1/99
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Parents and guardians have liberty to direct the _____ and _____ of their children.
Parents and guardians have liberty to direct the upbringing and education of their children.
Texas abortion law provides exceptions for the _____ and _____ of the mother.
Texas abortion law has no exception for _____ or _____.
Texas abortion law provides exceptions for the life and health of the mother.
Texas abortion law in the outline has no exception for rape or incest.
Breach of Promise to Marry: A petitioner can prove a breach-of-promise-to-marry contract with either written evidence signed by _____ or testimony from at least _____ disinterested witnesses.
Texas has a _____-year statute of limitations for breach of promise to marry.
A petitioner can prove a breach-of-promise-to-marry contract with either written evidence signed by each party or testimony from at least two disinterested witnesses.
Texas has a 1-year statute of limitations for breach of promise to marry.
Breach of promise to marry:
Damages:
Monetary and _____ value of the marriage (_____ damages), as well as the expenses incurred in _____ for the marriage (_____ damages).
Damages for mental anguish and humiliation as also recoverable
Defenses:
Plaintiff’s lack of _____ or love for the defendant
_____ decision to end the engagement
Breach of promise to marry:
Damages:
Monetary and social value of the marriage (expectation damages), as well as the expenses incurred in preparation for the marriage (reliance damages).
Damages for mental anguish and humiliation as also recoverable
Defenses:
Plaintiff’s lack of chasity or love for the defendant
Mutual decision to end the engagement
Gifts Given in Contemplation of Marriage
Ask first whether the gift is a gift given in contemplation of marriage
If engagement gift, it is a _____ gift, and the condition is _____
An argument can be made that the ring/gift was an _____ gift (i.e. birthday/Christmas gift)
Courts consider the _____ of the gift, _____ , and _____ of the broken engagement
Until the condition is met, the recipient only has _____ interest, giver has _____ interest
If the ring is an engagement gift/ring, the recipient must fulfill the condition (marriage) to become the _____ owner of the conditional gift
Once the condition is fulfilled, the recipient may keep the gift/ring as their personal and separate property in the case of divorce/separation
Gifts Given in Contemplation of Marriage
Ask first whether the gift is a gift given in contemplation of marriage
If engagement gift, it is a conditional gift, and the condition is marriage
An argument can be made that the ring/gift was an unconditional gift (i.e. birthday/Christmas gift)
Courts consider the nature of the gift, circumstances, and cause of the broken engagement
Until the condition is met, the recipient only has possessory interest, giver has ownership interest
If the ring is an engagement gift/ring, the recipient must fulfill the condition (marriage) to become the unconditional owner of the conditional gift
Once the condition is fulfilled, the recipient may keep the gift/ring as their personal and separate property in the case of divorce/separation
In a majority of states using a no-fault approach to broken engagements, who gets the engagement ring?
Texas follows an _____-fault approach to broken engagements.
The recipient must return the ring regardless of fault.
Texas follows an at-fault approach to broken engagements.
Prenups: In Texas-
Enforceable prenups: must be (1) in _____ AND (2) _____ by both parties to be enforced.
Defenses to an enforceable prenup:
Signing must be _____ AND
Factors demonstrating voluntariness: (cannot be _____ before the wedding!)
_____ AND failure to disclose _____ or _____ _____of the other party
Unconscionability: _____ unfair to one party, and is judged by conditions at the _____ of signing
_____ unconscionability: lack of _____ OR _____ bargaining power
_____ unconscionability: whether the provisions of the agreement are _____ in _____
Prenups: In Texas-
Enforceable prenups: must be (1) in writing AND (2) signed by both parties to be enforced.
Defenses to an enforceable prenup:
Signing must be voluntary OR
Factors demonstrating voluntariness: (cannot be days before the wedding!)
Unconscionability AND failure to disclose property or financial obligations of the other party
Unconscionability: grossly unfair to one party, and is judged by conditions at the time of signing
Procedural unconscionability: lack of understanding OR unequal bargaining power
Substantive unconscionability: whether the provisions of the agreement are mutual in scope
Although the right to marry is a fundamental right, the right is subject to restrictions: _____ , _____ , _____ -_____ .
Although the right to marry is a fundamental right, the right is subject to restrictions: incest, bigamy, under-age.
Incest bans are generally constitutional because they are supported by legitimate state interests such as preventing _____ defects and protecting family relations.
Incest bans are generally constitutional because they are supported by legitimate state interests such as preventing genetic defects and protecting family relations.
Bigamy is banned in _____ states, and Texas treats bigamy as a _____.
Bigamy is banned in all states, and Texas treats bigamy as a felony.
Texas does not permit marriage below the age of _____; creates a _____ marriage if married underage and not emancipated.
Texas does not permit marriage below the age of 16; creates a VOID marriage if married underage and not emancipated
A valid marriage must be entered into _____ and parties MUST have the _____ _____ to consent.
Voluntariness: Voluntariness in marriage is often defined as the absence of _____ and _____.
_____ that parties have mental capacity to marry unless proven otherwise (low burden)
A valid marriage must be entered into voluntarily and parties MUST have the mental capacity to consent.
Voluntariness: Voluntariness in marriage is often defined as the absence of fraud and duress.
Presumption that parties have mental capacity to marry unless proven otherwise (low burden)
A valid marriage must be entered into voluntarily, and parties must have the mental capacity to _____ to marriage. There is a presumption that parties have mental capacity to marry unless _____ otherwise.
Marriage must be entered into voluntarily, and parties must have the mental capacity to consent to marriage. There is a presumption that parties have mental capacity to marry unless proven otherwise.
Texas may grant an _____ for in _____ marriage (fraud, duress, or force) if it induced the marriage and the coerced party has not voluntarily _____ with the other after learning of the fraud or being released from force/duress.
whether the fraud/duress/force _____ the marriage
continuing _____ = divorce
Texas may grant an annulment for fraud, duress, or force if it induced the marriage and the coerced party has not voluntarily cohabited with the other after learning of the fraud or being released from force/duress.
Immigration fraud = _____ marriages and _____ liability
Imprisoned for not more than 5 years or fined not more than 250k (or both)
_____ spouse waiver: allows _____ immigrant women to apply for permanent legal residence without their abusive citizen spouse’s _____
Immigration fraud = void marriages and criminal liability
Imprisoned for not more than 5 years or fined not more than 250k (or both)
Battered spouse waiver: allows battered immigrant women to apply for permanent legal residence without their abusive citizen spouse’s participation
All states (save AL) require licensure prior to marriage solemnization. Failure to obtain a marriage license will generally not be fatal to a marriage unless the failure makes the marriage _____ under statute.
All states (save AL) require licensure prior to marriage solemnization. Failure to obtain a marriage license will generally not be fatal to a marriage unless the failure makes the marriage void under statute.
A formal marriage generally requires a _____, although the nature of the ceremony is left to the parties and celebrant.
A formal marriage generally requires a ceremony, although the nature of the ceremony is left to the parties and celebrant.
Proxy marriage: A proxy marriage is where one party is _____ to attend so someone _____ _____ for that party
Texas permits proxy marriage when the absent party is a member of the _____ forces stationed in another country and unable to attend.
Proxy marriage: A proxy marriage is where one party is unable to attend so someone stands in for that party
Texas permits proxy marriage when the absent party is a member of the armed forces stationed in another country and unable to attend.
A common-law marriage is just as valid as a ceremonial/formal marriage in states that recognize it and requires a common-law _____ to end it.
A common-law marriage is just as valid as a ceremonial marriage in states that recognize it and requires a common-law divorce to end it.
Texas recognizes _____-law marriages.
The four elements of a Texas common-law marriage are _____ , _____ agreement to marry, living together, and _____ _____ as married.
_____ : Understanding that marriage is a legal status + permanent
_____ agreement to marry NOT future agreement
Can be demonstrated by conduct (i.e. purchasing a family home together)
Living together: must cohabit in the _____ you want to recognize your marriage
_____ _____ as married: means community representation/publicly representing other as _____ and _____.
Texas recognizes common-law marriages.
The four elements of a Texas common-law marriage are capacity, present agreement to marry, living together, and holding out as married.
Capacity: Understanding that marriage is a legal status + permanent
Present agreement to marry NOT future agreement
Can be demonstrated by conduct (i.e. purchasing a family home together)
Living together: must cohabit in the state you want to recognize your marriage
Holding out as married: means community representation/publicly representing other as _____ and _____.
A curative device is a legal doctrine used to _____ a marriage that may have skipped steps necessary for a formal marriage.
invalid formal/ceremonial marriage → valid _____ _____ marriage (granted the jurisdiction recognize those marriages)
putative spouse doctrine: protects a person who participated in _____ _____ in a ceremonial marriage while unaware of a reason that made the marriage invalid (_____ or _____)
_____ against a plaintiff’s argument that a marriage is invalid
A curative device is a legal doctrine used to cure a marriage that may have skipped steps necessary for a formal marriage.
invalid formal/ceremonial marriage → valid common law marriage (granted the jurisdiction recognize common law marriages)
putative spouse doctrine: protects a person who participated in good faith in a ceremonial marriage while unaware of a reason that made the marriage invalid (void or voidable)
protects against a plaintiff’s argument that a marriage is invalid
Void/voidable marriage:
A void marriage treats the couple as if the marriage _____ happened.
A void marriage can be challenged by a _____ party and even after the death of one party.
A voidable marriage remains valid until a _____ declares it invalid.
A voidable marriage can generally be challenged only by the _____.
Void/voidable marriage:
A void marriage treats the couple as if the marriage never happened.
A void marriage can be challenged by a third party and even after the death of one party.
A voidable marriage remains valid until a court declares it invalid.
A voidable marriage can generally be challenged only by the parties.
Annulment: declares that the marriage _____happened and is generally available for _____marriage or _____marriages found void
_____back doctrine: an annulment can be used to reinstate benefits lost on marriage
Divorce is _____for valid marriages
Annulment: declares that the marriage never happened and is generally available for void marriage or voidable marriages found void
Relation back doctrine: an annulment can be used to reinstate benefits lost on marriage
Divorce is REQUIRED for valid marriages
There are two property law regimes: (1) _____-_____ property regime and (2) _____property regime.
_____-_____property regime: property generally belongs to the spouse who _____ it or whose name is on the _____.
duty of support: husbands had a duty to support their wives and children
doctrine of _____: states will rarely _____/adjudicate spousal responsibilities of an ongoing marriage, but will evaluate whether the support is _____
doctrine of _____: husband/surviving spouse is liable for providing necessaries (i.e. food, clothing, shelter, and medical care)
_____ property regime: property acquired during marriage is generally owned by _____ spouses, regardless of who earned or titled it.
There are two property law regimes: (1) common law property regime and (2) community property regime.
common-law property regime: property generally belongs to the spouse who acquired it or whose name is on the title.
duty of support: husbands had a duty to support their wives and children
doctrine of nonintervention: states will rarely intervene/adjudicate spousal responsibilities of an ongoing marriage, but will evaluate whether the support is sufficient
doctrine of necessaries: husband/surviving spouse is liable for providing necessaries (i.e. food, clothing, shelter, and medical care)
community property regime: property acquired during marriage is generally owned by both spouses, regardless of who earned or titled it.
When determining whether to change a child’s last name, the court evaluates the _____ _____of the child:
Is the child able to make an _____ choice in the matter of the name;
Is the bond between the father and child _____ at best and if the name is changed, will the bond _____;
Does the father _____ the child, manifest a continuing _____ in them, and object in a _____ time;
Will changing the name further _____?
When determining whether to change a child’s last name, the court evaluates the best interests of the child:
Is the child able to make an intelligent choice in the matter of the name;
Is the bond between the father and child weak at best and if the name is changed, will the bond weaken;
Does the father support the child, manifest a continuing interest in them, and object in a reasonable time;
Will changing the name further estrangement?
Under Title VII as amended by the Pregnancy Discrimination Act, discrimination based on _____ is discrimination based on sex.
includes breastfeeding
Under Title VII as amended by the Pregnancy Discrimination Act, discrimination based on pregnancy is discrimination based on sex.
includes breastfeeding
The Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) provides up to _____ weeks of unpaid leave with a guaranteed right of return.
limited to named relationships and requires a _____ medical condition.
serious medical condition: an illness, injury, impairment, or physical or mental condition that requires _____ care or _____ treatment
The Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) provides up to 12 weeks of unpaid leave with a guaranteed right of return.
limited to named relationships and requires a serious medical condition.
serious medical condition: an illness, injury, impairment, or physical or mental condition that requires inpatient care or continuing treatment
Tort damages in Texas:
damages for pain and suffering, physical pain, and disfigurement are generally _____ property.
lost earnings, including disability insurance and workers' compensation, are generally _____ property.
Tort damages in Texas:
damages for pain and suffering, physical pain, and disfigurement are generally separate property.
lost earnings, including disability insurance and workers' compensation, are generally community property.
Criminal conversation (adultery) is _____ recognized as a tort in Texas.
requires _____ _____
Defenses = injured spouse’s _____ and the statute of limitations
Criminal conversation (adultery) is not recognized as a tort in Texas.
requires sexual intercourse
Defenses = injured spouse’s consent and the statute of limitations
Alienation of affection is recognized in only _____ states and is not recognized in Texas.
Alienation of affection:
_____ marriage before the defendant's interference.
The defendant's wrongful and malicious acts must be the _____ cause of the loss of love and affection.
Alienation of affection is recognized in only 6 states and is not recognized in Texas.
Alienation of affection:
in-tact/happy marriage before the defendant's interference.
The defendant's wrongful and malicious acts must be the proximate cause of the loss of love and affection.
The two marital evidentiary privileges are the adverse spousal testimonial privilege and the marital _____ privilege.
testimonial privilege: enables spouses to decline to testify adversely to each other in a _____ trial
must be married at time of _____
communications privilege: prevents admission of evidence of private communications between spouses made _____ the marriage
Criminal and civil trials
must be married at time of _____
The two marital evidentiary privileges are the adverse spousal testimonial privilege and the marital communications privilege.
testimonial privilege: enables spouses to decline to testify adversely to each other in a criminal trial
must be married at time of testimony
communications privilege: prevents admission of evidence of private communications between spouses made during the marriage
Criminal and civil trials
must be married at time of communication
Exceptions for marital evidentiary privilege:
There is _____ parent-child privilege according to the outline.
_____ participation in _____
Crimes against a _____ or _____ (important in DV cases)
Exceptions for marital evidentiary privilege:
There is no parent-child privilege according to the outline.
Joint participation in crime
Crimes against a spouse or child (important in DV cases)
Civil protection orders are issued by a judge on application of an IPV victim to restrain an abuser from committing _____ acts of IPV.
Civil protection orders are issued by a judge on application of an IPV victim to restrain an abuser from committing additional acts of IPV.
A temporary emergency protection order is usually _____ parte.
does not require _____ to the abuser
A temporary emergency protection order is usually ex parte.
does not require notice to the abuser
A permanent protective order requires advance notice and a _____.
In Texas, a permanent protective order generally lasts _____ years.
A permanent protective order requires advance notice and a hearing.
In Texas, a permanent protective order generally lasts 2 years.
Self-defense requires an imminent threat of force, reasonable fear of death or serious bodily injury, and a _____ response.
Self-defense requires an imminent threat of force, reasonable fear of death or serious bodily injury, and a proportional response.
Mandatory arrest policies require arrest based on _____ cause of IPV. With no-drop policies requiring prosecutors to advance all IPV cases to _____.
Mandatory arrest policies require arrest based on probable cause of IPV. With no-drop policies requiring prosecutors to advance all IPV cases to trial.
High-lethality IPV risk factors include prior IPV, especially choking, forced sex, stalking, and _____ use.
often used to demonstrate the need for a temporary/permanent protective order
High-lethality IPV risk factors include prior IPV, especially choking, forced sex, stalking, and weapon use.
often used to demonstrate the need for a temporary/permanent protective order
Criminalizing threats requires _____ intent, specifically a _____ standard.
_____ : means the defendant knew there was a _____ that the threats would strike fear.
True threats are _____ protected by the First Amendment.
A true threat must be perceived by a _____ person as a threat.
Criminalizing threats requires subjective intent, specifically a recklessness standard.
recklessness: means the defendant knew there was a _____ that the threats would strike fear.
True threats are NOT protected by the First Amendment.
A true threat must be perceived by a reasonable person as a threat.
Stalking is a pattern of repeated and unwanted attention, harassment, contact, or other conduct directed at a person that would cause a reasonable person to feel _____.
Stalking is generally not a First Amendment issue because it is _____ rather than speech.
Stalking is a pattern of repeated and unwanted attention, harassment, contact, or other conduct directed at a person that would cause a reasonable person to feel fear.
Stalking is generally not a First Amendment issue because it is conduct rather than speech.
There is (1) _____ -_____ divorce and (2) _____ -fault divorce.
TEXAS accepts fault grounds _____ no-fault grounds, but instead of insanity the statute says confinement in a mental institution
There is (1) fault-based divorce and (2) no-fault divorce.
TEXAS accepts fault grounds and no-fault grounds, but instead of insanity the statute says confinement in a mental institution
Fault-based grounds for divorce: _____ , _____ , _____ , _____ conviction, and _____.
Fault-based grounds for divorce: Adultery, cruelty, desertion, felony conviction, and insanity.
Adultery/Infidelity: _____ + _____ = creates the _____ that they engaged in actual sex
_____ : the tendency or personality that would lead to people to engage in adultery
_____ : opportunity _____ act of sex itself
All types of evidence can be used to prove both elements
Courts will ask for "convincing proof" (preponderance + bite)
Adultery/Infidelity
Elements/considerations: disposition + opportunity = inference that they engaged in actual sex
Disposition: the tendency or personality that would lead to people to engage in adultery
Opportunity: opportunity NOT act of sex itself
All types of evidence can be used to prove both elements
Courts will ask for "convincing proof" (preponderance + bite)
Cruelty = _____ of cruel behavior
Some states require adverse health effects
_____ health is enough, better w/_____ effects
Statute of limitations issues
Continuing tort of DV and the cause of action does not _____ until the last episode of DV
In a legal suit, a court may consider entire history of DV
Actual DV = cruelty
Cruelty = pattern of cruel behavior
Some states require adverse health effects
Mental health is enough, better w/physical effects
Statute of limitations issues
Continuing tort of DV and the cause of action does not accrue until the last episode of DV
In a legal suit, a court may consider entire history of DV
Actual DV = cruelty
Desertion/Abandonment
Separation without _____ or _____
Both may be inferred from circumstances
“consent” = more conduct than acquiescence
But: consent can be removed if the consensual break becomes _____ /_____
“cause” = cruelty, adultery, etc.
Intent to _____ , abandon, or terminate the relationship
For a _____ _____ (often one year)
Desertion/Abandonment
Separation without consent or cause
Both may be inferred from circumstances
“consent” = more conduct than acquiescence
Example: Take a break -> moves apart from each other = consensual break and no intent to abandon
But: consent can be removed if the consensual break becomes permanent/indefinite
“cause” = cruelty, adultery, etc.
Example: Wife moves to an apartment + husband helps her move = not consent
Intent to desert, abandon, or terminate the relationship
For a statutory period (often one year)
Defenses negated fault thus blocked a divorce in fault-based states:
_____
_____
_____
_____
Defenses negated fault thus blocked a divorce in fault-based states:
Recrimination
Condonation
Collusion
Connivance
Recrimination: only an _____ party can procure a divorce
Meaning: If both parties are _____ of _____ , neither gets a divorce
Recrimination: only an innocent party can procure a divorce
Meaning: If both parties are guilty of wrongdoing, neither gets a divorce
Condonation: a spouse cannot sue for fault-based divorce on issue that a they have already _____ their spouse for
Elements: forgiveness must be _____ + the forgiven spouse must _____ their ways
Condonation: a spouse cannot sue for fault-based divorce on issue that a they have already forgave their spouse for
Elements: forgiveness must be informed + the forgiven spouse must mend their ways
Connivance: _____ your spouse to engage in some marital _____ -_____ (often adultery) and then using that as fault grounds for divorce
Connivance: convincing your spouse to engage in some marital wrong-doing (often adultery) and then using that as fault grounds for divorce
Collusion: both partners agree to _____ or _____ evidence of fault in order to secure a divorce
Collusion: both partners agree to create or fabricate evidence of fault in order to secure a divorce
No-fault divorce
Elements/considerations: Living _____ and _____ for a period of time (usually _____ year)
Courts have a liberal understanding of these requirements, not even requiring a spouse to _____ the marital home -> just separate bedrooms
TEXAS: marriage just needs to be _____ !
No-fault divorce
Elements/considerations: Living separate and apart for a period of time (usually one year)
Courts have a liberal understanding of these requirements, not even requiring a spouse to leave the marital home -> just separate bedrooms
TEXAS: marriage just needs to be insupportable!
A court may dissolve the marriage (meaning just to divorce) if:
The court has jurisdiction over the _____ ; and
Lack of personal jurisdiction over the _____ is not a bar to dissolving the marriage.
The respondent receives _____ satisfying _____ _____ (an opportunity to be heard)
For the divorce itself, the respondent need _____ appear and need not have _____ contacts with the forum.
IMPORTANT: NOTICE ≠ SERVICE OF PROCESS
A court may dissolve the marriage (meaning just to divorce) if:
The court has jurisdiction over the petitioner; and
Lack of personal jurisdiction over the respondent is not a bar to dissolving the marriage.
The respondent receives notice satisfying Due Process (an opportunity to be heard)
For the divorce itself, the respondent need not appear and need not have minimum contacts with the forum.
A court has subject matter jurisdiction if the petitioner has a _____ to the forum:
_____ : _____ in the state + intent to remain _____ ; or
TX: >_____ months
Statutory _____ for the required period
TX: >_____ days in county
A court has subject matter jurisdiction if the petitioner has a connection to the forum:
Domicile: presence in the state + intent to remain indefinitely; or
TX: >6 months
Statutory residence for the required period
TX: >90 days in county
Under the _____ _____ and _____ clause, a state generally must recognize another state’s divorce decree when the issuing state had jurisdiction.
exception = _____ attack: challenging a judgment in a different (sister) state by arguing that the original court lacked _____
only available for _____ _____ judgments
jurisdiction was based only on one party’s _____ and the other party was _____
Under the full faith and credit clause, a state generally must recognize another state’s divorce decree when the issuing state had jurisdiction.
exception = collateral attack: challenging a judgment in a different (sister) state by arguing that the original court lacked jurisdiction
only available for ex parte judgments
jurisdiction was based only on one party’s presence and the other party was absent
Regarding service of process, the petitioner cannot _____ trick someone into entering the state solely to serve them.
Regarding service of process, the petitioner cannot fraudulently trick someone into entering the state solely to serve them.
To challenge a forum (under forum non _____ ) even if the court has jurisdiction, a party can argue that the case should be heard somewhere else because the current forum is seriously _____ .
_____ Appearance: allows a party to appear in court without consenting to personal jurisdiction.
NOT general appearance
To challenge a forum (under forum non conveniens) even if the court has jurisdiction, a party can argue that the case should be heard somewhere else because the current forum is seriously inconvenient.
Special Appearance: allows a party to appear in court without consenting to personal jurisdiction.
NOT general appearance
Federal courts may _____ issue a divorce decree, alimony judgment, or child-custody order -> but may _____ state-court decisions
Federal courts may not issue a divorce decree, alimony judgment, or child-custody order -> but may enforce state-court decisions
There are two theories of property division on divorce
_____ theory: Property went to whoever's name was on the title
_____ distribution: Most courts then moved to equitable distribution
There are two theories of property division on divorce
Title theory: Property went to whoever's name was on the title
Equitable distribution: Most courts then moved to equitable distribution
Within equitable distribution, there are three approaches:
Marital property (Texas = community property) + majority approach
Identify property acquired _____ marriage, that's marital property and can be divided _____ regardless of title
Exclude _____ property (gift, devise, descent), cannot be divided, but can be considered In equitable division
Hotchpot
Gathers up all the property owned by the parties regardless of character as _____ or _____
All of the property is subject to equitable division
Hybrid
First identify and divide the _____ property
If the result is unjust, look to the _____ property and divide it to achieve equity
Unjust = enough for a spouse to _____ on
Within equitable distribution, there are three approaches:
Marital property (Texas = community property) + majority approach
Identify property acquired during marriage, that's marital property and can be divided equitably regardless of title
Exclude separate property (gift, devise, descent), cannot be divided, but can be considered In equitable division
Hotchpot
Gathers up all the property owned by the parties regardless of character as marital or separate
All of the property is subject to equitable division
Hybrid
First identify and divide the marital property
If the result is unjust, look to the separate property and divide it to achieve equity
Unjust = enough for a spouse to live on
Vested _____ unvested pension benefits are marital property subject to division on divorce
For unvested pension benefits: _____ allocated to interest that has accrued on them but entitled the amount initially given
Subject to contributions made during (marital property) marriage and before (separate property) marriage
Vested AND unvested pension benefits are marital property subject to division on divorce
For unvested pension benefits: NOT allocated to interest that has accrued on them but entitled the amount initially given
Subject to contributions made during (marital property) marriage and before (separate property) marriage
Investments in a Spouse’s Future Success
The majority rule is that the court will _____ divide investments in a spouse's future success, except for business _____ .
But will consider investments for equitable division/support (even Texas)
Investments in a Spouse’s Future Success
The majority rule is that the court will not divide investments in a spouse's future success, except for business goodwill.
But will consider for equitable division/support (even Texas)
TEXAS COMMUNITY PROPERTY
Community property is _____ property acquired _____ marriage (like marital property); _____ does not matter, nor does it matter whose wages were used to purchase the property
Separate property is property owned by one spouse _____ marriage, or acquired during marriage by _____ , _____ or _____
Texas courts have _____ power to separate property, unless they were _____ with community property → to prove comingling = trace out where the money origins to apportion separate property
BUT: Commingling separate and community funds and unable to separate → _____ property
If contributions were made to another spouse’s _____ property with _____ funds or community efforts, the other spouse can seek _____
TEXAS COMMUNITY PROPERTY
Community property is all property acquired during marriage (like marital property); Title does not matter, nor does it matter whose wages were used to purchase the property
Separate property is property owned by one spouse before marriage, or acquired during marriage by gift, devise or descent
Texas courts have NO power to separate property, unless they were comingled with community property → to prove comingling
If contributions were made to another spouse’s separate property with community funds or community efforts, the other spouse can seek reimbursement = trace out where the money origins to apportion separate property
BUT: Commingling separate and community funds and unable to separate, then all is considered community property
Texas’ community property approach:
Identify the _____ property (property acquired during the marriage) and enter a “_____ and _____ ” division of the estate
Texas courts have _____ power to separate property, but may _____ it when determining a “_____ and _____ ” division
Texas’ community property approach:
Identify the community property (property acquired during the marriage) and enter a “just and right” division of the estate
Texas courts have no power to separate property, but may consider it when determining a “just and right” division
In Texas, couples can change the character of separate and community property:
_____ : can only keep property separate, since there is no _____ estate prior to marriage
Cannot convert things in a prenup community → separate
But can keep property separate
_____ -_____ agreement: can fully recharacterize property as community or separate
Must state clearly the recharacterization of property (courts will not assume); written and signed by both parties
_____ on _____ : can agree to a “just and right” division of property, including recharacterization, and if the judge _____ it is “just and right” then will enter it into divorce decree
Extremely common
"just and right" because the parties agreed upon it → _____ super unjust
In Texas, couples can change the character of separate and community property:
Prenup: can only keep property separate, since there is no community estate prior to marriage
Cannot convert things in a prenup community → separate
But can keep property separate
Post-marital agreement: can fully recharacterize property as community or separate
Must state clearly the recharacterization of property (courts will not assume); written and signed by both parties
Agreement on divorce: can agree to a “just and right” division of property, including recharacterization, and if the judge agrees it is “just and right” then will enter it into divorce decree
Extremely common
"just and right" because the parties agreed upon it → UNLESS super unjust
When determining whether to award spousal support, courts will _____ consider fault, unless:
Marital fault has negatively affected economic status of the parties (_____ _____ ) or
_____ fault
_____ with a close friend/family member
sexual felony on spouse
TX: courts consider pattern of violence on a just and right division
MUST be within the last 2 years and a conviction
When determining whether to award spousal support, courts will not consider fault, unless:
Marital fault has negatively affected economic status of the parties (economic misconduct) or
Egregious fault
Adultery with a close friend/family member
TX: courts consider pattern of violence on a just and right division
MUST be within the last 2 years and a conviction
Determining the Amount of Support – Standards
Other jurisdictions (Alizzi): actual need for support + the paying spouse’s ability to pay
TEXAS uses “_____ _____ needs”
Covers essential food, modest housing, utilities, clothing, and basic healthcare
Will take no regard to _____ /situations before marriage
Once separated -> if spouse is not _____ to earn money or enhance their _____ to earn money (training or school) = no maintenance
Does not cover luxury travel, high-end cars, or expensive entertainment
Monthly cap: Lesser of $5,000 or 20% of payor's gross monthly income
Determining the Amount of Support – Standards
Other jurisdictions (Alizzi): actual need for support + the paying spouse’s ability to pay
TEXAS uses “minimum reasonable needs”
Covers essential food, modest housing, utilities, clothing, and basic healthcare
Will take no regard to lifestyle/situations before marriage
Once separated -> if spouse is not seeking to earn money or enhance their ability to earn money (training or school) or else no maintenance
Does not cover luxury travel, high-end cars, or expensive entertainment
Monthly cap: Lesser of $5,000 or 20% of payor's gross monthly income
TEXAS Spousal Maintenance
Texas only grants alimony if there is not enough property (_____ and _____ ) in the hands of the needy spouse to meet her minimum reasonable needs AND one of the following requirements:
Payor spouse was convicted of a crime of _____ _____ within the _____ years prior to divorce filing
_____ as a fault defense- demonstration that husband was forgiven
Needy spouse has a physical or mental _____ that prevents her from earning income sufficient to meet her minimum reasonable needs
Was married for _____ years and can’t earn enough to meet (you guessed it!) minimum reasonable needs
Is custodian of a _____ of the marriage with a physical or mental _____ that prevents her from earning enough to meet minimum reasonable needs
TEXAS Spousal Maintenance
Texas only grants alimony if there is not enough property (separate and community) in the hands of the needy spouse to meet her minimum reasonable needs AND one of the following requirements:
Payor spouse was convicted of a crime of family violence within the two years prior to divorce filing
Condonation as a fault defense- demonstration that husband was forgiven
Needy spouse has a physical or mental disability that prevents her from earning income sufficient to meet her minimum reasonable needs
Was married for 10 years and can’t earn enough to meet (you guessed it!) minimum reasonable needs
Is custodian of a child of the marriage with a physical or mental disability that prevents her from earning enough to meet minimum reasonable needs
Almost all Texas alimony is _____
Three exceptions that could (but won’t always) lead to permanent alimony
Spouse’s physical or mental _____ that prevents her from supporting her minimum reasonable needs
Custody of _____ or young child which prevents her. . . .
Catch all: “Another _____ impediment to earning. . .
Almost all Texas alimony is temporary
Three exceptions that could (but won’t always) lead to permanent alimony
Spouse’s physical or mental disability that prevents her from supporting her minimum reasonable needs
Custody of infant or young child which prevents her. . . .
Catch all: “Another compelling impediment to earning. . .
Length of alimony is the shortest length necessary. . . And then depends on grounds for alimony
Marriage of less than 10 years + family violence = _____ years maximum
Marriage of 30 years or more = _____ years
Marriage of 20 years but less than 30 = _____ years
Marriage of 10 years but less than 20 = _____ years
Marriage of less than 10 years and no family violence = _____ eligible for alimony
Length of alimony is the shortest length necessary. . . And then depends on grounds for alimony
Marriage of less than 10 years + family violence = 10 years maximum
Marriage of 30 years or more = 10 years
Marriage of 20 years but less than 30 = 7 years
Marriage of 10 years but less than 20 = 5 years
Marriage of less than 10 years and no family violence = not eligible for alimony
_____ circumstances may justify modification/termination of support, but property division is final (unless timely appeal)
Remarriage/_____ of needy spouse as a reason to modify spousal support
To prove _____ , requires more than a one night stand/less serious relationship
Looking for whether the relationship is more serious and reduced the financial needs
Large/substantial change in financial circumstances
_____ of payor spouse
BUT: Debts for child or spousal support _____ dischargeable in bankruptcy
Changed circumstances may justify modification/termination of support, but property division is final (unless timely appeal)
Remarriage/cohabitation of needy spouse as a reason to modify spousal support
To prove cohabitation, requires more than a one night stand/less serious relationship
Looking for whether the relationship is more serious and reduced the financial needs
Large/substantial change in financial circumstances
Bankruptcy of payor spouse
BUT: Debts for child or spousal support not dischargeable in bankruptcy
Divorce entered December 31, 2018 and on = _____ deduction for the payor and the receiver does _____ have to report it
Divorces before December 31, 2018 = the _____ has to report alimony as income
Divorce entered December 31, 2018 and on = no deduction for the payor and the receiver does not have to report it
Divorces before December 31, 2018 = the receiver has to report alimony as income
Three models for calculating child support:
_____ -_____ model
_____ of income model
Followed by Texas
Ordinarily 20% of monthly income (after taxes + deductions)
Melson formula
Three models for calculating child support:
Income-shares model
Percentage of income model
Followed by Texas
Ordinarily 20% of monthly income (after taxes + deductions)
Melson formula
Income Shares Model (majority rule)
Looks to parents’ _____ income, determines share to go to child support, apportioned by _____ of income.
Income Shares Model (majority rule)
Looks to parents’ combined income, determines share to go to child support, apportioned by proportion of income.
Percentage-Shares Model (minority rule (with TEXAS))
Only considers incomes of the _____ parent
Percentage-Shares Model (minority rule (with TEXAS))
Only considers incomes of the noncustodial parent
Special Issues in Child Support
High income parents: TEXAS caps income, with the highest amount of child support available at $_____ per month.
Low income parents: TEXAS reduces the percentage for one child from 20% to _____ % if parent earns less than $1,000 per month
Post-majority support (education + disability)
Special Issues in Child Support
High income parents: TEXAS caps income, with the highest amount of child support available at $11,700 per month.
Low income parents: TEXAS reduces the percentage for one child from 20% to 15% if parent earns less than $1,000 per month
Post-majority support (education + disability)
Post-Majority Support: Education
A noncustodial parent can be forced to pay for college expenses, subject to scenarios where children of divorce are _____ not able to attend college (i.e. father _____ /_____ on paying for child to attend college).
Alternative argument: A child may sue a parent for the failure to uphold the _____ (in case the parent made a _____ to pay for college and reneged)
However, a child will not succeed on a suit arguing that a parent (of an _____ marriage) has a _____ to pay college expenses due to:
Doctrine of _____ : The state does not have a role in adjudicating intact family matters
Family _____ concerns with avoiding interference with an intact family
Post-Majority Support: Education
A noncustodial parent can be forced to pay for college expenses, subject to scenarios where children of divorce are unfairly not able to attend college (i.e. father refuses/reneges on paying for child to attend college).
Alternative argument: A child may sue a parent for the failure to uphold the contract (in case the parent made a promise to pay for college and reneged)
However, a child will not succeed on a suit arguing that a parent (of an intact marriage) has a duty to pay college expenses due to:
Doctrine of Nonintervention: The state does not have a role in adjudicating intact family matters
Family privacy concerns with avoiding interference with an intact family
Post-Majority Support: Disabled Child
There is _____ parental duty to support an adult child with disabilities who cannot support themselves, unless a state by statute or case law imposes such a duty.
TEXAS: Does allow for _____ support past age 18 for disabled child if:
Child requires _____ care and _____ supervision because of a mental or physical disability AND
Will not be capable of _____ -_____ AND
The disability existed _____ or _____ the child's 18th birthday
Post-Majority Support: Disabled Child
There is NO parental duty to support an adult child with disabilities who cannot support themselves, unless a state by statute or case law imposes such a duty.
TEXAS: Does allow for indefinite support past age 18 for disabled child if:
Child requires substantial care and personal supervision because of a mental or physical disability AND
Will not be capable of self-support AND
The disability existed on or before the child's 18th birthday
Modification of Child Support: Subsequent Families
Noncustodial parents often seek to lower the amount because they are now responsible for also supporting kids born after the divorce.
Majority rule: stepparent does _____ have a burden to support stepchildren (unless they _____ the stepchild)
often: all children must have an _____ share of the pie
Modification of Child Support: Subsequent Families
Noncustodial parents often seek to lower the amount because they are now responsible for also supporting kids born after the divorce.
Majority rule: stepparent does not have a burden to support stepchildren (unless they adopt the stepchild)
often: all children must have an equal share of the pie
Modification of Child Support: Employment Changes
Child support awards may be modified in the event of employment changes granted the applicant is not _____ unemployed OR underemployed.
Unemployment or underemployment: Must NOT be _____ + _____ !
*TEXAS does not require unemployment/underemployment to be _____ + _____ .
Modification of Child Support: Employment Changes
Child support awards may be modified in the event of employment changes granted the applicant is not voluntarily unemployed OR underemployed.
Unemployment or underemployment: Must NOT be voluntary + unreasonable!
*TEXAS does not require unemployment/underemployment to be voluntary + unreasonable.
Imputed Income
If the court finds that the unemployment/underemployment is _____ AND _____,, the court will impute income.
Imputed income: Court will imputed income using prior history of employment; minimum wage; and department of labor stats
Imputed Income
If the court finds that the unemployment/underemployment is voluntary AND unreasonable,, the court will impute income.
Imputed income: Court will imputed income using prior history of employment; minimum wage; and department of labor stats
Multistate Child Support Cases
Three approaches which a court may assert personal jurisdiction over a defendant (noncustodial/payor parent):
_____ : A court must have sufficient _____ _____ (defendant must have purposefully availed himself to the jurisdiction)
Mere _____ to the relocation of a child is not minimum contacts because the defendant does not purposefully avail himself in CA
Texas long-arm: The child resides in this state as result of _____ /_____ of the individual/payor
Acts: leaving a spouse/foreseeable that the custodial spouse will move to Texas (family in there)
DIRECTIVES not acquiescence (“Go live with your mother!”)
UIFSA
Court who _____ issued CS order retains exclusive continuing jurisdiction
So long as child/custodial parent _____ in state
Multistate Child Support Cases
Three approaches which a court may assert personal jurisdiction over a defendant (noncustodial/payor parent):
Kuklo: A court must have sufficient minimum contacts (defendant must have purposefully availed himself to the jurisdiction)
Mere acquiescence to the relocation of a child is not minimum contacts because the defendant does not purposefully avail himself in CA
Texas long-arm: The child resides in this state as result of acts/directives of the individual/payor
Acts: leaving a spouse/foreseeable that the custodial spouse will move to Texas (family in there)
DIRECTIVES not acquiescence (“Go live with your mother!”)
UIFSA
Court who initially issued CS order retains exclusive continuing jurisdiction
So long as child/custodial parent remain in state
Separation/Property Division/Marital Settlement Agreements
Court will usually uphold the agreement reached by the parties
But courts can reject if the separation agreement is _____ :
_____ : no notice, no transparency, no free choice
_____ : excessively one sided/oppressive, limiting legal remedies
Separation/Property Division/Marital Settlement Agreements
Court will usually uphold the agreement reached by the parties
But courts can reject if the separation agreement is unconscionable:
Procedural: no notice, no transparency, no free choice
Substantive: excessively one sided/oppressive, limiting legal remedies
If an agreement is incorporated into divorce decree + _____ about modification, the agreement is modifiable granted: (1) _____ property division and (2) _____ if support
If an agreement is incorporated into divorce decree + silent about modification, the agreement is modifiable granted: (1) Not modifiable if property division and (2) modifiable if support
When determining the best interests of the child, a court may NOT consider: race, sex, religion, a parent’s sexual orientation and gender identity.
However, a court may consider: a parent’s _____ , prevalence of domestic violence, and the child’s _____ (but its not binding on the court)
When determining the best interests of the child, a court may NOT consider: race, sex, religion, a parent’s sexual orientation and gender identity.
Domestic violence may be treated as relevant to determining child custody.
Domestic violence requires _____ _____ injury OR a pattern of DV
Two approaches:
_____ approach: Courts may demonstrate a _____ of no custody for parents that participate in domestic violence
_____ approach: Domestic violence may be treated as _____ to determining child custody
Domestic violence may be treated as relevant to determining child custody.
Domestic violence requires serious bodily injury OR a pattern of DV
Two approaches:
Presumption approach: Courts may demonstrate a presumption of no custody for parents that participate in domestic violence
Relevance approach: Domestic violence may be treated as relevant to determining child custody
Texas: Domestic Violence + Child Custody
Texas uses the _____ approach, BUT requires _____/relevance of DV in deciding visitation/possessory conservatorship
If within past 2 years, no access to child unless court finds “will not endanger child” + best interests of the child
If allowed access, can restrict it (supervision required, safe exchange of possession protocols, required abstention from drugs/alcohol 12 hours before visit, etc.)
Same rules if parent accused of child neglect/abuse
Texas: Domestic Violence + Child Custody
Texas uses the presumption approach, BUT requires consideration of DV in deciding visitation/possessory conservatorship
If within past 2 years, no access to child unless court finds “will not endanger child” + best interests of the child
If allowed access, can restrict it (supervision required, safe exchange of possession protocols, required abstention from drugs/alcohol 12 hours before visit, etc.)
Same rules if parent accused of child neglect/abuse
Agreed parenting plans: allow the parents to avoid a court determining child _____ and _____
Needs court’s _____ -> if _____ , incorporated in the divorce decree
Enforceable by _____ if _____ in the decree
can include geographical restrictions
Agreed parenting plans: allow the parents to avoid a court determining child custody and support
Needs court’s approval -> if approved, incorporated in the divorce decree
Enforceable by contempt if incorporated in the decree
If parents can’t agree in parenting plan = standard visitation schedule usually imposed by statute
TX: no visitation for _____ years after child abuse
If parents can’t agree in parenting plan = standard visitation schedule usually imposed by statute
TX: no visitation for 2 years after child abuse
Support/Custody Unlinked & How to Enforce Visitation
Turner v. Turner: failure to pay child support does _____ justify limitations on visitation
If the noncustodial parent does not exercise scheduled visitation, the noncustodial parent _____ be held in contempt of court for failure to comply with visitation BUT can _____ the order to reflect reality
Allows modification of child _____ + child _____
If custodial parent does _____ comply with scheduled visitation, a court will hold the custodial parent in _____ and may result in change of custody
Support/Custody Unlinked & How to Enforce Visitation
Turner v. Turner: failure to pay child support does NOT justify limitations on visitation
If the noncustodial parent does not exercise scheduled visitation, the noncustodial parent CANNOT be held in contempt of court for failure to comply with visitation BUT can MODIFY the order to reflect reality
Allows modification of child SUPPORT + child CUSTODY
If custodial parent does NOT comply with scheduled visitation, a court will hold the custodial parent in CONTEMPT and may result in change of custody
Statutes granting grandparent custody/visitation _____ have a _____ that a fit parent’s decisions are in the _____ _____ of the child; rejected presumption in favor of grandparent visitation
Statutes granting grandparent custody/visitation MUST have a presumption that a fit parent’s decisions are in the best interests of the child; rejected presumption in favor of grandparent visitation
In order for a court to modify the child custody order, a change must be so _____ and _____ that the child’s _____ _____ require custody change.
OFTEN: _____
In order for a court to modify the child custody order, a change must be so material and substantial that the child’s best interests require custody change.
OFTEN: relocation
The Uniform Child Custody _____ and _____ Act (UCJEA) provides guidance to determine whether a court has jurisdiction to modify a child custody order.
Maintains priority for _____ _____ jurisdiction
"Home state" means that a child lived in the state for the previous _____ months before suit
Minor modifications to the other three grounds for jurisdiction (significant connection between the state and the parties; emergency; and no other state has jurisdiction)
Allows courts exercising _____ jurisdictions to only issue _____ orders
The Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and Enforcement Act (UCJEA) provides guidance to determine whether a court has jurisdiction to modify a child custody order.
Maintains priority for home state jurisdiction
"Home state" means that a child lived in the state for the previous six months before suit
Minor modifications to the other three grounds for jurisdiction (significant connection between the state and the parties; emergency; and no other state has jurisdiction)
Allows courts exercising emergency jurisdictions to only issue temporary orders
Marital Presumption
Presumption (essentially a rule of law) that child born or conceived _____ marriage is the child of the _____ .
Extends to same sex couples!
Marital presumption _____ functional parent presumption in determining which “father” is the legal parent of a child.
Marital Presumption
Presumption (essentially a rule of law) that child born or conceived during marriage is the child of the husband.
Extends to same sex couples!
Marital presumption > functional parent presumption in determining which “father” is the legal parent of a child.
Functional parent presumption: A presumption that in _____ a child into their _____ , _____ out as a parent, and _____ out as a parent, that the individual is the functional parent of the child.
Functional parent presumption: A presumption that in bringing a child into their home, acting out as a parent, and holding out as a parent, that the individual is the functional parent of the child.
General rule: Donors of _____ and _____ are _____ legal parents of the resulting child.
BUT: A court may find legal parentage with a poorly contracted donor agreement ( In re M.F.)
A donor can hold out as being a parent (even if signed away rights in contract) which creates a _____ parent _____ !
General rule: Donors of sperm and eggs are not legal parents of the resulting child.
BUT: A court may find legal parentage with a poorly contracted donor agreement ( In re M.F.)
A donor can hold out as being a parent (even if signed away rights in contract) which creates a functional parent presumption!
General rule: the _____ parents are the _____ parents of the child born to surrogate, surrogate is not!
Regardless of the type of surrogacy, BUT:
More difficult with _____ surrogacy (due to _____ tie) to the child to establish legal parentage
General rule: the intending parents are the legal parents of the child born to surrogate, surrogate is not!
Regardless of the type of surrogacy, BUT:
More difficult with traditional surrogacy (due to genetic tie) to the child to establish legal parentage
Texas Surrogacy Statutes (_____ surrogacy only, not traditional)
Only _____ couples qualify as intending parents
Must be performed by _____
Can go to court before implantation to get an order that the agreement is _____ and declaring that the intended parents will be the _____ parents of the child once born
Texas Surrogacy Statutes (gestational surrogacy only, not traditional)
Only married couples qualify as intending parents
Must be performed by doctor
Can go to court before implantation to get an order that the agreement is valid and declaring that the intended parents will be the legal parents of the child once born
Embryo Disputes
Embryo disputes are usually triggered by divorce or death of one parent
These disputes are resolved by considering it as a _____ matter, as embryos are considered _____ :
Based on _____ when embryo created
Based on weighing of _____ of the parties
Special interests (testicular cancer)
Based on mutual contemporaneous _____
Agree or leave them there
Embryo Disputes
Embryo disputes are usually triggered by divorce or death of one parent
These disputes are resolved by considering it as a contractual matter, as embryos are considered property:
Based on contract when embryo created
Based on weighing of interests of the parties
Special interests (testicular cancer)
Based on mutual contemporaneous consent
Agree or leave them there
Adoption: creates a _____ family that is to be treated in _____ as any other family
Adoption: creates a legal family that is to be treated in law as any other family
Graves v. Estabrook
Facts: surviving fiancée attempts to recover for negligent infliction of emotional distress which requires a claimant be “closely related”
Holding: _____ rule– Partner is entitled to recover for negligent infliction of emotional distress as they are “_____ related” (factors considered = engaged; lived together for 7 years; mutual dependence; common contributions of a life together; mutual emotional reliance; day-to-day relationship; and attending to life’s mundane requirements
_____ rule (TEXAS): does not recognize negligent infliction of emotional distress as a cause of action for non-marital couples, but may be tagged on to other tort claims
Requires claimant to be within the zone of _____ that the negligent party would have _____ the trauma to bystanders
Next theory of recovery -> common law marriage (TEXAS)
Graves v. Estabrook
Facts: surviving fiancée attempts to recover for negligent infliction of emotional distress which requires a claimant be “closely related”
Holding: Minority rule– Partner is entitled to recover as they are “closely related” (factors considered = engaged; lived together for 7 years; mutual dependence; common contributions of a life together; mutual emotional reliance; day-to-day relationship; and attending to life’s mundane requirements
Majority rule (TEXAS): does not recognize negligent infliction of emotional distress as a cause of action, but may be tagged on to other tort claims
Requires claimant to be within the zone of danger that the negligent party would have foreseen the trauma to bystanders
Next theory of recovery -> common law marriage (TEXAS)