1/42
Looks like no tags are added yet.
ethics
Norms for conduct that distinguish between acceptable and unacceptable behavior
Ethics promote the aims of research
Ethics promote values essential to collaborative work
Ethics ensure researchers are accountable to the public
Ethics build public support for research
Why is ethics important in human subjects research?
Nuremberg Code (1947)
Code of ten ethical principles created for judging Nazi doctors
and scientists who conducted unethical medical experiments.
The Declaration of Helsinki (1964)
World Medical Association statement, first adopted in 1964 and most recently revised in 2024.
National Research Act of 1974
Law that established the National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research. This group was charged with determining the basic ethical principles upon which research should be based in the United States.
the Belmont Report
-is the foundation of the current human subjects research protections in the United States
-was issued by the National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research
-respect for persons
-beneficence
-justice
What are basic ethical principles identified by the Belmont Report?
respect for persons in the Belmont Report
-Asserts that individuals are autonomous agents and that those
with diminished autonomy are entitled to protection.
-This principle is responsible for the following research provisions:
• Voluntariness
• Informed consent
• Protection of privacy
• Additional safeguards for diminished autonomy
beneficence in the Belmont Report
-Asserts that research should do no harm, and should aim to
maximize benefits while minimizing harms.
-This principle is responsible for the following research provisions:
• Obligation to use most appropriate study design
• Obligation to use existing procedures for treatment or diagnosis
where possible
• Maximize expected benefit while minimizing risk
• Data monitoring should occur
justice in the Belmont Report
Asserts that people should be treated fairly and should equitably
share benefits and burdens of research
research
A systematic investigation, including research development, testing, and evaluation, designed to develop or contribute to generalizable knowledge
no
Publishing in a journal (alone does not define research). Is this research?
yes
Investigation of OTC naloxone availability at pharmacies across the USA. Is this research?
no
Public-health surveillance authorized by a public-health authority. Is this research?
no
Collection of information by a criminal justice agency for criminal justice purposes. Is this research?
no
Authorized operational activities for a federal agency in support of
intelligence, homeland security, or other national security missions. Is this research?
human subject
is a living individual about whom an investigator conducting research:
• Obtains information or biospecimens through intervention or interaction and uses, studies, or analyzes them;
OR
• Obtains, uses, studies, analyzes, or generates identifiable private
information or identifiable biospecimens.
The Common Rule (§46.111)
calls for safeguards when participants may be vulnerable to coercion or undue influence:
• Prisoners
• Children
• Individuals with impaired decision-making capacity
• Economically or educationally disadvantaged persons
pregnant women and fetuses (Subpart B), prisoners (C), and children (D)
Who has additional regulatory protections in regards to human subjects?
We uphold principles of ethical research at institutions through training requirements for research and through the use of Institutional Review Boards
How do we uphold principles of ethical research?
-At the University of Mississippi, research personnel working with human participants or their data must complete required CITI training.
-Training pathways depend on the study and role. Consult the UM Human Research Handbook and IRB
What are required trainings to conduct human subjects research?
Institutional Review Board (IRB)
is an institutional committee that reviews human subjects research to ensure that the rights and safety of participants are protected
The Common Rule (45 CFR 46, Subpart A)
sets federal requirements for covered human subjects research. Other regulations may also apply.
Required IRB review, approval, or institutional determination
What must be down before recruitment and study procedures begin?
Safety
Subject Selection
Consent
Methodology
Participant
Incentives
What does the IRB evaluate?
-exempt determination
-expedited IRB review
-full board review
What are types of reviews performed by the IRB?
Exempt determination
Must meet a specific regulatory exemption category (not simply any minimal-risk study)
Expedited IRB review
• Eligible research no greater than minimal risk
• IRB chair or designee may approve or request changes (cannot disapprove under expedited procedure)
Full board review
• Convened IRB reviews studies needing this pathway
• Board can approve, modify, or disapprove
Informed consent
-is an ongoing process: participants or authorized representatives receive understandable information about the study, its risks, benefits, and alternatives
-Participation must be voluntary. Consent is generally
documented unless an allowable exception or waiver applies.
persons who have not attained the legal age for consent to treatments or procedures involved in the research under the applicable law of the jurisdiction in which the research will be conducted (in the US it is a matter of state and local laws for legal age)
For the purposes of research, who is considered a child?
Most children cannot independently provide legally effective consent for research; applicable law determines exceptions
Can children consent to research?
assent
Children who are able to do so generally provide __________
(affirmative agreement). The IRB determines when assent is
needed or may be waived.
One parent may be sufficient if the IRB so finds
No greater than minimal risk (§46.404): Whose permission is required for children to participate in research?
One parent may be sufficient if the IRB so finds
Greater than minimal risk; prospect of direct benefit (§46.405): Whose permission is required for children to participate in research?
Both parents, with specified regulatory exceptions
Minor increase over minimal risk; no direct benefit (§46.406) : Whose permission is required for children to participate in research?
Both parents, with specified regulatory exceptions
Special review for serious problem affecting children (§46.407) :
Whose permission is required for children to participate in research?
An IRB may waive parental permission when applicable regulatory requirements are met:
• For example, minimal risk and research not practicable without a waiver
• The waiver does not adversely affect the child's rights and welfare
• When parental permission is not a reasonable protection (e.g., abused or neglected children)
• An appropriate alternative safeguard is provided and the waiver is legally permitted
When can parental permission be waived?
no
Does being an older age alone make a person a vulnerable category under the common rule?
Yes. Older adults can provide their own informed
consent. Evaluate decision-making capacity individually when a
specific concern exists
Can older adults consent to research?
-Justice requires equitable inclusion across ages
-We need evidence of safety and benefit in older adults
Why is it important to include older adults in research?
-When comorbidities create specific study-related risks
-When medications or interactions affect study risk
-When individual decision-making capacity is uncertain
When might we use caution in including older adults in research?
Unjustified upper-age exclusion criteria
Mobility or physical-access barriers
Transportation and caregiver logistics
Vision or hearing impairments
Fatigue or high study burden
Limited digital access or technology support
What are barriers to older adults participating in research?