1/40
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Describe Anselm’s Ontological argument.
-God cannot be thought to not exist. If you can conceive of the greatest possible being, that being must exist because a being that actually exists would be greater than one that exists only in your imagination.
Explain the qualities often associated with God.
-Omnibenevolent: all good, omniscient: all knowing, omnipotent: all powerful, omnipresent: all present
Explain what three positions are on the question of God’s existence.
-Theist, Atheist, Agnostic
Explain the method of argument known as ‘reductio ad absurdum’.
-Assume the opposite of what you would like to prove, and then show that this would imply something impossible or absurd.
Explain Gaunilo’s example of the ‘lost island’.
-You can’t make something real just by defying it as the greatest/perfect thing
Explain Moore’s argument that existence is not a predicate.
-Argues that “exists” is not a property that makes a thing greater or better. Saying something exists doesn’t add a characteristic to the thing.
Explain Rowe’s example about the ‘magican’ and the ‘magico’.
-Magican: an existing magician, magico: non-existing magician, Simply defining something as the greatest possible version of something doesn’t make it exist. Think unican vs unico
Explain Taylor’s Cosmological argument.
-Argues that the universe must have a cause of explanation and that this ultimately points to God.
What is the principle of sufficient reason and how does it relate to a proof of God’s existence?
-In the case of any positive truth in something that exists is some case/explanation for it. Think stuffed bunny in classroom. If the universe exists, then there has to be a reason it exists, a creator, that creator is God
Explain Paley’s argument from design.
-Believes that anything that has a purpose, order, or assembly of parts must have an intelligent creator.
Describe three factors that Paley thinks WOULD NOT undermine the judgment that a watch sitting in the forest must have been made by a watchmaker.
-You have never seen a watch being made, the watch has a flaw, none would say that the watch came from random chance events
Explain Nagel’s critique of the Cosmological argument.
-Does everything have to have a cause? If everything has to have a cause, then why doesn’t god have to have a cause?
Explain Nagel’s critique of the argument from design.
The real reason that we know the watch has a maker is because we make the watches, not because it has a function
Explain Nagel’s critique of ‘religious experience’ as a source of evidence for God’s existence.
-Argues that religious experiences are not reliable evidence for God’s existence because an experience can feel real to the person having it without actually proving what they experienced outside their minds.
Explain Nagel’s ‘problem of evil’.
-God is all-powerful, God is perfectly good, evil and suffering exist… why would an all-powerful, perfectly good God allow evil to exist?
Explain Pascal’s wager.
-Nobody can prove that God exits because God is beyond the limits of human understanding. Despite this, we do know that God either exists or doesn’t exist.
Explain an objection to Pascal’s wager.
-Many Gods Objection: religions that have many different gods, a singular “God” cannot just exist because many could or none at all no in between.
Explain Clifford’s example of the ship owner
-If you see a sinking shop, the ship owner (not you observing) is morally responsible even if you believe the ship is safe, because you feel as though you did not have enough good evidence for your belief. It is wrong to believe anything without sufficient evidence.
Explain two reasons that Clifford gives why it is wrong to maintain a ‘credulous character’.
-Self-harm: makes you a poor judge of what is true and false, and unable to face uncomfortable truths. Social Harm: other people that are influenced by you will also develop a ‘credulous character’.
Provide three reasons that God’s hiddenness is a disadvantage according to McKim.
-Make it harder for people to believe that God exists, makes it harder for people to have a close personal relationship with God, makes it harder for people to devote themselves to and worship God
Explain the test that Everitt suggests for gaining evidence that a certain type of being does NOT exist.
-If there is a being with nature N and intentions I, then the being will produce change C in the world. The world does not display change C, therefore there is evidence that the being does not exist.
How is the actual world not appropriate as an expression of God’s intentions according to Everitt?
-Humans would appear early in the universe, humans would appear not long after non-human animals, the earth would be in the center of the universe, the universe would not be vastly larger than earth.
Explain the theory of utilitarianism.
-Act always to promote the greatest amount of overall happiness for the greatest number of people
Explain Mill’s claim that happiness is the only thing that we pursue as an end and not as a means.
-If we pursue happiness, that is the ultimate end of human action.
Explain Mill’s response to the claim that “Utilitarianism is a theory fit for swine”.
-It is better to be an unhappy human being than a satisfied rude person.
Explain a basic criticism of utilitarianism other than ‘theory fit for swine’.
-It’s too demanding.
Explain Kant’s shopkeeper example.
-If a shopkeeper is charging all customers the correct price, but is doing it to keep a good reputation to others, he is doing it out of self-interest and does not really have moral worth
Why does Kant say that only a good will is good in itself?
-Good will is shown when you act from the motive of duty too uphold the moral law, only an act done from the motive of duty has moral worth, an act that is done from the motive of inclination has no moral worth.
Explain both versions of the categorical imperative.
-Version 1=act always so that the maxim which describes your action could be willed to be a universal law
Version 2= never treat a human being as a means to an end, but always as an end in itself
Explain O’Neill’s account of what it is to treat someone as a mere means.
-You use someone as a means when you involve them in an interaction that they would not consent to
Describe an action that is morally obligatory according to one ethical theory and morally impermissible according to another.
-Lying to someone…
Kant: lying is morally impermissible because he believes we have a duty to be truthful following moral rules regardless of consequences
Utilitarianism: lying can be morally obligatory if it produces the greatest overall happiness or prevents greater harm
Explain Singer’s argument that we have a moral obligation to assist the global poor.
-Since giving away some of our money does not require us to sacrifice anything of comparable moral importance, we should help.
Explain why Singer says that the problem of global hunger is not a problem of scarcity of resources.
-It’s a problem of poor distribution and waste of available resources instead
Explain two objections to Singer’s argument that we have a moral obligation to assist the absolute poor.
-If we have to give up “too much money”, then that could be considered as too demanding
We have our own obligations to family, friends, and other people in our communities. Singer’s argument seems to treat strangers as closer to us than what is morally required.
Explain two possible differences between killing and failing to assist.
-Difference in motivation (think drunk driver vs killer driver)
-It is very easy not to kill, but it is very hard to save all the lives that you could
Explain Singer’s response to two of the differences between killing and failing to assist.
-Singer argues that the motivation behind an action does not necessarily determine whether it is morally wrong, what matters is whether we could have prevented the harm
Singer argues that the fact that we cannot save everyone does not mean we shouldn’t save anyone, it is at relatively little close to yourself to do so
Discuss Singer’s response to two of the objections to his argument.
-“Too demanding”: Morality should in fact require significant sacrifice
“We have special obligations to family and friends”: He never says you can’t prioritize people close to you, the suffering of strangers still matter morally even if you don’t know them
Explain the trolley problem by explaining ‘bystander at the switch’, and ‘transplant’.
-If you’re driving a trolley and you pull a switch to divert it, you will kill one person but save five
If one healthy patient comes in for a checkup but five need organ transplants, the doctor could use (kill) the healthy person but save five sick patients
Explain Thomson’s discussion of the fat man on the bridge.
-A trolley is heading toward five people, a fat man is above the track and if you push him onto it his body would save 5 people but kill him. Most people think this is wrong even though it is the same as bystander at switch ex.
Explain Thomson’s solution to the trolley problem.
-It can be permissible to redirect a threat so that fewer people die, but it is not permissible to intentionally kill someone and use them as a means to save others
Explain Thomson’s example of the ‘looping track’.
-Like the bystander at switch except the one person on a loop’s body stops the trolley from reaching the five people, so they are playing a casual role (as a means to save others)