1/30
exceptions to search warrants
what do most exceptions rely on
exigent circumstances (emergency), time constraints
when is it reasonable for an officer to act without a warrant
exigent situation
general rules: exigency and exceptions
evidence will be destroyed or suspect will flee
limits the scope of the search
the warrantless action lasts no longer than the exigency
still need probable cause
warden v. hayden facts
facts: police follow him after armed robbery, officers enter, wife consents to letting search without warrant, find him in upstairs bedroom pretending to be asleep, arrest him, continue to search adjoining bathroom, lift up toilet tank, find shotgn and pistol
warden v. hayden: what is the exigency
armed robber
warden v. hayden: does it end when hayden is found, was it ok for officers to keep searching
bc they know he armed robber, firearm continues exigency, search legal
search incident to lawful arrest (SILA)
allows officer who made lawful custodial arrest to conduct a search without a warrant
no SILA if illegal arrest, CONTEMPORANEUS = at the same time!
SILA factors
arrestees person
area within immediate control
within reach where can grab weapons/destroy evidence
if occurred in home, closets and other spaces immediately adjoining the place of arrest
why do we allow/have SILA
officer safety
preservation of evidence
where does SILA allow an officer to search
room of arrest and adjoining areas where persons may be hiding/launch a dangerous attack
PC in SILA
pc in sila exception flows autamatically from arrest itself
if arrest illegal, no SILA
Chimel v. CA (sila) facts
wanted for burgaly of coin shop
police search everywhere and argue it was legal under lawful arrest
bring him/wife to open drawers, move clothing, etc.
they seize coins, metals, tokens
search took 45 min to an hour
does Chimel win or lose
win!
search went far past person, immediate control, and past any area that was adjoining/attack
riley v. ca and Wurie v. comm of Ma
riley: pull over for traffic violation (expired liscence), see firearms in car, arrest him, search cellphone without warrent, find gang related photos, use to charge with additional crimes.
wurie: see him make drug sale (from car), arrest him, has too phones, seize both, keeps getting call from “my house”, wallpaper was woman and baby, use directory to trace “my house” number, go to building and see woman/baby and name on mailbox, get warrant, find 250 g of crack, mari, etc.
They both win because cellphone part of daily life and important part of fuman anatomy, keeps digital record of every aspect of your life
ny v belton
speeding, trooper pulls over, smelled weed in car and saw envelope, 4 defendents one cop, searches car and passanger compartment, in black jacket finds cocaine, goes to supreme court and asks if searching jacket lawful sila, court says YES, applies chimel- officer safety, 4 guys one cop, drugs easily disposable
BELTON IS BRIGHTLINE RULE, bad for defendents, cant search OG trunk
AZ v. GANT (2009)
FACTSÂ
police go to gant house looking for drug activity, give his name, run find out he has suspending liscence, arrest him, warrentless search, inside jacket in b
Tucson police received an anonymous tip that a house on North Walnut Ave. was being used to sell drugs.
Two officers went to the house and knocked. Gant answered and said the owner wasn’t home and would return later.
A records check showed Gant’s license was suspended and there was an outstanding warrant for driving with a suspended license.
Later that evening, the officers returned. Other officers were already arresting two people at the house (a man for giving a false name and a woman for drug paraphernalia).
Gant drove up, parked in the driveway, got out, and walked toward the officers. They arrested him on the warrant about 10-12 feet from his car, handcuffed him, and locked him in a patrol car.
Officers then searched his car and found a gun and a bag of cocaine in a jacket pocket on the back seat.
did gant win or lose
won
Chambers v. Maroney (1970) *Leading case on MVE (for tests) facts
May 20, 1963: A gas station attendant in North Braddock, PA, was robbed at gunpoint. (An earlier robbery of another station that evening was also tied to the same group.)
Witnesses described the getaway car as a compact station wagon. Descriptions said one robber wore a green sweater and another a trench coat, and a witness gave the car’s color as light blue.
Shortly after, police stopped a light blue compact station wagon carrying four men matching those descriptions.
All four were arrested on the spot.
The car was driven to the police station, where it was searched without a warrant.
Found: two .38 revolvers in a compartment under the dashboard, and cards belonging to the victim. A glove with change and other robbery-linked items were also tied to the evidence.
Chambers was convicted of robbery. The evidence was admitted at trial, and he sought habeas relief.
holding:
With PC to believe a car contains evidence or contraband, police may either search it immediately or seize it and search it later at the station without a warrant.
The Court saw no constitutional difference between the two. Immobilizing the car to get a warrant is as intrusive as searching it, so the search is allowed.
The exigency is the car’s mobility, which existed at the time of the stop.
Consequence of Chambers?
The exigency that justifies a warrantless car search does not terminate simply because the car is unoccupied, and the people are in custody unable to take the car. Â
Coolidge v. NH (1971) facts
Jan. 13, 1964: Pamela Mason, a 14-year-old, disappeared while babysitting in Manchester, NH. Her body was found about a week later.
Police developed Edward Coolidge as a suspect through a tip from a neighbor and his own statements. The investigation went on for weeks.
Jan. 28: Two officers came to his home and questioned him, and he later took a polygraph at the station. During this time his wife voluntarily handed over guns and clothes to the officers, which the Court held was valid consent (she wasn’t acting as a police agent).
Feb. 19: The state Attorney General, who was running the investigation, issued the arrest and search warrants as acting justice of the peace. Police arrested Coolidge inside his home and seized his 1951 Pontiac from the driveway, towing it to the station.
The car was searched at the station, then again over a year later. Vacuum sweepings turned up gunpowder particles matching the victim’s clothing.
Coolidge was convicted of murder. The NH Supreme Court affirmed.
CA v. Carney (1985) facts
May 31, 1979: DEA agent Williams got an uncorroborated tip that Charles Carney was trading marijuana for sex with boys out of his motor home in San Diego.
Agents surveilled the motor home, which was parked in a downtown lot a couple of blocks from the courthouse, with its windows covered.
They watched a youth, Robert Clark, enter. After about an hour, they stopped Clark when he left, and he said Carney had given him marijuana in exchange for sex.
At the agents’ request, Clark returned and knocked on the door. When Carney stepped out, the agents entered without a warrant or consent.
Inside, they saw marijuana, plastic bags, and scales in plain view. Carney was arrested, and the motor home was taken to the station, where agents found more marijuana in the cupboards and refrigerator.
The California Supreme Court held that a motor home is a home and requires a warrant. The U.S. Supreme Court reversed.
2 main reasons SC decided the way they did in carney
1. Motor vehicles and mobile homes have a reduced expectation of privacy than a traditional home.Â
They're pervasively regulated by the government (stickers, insurance, license)
az v grant chronilogical
Aug. 25, 1999: Tucson police received an anonymous tip that a house on North Walnut Ave. was being used to sell drugs.
Two officers went to the house and knocked. Gant answered and said the owner wasn’t home and would return later.
A records check showed Gant’s license was suspended and there was an outstanding warrant for driving with a suspended license.
Later that evening, the officers returned. Other officers were already arresting two people at the house (a man for giving a false name and a woman for drug paraphernalia).
Gant drove up, parked in the driveway, got out, and walked toward the officers. They arrested him on the warrant about 10-12 feet from his car, handcuffed him, and locked him in a patrol car.
Officers then searched his car and found a gun and a bag of cocaine in a jacket pocket on the back seat.
az v gant where/how was he searched?
car
the passenger compartment,
including the jacket on the back seat,
after he was already secured in a patrol car.
SILA under Belton
az v gant - how many officers?
5
gant v az - pc?
For the arrest: Yes. There was a warrant for driving with a suspended license.
For the car search: No. The anonymous drug-house tip was uncorroborated and never established PC to search the car. The arrest offense (suspended license) couldn’t have left evidence in the car, so the “evidence of the offense” prong failed too. The State didn’t rely on the automobile exception.
Result: The cocaine was suppressed.
Test takeaways (MVE elements)
Need PC to believe the vehicle contains contraband or evidence of a crime. A lawful arrest isn’t required.
No warrant needed. No separate exigency needed beyond the car’s inherent mobility.
The search can happen later and elsewhere, as long as PC existed when the car was seized.
Scope is limited by what the PC covers, meaning anywhere the object could be (later refined in United States v. Ross (1982)).
Coolidge v. NH holding
Warrant invalid: The Attorney General was the chief investigator and prosecutor, so he wasn’t a neutral and detached magistrate.
Motor vehicle exception (rejected): No exigency. The car sat in a driveway, Coolidge was in custody, and police had long known about it. Chambers is distinguished because there PC arose suddenly with a mobile car on the road.
Search incident to arrest (rejected): Arrest happened inside the home, and the car was outside and not within his reach.
Plain view (rejected, plurality): Police expected to find the car, so the discovery wasn’t inadvertent.
Consent (rejected as to the car): Wife’s consent covered the guns and clothing, not the car.
Coolidge v. NH addition to test
MVE needs real exigency or a car that’s mobile and readily usable, not just PC. A car parked at a home that police have long suspected isn’t the Chambers situation.
Warrant must be issued by a neutral and detached magistrate, not someone running the investigation.
Plain view elements (plurality): (1) prior lawful justification for the intrusion, (2) inadvertent discovery, (3) incriminating character immediately apparent.
Horton v. California (1990) later dropped the inadvertence requirement, so now only (1) and (3) matter.
Later development: Collins v. Virginia (2018) ties back here by refusing to let the MVE reach cars in a home’s curtilage.
CA v. Carney holding
The MVE applies to a motor home that is readily mobile and parked in a place not regularly used for residential purposes (here, a public lot).
Two rationales:
Ready mobility, which creates the exigency.
Reduced expectation of privacy in vehicles, because they’re pervasively regulated.
The Court said it was not deciding a motor home on blocks, hooked up to utilities, or parked in a trailer park.
CA v. Carney takeaways
Factors suggesting a vehicle rather than a home: location, whether it’s connected to utilities, whether it’s licensed and registered, whether it’s on a public road or lot, and whether it’s on blocks or otherwise immobilized.
Rule: if the vehicle is “being used on the highways” or is “readily capable of such use” and is found stationary in a place not regularly used for residential purposes, the MVE applies.
The dissent (Stevens, joined by Brennan and Marshall) argued that a motor home is a home and the majority’s line is hard to apply.