True crim

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/344

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

345 Terms

1
New cards
What are the sources of criminal law?
State legislatures and D.C.; federal statutes; the U.S. Military Code; executive agencies; international treaties; the MPC; federal and state constitutions; case law; English and American common law.
2
New cards
What is the Model Penal Code (MPC)?
Written by the American Law Institute (judges, scholars, lawyers) to rationalize criminal law and give a consistent framework for intent and accomplice liability. Binding only where a state has adopted it; otherwise courts look to it persuasively, especially its four mental states.
3
New cards
What is the common law?
English law as adopted and modified by each state and the federal government. It is both judge
4
New cards
What is the taxonomy of crimes?
Property (theft, burglary, trespass); economic markets (receiving stolen goods, counterfeiting, securities fraud); regulatory (traffic, tax, health/insurance and welfare fraud); against the person (murder, rape, assault, battery); against morality (gambling, public indecency).
5
New cards
What is retribution?
Non
6
New cards
What is deterrence?
Utilitarian, forward
7
New cards
What is rehabilitation?
Utilitarian: reform D (training, counseling, drug treatment) into a law
8
New cards
What is incapacitation (isolation)?
Utilitarian: remove D from society so he can't harm others; works only if he doesn't offend in prison.
9
New cards
What is denunciation?
Public condemnation or shaming of the conduct (hybrid/utilitarian theory).
10
New cards
What is restorative justice?
Repairing the harm; often used with juveniles; gives victims closure and reintegrates the offender.
11
New cards
What is the proportionality principle?
Punishment should match the gravity of the crime.
12
New cards
Which theory of punishment best fits Dudley & Stephens?
Retribution. Deterrence is unlikely to work on starving people, rehabilitation is of little use, and isolation is unnecessary because they aren't dangerous to others.
13
New cards
What is necessity (as used in Dudley & Stephens)?
D claims he had to commit the crime to avoid a greater harm (starvation). Dudley holds it is never a defense to killing an innocent person.
14
New cards
Who sentences a defendant?
The judge (the jury decides only the death penalty). Any sentence within the principles of punishment is allowed.
15
New cards
What are alternative sanctions?
Probation, community service, treatment programs, fines, house arrest/electronic monitoring.
16
New cards
What does "incarceration nation" refer to?
The U.S. has about 5% of the world's population but roughly 22–25% of its prisoners (about 1.9 million people); its rate is about 6x Canada's, 9x Germany's, 16x China's, and 19x India's.
17
New cards
A first time shoplifter gets community service plus job training. Which theory?
Rehabilitation. (A long sentence publicized to warn others = general deterrence.)
18
New cards
What must the prosecution prove and why?
Every element beyond a reasonable doubt (BRD). It reduces convictions based on factual error, liberty is at stake, and it keeps public confidence that innocent people aren't condemned.
19
New cards
Burden of production vs. burden of persuasion?
Production: enough evidence to put an issue before the jury. Persuasion: who must convince the factfinder, and by how much.
20
New cards
What is a general defense (failure of proof)?
"You can't prove an element." D attacks an element and the State still must prove everything BRD. Ex: Navarro (no intent to steal), Wetmore (mental condition negates specific intent), Martin (no voluntary act).
21
New cards
What is an affirmative defense?
"Yes, I did it, but I'm excused or justified." Ex: insanity (D bears the burden: preponderance or clear and convincing); self
22
New cards
What happens if the evidence is insufficient or D is acquitted?
Directed verdict of acquittal if the evidence is insufficient; the State can't appeal a not
23
New cards
What is the sufficiency of the evidence test?
Could a reasonable jury find guilt BRD, viewing the evidence in the light most favorable to the prosecution? (Curley)
24
New cards
Standard of review for a sentence vs. a conviction?
Sentence: abuse of discretion (Suitte). Conviction: sufficiency of the evidence, viewed in the light most favorable to the prosecution (Curley).
25
New cards
What is a plurality opinion?
A majority agrees on the result but not the reasoning. The plurality opinion is the one joined by the most justices in the majority; it controls the judgment but has weaker precedential force (Ewing, Powell, Harmelin).
26
New cards
What are the duties of defense counsel and prosecutors?
Defense counsel: be competent (especially in capital cases), don't misrepresent facts, don't appeal to prejudice, owe a duty to the administration of justice. Prosecutors: seek justice not convictions, charge only with probable cause, don't seek unfairly harsh sentences.
27
New cards
What is jury nullification?
The jury rejects the evidence or refuses to apply the law (to send a message or because the result seems unjust). A juror has the power, not the right. Defendants can't argue for it, and a juror who won't follow the law can be removed (People v. Williams).
28
New cards
What is the principle of legality?
No crime or punishment without a pre
29
New cards
What is the plain meaning rule?
If a statute has a plain meaning, that meaning controls absent a strong indication of contrary legislative intent. If it's ambiguous, remember the rule of lenity.
30
New cards
What are the canons of statutory interpretation in order?
(1) Plain language; (2) statutory context; (3) noscitur a sociis; (4) ejusdem generis; (5) legislative history; (6) avoid absurd results; (7) rule of lenity.
31
New cards
What is the statutory context canon?
Read the law as a whole, not just one sentence. If another section allows service dogs, the prohibition has an exception.
32
New cards
What is noscitur a sociis?
"A word is known by its neighbors": a word's meaning depends on the words around it. "Cars, trucks, motorcycles, and other vehicles" suggests motorized transportation.
33
New cards
What is ejusdem generis?
General words after a list are limited to things like the listed items. "Cars, trucks, buses, and similar vehicles" → "similar vehicles" wouldn't include bikes.
34
New cards
What is the legislative history canon?
Look at what lawmakers were trying to accomplish when passing the law (e.g., a law passed to stop drunk driving helps explain an unclear provision).
35
New cards
What is the rule of lenity?
Genuine ambiguity is resolved in D's favor (due process: fair warning). The professor stresses it is a last resort, used only if ambiguity survives the other canons (Dauray).
36
New cards
When is a statute void for vagueness?
When it (1) fails to give a person of ordinary intelligence fair notice of what is forbidden, or (2) invites arbitrary enforcement by leaving police too much discretion. (Due process, 5th and 14th Amendments.)
37
New cards
Which vagueness concern is the more important one?
Arbitrary enforcement: the legislature must set minimal guidelines for police (Kolender).
38
New cards
How do vague laws connect to racial inequity?
Vague loitering, vagrancy, and disorderly
39
New cards
An ordinance bans acting "suspiciously in public." Valid?
Likely void for vagueness: no fair notice, and police decide case by case what is "suspicious."
40
New cards
What does the Eighth Amendment require on proportionality?
Not strict proportionality; it forbids only grossly disproportionate sentences (e.g., life for stealing $10 of candy).
41
New cards
What is the Solem v. Helm three part test?
(1) Gravity of the offense vs. harshness of the penalty; (2) sentences for other crimes in the same jurisdiction; (3) sentences for the same crime in other jurisdictions. No factor controls (taken from the Rummel v. Estelle dissent).
42
New cards
What is the rule of thumb for Eighth Amendment cases?
Categorical bright lines for the death penalty and juvenile LWOP; deferential, case
43
New cards
What evidence of consensus did Graham rely on?
(1) Almost no other country imposes juvenile LWOP; (2) adolescent brain science (as in Roper); (3) actual sentencing practice: rarely imposed even where allowed.
44
New cards
What are recidivist statutes?
Laws imposing harsher sentences on repeat offenders (California three strikes; Fla. Stat. § 775.084). Sentencing guidelines aim for uniformity.
45
New cards
Death for armed robbery with no injury vs. 25 to life for a third felony theft?
Death for armed robbery with no injury → likely unconstitutional (Coker/Kennedy: death reserved for homicide). 25
46
New cards
What does the Equal Protection Clause require in criminal law?
14th Amendment (applies to the federal government through the 5th): the government can't enforce criminal laws in a way that discriminates between similarly situated people. Classifications or enforcement by race, national origin, or another suspect class get strict scrutiny: narrowly tailored to a compelling interest.
47
New cards
What are the systemic problems with the death penalty?
Inadequate counsel; executing the mentally ill; how executions are carried out; and actual innocence alone is not a freestanding constitutional ground to overturn a sentence.
48
New cards
What makes a defendant death eligible?
At least one aggravating factor (McCleskey).
49
New cards
What is the formula for criminal liability?
Actus reus + mens rea + causation + social harm = liability.
50
New cards
What are the 5 elements of a crime?
(1) Actus reus: a voluntary act, or a failure to act when legally required; (2) mens rea: the required guilty mental state; (3) causation: D's conduct caused the prohibited result; (4) concurrence: the mental state existed at the time of the conduct; (5) attendant circumstances: additional facts that must exist for the conduct to be the crime.
51
New cards
What are the components of the actus reus?
Voluntary conduct or omission; attendant circumstances; result (only for result crimes like murder); causation. Common law and the MPC treat actus reus similarly.
52
New cards
Can you be punished for bad thoughts alone?
No. There must be conduct. But a state may punish more severely a crime motivated by bias against a protected class, because it punishes the conduct, not the thought (Wisconsin v. Mitchell).
53
New cards
What is a voluntary act?
A bodily movement willed by the actor (MPC § 2.01: the product of the actor's effort or determination).
54
New cards
What acts are involuntary under the MPC?
(1) Reflexes or convulsions/seizures; (2) movement during unconsciousness or sleep; (3) conduct during or resulting from hypnosis; (4) any movement not the product of effort or determination.
55
New cards
Are habitual acts voluntary?
Yes. Habits and trained responses are voluntary even on "auto
56
New cards
What is automatism?
Being capable of action but not conscious of it (as in a seizure); it shields D from liability for the involuntary act.
57
New cards
What is time framing?
A court widens the time frame to an earlier voluntary act that created the risk of a later involuntary harmful act (Decina: choosing to drive knowing he was prone to seizures).
58
New cards
How do Martin and Decina differ?
Decina made his own free choice to drive knowing the risk → liable. Martin never chose to be in public; police carried him there → not liable.
59
New cards
D sleepwalks and breaks a vase. Liable?
No voluntary act. Contrast: D, told by his doctor not to drive on new medication, drives, blacks out, and hits someone → liable under Decina time framing.
60
New cards
What is the general rule on omissions?
No legal duty to act (moral obligation ≠ legal duty). Liability for an omission requires a legal duty AND the physical ability to act.
61
New cards
Why is there no general duty to act?
Motives are hard to judge, line
62
New cards
What are the five sources of a legal duty to act?
(1) Statute; (2) special relationship; (3) contract; (4) voluntary assumption of care; (5) creating the risk.
63
New cards
What are examples of a statutory duty to act?
Paying taxes; stopping after a car accident; mandatory reporters (teachers, social workers); Good Samaritan statutes.
64
New cards
Which special relationships create a duty to act?
Spouses; parent
65
New cards
What are examples of a contractual duty to act?
A paid caregiver or a lifeguard (Pestinikas).
66
New cards
What is voluntary assumption of care?
Taking charge of a helpless person and secluding them from others' help creates a duty to act.
67
New cards
What is the creation of risk duty?
Creating the danger (running someone over, knocking someone into a pool) creates a duty to help.
68
New cards
What are Good Samaritan statutes?
Civil versions (common) protect rescuers from liability; criminal versions (rare) impose a duty to help. Hawaii: no duty, rescuers protected unless grossly negligent. Vermont: must give reasonable assistance if no danger to yourself; civil immunity unless grossly negligent or paid; fine up to $100.
69
New cards
A child drowns in a shallow pool. Who has a duty: a stranger or the babysitter or the driver who hit the child?
Stranger: no duty (unless a criminal Good Samaritan statute applies). Babysitter: contract duty. Driver who hit the child: created the risk.
70
New cards
Can you be punished for a status?
No. Punishing a status (addict, alcoholic, homeless) is cruel and unusual (8th and 14th Amendments); only conduct can be punished.
71
New cards
What is the status crime line from Robinson to Powell to Jones?
Robinson: pure status → unconstitutional. Powell: status plus conduct (being drunk in public) → constitutional. Jones: conduct unavoidable given the status (sleeping outside with no shelter beds) → unconstitutional as applied.
72
New cards
What is mens rea?
The mental state the crime requires at the time of the act. Broad sense: general blameworthiness. Narrow/elemental sense (MPC): the specific mental state in the offense's definition.
73
New cards
How does the common law sort mental states?
Common law terms (willfully, intentionally, purposely, maliciously, knowingly) largely mean the same thing; the common law sorts crimes into general intent, specific intent, and strict liability.
74
New cards
What are the four MPC mental states from most to least culpable?
Purposely → knowingly → recklessly → negligently.
75
New cards
What does "purposely" mean under the MPC?
Conscious object to engage in the conduct or cause the result. (Ex: kill a guy with a bomb.)
76
New cards
What does "knowingly" mean under the MPC?
Aware of the nature of the conduct, or practically certain the result will follow. (Ex: I bomb my target knowing his girlfriend is with him.)
77
New cards
What does "recklessly" mean under the MPC?
Consciously disregards a substantial and unjustifiable risk; a gross deviation from a law
78
New cards
What does "negligently" mean under the MPC?
Fails to perceive a substantial and unjustifiable risk that a reasonable person would perceive. Objective standard; no awareness required. (Ex: I didn't know debris would kill a guy in the parking lot.)
79
New cards
What are the MPC material elements?
Conduct (driving) + attendant circumstance (under the influence) + result (serious injury).
80
New cards
How do courts decide which element a mens rea word modifies?
They use the canons of statutory construction to find legislative intent. Jurisdictional elements (e.g., "within federal jurisdiction") need not carry the same mental state as the other elements (Yermian).
81
New cards
What is the difference between the Yermian and Holloway questions?
Yermian asks WHICH elements need a mental state; Holloway asks what KIND of intent suffices (conditional intent is enough).
82
New cards
General intent vs. specific intent in one line?
General intent: D intends to perform the act itself. Specific intent: D intends the act AND the prohibited result of that act.
83
New cards
What is intent at common law?
Conscious purpose to cause the result, or knowledge to a virtual certainty that the harm will result. MPC "purposely" = intent.
84
New cards
What is a general intent crime?
No intent beyond the act; the State need only show D intended the prohibited act (trespass, battery). Crimes requiring only recklessness or negligence are general intent.
85
New cards
What is a specific intent crime?
An additional intent beyond the act: look for "with intent to," a special motive, or awareness of an attendant circumstance. Voluntary intoxication is a defense only to specific intent crimes.
86
New cards
Which crimes are general intent?
Assault and battery (aggravated versions are specific); rape; arson; kidnapping; false imprisonment; involuntary manslaughter; depraved heart murder.
87
New cards
Which crimes are specific intent?
Burglary; robbery; forgery; larceny; solicitation; attempt (always); conspiracy; 1st
88
New cards
Is voluntary intoxication a defense to arson?
No. Arson is general intent, so voluntary intoxication can't negate it (People v. Atkins).
89
New cards
What is strict liability?
No mens rea for the element; proving the act is enough and mistake is no defense. Mostly public
90
New cards
What are the signs that a statute is strict liability?
(1) Statutory, not common law; (2) legislative policy against mens rea; (3) a "reasonable conduct" (regulatory) standard; (4) small penalty (a factor, not a cap); (5) little reputational damage.
91
New cards
A clerk sells beer to a 17 year old with a convincing fake ID. Defense?
No. Strict liability, so the honest mistake is no defense. Contrast: taking furniture from a "free" sign that wasn't free → Morissette: theft still requires intent.
92
New cards
What is the natural and probable consequences doctrine?
Intent to kill may be presumed where the natural and probable consequence of D's wrongful act is death (Fugate, citing State v. Slater). Intent is usually proven circumstantially.
93
New cards
What is knowledge at common law vs. under the MPC?
Common law: D is aware of the fact or correctly believes it exists. MPC § 2.02(7): knowledge is established if D is aware of a high probability of the fact unless he actually believes it doesn't exist. Can be actual (direct evidence) or constructive (inferred).
94
New cards
What is willful blindness?
It equals knowledge. D (1) subjectively believed there was a high probability the fact existed and (2) took deliberate actions to avoid learning it (Global
95
New cards
What is transferred intent?
When D intends to harm one person but accidentally harms another, D's intent transfers to the person actually harmed, and D is punished as if he hit the intended victim ("intent follows the bullet"). MPC § 2.03(2)(a).
96
New cards
Why does intent transfer?
D is just as culpable, and society is harmed just as much, as if he had hit his intended victim.
97
New cards
D aims at A and misses and kills B. What charges?
Usually two: (1) attempted murder of A and (2) murder of B (People v. Scott).
98
New cards
When does transferred intent NOT apply?
(1) Misidentification (no transfer needed: one victim, one charge); (2) intent "used up" on the target; (3) the statute requires intent toward a specific person; (4) a different type of harm (person → property or property → person).
99
New cards
D throws a rock at X and misses and breaks a window. Transferred intent?
No. Different harm (person → property), so no transfer. Same for property → person: a rock thrown to break a window that hits someone inside doesn't transfer.
100
New cards
D shoots the man he thinks is Tom but it is actually Bob. Transferred intent?
Not needed: misidentification. He shot the person he aimed at, so it's murder of Bob.