1/85
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What are the main methods by which a lease can be terminated?
Effluxion of time, exercise of a break clause, surrender, notice to quit and merger.
What happens when a lease ends by effluxion of time?
The contractual term expires.
What can a protected tenant do when a lease expires by effluxion of time?
The tenant can hold over and remain in occupation.
What happens if a landlord consents to an unprotected tenant remaining in occupation after the lease expires?
The tenant may become a tenant at will. If the landlord accepts rent, this could instead create a periodic tenancy.
What is a break clause?
A pre-agreed contractual right allowing a party to terminate a lease before the end of its term.
How is a break clause exercised?
It requires positive action by the relevant party to exercise the right.
What is the effect of a tenant exercising a break clause in a protected tenancy?
The break is effective and the tenancy ends.
What is the effect of a landlord exercising a break clause in a protected tenancy?
It only brings the contractual term to an end; the tenant can still hold over.
What is surrender of a lease?
The termination of a lease by agreement between the landlord and tenant, rather than through a pre-agreed contractual mechanism.
Can a protected tenancy be surrendered?
Yes. Surrender is possible even where the tenancy is protected.
What is a reverse premium?
A premium paid by the tenant to the landlord as part of a surrender agreement.
How must an express surrender of a lease be made?
By deed.
When does surrender occur by operation of law?
Where the landlord and tenant act in a way that is inconsistent with the continuation of the tenancy.
What is an example of surrender by operation of law?
The tenant leaves the property and hands over the keys, which the landlord accepts.
Are express surrender and surrender by operation of law effective for protected tenancies?
Yes. Both methods are effective even where the tenancy is protected.
What procedure must be followed for an agreement to surrender a protected tenancy in advance of a deed?
A procedure similar to contracting out of a protected tenancy must be followed.
When can a lease be terminated by notice to quit?
Where the lease is a periodic tenancy.
What is the required length of notice to quit?
The notice must mirror the period of the tenancy, except for a yearly tenancy, which requires six months' notice.
Who can serve a notice to quit?
Either the landlord or the tenant.
What must a notice to quit specify?
A specific date on which the tenant must vacate, which must be the first or last day of a tenancy period.
What is the effect of a landlord serving notice to quit on a protected periodic tenancy?
It ends the periodic tenancy, but the tenant can still hold over under statutory protection.
How can a landlord recover possession from a protected tenant following a notice to quit?
The landlord can serve a hostile s 25 notice, which can also operate as a notice to quit if it complies with all the relevant notice to quit timing requirements.
Can a tenant of a protected tenancy serve a s 26 notice?
No.
Is a tenant's notice to quit effective where the tenancy is protected?
Yes. A tenant's notice to quit is effective whether or not the tenancy is protected.
When does merger terminate a lease?
Where the landlord acquires the tenant's interest, or the tenant acquires the landlord's interest.
Can merger occur where a third party acquires both interests?
Yes. Merger can occur if a third party acquires both the landlord's and tenant's interests.
What is the general measure of damages for breach of a tenant's covenant?
To put the landlord back in the position they would have been in but for the breach.
What are the disadvantages of pursuing damages for breach of a lease covenant?
Claims can be costly and time-consuming, and damages are unliquidated, meaning the amount is ultimately determined by the court.
What special notice requirement applies to a landlord claiming damages for breach of a repair covenant?
For a lease with a term of at least seven years and at least three years left to run, the landlord must serve a s 146 notice.
How long must a tenant be given to serve a counter notice in relation to a s 146 notice for breach of repair?
28 days. Serving a counter notice makes it more difficult for the landlord to proceed.
What is the measure of damages for breach of a repair covenant in the relevant long leases?
The loss to the landlord's reversion, rather than the cost of putting the premises into full repair.
What is an action in debt as a landlord's remedy?
A claim to recover a fixed sum of money owed by the tenant, such as unpaid rent.
What is the limitation period for recovering rent through an action in debt?
The landlord can only recover rent due in the six years before the issue of proceedings.
Why might the six-year limitation period be problematic for landlords of long leases?
Low ground rents may remain unpaid for a long period, meaning some arrears may fall outside the six-year recovery period.
What are the disadvantages of an action in debt?
Claims can be costly and time-consuming.
What are the advantages of an action in debt for a landlord?
It provides a liquidated claim for a fixed sum; pursuing the debt can give the tenant breathing space; and there may be a further possibility of pursuing a former tenant where the lease has been assigned or an AGA has been given.
Why might a landlord require a guarantor or rent deposit?
Where the landlord has concerns about the covenant strength of the tenant or an assignee.
How can a landlord recover losses from a guarantor?
By relying on the contractual terms of the guarantee.
What obligations will a tenant's guarantee normally cover?
Normally the tenant's obligations generally, not just rent.
How can a landlord use a rent deposit?
The landlord can draw on the deposit where there are rent arrears.
What document usually governs a rent deposit?
A separate rent deposit deed.
Can a rent deposit be used for breaches other than non-payment of rent?
Yes. The rent deposit deed may allow the landlord to use it for any breach of the lease.
What happens after a landlord withdraws money from a rent deposit?
The tenant will usually be required to top up the deposit.
What is Commercial Rent Arrears Recovery (CRAR)?
A self-help remedy allowing a landlord to recover qualifying commercial rent arrears by taking control of the tenant's goods.
When can a landlord use CRAR?
Where the premises are purely commercial, at least seven days' principal rent is owed, and the lease has not been forfeited.
Does principal rent for CRAR include service charges?
No. The minimum seven days' arrears must relate to principal rent, not service charges.
Who must a landlord appoint to exercise CRAR?
An enforcement agent who holds the required court certificate or is exempt from the requirement, for example a police officer.
What notice must be given before an enforcement agent enters premises to exercise CRAR?
Seven clear days' notice of the intention to enter the premises.
What information must a CRAR notice contain?
Details including the amount of the debt, how to repay it, details of the enforcement power being used and the enforcement agent's contact details.
What can an enforcement agent do if the CRAR notice expires without repayment?
Enter the premises and take control of goods belonging to the tenant, up to the value of the debt owed.
What notice is required before seized goods can be sold under CRAR?
A further seven clear days' notice must be served if the landlord intends to sell the seized goods.
What is the main advantage of CRAR?
It is a self-help remedy that can be quicker and cheaper than court proceedings.
What equitable remedies may be available to a landlord for breach of a lease covenant?
Specific performance and injunctions.
When might specific performance be available to a landlord?
It is rarely available, particularly for breaches of repair obligations, and will only be granted in exceptional circumstances.
When might a landlord seek an injunction relating to an unlawful assignment?
Where the landlord is aware that the tenant intends to assign the lease unlawfully.
Is an injunction likely to be available if an unlawful assignment has already taken place?
No. An injunction is unlikely to be granted once the assignment has already occurred.
What is forfeiture of a lease?
A landlord's right to terminate a lease by re-entry following a tenant's breach, where the lease expressly provides for that right.
What is required before a landlord can forfeit a lease?
The lease must contain an express right of forfeiture.
What is the usual position regarding forfeiture for non-payment of rent?
The lease will usually contain a forfeiture provision allowing forfeiture after any specified grace period. No s 146 notice is required.
When is a s 146 notice required before forfeiture?
For a non-rent breach, including breach of tenant obligations or an insolvency event.
What must a s 146 notice do?
Give details of the breach and provide the tenant with a reasonable opportunity to remedy it.
What is waiver of the right to forfeit?
Waiver occurs where the landlord, knowing of the relevant breach, performs an unequivocal act recognising the continuing existence of the lease and communicates that act to the tenant.
Does the landlord need to intend to waive the right to forfeit?
No. The landlord's intention is irrelevant if the required unequivocal act is performed and communicated with knowledge of the breach.
What is the effect of waiver for a non-continuing breach?
Waiver is permanent: the landlord loses the right to forfeit for that particular breach.
Which breaches are examples of non-continuing breaches for the purposes of waiver?
Non-payment of rent, unlawful assignment and an insolvency event.
What is the effect of waiver for a continuing breach?
The right to forfeit arises again each day the breach continues.
Which breaches are examples of continuing breaches for the purposes of waiver?
Breach of a repair covenant, breach of a user covenant and failure to comply with an insurance obligation.
What are the landlord's two options for exercising forfeiture?
Peaceable re-entry or applying to the court for a possession order.
What is peaceable re-entry?
The landlord physically re-enters the premises to recover possession, typically by changing the locks and placing a notice on the door.
What practical consequences can peaceable re-entry have for a tenant's business?
It can cause embarrassment and disruption, particularly where bailiffs attend to change the locks or place a notice on the door.
How might a tenant challenge peaceable re-entry?
If it was not carried out lawfully, or if the tenant's stock, equipment or belongings were lost, damaged or stolen.
What are the advantages and disadvantages of seeking a court order for forfeiture?
It costs more and takes longer than peaceable re-entry, but makes it harder for the tenant to challenge the forfeiture.
When can a tenant apply for relief from forfeiture?
Following receipt of a s 146 notice.
How can a tenant obtain relief from forfeiture for non-payment of rent?
By paying all rent arrears and the landlord's costs.
Is relief from forfeiture automatic?
No. It is a discretionary remedy.
What is the effect of relief from forfeiture?
The court restores the lease as if forfeiture had never taken place, aiming to put the parties back in the position they would have been in but for the forfeiture.
Who besides the tenant may apply for relief from forfeiture?
Other parties deriving an interest from the tenant's lease, such as a mortgagee or undertenant.
What might happen where an undertenant obtains relief from forfeiture?
The undertenant could become the landlord's direct tenant.
What special procedure applies before forfeiture for breach of a repair obligation in certain long leases?
The landlord must serve a s 146 notice detailing the breach and the remedy required, giving the tenant a reasonable time to remedy it and advising the tenant of the right to serve a counter notice.
Which leases are subject to the special rules for forfeiture for breach of repair?
Leases granted for a full term of at least seven years with at least three years remaining to run.
What must a landlord obtain before commencing proceedings for forfeiture for breach of repair in the relevant long leases?
Leave of the court.
How long does a tenant have to serve a counter notice following a s 146 notice for breach of repair?
28 days.
What is a self-help clause under Jervis v Harris?
A clause allowing the landlord to enter the premises, carry out repairs and recover the cost from the tenant.
What powers does a landlord have under a Jervis v Harris self-help clause?
The landlord can enter the property, carry out the necessary repairs and recover the costs from the tenant.
Is a s 146 notice required before exercising a Jervis v Harris self-help clause?
No.
How are repair costs recovered under a Jervis v Harris clause?
The costs are treated as a debt owed to the landlord, allowing the landlord to recover the full amount.