1/29
IGO, ICJ, ICC
what is the intergovernmental organisations
created by treaty that outlines the IGO’s purpose and operation, IGO’s are permanent, enter into agreements, subject into international law
what are 4 examples of IGO’s promoting human rights
the EU has their own HR bill
African union founded upon principle of R2P
commonwealth of nations, heavily involved in promotion of rights, e.g commonwealth charter (2012)
what is the ICJ (international court of justice)
ICJ is organ of UN, began operations in 1946, netherlands, has 2 roles
to hear and judge disputes between states
to issue advisory opinions on matters of international law
example of ICJ ruling
AUS v Japan (2015), ordered to stop whaling in antarctica, continued to practice
why doe the ICJ receive criticism
requires consent of state parties so has little jurisdiction (only 75 countries consented)
unable to hear cases brought by individuals/private organisations, few powers of enforcement
what is the ICC (international criminal court)
established in 2002, rome, first permanent tribunal to help end impunity for perpetrators of most serious crimes against international community (genocide)
authority of the ICC
jurisdiction to prosecute individual people rather than states (negates state sovereignty as an excuse for abuse)
ICC ruling example
Thomas Dyilo, warlord in congo, first ever to be jailed by ICC, took 5 years to bring to justice, convicted of war crimes, 14 years in prison
what is a non governmental organisation
operates like charities, helping groups and individuals free from government bureaucracy, examples:
amnesty international
red cross
human rights watch
NGOs help with what
helps government compliance with HR by investigating and publicising cases of HR violations, puts pressure on governments, more complaints=pressure=reforms
role of the media
operates similarly to NGO’s in naming/shaming HR violations, by investigation and reporting, media can influence public opinion/government action
effectiveness of the media
effectivness is challenged in countries where its unsafe for reports to work, resulting in censorship, imprisonment, death (837 reporter deaths since 1994)
incorporation of HR into domestic law
for international law to work, human rights needs to be implemented into domestic laws, e.g. children have right to education (convention on rights of the child 1990)
example of incorporation of HR into domestic laws
papua new guinea, no laws about how long a child need to go to school
aus: are laws of school until 16, family cant stop education
how to make treaty enforceable in AUS?
signing treaty doesnt count, rights and obligations of the treaty need to be incorporated in AUS law
when commonwealth ratifies treaty, parliament pass legislation, amend existing laws to incorporate obligations
how to make international HR treaties apart of domestic law
international HR treaties, until ratified and enacted are not apart of domestic law instead common law and statute law used to protect HR
process of incorporating rights, examples
family law act 1975, convention on the rights of the child is incorporated into aus law through this law
sex discrimination act 1984, convention of elimination of discrimination against women is incorporated
positives of incorporation
aus have ratified many treaties
aus has a decent human rights record
negatives of incorporation
aus still allows HR abuses, detaining asylum seekers (despite convention relating to states of refugees)
legislation can be amended, e.g. 2014, government amended discrimination act 1975, legal to insult someone based on race
define ratify
international act by which a nation state indicates its consent for a treaty that it has previously signed
the constitution plays 2 main roles
lays down system of government, recognises HR
sources of HR, including express, implied rights
what are express rights
included in constitution, like freedom of religion, right to vote, right to trial by jury in federal indictable cases
what are implied rights
rights not written in the constitution but needed so that the constitution can function effectively, e.g. right to freedom of political communication
what are the 3 constitutional division of powers
exclusive
residual
concurrent
what are exclusive powers
powers granted to federal parliament only, e.g. trade, foreign affairs, defense
what are residual powers
powers that belong solely to the state, e.g. transport, education, law & order
what are concurrent powers
powers shared between the federal and state governments, e.g. healthcare, consumer protection, anti discrimination
what are 2 examples of HR legislation in statute law
anti discrimination act 1997 (protects freedom from discrimination)
children and young persons (care and protection) act 1988 (protects right as like CRC)
high court rulings of HR
can overturn legislation incompatible with constitutional rights, e.g. overturned anti association bikie legislation, tried to remove freedom of association
what does the AHRC do
independent national body, releases reports that highlight HR issues, resolved:
inquiry of paid paternal leave act 2010
contributed to migration amendment act 2005, requiring release of child detainees