytic truth
C2: Therefore, ‘God does not exist’ is not a contradiction
C3: Therefore, we cannot deduce the existence of God from the concept of God
C4: Therefore, ontological arguments cannot prove that God exists