1/9
Looks like no tags are added yet.
First point
we are typically most clearly responsible for our actions
Second point
if others take over tasks from us, they may become responsible- and deserve praise or blame- for how they perform the task and the consequences they bring about
third point
However, if we ask somebody else to cause some form of harm, we can deserve a large part of the blame for this harm
fourth point
In contrast, when it comes to deserving praise for good outcomes, we typically need to play a more active role in the production of the good outcome
fifth point
Doing good (e.g. helping others) as a means to promoting one’s self-interest is usually not seen as very praiseworthy, whereas harming others as a means of promoting one’s self-interest is typically seen as clearly making one blameworthy
sixth point
If we bring about somerhing good (e.g,. another person benefits) as a foreseen side effect of pursuing our own self-interest, this is usually not seen as an instance of intentionally doing good in a praiseworthy way. In contrast, if we bring about something bad (e.g., another person is harmed) as a foreseen side effect of pursuing our own self-interest, this is typically seen as an instance of intentionally doing something bad in a blameworthy way.
Seventh point
To deserve praise for some good outcome, we typically need to exert effort, display some talent or skill, or make some sacrifice that leads to the good outcome. In contrast, we can deserve blame for some bad outcome without having exerted any special effort, displayed any special talent or skill, or made any particular sacrifice.
Eighth point
To deserve blame for something bad that happens, it can be enough that we allowed the bad outcome to happen, by being negligent or by not being careful enough. Allowing something good to happen, in contrast, is seldom sufficient grounds for counting as praiseworthy for the good outcome.
nineth point
Whether we are responsible for some outcome typically depends in part on whether we had any control over the outcome, as well as on whether it was something we could have predicted.
Tenth point
Whether we have a strong moral responsibility to try to make things go well for other people sometimes depends on whether we have any special relarionships to those other people (i.e., whether they are our children, students, patients, clients, etc.) However, whether we have a strong moral responsibility to avoid harming others typically does not, in the same way, depend on whether we have any special relationship to them.