1/192
Looks like no tags are added yet.
proper role of government
promoting the general welfare
optimizing the greater good for the most amount of people
goal of businesses
making profit for their owners
an ethical reputational obligation to some level of CSR
what happens when business’ activities conflict with the role of the government
regulations
dangers of regulation
too much
too little
unenforced/poorly enforced regulations
problems with too many regulations
can stifle business development
create barriers to entry
costs make it difficult to start a business
can result in a business being uncompetitive internationally
problems with too little regulation
ex. vietnam streetside haircuts (training, power grid, etc.)
ex. cambodia housing
barber requirements in WA
1000 hours of barber school
usually in the middle compared to other states
EMT requirements in WA
take a course for 178 hours
cpr certification
pass a national exam
gujarat factory solution
auditors paid from a pool of money collected from factories
randomly assigned to factories and were not allowed to audit the same factory twice
auditors paid a bonus for accurate reports, fined for inaccurate reports
upton sinclair
muckraker
poor with rich relatives
went undercover in a meat packing factory and noticed poor worker conditions and food safety conditions
“aim for the heart and hit them in the stomach”
securities act of 1933
looked at brand new businesses selling stock to the public
companies selling stocks must provide the public with sufficient information to make an informed decision
auditing company must come audit before stocks are sold
before selling any securities companies must file a registration statement and prospectus to summarize the security and outline risks
disclosure act
doesnt assure accuracy of information, but can jump in later and punish people for misleading information
securities act of 1934
existing publicly traded corporations must be independently audited every quarter and file annual reports so that shareholders have an unbiased view of the organization
Inputs
external pressures that shape governments’ policy decisions and strategy
goals of public policy
goals can be broad and subjective. one persons goal may be another persons burden
regulations limit freedom and come with costs.
policy instruments and tools
penalties and incentives (carrots & sticks)
penalties
a fine to compel a company to start or stop doing something
legal actions can be initiated against a business like taking away a license
information, King County the government requires restaurants to publicly post information that might damage the business
penalties for sick leave noncompliance
in COVID, sick leave was extended to gig workers, eg. postmates
a lot of companies fined because they did not comply with sick leave regulations
why do we regulate
market failure
externalities
government approved monopolies
regulations to promote ethical conduct
self regulation doesnt always work
tort laws are an inadequate remedy
guard against consumers solely relying on caveat emptor
guard rails
cost benefit analysis
market failure - policy
when a marketplace fails to adjust prices for the true cost of a firm’s behavior
guardians and conservatorship - nobody watching the person taking care of the people who need it
now, in determining reasonable compensation for a guardian, the court approves compensation that shouldn’t exceed typical amounts paid for comparable services in the community
externalities
an expense, cost, or byproduct that is not borne by the business or consumer, but by the public
pollution
the problem with pollution is that either consumer, producer, or government has to pay
gov choices w externalities
tell producers to pay for these costs, they pass it down to customers
tell consumers to pay for the costs (garbage disposal fee)
tell the public to pay the costs
ban it entirely (microbeads) when nothing else works
government approved monopolies
makes no sense for 2 sewer systems or electricity grids etc., better to regulate prices for one company that runs these (Puget Sound Energy)
regulations to promote ethical conduct
you may want to speed on the highway but if you are caught you get a ticket
False Claims act
also known as the Qui Tam act
whistleblowers get a % of recovered money when they report their employer
Federal Sentencing Guidelines
rewards companies that step forward and voluntarily disclose their misconduct or if they name the people in their company that are breaking the law
self regulation
industry says that they are smart enough to self regulate
examples of it failing: movie ratings, video game ratings
examples of it working: novotel hotel
government’s relationship with business can be either
cooperative or adversarial
democracy
the presence of political freedom
all those who are affected by a decision should have a right to participating in making that decision
free enterprise system
a socioeconomic system based on private ownership, profit seeking firms, and the principles of free markets
authoritarian capitalism
a free market economy with political control by nonelected elite
usually, political and economic freedoms are related, since more control over government decisions can lead to pushes for greater economic opportunity, and open markets can give people the resources to participate more effectively in politics
central state control
central gov owns property used to produce goods and services
heritage foundation
a conservative think tank
scores nations on an index of economic freedom, the fundamental rights of every human to control his own property
singapore, switzerland, ireland, and taiwan were the highest, US was the 25th
Apple Anti Trust
accused apple of illegaly monopolizing the smartphone market due to restrictive app store terms, high fees, and a “walled garden” approach to hardware and software
why would a company welcome regulation?
set minimum standards for firms
build public confidence in product safety
create fair playing fields for competition
create barriers to entry to maintain comp advantage
economic sanctions
governments may order companies not to conduct business in another country because of a war, human rights violations, or lack of a legitimate government
embargo
ban on trade
broadly restricted countries (for the US)
Iran, North Kora, Syria, Cuba, the Crimea, Donetsk People’s Republic, and Luhansk People’s Republic
sources of authority
political systems
consitutions
common law
monarchies
military dictatorships
religious authority
examples of policy inputs
economic & foreign policy concerns
domestic political pressure from constituents and interest groups
technical information
media attention
economic policies
fiscal policies
trade policy
monetary policy
taxation policy
industrial policy
trade policy
fiscal policy
patterns of governments collecting and spending funds to stimulate the economy
government spending by level
local - employ teachers, trash collectors, police, firefighters
state - roads, social services, parkland
national - military defense, international relationships, public works
trade policy
rules for imports and exports
India’s priority for 2021-2026 was to become a leader in international commerce, so to this end boosted exports of merchandise and services heavily
monetary policy
policies that affect the supply, demand, and value of currency
affects the country’s ability to borrow and lend money, and supports citizen and investor confidence
social policies
government policies related to fields like healthcare and education that affect the lives of people in society directly
public policy vs regulation
public policy refers to a broader set of intents and goals to address a societal issue, while regulations are formal binding rules intended to accomplish those public policies
economic regulations
fiscal policy (tax breaks + tax credits)
price/wage controls
public resource allocation
resource rationing
antitrust
predatory pricing
the practice of selling below cost to drive rivals out of business
Google antitrust
claimed that Google was abusing its power over the adtech industry by hurting advertisers that tried to use competing products by funneling transactions to its own adtech products and extracting inflated fees
structural remedy
breakup of a monopolistic firm
conduct remedy
an agreement that the offending firm will change its conduct under gov supervision
intellectual property remedy
disclosure of information to competitors
social regulations
aimed at protecting consumers and environment, and providing workers with safe and healthy working conditions
cost is loss of personal freedom
criticism of these regulations is that they lead to creation of a “nanny state”
why should firms be politically involved
economic stakes are high for firms and business counterbalances other social interestswh
concerns about firms being politically involved
managers are not qualified enough to be engaging in political debate
business is too big and powerful and selfish to care about the common good
business risks its credibility by engaging in politics
federal election spending
OpenSecrets predicts that 2024’s federal election cycle was on track to be the costliest ever, with a total cost of atleast $15.9B (2020’s cycle had a record breaking cost of $15.1B)
largely through independent expenditure by Super PACs and hybrid PACs
corporate political strategy
the activities taken by organizations to acquire, develop, and use power to obtain an advantage
poltical actions by businesses
information strategy
financial incentives strategy
constituency building strategy
information strategy
businesses seek to provide gov policymakers with information to influence their actions via lobbying
lobbying
direct communication
expert witness testimony
financial incentives strategy
businesses provide incentives to influence gov policymakers to act a certain way, like by supporting a political action committee that contributes to a campaign
poltical contributions
economic leverage
constituency building strategy
businesses seek support from other affected organizations to better influence gov policymakers to act in a way that helps them
stakeholder coalitions
advocacy advertising
public relations
legal challenges
lobbying laws
lobbying activites must be disclosed publicly
organizations employing lobbyists must register with the government
must file regular reports on lobbyist earnings and organizations expenses
must indicate the issues and legislation that were the focus of their efforts
revolving door phenomenon
circulation of individuals between business and government
lloyd austin
us army from 1975-2012, head of US forces in Iraq, then Army vice chief of staff
head of US central command
then on the boards of Nucor, Tenet, and United Tech.
United Tech merged with Raytheon Company to form Raytheon technologies
Raytheon was among top 5 lobbying spenders in defense, and spent ~$11M lobbying in 2020
Austin was earning 7 figures here
Austin also worked at Pine Island Capital partners, defense PE firm
in 2022, Austin became the first Black secretary of defense
problems with the revolving door
former corp execs might be favorable towards former employers
businesses can offer jobs to influence policy
PwC revolving door case
PwC client was trying to qualify for a tax break, former PwC employee was working for US treasury and drafting tax break qualifications
client got the qualification, former employee came back to PwC and made partner
harris fundraising
$81M in the first 24 hours after announcing bid
$11.5M in a single hour peak
$100M between sunday afternoon and monday evening
many donations were coming from large individual business donors
$310M in one month compared to Trump’s $138.7M in July
total $500M raised
Political Action Committees
independently incorporated organizations that solicit contributions and channel funds to candidates seeking office
multicandidate PACs allowed to give $5000 per candidate per election, $15000 per national party per calendar year
non-multicandidate PACs allowed $52000 per candidate per election and $41300 per party per year
prevalent in telecom, financial services, and defense industries
Super PACs
can accept unlimited contributions as long as they don’t donate directly to candidates, parties, or other PACs
still influence elections by spending on advertising or donating to other independent (but still poltically affiliated) organizations
Tax Exempt Organizations
527, 501c4, or 501c6
poltical campaign groups officially unaffiliated with individual parties and so not liable for campaign spending restrictions
527 groups can raise unlimited money for general political activities but can’t directly support or oppose a specific candidate
soft money
unlimited political contributions to a national political party to support party building activities
bipartisan campaign reform act
prohibited soft money, 527 organizations rose as a way to get around these restrictions
dark money
political contributions made to tax exempt organizations, not required to report donor name or size of contribution to the FEC
public issue
an issue of mutual concern to the business and its stakeholder(s)
result of performance expectation gap
performance expectation gap example
hidden fees vs. transparency
hotel industry was terrible about hidden “resort fees” for use of internet and pool
airlines also had hidden feestyp
types of public issues
strategic issues
political issues
social issues
strategic issues
internal and to normative issues, usually related to money and what to prioritize it for
touch lots of stakeholders, often including competitors
what led to a dip in kroger’s stock
Amazon acquired whole foods, making investors in Kroger very nervous because of Amazon’s impressive supply chain
kodak’s strategic failure
kodak highly focused on other film camera companies like fujifilm, forgot to consider innovation that led to digital camera companies rendering all film cameras basically obsolete
political issues
external issues that often transform into laws and regulations
like the $800 tow
market failure leads to performance expectations gap leads to political issues
Finnair example
the Asia Strategy, asian airlines could easily get to Helsinki, led to half of Finnair’s revenue
during Russia Ukraine war, Russian airspace was closed down and led to Finnair having to change their routes, led to them losing over $1b in 3 years
tariffs
used to be seen as almost always an economic tool
Trump uses tariffs as a bargaining tool or as leverage over other countries in a nontraditional manner, used them against Mexico and Canada (obv Canada not letting drugs through)
social issues
a result of cultural shift in how society sees things
measure of red tape
us in the top 5 overall
top 5 for quickness in days needed
not top 5 for number of procedures
network effect
the idea that softwares become more useful when more people use them
this is why operating software has a high barrier to entry
cadillac effect
the idea that if the government puts in a regulation saying that if you can only buy a cadillac, everyone is going to buy a cadillac even if they would be fine with a much cheaper car
for barbers, not everyone cares about dropping a ton of money for a nice barber, but they have to since no one else is allowed to give cuts
makes policymakers think of the balance between quality and safety that’s not going to serve as a barrier to entry and impartially benefit those who are already in
The Great Depression
the general perception was that financial markets at this time were underregulated
businesses were very lightly regulated, this is what people thought was the issue
led to the securities acts of 1933 and 1934
WW2
a period of high government regulation
wage and price controls, high levels of rationing on gas, butter, flour, etc.
post WW2
1950s
period of light gov regulation, but this was cyclical
in 1960s and early 1970s there was much more regulation (EPA, Civil Rights Acts, OSHA, Consumer Product Safety Act)
1970s-1990s - a period of DEREGULATION
mid 2000s+ - greater regulation of financial markets and scrutiny of internal corporate conduct
2007-2009 - global financial crisis let to increased regulatory response due to collapsing banks
hard for Obama to pass legislation due to divided government, so regulation was primarily accomplished via rulemaking (legislation from administrative agencies, can be changed)
Trump 1 - moderate deregulation
Biden - greater regulation but lack of control over congress
trump 2 - most significant era of deregulation in history, opposite of FDR (mass firing of regulators)
stages of public policy
input
goals
tools
effects
restaurant safety ratings
needs to improve - closed within the last year or needed multiple return inspections, not rated on a curve
okay - many red critical violations over last 4 inspections, 10% of restaurants per zip code
good - some red critical violations over last 4 inspections, 40% of restaurants per zip code
excellent - no or few red critical violations over last 4 inspections, 50% of restaurants in each zip code
types of policy tools
fines
incentives
taking away business licenses
informational tools
postmates sick leave settlement
$1M in back wages, interest, liquidated damages, and civil penalties + $20k in fines to Seattle
under Seattle’s Gig Worker Paid Sick and Safe Time (PSST) Ordinance
effects of policy
both intended and unintended
generally calculated through cost benefit analysis
minimum wage example - $1 increase in minimum wage led to 6.4% increase in overall health violations, 15.3% increase in less severe violations (blue risk factors), no red risk violations
why are tort laws sometimes an inadequate remedy
tort law - you sue somebody after they cause you harm, but only works if the person has money or insurance. if they have neither, you get nothing
take back laws
sometimes, there are laws in place to make people take things back
you pay $10 when you change your motor oil because companies must recycle your oil
entertainment software rating board
non profit, self regulatory body that assign ratings for video games based on age appropriateness, content, and interactive elements
helps ensure responsible web and mobile privacy practices among companies in its privacy online program
regulations against caveat emptor
consumers have some responsibility to think about their buying decisions, but a lot of times even the most prudent customers are left in the dark on some things, so companies are made to provide certain information that can influence this decision
guard rails
rules designed to protect the system when in a situation without those guard rails people would do things that are deemed bad for greater society but in their personal interest
ex. insider trading