1/28
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Ethics historically prioritized…
Human Concerns (Anthropocentric Ethics)
Ancient Countercurrents show…
early hints of environmental ethics, that nature has its own value and beauty, and that the entire world is interconnected.
Natural Beauty Has Value (Symposium): Plato argued that appreciating physical beauty in nature helps us understand higher truths.
Everything Is Connected (Theory of Forms): Plato believed all things come from the same ultimate blueprint, meaning humans aren't entirely separate from or above nature.
The World Is a Living Whole (Neo-Platonists): Thinkers like Plotinus viewed the entire world as one living, unified organism—an early version of ecosystem-focused ethics (ecocentrism).
The Great Chain of Being is a chain from angels down to the non living. The logic of the hierarchy is that…
Lower creatures existed to serve the needs of higher creatures, with human beings at the apex of the natural world.
(angels > humans > animals > plants > non living things)
Cartesian Mechanism was the philosophical view of René Descartes that argued that…
non human animals are machines (automata). Animals lack a rational soul and free will, and their actions are driven by instinct and therefore are mechanical, supporting that humans have no direct moral duties toward animals.
The use of animals and zoos is justified through…
anthropocentrism. Animals not only can be farmed, but used for human amusement.
Kant identified 3 reasons that should guide our conduct towards other living things:…
Utility (how useful animals are to human needs)
Reflexivity (how we treat animals reflects how we treat humans)
Sentience (animals have degrees of rational capacities)
According to Kant, Animals should be given moral consideration if…
Utility - protect animals if doing so benefits humans
Reflexivity - cruelty to animals is bad because it encourages a person to act cruelly to other people
Sentience - creatures with higher capacities should be given greater consideration
Anthropocentric Environmentalism refers to environmental protection that is justified primarily by…
human interests, rather than nature’s intrisic value
How does Stewardship fit into Anthropocentric Environmentalism?
Humans are at the top(apex) of creation, but have a responsibility to care for the environment to support present and future generations.
How does Cartesian Mechanism fit into Anthropocentric Environmentalism?
Only beings with a rational soul (humans) deserve direct moral consideration
How does Kantian Animal Ethics fit into Anthropocentric Environmentalism?
Animals get consideration based on their sentience or utility to humans
Biocentric Ethics:
Non human living beings are given moral consideration for their own sake, rather than just for human benefit
How does Natural Theology support Biocentrism?
Plants and animals were not created for humans and have their own interests and value because they reflect the glory of God (proposed by thinkers like John Ray)
What is Albert Schweitzer’s Biocentrism’s central moral principle?
It is good to maintain and encourage life, it is bad to destroy life or obstruct it.
The 3 main duties in Schweitzer’s Biocentrism are…
recognize humans live among other life forms
respect each organism’s right to pursue its own good as an independent center of life
act sympathetically to help other life forms continue to live well
Schweitzer’s Biocentrism focuses on the wellbeing of…
individual living beings (individualistic, not holistic)
Real world examples of Biocentric ethics:…
the animal liberation movement, anti-animal testing activism
Ecocentrism is an ethical approach where moral consideration focuses on…
the health, stability, and wellbeing of whole ecosystems, rather than just living things
Compare Ecocentrism and Biocentrism - Holistic or Individualistic?
Ecocentrism is holistic - value to whole interconnected systems including all living, and non living things like soils
Biocentrism is individualistic - value to individual organisms
The Land Ethic explains that
a thing is right when it tends to preserve the integrity, stability, and beauty of the biotic community (all living things, but also soils, water, and air).
It is wrong when it tends otherwise.
Mink farming and the three perspectives
Anthropocentric - acceptable as long as profit is made, and human interests are served
Biocentric - wrong because the minks suffer
Ecocentric - wrong because the minks are removed from their natural ecological roles, and releasing captive ones disrupts balance in ecosystems
The Clayoquot Sound logging conflicts were…
protests and road blockades in BC against clear cutting temperate coastal rainforests and old growth trees, led to 800 arrests and eventual policy change
John Locke’s view of land and natural resources:
Land only becomes valuable or owned when humans work it by harvesting/mining, leaving land unworked in its natural state is considered wasted.
Locke’s legacy is Anthropocentric because…
It views nature purely as a resource for human economic gain, measuring a forest’s worth only by what can be extracted by it
The Gaia Hypothesis is an ecocentric view that…
treats a forest or earth as an interconnected system with aesthetic and moral value, rather than just a natural resource for humans
Does ecocentrism allow resource extraction?
Yes, but only if it ecologically sustainable in a way that respects the ecosystem’s health and integrity.
Forestry Management in Canada and the Lockean view:
Governments often view forests primarily as economic natural resources, main goal is to find timber buyers, forests treated as tree farms rather than living ecosystems.
Industrial tree harvesting is unsustainable in the long run because…
tree renewal takes decades. future timber extraction becomes increasingly expensive and produces lower quality wood from degraded soils.