1/10
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Offender profiling
Investigative technique used to help police narrow down field of enquiry + list of likely suspects when solving crimes
Involves careful scrutiny of crime scene + analysis of evidence → generate hypotheses ~ probable characteristics + social background + routine behaviour of offender
Two primary methods:
Typology (top down)
Data driven (bottom up)
Offender profiling: typology
Originated FBI’s behavioural science unit in 1970s
Developed by in-depth prison interviews conducted with 36 sexually motivated serial killers ~ Ted Bundy + Charles Manson
Devised typologies from data → based on their modus operandi (way of working) + evidence left at crime scene
Relies heavily on profiler’s intuition
Criminals are classified into one of two main typologies
Offender profiling: typology → organised offenders
Present clear evidence of:
Pre-meditated planning
Often deliberately target specific type of victim
Maintain high level of control during attack
Leave very little evidence
Usually above average intelligence
Professional + skilled occupations
Socially + sexually competent
Usually married + may have children
Offender profiling: typology → disorganised offenders
Present evidence of:
Little planning = spontaneous + spur of the moment + done in moment of passion
Often leave body at scene + evidence = impulsive + little control
Usually below average intelligence
Unskilled work or unemployed
History of failed relationships + sexual dysfunction
Often live alone + relatively near where offence took place
Offender profiling: typology AO3
- Limited application → generally can only be used for severe + sexually motivated crimes ~ rape + sadistic murder = not helpful for common offences ~ fraud
- Too simplistic → two categories = highly restrictive + offender may show behaviours of both typologies
Canter analysed 100 serial murderers → although most killers showed organised traits = no distinct disorganised type suggesting lack of scientific validity
- Flawed original sample → approach devised from 36 serial sex murderers = cannot generalise to wider criminal population
- Data driven approach is better → uses statistical methods + psychological analysis = understand offender from the ground up
Offender profiling: data driven approach (bottom up)
Pioneered by psychologist David Canter
British method
Uses statistical procedures + psychological theory → build understanding of offender from bottom up
Offender profiling: data driven approach → investigative psychology
Attempts to apply statistical analysis + psychological theory → establish patterns of behaviour that co-occur across crime scenes
Smallest space analysis stat technique → enter crime details = shows behaviours that tend to occur together across offences
Matching new offence against baseline = can reveal insights about offender’s personal history + background
Offender profiling: data driven approach → investigative psychology concepts
Interpersonal coherence → assumption the way offender behaves at crime scene + interaction with victim = will be consistent everyday life behaviour ~ highly controlling individual = display controlling behaviour during attack
Forensic awareness → offenders whose behaviour indicates knowledge of criminal justice system + police interrogation ~ wiping fingerprints
Offender profiling: data driven approach → geographical profiling
Uses info of spatial locations of linked crime scenes → make inferences about offender’s likely home or operational base
Assumes serial offenders stay within familiar areas → gives investigators ‘centre of gravity’ = likely to include offender’s base
Allows investigators to map out ‘jeopardy surface’ → make educated guesses about where offender might strike next
Offender profiling: data driven approach → Canter’s circle theory
Describes how offender’s crimes are spread in relation to home base
Proposed two models of spatial decision-making:
Marauder → offender who operates in close proximity to home base = crimes tend to form rough circle around usual residence
Commuter → offender who travels some distance from home to offend = harder to profile geographically
Pattern of offending still reveals ‘mental maps’ ~ mode of transport + employment status
~ Bodies left in road laybys in scattered areas = delivery driver
Offender profiling: data driven approach AO3
+ Research support Lundrigan + Canter → analysed 120 murder cases + found spatial consistency in body disposal sites = supporting concept of ‘centre of gravity’ + geographical profiling
+ Scientific + objective basis → relies on statistical databases + smallest space analysis > intuitive inference of profiler = higher scientific credibility vs typology approach
+ Wider application → data driven techniques = can be applied to wider range of offences ~ theft
- Profiling failures