1/18
Comprehensive practice flashcards covering basic neuroscience methods, ethical frameworks, free will and Libet's experiments, moral psychology, models of addiction, and naturalistic perspectives on psychedelic therapy.
Distinguish gray matter from white matter and explain why brain region-to-function mapping is described as "many-to-many."
Gray matter consists of neuronal cell bodies and local processing units; white matter consists of myelinated axon tracts connecting distant regions. Mapping is "many-to-many" because a single region contributes to multiple functions, and a single function depends on a distributed network of regions.
Compare EEG and BOLD fMRI in terms of their spatial and temporal trade-offs, and explain the limits of lesions/stimulation.
EEG records electrical activity with high temporal resolution (good timing) but poor spatial precision. BOLD fMRI measures an indirect blood-oxygen signal with good spatial resolution but slow, indirect timing. Lesions/stimulation test causal necessity, but are limited by damage spread, network effects, and functional compensation.
What is the "reverse inference fallacy" in neuroimaging? What evidence is required to strengthen a reverse inference?
Inferring a specific mental process solely from activation in a brain region (e.g., insula activity = love). It fails because brain regions are multifunctional. Strengthening it requires independent evidence of regional selectivity and converging behavioral/psychological measures.
Distinguish empirical claims from normative claims. What additional premise is required to move from a brain scan observation to an ethical conclusion?
Empirical claims describe physical facts or psychological processes (what is); normative claims evaluate rules, duties, or permissions (what ought to be). Moving between them requires an explicit, independent normative premise (e.g., a rule stating that a specific physical impairment warrants a reduced legal sentence).
Briefly define consequentialism, utilitarianism, deontology, and virtue ethics, and list the four bioethical principles.
Consequentialism evaluates actions by outcomes; utilitarianism maximizes overall well-being. Deontology weighs duties and constraints; virtue ethics attends to character. The four bioethical principles are Autonomy, Beneficence, Non-Maleficence, and Justice.
What is the difference between determinism and fatalism regarding human deliberation and action?
Determinism states that a fixed past and natural laws permit only one future, but human deliberation and conscious choices remain part of the causal chain that produces that future. Fatalism states that an outcome occurs regardless of what we think, choose, or do.
Describe Benjamin Libet’s readiness-potential experiment and reconstruct the "bypassing" argument derived from it.
Libet showed that unconscious brain preparation (readiness potential) begins 300–500ms before reported conscious awareness of an intention to move. The bypassing argument claims that if unconscious processes initiate action before conscious awareness, conscious intentions are bypassed epiphenomena and free will is an illusion.
What are two major objections or alternative interpretations that challenge Libet’s bypassing argument?
(1) Early neural activity may represent general motor preparation rather than a completed, irreversible decision. (2) Laboratory wrist flexes do not generalize to deliberate, consequential choices. Unconscious urges can naturally prompt a conscious intention that contributes to an unfolding agentic sequence.
Explain May's "corporate model" of agency and how it answers the skeptic's "origins objection."
May views the whole person as an agent where conscious and unconscious processes cooperate like a corporation (illustrated by skilled action or precommitment). To the origins objection ("you didn't choose your background values"), May replies that responsibility rests on ongoing adult capacities to understand, control, and revise one's values.
What is the difference between the Trolley switch case and the Footbridge case, and why does this pair alone fail to isolate a single cause?
Switch involves diverting a trolley (impersonal harm, widely approved); Footbridge involves pushing a man off a bridge (personal harm, widely rejected). Several features vary simultaneously between the cases (physical contact, directness, agency), so the pair alone does not isolate a single causal factor.
Summarize Greene et al.’s fMRI findings regarding personal moral dilemmas, including brain regions and reaction-time patterns.
Personal dilemmas engage emotion-related areas (medial frontal gyrus BA 9/10, posterior cingulate BA 31, angular gyrus BA 39) and show reduced working memory activation (middle frontal gyrus BA 46, parietal lobe BA 7/40). Utilitarian responses to personal dilemmas take longer because agents must overcome emotional interference.
What is the difference between explaining a moral intuition and debunking it?
Explaining a moral intuition is descriptive (tracing its causal origin or emotional history). Debunking is an epistemic claim asserting that the belief loses justification because the underlying causal process is epistemically unreliable. Merely identifying an emotional origin does not establish unreliability.
What is Sarah Pickard's central explanatory target for addiction, and how does "wanting" dissociate from "liking"?
Pickard's target is persistent drug use despite evident, severe costs to the person's own good. "Wanting" (mesolimbic dopamine-driven incentive salience/motivation to obtain) can dissociate from "liking" (opioid-driven actual pleasure/enjoyment), as tolerance habituates liking while sensitization amplifies wanting.
Distinguish compulsion from extreme difficulty, and explain how outcome devaluation tests habit vs. goal-directed action.
Compulsion implies complete inability to refrain; high difficulty means refusal is hard but possible (proven when individuals deliberately refrain for incentives). Outcome devaluation alters an outcome's value (e.g., feeding to satiety); dropping behavior proves it was goal-directed, while persisting proves it was habitual.
Contrast the strict brain disease model of addiction with Pickard's "psychology-first" approach.
The brain disease model views addiction as a chronic neural pathology causing compulsion, sometimes implying loss of choice. Pickard's psychology-first approach begins with what drug use does for the person in their life context, integrating neuroscience while preserving agency and maintaining responsibility without active blame.
Reconstruct the "comforting-delusion objection" against psychedelic therapy under naturalism.
(1) Naturalism is true. (2) Psychedelic therapy reduces distress by inducing unsupported, non-naturalistic metaphysical beliefs (a poor epistemic profile). (3) This poor epistemic profile gives reason for caution in recommending therapy.
Explain Philip Letheby’s naturalistic reply to the comforting-delusion objection, referencing self-models and unselfing.
Letheby argues that therapeutic benefit does not depend on false metaphysical beliefs. Healing arises from natural neuroplasticity, loosening rigid narrative self-models (Default Mode Network), and fostering "unselfing"—shifting attention away from defensive self-preoccupation toward connection and psychological insight.
What are the two strict conditions required for a belief or mental state to possess "epistemic innocence"?
(1) It delivers a significant epistemic or therapeutic benefit that advances functioning/well-being. (2) There is no available alternative at that time delivering the same benefit with fewer epistemic costs.
List the five recurring distinctions emphasized throughout the course.