issues and debates 🤔

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/44

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

45 Terms

1
New cards

Define gender bias

Treating a person in a more or less favourable way based on their gender

2
New cards

Define alpha bias (gender)

When there is a misrepresentation of behaviour because researchers overestimate differences between men and women

3
New cards

Define beta bias (gender)

When there is a misrepresentation of behaviour because researchers underestimate or minimise differences between men and women

4
New cards

Define androcentrism

Refers to having a male-centred view of the world. Male behaviour is judged to be the norm, more acceptable and desirable

5
New cards

Define universality

Where a theory is thought to apply to all people in the same way despite any differences between gender or cultures

6
New cards

Give an example of alpha bias in terms of gender bias

Freud’s Theory of Personality


  • During the phallic stage (ages 4/5), girls overcome the Electra Complex (penis envy) and boys overcome the Oedipus Complex (castration anxiety) by identifying with their same-sex parent and internalising their moral views

  • Freud stated that girls do not identify with their mothers as strongly as boys identify with their fathers. Girls identify passively while boys identify actively.

  • The superego (morality principle) also develops during this stage.

  • If a girl’s identification is weaker, this means they will internalise a weaker set of morals


7
New cards

Give an example of beta bias in terms of gender bias

Fight or flight response


  • Early research into the fight or flight response used only male animals as they experienced fewer hormonal fluctuations and so changes in adrenaline, due to environmental stressors, can be more reliably measured

  • Results/conclusions drawn from this study were thought to be universal and generalised to males and females

  • However, later research by Taylor et al highlighted that women are more likely to exhibit a ‘tend and befriend’ response instead


8
New cards

Give an example of androcentrism in terms of gender bias

PMS has been criticised by some as being a social construction, which trivialises female emotion, particularly anger. On the other hand, male anger is seen as a logical response to external pressures (Brescoll and Uhlman)

9
New cards

Strengths of gender bias

  • Recognition of gender bias has contributed to the development of feminist psychology

    • This approach challenges androcentric assumptions within traditional psychology

    • Feminist psychologists have questioned whether theories and research have treated male behaviour as the norm and female behaviour as a deviation from it

    • Eagly (1978), for example, acknowledged that women may be less effective leaders in some circumstances but argued that this knowledge should be used to develop appropriate training and increase the representation of women in leadership

    • This demonstrates that recognising gender bias can allow psychology to challenge stereotypes rather than simply reproduce them.


  • Led to psychologists to recognise the importance of reflexivity in research

    • Researchers should consider how their own gender-related assumptions and expectations may influence the questions they ask, the way they conduct research and how they interpret their findings

    • This can help researchers identify potential sources of bias rather than assuming that psychological research is completely objective

    • A reflexive approach can therefore help to reduce gender bias within the research process


10
New cards

Limitations of gender bias

  • Another consequence is that psychologists need to be careful not to overcorrect for gender bias

    • Alpha bias can exaggerate differences between males and females, whereas beta bias can minimise or ignore genuine differences

    • Hare-Mustin and Marcek (1988) argued that beta bias can obscure women's specific needs, such as those associated with pregnancy, childbirth and parenting

    • Therefore, reducing gender bias does not necessarily mean treating males and females as identical; psychologists need to distinguish between socially constructed differences and meaningful differences



  • Gender bias can have wider social consequences because psychological research can influence expectations about the roles of men and women

    • For example, Bowly's theory of maternal deprivation placed particular importance on the mother's presence during a child's early development and linked prolonged separation from the mother with later emotional and behavioural difficulties

    • This could reinforce the expectation that mothers should remain at home to care for their children, while placing greater responsibility on mothers if children later develop difficulties

    • Therefore, gender-biased psychological research can reinforce traditional gender roles and contribute to social pressure on women, showing that the consequences of gender bias can extend beyond psychology itself


11
New cards

Define culture

The values, beliefs and patterns of behaviour shared by a group of people

12
New cards

Define culture bias

The tendency to judge people in terms of one’s cultural assumptions

13
New cards

Define ethnocentrism

Seeing the world only from one’s own cultural perspective, and believing that this one perspective is normal and correct

14
New cards

Define cultural relativism

The idea that behaviour can only be understood if the cultural context is taken into consideration

15
New cards

Give an example of alpha bias in terms of culture bias

Ainsworth’s Strange Situation

  • The ‘Strange Situation’ was developed and originally assessed in Westernised cultures by Mary Ainsworth, an American psychologist

  • It suggested that secure attachments are characterised by moderate stranger and separation anxiety

  • Therefore, German mothers, whose children showed little separation and stranger anxiety (thus being insecure-avoidant according to Ainsworth’s system), were deemed as cold and rejecting


16
New cards

Give examples of ethnocentrism/beta bias in terms of culture bias

IQ tests

  • The US army used IQ tests as a way to select recruits during WW1

  • These tests were culturally biased towards the dominant white majority, causing the results to show African-Americans at the bottom of the IQ scale

  • This led to incorrect and harmful stereotypes being formed against cultural minorities living in America, consequences of this are still around today


17
New cards

Give an example of cultural relativism in terms of culture bias

Milgram


  • Milgram’s study into obedience was originally conducted using 40 male American participants, but then also replicated using Spanish students (Miranda et al. found over 90% obedience rates in Spanish students) and Australian students (where only 16% of female participants continued to the highest voltage setting, as shown by Kilham and Mann)

  • This suggests that Milgram’s original results were specifically bound to American cultures


18
New cards

Smith and Bond (1998)

  • Surveyed European textbooks on social psychology

  • Found that 66% of the studies were American, 32% European and only 2% from the rest of the world


19
New cards

Define etic

An etic approach looks at behaviour from outside of a given culture and attempts to describe those behaviours as universal

20
New cards

Define imposed etic

When a researcher assumes a theory or concept developed in one culture applies universally to all others

21
New cards

Give an example of an imposed etic

Ainsworth’s Strange Situation

22
New cards

Define emic approach

Looks at behaviour from inside of a given culture and identifies behaviours that are specific to that culture

23
New cards

Strengths of culture bias

  • Not all psychological behaviour is necessarily culture-bound

    • Ekman et al. (1969) found evidence that people from different cultures could recognise basic facial expressions of emotion, supporting the idea that some emotional expressions have universal features

    • This suggests that psychologists need to consider both universal behaviours and cultural differences rather than assuming that all behaviour is either completely universal or completely culture-specific


  • Greater awareness of cultural bias has led psychologists to consider cultural context more carefully when understanding mental health

    • The DSM has added the CFI (Cultural Formulation Interview) to account for how mental health problems may be experienced and expressed differently across cultures

    • For example, Black men in the UK have experienced disproportionately high rates of psychosis diagnoses, so clinicians need to consider whether differences in diagnosis may be influenced by social and cultural factors, rather than assuming they are biological.

    • The CFI encourages clinicians to explore how a person understands and experiences their difficulties, including whether experiences such as hearing voices have a spiritual or culturally accepted meaning

    • This can help clinicians decide whether an experience actually represents a symptom of mental disorder and reduce the risk of culturally biased diagnosis


24
New cards

Limitations of culture bias

  • Psychological research may be culturally biased because it relies heavily on WEIRD populations, Western, Educated, Industrialised, Rich and Democratic

    • Heinrich et al. (2010) highlighted that countries representing only around 12% of the world's population provided 96% of psychological research participants in an analysis of major psychology journals. 68% of participants came from the US alone

    • This shows how heavily psychology has relied on a relatively narrow range of cultures, meaning findings may be generalised to people from other cultures even when their values, experiences and behaviour differ

    • As a result, psychology may develop explanations that appear universal but are actually culturally specific


  • Cultural bias can have serious social consequences when research is used to make judgements about different cultural or ethnic groups

    • E.g. US Army intelligence tests included questions that were more familiar to people from American culture. European immigrants scored slightly lower than white Americans, while African-American recruits had the lowest average scores

    • Gould (1981) argued that these results were interpreted as evidence that some ethnic groups were less intelligent, rather than considering the cultural bias of the tests

    • This could reinforce stereotypes and discrimination, showing that culturally biased psychological research can influence how groups are treated in wider society


25
New cards

Culture Bias: Heinrich et al. (2010)

  • Highlighted that countries representing only around 12% of the world's population provided 96% of psychological research participants in an analysis of major psychology journals.

  • 68% of participants came from the US alone


26
New cards

What does WEIRD stand for?

  • Western

  • Educated

  • Industrialised

  • Rich

  • Democratic


27
New cards

Define soft determinism

Human behaviour is determined, but we have the opportunity to exercise free will if need be

28
New cards

Define free will

We have the ability to behave in the way we want - our actions are voluntary and we have freedom of choice

29
New cards

Define hard determinism

We have no control or choice on our course of action

30
New cards

What are the different determinants of behaviour?

  • Biological determinism

  • Environmental determinism

  • Psychic determinism


31
New cards

Define biological determinism

The belief that our physical and mental behaviour is shaped by biological influences that we cannot control


  • Genes influence brain structure and neurotransmitters, such as serotonin and dopamine, are often implicated in behaviour


32
New cards

Define environmental determinism

The belief that behaviour is shaped by features of our environment (stimulus-response) that we cannot control

33
New cards

Define psychic determinism

The belief that behaviour is shaped or caused by unconscious psychodynamic conflicts that we cannot control

34
New cards

Examples of biological determinism

  • Localisation of function

  • Biological explanation of OCD


35
New cards

Example of environmental determinism

  • Learning theory (attachment)


  • Watson and Raynor (1920) demonstrated how a fear response could be conditioned in Little Albert


36
New cards

Example of psychic determinism

Freud's psychosexual theory

  • Suggests that unresolved conflicts during childhood can lead to fixation, which may influence adult personality

  • For example, fixation at the anal stage was proposed to produce an anal personality


37
New cards

Why is there scientific emphasis on casual explanations?

Science aims to identify causes of behaviour so that psychologists can understand, predict and potentially change behaviour

  • For example, if research shows that learning experiences contribute to the development of a phobia, psychologists can use this knowledge to understand how the phobia developed and develop treatments to reduce it.


38
New cards

Does scientific emphasis on casual explanations fit with free will or determinism?


Determinism


39
New cards

Why is scientific emphasis on casual explanations important?

  • Psychologists can use controlled experiments to manipulate one factor and measure its effect on behaviour, allowing them to investigate cause-and-effect relationships

  • If the same findings can be replicated, there is greater confidence that the relationship is genuine rather than the result of chance or other factors


40
New cards

Strength of free will

  • The concept of free will can have useful practical applications

    • If people believe they have control over their own behaviour, they are more likely to see themselves as responsible for their actions and believe they can change their behaviour

    • For example, this can encourage people to take responsibility for unhealthy behaviours and make changes to improve their lives

    • This suggests that even if behaviour is partly influenced by deterministic factors, the belief in personal choice and control can have positive consequences, supporting the value of free will as a psychological concept


41
New cards

Limitations of free will

  • Difficult to test scientifically

    • Free will assumes that people can make independent choices that are not determined by previous causes

    • However, if a decision is genuinely free, it is difficult to identify or measure what caused the decision and therefore difficult to objectively test or predict it

    • This is a limitation because psychological explanations are expected to be testable and supported by empirical evidence

    • Therefore, free will may be difficult to investigate scientifically compared with deterministic explanations, which can identify and test possible causes of behaviour



  • Not supported by neurological evidence

    • For example, Soon et al (2008) found that the brain activity related to the decision to press a button with the left or right hand occurs up to 10 seconds before participants report being consciously aware of making the decision

    • This suggests that even our most basic experiences of free will are decided and determined by our brain before we become aware of them

    • Therefore, this research supports biological determinism and refutes free will


42
New cards

Strengths of determinism

  • Consistent with the aims of science

    • The notion that human behaviour is orderly and obeys laws, places psychology on equal footing with other more established sciences increasing its credibility

    • The prediction and control of human behaviour has led to the development of treatments and therapies, such as drug treatments for depression

    • This suggests the experience of mental illnesses like depression is somewhat biologically determined as no one chooses to have depression

    • Therefore, being biologically determined means it can be treated as a casual relationship, supporting the aims of science


43
New cards

Limitations of determinism

  • Determinism may oversimplify complex human behaviour

    • MZ twin studies rarely show 100% concordance, suggesting that genes do not completely determine behaviour

    • For example, studies have found around 80% similarity for intelligence and 40% concordance for depression in MZ twins

    • If genes were the only determining factor, MZ twins would be expected to show almost identical outcomes. Instead, differences between twins suggest that behaviour is influenced by many interacting factors, including biological, cognitive, emotional and environmental influences

    • Therefore, reducing behaviour to a single determining cause may provide an incomplete explanation of human behaviour



  • Hard determinism creates difficulties for the idea of free will and moral responsibility

    • If behaviour is completely determined by biological or environmental causes, individuals could argue that they could not have acted differently

    • This creates difficulties for systems such as the justice system, which generally holds people responsible for their actions. If people are viewed as having no control over their behaviour, it becomes difficult to justify moral responsibility and punishment

    • This raises an important question about whether people should be held responsible for actions that were determined by factors outside their control


44
New cards

Strengths of nature/nurture debate

  • The nature-nurture debate should be viewed as an interaction rather than a choice between two separate explanations

    • MZ twins have very similar genes, yet concordance rates for behaviour and psychological disorders are rarely 100%

    • This suggests that nature alone cannot explain behaviour, while differences between individuals' experiences also show that nurture cannot be considered in isolation

    • The diathesis-stress model supports this view by suggesting that a biological vulnerability may only lead to a disorder when combined with an environmental stressor

    • Therefore, behaviour is best understood as the result of nature and nurture working together.



  • Nurture can influence nature, showing that the two cannot be separated

    • Experiences and learning can cause physical changes in the brain, meaning that environmental influences can affect biological characteristics

    • Maguire et al. (2000), for example, found that London taxi drivers had a larger volume of grey matter in the hippocampus, with greater changes associated with longer experience as a taxi driver

    • This suggests that environmental experience can influence biological development, supporting the interactionist view



  • Epigenetics provides further evidence that nature and nurture interact. Epigenetics refers to changes that affect how genes are expressed without changing the DNA itself

    • Environmental experiences, such as stress, diet or childhood experiences, can influence whether certain genes are switched on or off. This means that having a particular gene does not automatically mean that a particular behaviour or characteristic will develop

    • For example, two people may have very similar genes but develop differently because their experiences affect how those genes are expressed

    • Therefore, epigenetics shows that nature provides biological potential, while nurture can influence how that potential is expressed, supporting the view that nature and nurture cannot be considered separately


45
New cards

Example of the diathesis-stress model

  • A person may inherit gene variants associated with an increased vulnerability to
    OCD, such as variants of the SERT or COMT genes, from a parent who carries them.

  • However, this genetic vulnerability does not mean that the person will definitely develop OCD.

  • An environmental experience, such as serious illness, an accident or loss within the family, may create intense anxiety and a fear that something bad will happen

  • In response to this anxiety, the person may develop repetitive behaviours, such as checking, washing or seeking reassurance, to try to reduce their anxiety.

  • If they already have a genetic vulnerability to OCD, these environmental experiences may contribute to the development of the disorder.

  • This demonstrates how inherited biological factors and environmental experiences can interact to influence behaviour.