1/54
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What is a land estate?
A legallly defined interest in land
Heirs
People legally entitled to inherit someone’s property when that person dies without a valid will (intestate) — heirs do not exist until someone dies (they are only prospective heirs, only “mere expectancy”
Assigns
People/entitles to whom someone transfers their rights or interests in property (through a transfer or assignment during the original owner’s lifetime or otherwise)
Devisees
People who receive real property under someon'e’s valid will
Fee tail
“to A until bloodline ends, then a reversion to grantor” — abolished in most states and at most theoretical existence in others
Will
a document that directs who receives someone’s property after death
Inheritance
the process of receiving property from someone who has died (either by will (or if no will), then the state’s intestacy laws)
Present possessory interests
fee simple absolute
life estate
defeasible fees (fee simple determinable, fee simple subject to condition subsequent, fee simple subject to executory limitation)
Defeasible fees
fee simple determinable
fee simple subject to condition subsequent
fee simple subject to execturoy limitation
Future interests retained by grantors
reversion
possibility of reverter
right of entry (power of termination)
Future interests in grantees
remainder
indefeasible vested
contingent
vested subject to complete divestment
vested subject to partial divestment (or subject to open)
executory interest
Future interest for: fee simple absolute
none
Future interest for: life estate
reversion or remainder
Future interest for: fee simple determinable
possible occurence of limitation event —> possibility of reverter
Future interest for: fee simple subject to condition subsequent
possible occurence of condition —> right of entry/ power of termination
Future interest for: fee simple subject to executory limitation
possible cutting off by occurence of limitation event —> executory interest
When does an interest vest in possession?
When the interest becomes a present possessory one
When does an interest vest in interest (but not possession)
means that the various types of uncertainty about the interest have been resolved
When remainders vest
Uncertainty as to who is in the class of people to inherit
Ex: “To A for life, then to A’s children” —> when A has children, remainder is vested subject to partial divestment
Uncertainty relating to contingencies
Ex: “To any of my now living children who pass the bar”
When reversion vests
Considered vested in interest upon its creation, whether or not the interest ever becomes possessory (not resolved until contingent event occurs)
When executory interests vest
Normally they must become possessory in order to vest in interest
Fee simple absolute
Potentially infinite duration (which is why it’s called a “fee”); NO limitations on its inheritability(which is why it’s called “simple”); cannot be divested, nor will it end on the happening of any event (which is why it’s “absolute”)
largest package of rights
in a transfer, a grantor is presumed to give all that they have, unless they indicate otherwise
Doesn’t need to say “and his/her heirs” → it will still create a fee simple
Ex: O grants Blackacre “to Marge and her heirs”
Fee simple absolute
Ex: O grants Blackacre “to Marge in fee simple”, or “to Marge”
Fee simple absolute
Ex: O grants Blackacre “to Marge”
Fee simple absolute
Life estate
Unlike the fee simple, the life estate comes to a natural end with the death of a named person, usually the holder of the estate
Life estate is alienable by gift or sale (but not will)
Ex: O grants Blackacre “to Marge for life, and then to Lisa”
Marge has a life estate (which ends with Marge’s death), followed by a remainder in fee simple in Lisa
Ex: “to Bart for life so long as alcohol is not consumed on the premises”
This is a life estate determinable (but less common); O retains reversion
Fee simple determinable
Ends automatically upon the occurrence of a named event, whereupon the grantor or the grantor’s successor takes the property
This event may never happen, in which case, the fee simple determinable acts much like the fee simple absolute, except for the possibility of the contingency happening
Created using language of duration — as long as; so long as; while; during; until.
Traditional language called this a “limitation” rather than a condition
Ex: O grants Blackacre “to Springfield Law School as long as it is used for instruction in the law, then to O”
Fee simple determinable (O has a possibility of reverter)
Fee simple subject to condition subsequent
Continues indefinitely, except upon the happening of a named event (the condition), the interest does not automatically end but can be ended by action (self-help or lawsuit) by the grantor or the grantor’s successor (who holds a future interest called a right of reentry/power of termination)
Created using language — but if; on condition that; provided that; provided; however, if (as opposed to language in duration in fee simple determinable)
And the condition subsequent is often separated form the description of the interest by a comma condition is treated as something separate from the interest that it can cut short, so it’s often in its own clause
Ex: O grants Blackacre “to Springfield Law School, but if it is not used for the instruction in the law then O has the right to reenter and take the premises”
Here, Springfield Law School has a fee simple subject to condition subsequent, and O has a right of entry/ power of termination — So, if a condo is built on Blackacre instead, then the Law School only loses Blackacre if O (or his successor in interest) takes action to recover the property
Fee simple subject to executory limitation
If the defeasible fee is followed by an interest not reserved to the grantor (i.e., granted to some third party at the time of conveyance of the present possessory estate), then this is a fee simple subject to executory limitation
The following future interest is called an executory interest
The future interest is to a third party
(“as long as” or “but if” style can be used interchangeably)
Ex: O grants Blackacre “to Springfield Law School as long as it is used for instruction in the law, then to Springfield Animal Hospital”
Fee simple subject to executory limitation; Springfield Animal Hospital has an executory interest
Ex: O grants Blackacre “to Springfield Law School, but if it is not used for instruction in the law, then to the Springfield Animal Hospital”
Fee simple subject to executory limitation; Springfield Animal Hospital has an executory interest
Reversion
Retains by the grantor — Follows the natural end of a life estate and in other contexts in which an owner has not disposed of the entire fee
Possibility of Reverter
The interest reserved follows a fee simple determinable to the grantor that —> will automatically get the property back if the limitation built into the fee simple determinable occurs
If the limitation event occurs, then O (or O’s successor as holder of the future interest) becomes the fee simple owner again
Ex: O grants Blackacre “to Springfield Law School as long as it is used for instruction in the law”
Fee simple determinable (O maintains reverter even if implicit)
Right of Entry/Power of Termination
Follows a fee simple subject to condition subsequent
Condition subsequent for the preceding interest and a condition precedent for the future interest
If the condition occurs, nothing happens automatically, but it does give O the right to oust the holder of the fee simple subject to condition subsequent (can either attempt a physical entry (subject to the limits on self-help or bring an action to recover possession)
Right of entry must be exercised within a reasonable time (potentially the statute of limitations in some states)
Interests created in a grantee
Remainder
Executory interest
Remainder
Follows a life estate (never a fee simple), which becomes possessory upon the natural end of the preceding interest (death)
Similar to a reversion, but instead the remainder is in a third party (not the grantor)
Indefeasibly vested remainder
Identity of the takes is known and there is no other contingency that has to be fulfilled before the interest is ready to become possessory other than the natural termination of the preceding interest
Ex: Marge grants Blackacre “to Homer for life, then to Bart, Lisa, and Maggie, and their heirs”
Ex: Marge grants Blackacre “to Homer for life, then to Bart, Lisa, and Maggie, and their heirs”
Life tenant to Bart; remainder (indefeasibly vested)
Ex: Marge grants Blackacre “to Homer for life, then to Bart if he graduates from high school by age 19”
Life tenant to Bart; remainder (contingent) (uncertainty as to the occurence of the condition)
If Homer dies before Bart graduates from high school, there is a reversion in Marge (which can be divested by Bart’s graduation before 19) if the grantor has not given everything a way, a reversion is retained
Ex: Marge grants Blackacre “to Homer for life, then to his children and their heirs”
Life tenant to Bart; remainder (contingent) (uncertainty as to the occurence of the condition); also vested subject to partial divestment (or subject to open)
Uncertainty as to the identity of the class of takers
If Bart graduates high school under 19 but Homer is still alive, then Bart’s remainder is vested in interest but not in possession
Contingent remainder
A remainder with uncertainty of identity of takes or occurrence of condition·
When uncertainty resolves, the remainders “vest in interest”
Ex: Marge grants Blackacre “to Homer for life, then to Bart if he graduates from high school by age 19, otherwise to Lisa and her heirs”
An alternative contingent remainder, so that one vests if the other one does not
Remainder — Vested subject to complete divestment
The occurrence of a condition can cause the interest to shift to someone else
Ex: Marge grants Blackacre “to Homer for life, then to Bart; but if Bart fails to graduate from high school by age 19, then to Lisa”
Ex: Marge grants Blackacre “to Homer for life, then to Bart; but if Bart fails to graduate from high school by age 19, then to Lisa”
Vested subject to complete divestment — the occurrence of a condition can cause the interest to shift to someone else
Vested subject to partial divestment (or subject to open)
t
Executory Interest
A future interest in a transferee (not retained by the grantor), but unlike the remainder following a life estate which becomes possessory upon the natural end of the preceding interest (death), the executory interest is an interest in a transferee (not retained by the grantor) that divests or cuts short in previous interest — so it’s an interest in transferee that cuts short previous interest
Ex: Marge grants Blackacre “to Bart, but if alcohol is ever consumed on the premises, then to Ned Flanders”
he fee simple subject to an executory limitation is cut off early by the happening of the condition subsequent, and the following interest in Ned Flanders is an executory interest
The executory interest divests the interest of a third party (here Bart), so it is a “shifting” executory interest
(Violates RAP)
Ex: Marge grants Blackacre “to Bart for life, remainder to Lisa 5 years after his death”
There is a reversion in Marge here that would become possessory in the 5-year period after Bart’s death, then Lisa has a “springing” executory interest because it divests the reversion in the grantor (Marge)
Ex: Homer grants Blackacre “to Marge for life, but if she remarries, then to Lisa”
An executory interest can cut short an interest that would otherwise come to a natural end (by death)
(can do these as long as it’s motivated by a concern to support a widowed spouse until remarriage, but not if they seemed to be motivated out of a desire to prevent someone’s marriage “to Marge, but if she ever marries Ned Flanders, then to Lisa”
This is fine with RAP, because Marge’s death puts an end to the possibility of Lisa’s interest vesting
Ex: Marge grants Blackacre “to Bart as long as the premises are not used for consuming alcohol during his lifetime, then to Ned Flanders”
Fee simple subject to an executory limitation followed by an executory interest
3rd party transferee becomes possessory automatically upon the condition happening, so no future interest in a grantee that works like the right of entry