1/11
Looks like no tags are added yet.
what is a private nuisance?
a nontrespassory invasion of another person’s interest in the use and enjoyment of his land
what is the threshold for interference with a nuisance claim?
it has to substantially and unreasonably interfere with the plaintiff’s use and enjoyment of their land
what kind of invasions are nuisances, usually?
they are usually intangible invasions
ex. smell, light, sounds, vibration, dust, pollution of air/water
if its a physical invasion, then what kind of action will it be?
trespass not nuisance
A person walking his dogs on his neighbor’s land - nuisance or trespass?
trespass
A person kenneling dogs outside and they bark all night and keep the neighbors up - nuisance or trespass?
nuisance, if it substantially interferes with the neighbor’s use and enjoyment of their property
a successful nuisance claim requires the plaintiff to:
show that the interference was substantial and unreasonable
what are the 2 ways in which a defendant’s interference can inhibit a plaintiff’s use and enjoyment of their land?
unintentional interference
intentional interference
what is an unintentional interference?
usually result from negligent, reckless or abnormally dangerous activities
very tort-like
most legal analysts isolate unintentional interferences from private nuisance analysis - they’re more like traditional negligence/strict liability actions
what is intentional interference?
the defendant know or should know that their activities or property condition will affect the use/enjoyment of neighboring property, but they feel that society should tolerate it despite inconveniences to neighboring landowners
what is substantial interference?
people with normal sensitivities would consider the interference to be substantial
what is the purpose of having a “substantial” interference element?
deters complaints by petty or overly sensitive plaintiffs