1/11
Week 8
What is the primary difference in welfare concerns between external factors (housing, diet) and artificial selection for extreme traits?
External factors are regulated and can be addressed to improve welfare, whereas selection for extreme traits affects every moment of the animal’s life, cannot be easily rectified, and is currently not legislated against.
Define pleiotropy in the context of selective breeding.
Pleiotropy occurs when a single gene influences multiple, seemingly unrelated phenotypic traits. Breeders selecting for one desirable trait often inadvertently get other (sometimes undesirable) traits.
What are common pleiotropic side effects associated with tameness in animals?
Floppy ears, curled tails, piebaldness (spotty coats), shortened/wider snouts, and increased reproduction.
What role do mutations play in selective breeding, and what is a major risk when breeders try to populate rare carriers?
Mutations are the source of new genetic variation. Trying to rapidly populate rare carriers creates a limited gene pool; while one copy of a mutation might be harmless, two copies (homozygous) often cause severe health problems (e.g., double merles leading to blindness and deafness).
What are the effects of a single copy (heterozygous carrier) versus two copies (homozygous) of the myostatin mutation?
Single copy (AG Group): Significant athletic benefits, increased muscle mass, and reduced body fat.
Two copies (Double Muscling / AA Group): Severe impacts including dystocia (requiring C-sections in Belgian Blues), reduced speed in horses/whippets, and impaired force production in mice.
What are some common skeletal and health abnormalities associated with dwarfism in companion animals?
Skeletal abnormalities (bowed legs, short bones, joint enlargement, spinal curvature, hip dysplasia), dental problems, and specific issues like pectus excavatum causing breathing problems in cats, or retinal degeneration in dogs.
What major historical shift occurred during the Victorian era regarding animal breeding?
The birth of formal animal showing (such as the formation of the Kennel Club in 1873) marked a turning point where status, pride, and form over function took priority over the animal's ability to fulfill a practical working function.
What health risks are associated with breeding the "perfect pug" and the Rhodesian Ridgeback?
Pug: Breeding for a tightly curled tail leads to hemivertebrae, potential loss of feeling in the back legs, and bladder control issues.
Rhodesian Ridgeback: Breeding for a hair "ridge" risks dermoid sinus, which causes serious infections involving the spinal cord.
How has intensive selection for growth rate and meat yield impacted modern broiler chickens compared to those from 1957?
Broilers have grown dramatically in size (from ~905g in 1957 to over 4kg in 2005), leading to severe skeletal and muscular issues, heart/metabolic problems, weaker immune systems, and higher mortality rates.
Compare the production and lifespan of a 1950s dairy cow versus a modern intensive dairy cow (Holstein-Friesian).
1950s Cow: ~4 litres/day, average production span of 5–10 years, and lifespan of 7–12+ years.
Modern Cow: ~28 litres/day, average production span of only 2.5–4 years, and a shortened lifespan of 4.5–6.5 years (natural lifespan is <20 years).
What is the purpose of the Innate Health Assessment (IHA) tool introduced by APGAW and Professor Dan O’Neill?
It provides a 10-point checklist of traits to avoid (such as extreme brachycephaly, lack of skin folds, correct jaw alignment, and natural leg length) to help breeders and puppy buyers avoid breeding or purchasing dogs with extreme, harmful conformations. Currently, the scheme is voluntary.
Compare and contrast the influence of evolution and domestication as selective pressures for managed animals (LO2).
Evolution: Natural selection driven by environmental pressures, survival of the fittest, and adaptation to natural habitats over long timescales.
Domestication & Artificial Selection: Human-driven pressures focused on productivity, tameness, or extreme aesthetic "form over function," often resulting in a restricted gene pool, pleiotropic side effects, and severe welfare com