1/13
Looks like no tags are added yet.
definition of state (montevideo)
State is considered a state if it satisfies 4 conditions:
permanent population
government
boarders
capacity of entering relationships with other countries
definition of state ( Max weber)
“ compulsory political organisation with a centralised governmen t that mantains a monopoly of the legitimate force within a certain territory “
(1. political organisation
centered government
monopoly of force
within a territoty)
characteristics of statehood (5)
defined territory
government
monopoly of force
permanet population
relationship with others states
sovereignety (has the capacity of deciding what the fuck he wants to do within its territory)
what is a public good
goods that once produced are easily available
not easily excluded
when one individual uses it, does not reduce the availability of it to others (NON- RIVALROUS)
usually provided by government
es. health care, education, public infrastructure, public radio
what is state capacity
“measurement of a state’s ability to fulfill its functions and accomplish its goals “
how can state capacity be assessed ?
effective gov / supply of goods
man taining rule of law/ by law
keeping its monopoly of force
what is Rule OF law
DEMOCRATIC regime
set of rules which regulates the daily life of a community
everyone is affected
requires separation of powers
to bring justice / protect
(to regulate who regulates)
what is the Rule BY law
NON-democratic regimes
law is a tool of the users, not a constraint on them
no separation of powers
Regulators can use the law as they want to es. supress opponents
Rule OF law ≠ Rule BY law
Rule OF law => DEMOCRATIC regimes
Rule BY law => NON-democratic regimes
stages of state faillure
strong
weak (es. Venezuela)
failling (es. Sudan) ( difficult to classify between the 2 stages)
collapsed( no authority, no justice, no public goods) es. Yemen
to help classify: fragile state index (12 criterias), the smaller the index is the better, the worst is Yemen and the best is Finland.
weak state characteristics
due to geographical / economic constrants
basically strong, but temporarely weak
intercommunal tension that not yet had become violent
crime rates / corruption increases,however still honor the rule OF law
diminishing provison of political goods
deteriorate infrastructures
GDP decreases
es. Iraq, Belarus
failed state characteristics
tense, conflicted, dangerous
government troops vs revolts
civil wars and disharmonies between communities ( ethnic and religion is a contributor not the root of failure)
loose authorities other some sections in the state, like in distant areas from the capital)
harass the majority, favour only few ones, like a party, unequal economic opportunity and declining GDP per capita, inflation rise
growth of criminal violence, no secure atmosper, criminal gangs take over the streets / warlords
limited quantities of public goods
flawed institutions, military is possible the only one with integrity
deteriorated / flawed infrastructure
education / health care system is private, food shortages and widespread hunger=> starvation
no democratic debate , large scale of corruption, bureocracy often used to opress citizens, state not able to do their fundamental jobs.
state has lost legitimacy
es. Sudan / Congo
leads to immigration
collapsed state characteristics
rare/ extreme version of failed state
security through the “rule of strong”, there are warlords, not recognised internationally
es. Somalia/ Afghanistan
non-terminal stage (does not last forever), es. Libanon, thanks to human securaty cooperation of leaders, it went again to a functioning state, after 1943 altered political and social circumstances)
Montevideo convention vs Max Weber state definition
Monteverde=> 4 conditions (! relationship with other states)
Max Weber => 4 conditions (monopoly of force)