1/7
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Desmond is a 30-year old man who runs a small landscaping business in Berkeley. His work consists mainly of designing gardens but he also does some planting and rock work. He is asingle, non-smoker, with no history of health problems.
Do you think that he would be interested in having health insurance? Why or why not?
No. He is healthy and single unlikely to prioritize health insurance
One day on the job, Desmond hurts his knee lifting rocks. His friend, a doctor, examines his knee at a party (not a formal visit) and says that Desmond will eventually need surgery. Desmond decides to purchase health insurance so that he won’t have to pay for the surgery out of pocket.
What is the term we use to describe Desmond’s decision to purchase insurance after aninjury?
What type of insurance market is Desmond in?
Adverse selection
Individual market/self purchase
Desmond calls an insurance agent for an interview. The agent asks him questions about his health, his medical history, his level of physical activity and the health of his family members.
Who has more information about the state of Desmond’s health in this interaction?
The agent’s questioning is part of what process?
What is the purpose of this process?
Desmond
Underwriting
Assess risk
Desmond answers these questions but does not mention his knee. He gets approved. The agent outlines his plan: he will have to pay $500 a month to the insurance company. At each doctor’s visit he will pay $30. He is responsible for the first $1000 of his medical bills but his insurance company will pay for all expenses over this amount. His insurance only covers health care providers who are members of his health insurance network. He has to pay the full costs of any care received out of the network.
What is the $500 monthly fee called?
If the company knew about Desmond’s bad knee would this fee increase or decrease?
What is the $30 fee called?
What is the $1000 amount called?
What type of health insurance plan does Desmond have?
Why would insurance companies want to work with a network of health care providers? Whywould providers want to be part of a network?
Premium
Increase
Copayment
Deductible
HMO
Insurance companies want to work with a network because they can negotiate price discounts and control utilization. Providers want to work with a network because it provides a guaranteed/steady supply of patients (gives them larger market share)
Now that Desmond knows that he is covered if anything happens to him, he starts taking on more dangerous jobs that involve building rock walls on steep hillsides.
What term do economists use to describe this change in behavior?
Now that he has insurance would Desmond be more or less likely to go to the doctor for preventative services?
Moral Hazard
More likely
2005: Desmond has his surgery and his business begins to thrive due to his innovative rock work designs. Desmond hires three workers to help him meet the increased demand: Rose, Daphne, and Jack. Rose is a single 40 year-old motorcyclist and a heavy smoker. Daphne is 25, healthy, newly married and planning on starting a family. Jack is 28 and single. All three would like Desmond to provide them with health insurance as part of their benefit package.
How do you rate Daphne, Rose, and Jack’s prospects of obtaining coverage in the individual market? Why?
Rose is a smoker, which will likely preclude her from getting coverage on the individual market. Daphne is considered to be in prime childbearing age so she could get coverage but it will likely be expensive. Jack should have no problem, would be cheapest.
Rather than wrangle with the health insurance issue himself Desmond decides to join the Yard Workers’ Collective (YWC), a union of several thousand landscapers- mostly single, healthy young men- which has negotiated a health insurance package for its members. He also pays for Rose, Daphne and Jack to join.
In what insurance market might YWC members be situated?
Are Desmond’s employees’ premiums higher or lower than they would be if they had tried to purchase health insurance on own?
If the insurance company charged all YWC members the same premium based on the average risk in the YWC pool what concept is being applied?
Employer/group market
Lower
Community rating
Because there are so many personal/medical bankruptcies among uninsured landscapers due to high-cost leaf-blower and weed-whacker injuries, the governor of California proposes a law that requires health insurance companies to accept applications from all landscapers without regard to their pre-existing conditions or other health risks (i.e. no underwriting). The governor later modifies the law to put price controls on insurance premium rates for landscapers. Now the highest premium rates charged can only be twice as high as the lowest rates.
What would happen to health insurance premiums for YWC members who already have insurance, given the passage of this law? Why?
Which workers are most likely to drop their YWC health insurance with the passage of this law?
What would happen to premiums if they leave?
Increase. Now that insurance companies have to cover everyone and have limits to what they can charge their highest risk customers, they will need to raise the prices paid by their existing/lower risk customers to protect themselves and balance out the risk.
Young and healthy
Increase