1/63
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What is Mental Imagery?
The ability to recreate the sensory world in absence of physical stimuli
Used to include ALL the senses: Auditory, Taste, Olfaction (smell) Tactile (touch)
What is Imagination?
The ability of the mind to be creative and resourceful, actively generating experiences, ideas, or concepts of external stimuli without their physical presence
What are the 4 functions of Mental Imagery?
Navigate
Planning
Decision Making
Memory
Dual Coding Theory (Paivio, 1964)
Brain uses two separate systems to process and store info
Verbal Code (text/words): Reading or hearing a word
Visual Code (mental images): Picture-based representations
Storing something using BOTH CODES creates a stronger memory
Paivio’s Paired-Associate Experiment
Participants studies pairs of words and were asked to remember which words went together
Encoding: study pairs of words
Concrete Words: Easy to picture
Abstract Words: Hard to picture
Conceptual Peg Hypothesis (Paivio, 1963)
Concrete nouns (House, Book, Bird, Car) create images that others words can “hang onto”
Abstract words like (integrity, truth, justice) don’t form clear visual images, no solid “peg” for the other word to hang onto.
Wilhelm Wundt early studies of imagery
Argued that thoughts occur with images
Thoughts CANNOT occur without images
Who is Francis Galton?
Used the method of “introspection”
Said people can still think even if they cannot form images
Thoughts CAN occur without images
What are the issues with this introspection approach?
Introspection failed to resolve the debate because self-reports are subjective, unobservable, and non-replicable.
Mental Chronometry (Shepard & Meltzer, 1971)
Chronometry = Time Measuring.
Researchers measured reaction times to see how long the brain takes to perform mental tasks.
Quantitative Methods
Mental Rotations (Shepard & Metzler, 1971)
A study of Visuo-Spatial Sketchpad & Mental Imagery
Varied complexity of each pair (Images rotated in different directions)
Measured reaction time in same/different task = Mental Chronometry
What were the Results of Mental Chronometry?
Greater Angle Rotation in the object
Evidence that people were able to mentally rotate images
(as they would with real objects)
Kosslyn (1973, 1978) Island Map Scanning: Findings
• Linear increase in RT: The greater the physical distance between landmarks, the longer participants took to respond.
• Shows the brain moves through mental space at a constant rate, preserving the map's spatial coordinates.
Kosslyn (1973, 1974, 1978) Object/Propeller Scanning: Findings
• Participants took significantly longer to verify details when scanning across the entire object than to a nearby feature
• Conclusion: Visual imagery is spatial in nature.
What is Spatial (Depictive) Representation Hypothesis (Kosslyn)?
• Brain creates an actual picture in the mind's eye.
• Mental imagery works like perception and is represented by spatial information.
What is Propositional Representation Hypothesis (Pylyshyn)?
• Brain does not store pictures; it stores abstract language, rules, and semantic-based representations (like a computer script/written list).
• Visual experience is merely a byproduct (epiphenomenon), not how the brain actually computes.
Define Propositions & Give Examples
Abstract, formal, symbolic statements (like lines of code) that capture relationship rules between objects rather than visual images.
• Examples: UNDER (CAT, TABLE), TOP (APPLE, LEAF), UNDER (SQUIRREL, TREE), and 3x + 9 = 20
Pylyshyn's "Tacit Knowledge" Argument
Argues participants in mental scanning studies aren't using visual images—they are unconsciously using tacit knowledge (learned real-world facts/rules) about spatial relations to mimic how long travel would take.
Finke & Pinker (1982): Procedure & Results
• Procedure: Showed 4 random dots, removed them, then flashed an arrow; participants judged if the arrow pointed to a previous dot.
• Results: Slower reaction time (RT) when the arrow was further from a dot.
Finke & Pinker (1982): Why use random dots?
• Eliminates tacit knowledge as an alternative explanation (no real-world rules apply to random dots, and participants weren't told to scan), proving mental scanning is naturally spatial and automatic.
Size in Visual Field (Kosslyn, 1975): Findings & Conclusion
• Smaller mental images (rabbit next to elephant) → Longer RTs to verify details
• Conclusion: Context changes mental image size, and differences in size are spatially represented in mental images (just like real perception).
The Perky Effect (1910): Procedure & Finding
• Procedure: Participants stared at a blank screen and imagined a common object (banana, leaf, tomato) while a very faint real picture of it was projected onto the screen.
• Finding: No one noticed the real image; it blended into their mental image, proving perception affects imagery without conscious awareness.
Letter Visualization Experiment (Farah, 1985)
• Demonstrates imagery affects perception.
• Congruent (imagine 'T', see 'T') better detection.
• Incongruent (imagine 'H', see 'T') worse detection
• Proves imagery and perception share overlapping brain areas (visual cortex).
Overall Conclusion of Imagery Studies
• Strong evidence supports the spatial nature of mental imagery
• Researchers use Reaction Time (RT) as the dependent variable to measure the time needed to "scan" or "travel" within a visualized scene.
Imagery Neurons: Kreiman et al. (2000)
• Single-cell recordings showed the exact same neurons that fired when looking at an object also fired when closing eyes and imagining that same object.
• Takeaway: Mental imagery and visual perception rely on overlapping neural representations.
fMRI Brain Imaging: LeBihan et al. (1993)
• Compared brain activity across 3 conditions: Perception (looking at stimulus), Imagery (imagining stimulus), and Baseline (no stimulus/no imagery).
• Result: Significant activation in the primary visual cortex during both perception and imagery (even with zero visual input).
PET Brain Imaging & Size: Kosslyn et al. (1995)
• Tested topographic organization of the visual cortex (organized like a physical map of what the eyes see).
• Imagining a small object activated a small area at the back of the occipital lobe; imagining a large object activated a much larger area extending further forward.
Category-Specific Imagery: O’Craven & Kanwisher (2000)
• Fusiform Face Area (FFA): Activated when seeing or imagining faces (without activating PPA).
• Parahippocampal Place Area (PPA): Activated when seeing or imagining places/landmarks (without activating FFA).
Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS): Kosslyn et al. (1999)
• TMS: Applies a magnetic field to temporarily disrupt or activate a brain region.
• Method & Result: Applying TMS to the visual cortex slowed reaction times during both perception (eyes open) and imagery (eyes closed) on 4-quadrant stripe grid questions, proving early visual areas are necessary for both.
Patient M.G.S. (Farah, 2000)
• Had her right occipital (visual) cortex removed.
• Mental Walk Test: Imagined walking closer to an animal until it overflowed her mental field.
• Removing part of the visual cortex shrank her mental visual field just like her real visual field, proving the visual cortex is critical for imagery.
Other Patient Cases: Color Loss & Unilateral Neglect
• Color Damage: Patients who lose color perception from brain damage also lose color in mental imagery.
• Unilateral Neglect (Hemineglect): Right parietal lobe damage causes patients to ignore the left half of both real visual space and mental imagery.
What is Aphantasia?
Condition where people have healthy eyesight and normal memory, but cannot generate any visual mental images ("mind blindness" / complete blackness).
Double Dissociation: Patient R.M.
(occipital/parietal damage): Can perceive and draw objects in front of him, but cannot draw from memory (Good perception / Poor imagery).
Double Dissociation: Patient C.K.
• visual agnosia
• Cannot recognize objects by sight, but can draw objects from memory (Poor perception / Good imagery).
How does Mental Imagery work for Blind People?
• Blind people can perform mental rotation and mental scanning with the same pattern as sighted controls (longer distance/angle → slower RT).
• Takeaway: Spatial mental imagery does not require visual experience; it can be built through other modalities like touch.
Conclusions About the Imagery Debate
• Imagery and perception share some mechanisms, but not all (brain activation is not complete)
• Key Differences: Perception is stable; imagery is fragile (needs continued refreshing) and harder to manipulate.
Functions of Mental Imagery: Memory Mnemonics
• Conceptual Peg: Concrete, high-imagery words (car, dog, book) are easier to remember than abstract words (freedom, truth, idea).
• Method of Loci: Uses spatial memory and imagination (placing items along a familiar mental route/location) to recall information easily.
Define Knowledge
• Explicit awareness of mentally available information about the exterior world and interior self gained through experience, organized for quick access.
Define Conceptual Knowledge
• Made up of all our concepts; enables us to recognize objects/events and make inferences and predictions.
Define Concepts
• Mental representations (stored in your head) of a class/individual, containing both feature and non-feature information (e.g., mental idea of a dog).
Define Categories
• The actual groups of objects that belong to the same class (e.g., houses, furniture).
Define Categorization
• The process of placing objects into categories so we understand the environment and take action.
Role of Non-Feature Based Similarity (Why computers struggle vs. humans)
• Physical features alone don't allow inferences/predictions. Humans rely heavily on non-feature similarity (meaning, function, causal theory, relational structure)
• Computers struggle because they only group by surface attributes ("looks").
How Different-Looking Items Group Together vs. Similar-Looking Items Split Apart
• Different-looking → Same category: Share function/concept (e.g., dollar bill, credit card, gold coin = currency; kangaroo pouch & baby backpack = carrying offspring)
• Similar-looking → Different categories: Differ in internal properties/origin (e.g., shark vs. dolphin = fish vs. mammal; real vs. counterfeit $100 bill).
Hierarchical Organization of Categories (3 Levels)
Superordinate (Global)
Basic
Subordinate (Specific)
What is the Superordinate (Global) level?
Highest, most abstract level; few shared features (~3); items look nothing alike (Furniture, Vehicles, Animal).
What is the Basic Level?
Main everyday type; used most in speech; recognized fastest (Chair, Shoes, Dog).
What is the Subordinate (specific) level?
EXACT brand/model/species; highest shared features (Golden Retriever, Nissan)
Why is the Basic Level of Categorization "Psychologically Special"?
• Going above it (to Superordinate) causes a large loss of information.
• Going below it (to Subordinate) yields little gain of information.
What is the Attribute/Entity Category?
Grouped ONLY by physical looks (banana, lemon, yellow tennis ball)
What is the Taxonomic Category?
Grouped by physical features + scientific/traditional class (apple, banana, orange = fruit)
What is the Thematic Category?
Appear together in the same event/story (leash, bowl, bone, collar)
What is the Relational/Role Category?
Play the EXACT SAME role/function
(key, passcode, fingerprint, keycard)
What is the Goal-Derived/Ad Hoc Category?
Created on the spot for a temporary goal
(things to grab in a house fire: passport, pet, laptop)
Physical Space vs. Psychological Space
• Physical distance = Psychological distance
things equally spaced physically can feel closer or further mentally).
What is Shepard’s Law of Generalization?
• The closer two items feel in psychological space, the more likely your brain assumes they work the same way and generalizes the same response to them.
• As psychological distance increases, generalization plummets.
What is Categorical Perception?
Brain warps continuous physical changes into discrete categories.
What is Within-Category Compression?
SAME = SAME DIFFERENCES
Even if physically different, our brain treats differences as non-existent.
What is Between-Category Expansion?
DIFFERENT CATEGORIES = EXPANDED DIFFERENCES
Two things fall into different categories, our brain expands the distance between them
What is Dunsmore & Murphy (Categorical Perception & Fear Conditioning) ?
• Participants saw varied circles (different sizes, colors, patterns) grouped into a category; one circle was paired with an electric shock.
• Result: Participants showed a fear response to ALL shapes in that group—proving categorization warps psychological space so previously different items feel psychologically similar.
What is Classic Definitional View? What is the Pros and Cons?
• An object belongs to a category only if it meets a strict checklist of defining features (e.g., chair = 4 legs, back, seat).
• Pros: Simple & efficient.
• Cons: Fails in real life because it doesn't allow variation (a 3-legged chair is still a chair; a hairless, non-barking dog is still a dog).
What is Wittgenstein (1953) & Family Resemblance?
• Solution to the Classic View: Category members don't need one single feature shared by everyone
They share an overlapping network of similar features (like family members sharing different combinations of a dad's nose, dad's eyes, and mom's skin tone), allowing variation.
What is Medin, Wattenmaker & Hampson (1987): Alien Figures Study?
• Procedure: Participants sorted 8 alien/bug figures (varying in head shape, body pattern, tail length, leg count) into 2 groups of 4.
• Expected vs. Actual Result: Researchers expected sorting by Family Resemblance, but most participants used Unidimensional Sorting—grouping based on one single trait
What is Unidimensional Sorting?
Grouped based on ONE single trait while ignoring all other features
ex. 4 legs vs. 8 legs