1/28
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What are the strengths of a meta-analysis/systematic review?
summarize all data on the topic
increase power to look for association
reveal peculiarities of different studies
What are the weaknesses of a meta-analysis/systematic review?
time and effort
publication and reporting bias
garbage in, garbage out
What are the strengths of a RCT?
weigh the benefits/harms
minimize bias due to co-interventions (if blinded)
balance confounding at baseline
What are the weaknesses of a RCT?
time consuming
costly
not good for rare outcomes
What are the strengths of a before-after study?
evaluate effect of a discrete, widespread intervention or exposure
real world setting
What are the weaknesses of a before-after study?
lack of blinding (performance and detection bias are substantial risks)
non-concurrent control group creates risk of confounding by temporal trends
external control group
Use of an _____ ______ _____ allows for adjustment for secular and seasonal trends
secular trends are minimized by…
short time intervals
seasonal trends are minimized by…
timing measurement with seasons
What are the strengths of a before-after study (with the same people in the before and after groups)?
including everyone in the population is ideal (no sampling)
many variables (age, gender, race, etc) are the same before and after, reducing risk of confounding
What are the weaknesses of a before-after study (with the same people in the before and after groups)?
potential confounding by time (non-concurrent control)
change in variables over time (e.g. age)
unintentional learning can confound the association
regression to the mean can confound the association if participants were chosen based on extreme values
attrition bias is a risk
What are the strengths of a before-after study (with different people in the before and after groups)?
No risk of unintentional learning, regression to the mean, or attrition bias
What are the weaknesses of a before-after study (with different people in the before and after groups)?
If there is any sampling of the population in obtaining the before and after groups, selection bias is a risk
Lack of randomization, so confounders are not balanced at baseline
What are the strengths of a prospective cohort study?
establish time sequence
Allow assessment of predictors unbiased by knowledge of outcome (avoid recall bias)
Good for rare exposures
Can study several outcomes
What are the weaknesses of a prospective cohort study?
Unmeasured confounders
Costly & Inefficient
Often requires large N
Hard to assess rare outcomes
Loss to follow-up
What are the strengths of a retrospective cohort study?
Similar strengths to the prospective cohort
design.
Less expensive
Less time-consuming
What are the weaknesses of a retrospective cohort study?
Similar to prospective cohort (except they are not costly and inefficient)
limited control over choice, quality, completeness, and accuracy of variables
What are the strengths of a multiple cohort study?
Only feasible approach for studying rare exposure to occupational/environ hazard
Using data from census/registry as external control group is population based & economical
What are the weaknesses of a multiple cohort study?
Accentuate problem of confounding because cohorts are assembled from separate populations
What are the strengths of a case-control study?
useful for studying conditions with long latent periods (because everything has already happened at the start of the study)
need relatively small number of participants
can be good for hypothesis generation
What are the weaknesses of a case-control study?
At risk for confounding and differential biases depending on RQ and methods used to collect data
potential for survivor bias in studies in which subjects need to be alive to answer questions
potential for recall bias in studies in which the predictor variables are measured retrospectively
limited to one outcome variable
does not establish a sequence of events
What are the strengths of a nested case-control study?
advantages of a cohort design
can be less costly if measuring predictor would have been costly
avoid sampling and recall biases
What are the weaknesses of a nested case-control study?
need a pre-existing defined cohort
they can be subject to differential recall bias if one or more is assessed retrospectively
What are the strengths of a case crossover study?
same as case control
avoid effect-cause with time component, confounding, and selection bias by using the same person as their own control
What are the weaknesses of a case crossover study?
only for short-term effects of intermittent exposures
What are the strengths of a cross-sectional study?
fast; don’t need to wait for follow up
no loss to follow up (though can have issue of item non-response)
can be converted to cohort if time component is added (but the question will be different)
What are the weaknesses of a cross-sectional study?
no time component, so at risk for effect-cause
At risk for confounding and differential biases depending on RQ and methods used to collect data (e.g. recall bias, detection bias)
Risk for sample bias
What are the strengths of a case series/case report?
can generate hypothesis
can increase awareness
inexpensive
can be converted to a case-control with the addition of a control group
most often used for rare outcomes, but can be used for rare exposures (occupational or environmental) or new interventions (e.g. new surgical procedure)
What are the weaknesses of a case series/case report?
No control group
Not valid for cause-effect interpretation
Concerns are the greatest for case-series
which are evaluating an intervention
When used to establish cause-and-effect,
can result in false leads, scares, and
wasted resources