1/15
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Roadmap
Overall conclusion directly answering client’s legal issue.
Necessary background information and explanation of general governing rules (lens/filter and umbrella rule).
Dispose of uncontroversial elements
Preview analysis, including a conclusion and a brief reason for each CREACC or CRAC.
Restate conclusion within the procedural context (i.e., the lens/filter).
Point heading
Complete sentence
Typically 10–35 words
Include a conclusion and a reason
Capitalize normally
Single-spaced
Follow with opening sentence that restates conclusion in slightly different terms
Conclusion
One-sentence prediction of issue/element
Rules
If statute → Break into elements or factors.
Elements → Each must be met.
Factors → Several things to weigh.
If no statute → Find where cases describe the overall rule that applies.
Identify element rules.
When or how is each element or factor met?
Sometimes defined in statute; more often fleshed out in cases.
Rule Cluster
Use binding law (if possible).
Try to use every case that will be illustrated in Explanation.
Distill requirements of the statute (if any) or cases.
Quote key language.
Use present tense.
Cite after every sentence.
Rule cluster should resemble a funnel (broad rule → narrower, more specific principles or sub-rules).
Explanation of the Rule
Hook
Trigger facts
Reasoning
Holding
Hook
State legal principle in present tense (usually restatement of sub-rule).
Tell reader why she is reading and what’s coming.
Center on legal principles; avoid starting with facts and starting with dates.
Trigger facts
What facts did court rely on in reaching its holding?
What facts can I compare/contrast with my client’s case?
Party names are typically not relevant and can be distracting—use litigation roles or generic nouns instead.
Reasoning
What was the rationale for the court’s holding?
Holding
What was the procedural posture?
How did court rule on the issue before it?
Analysis
Start with opening that tells the reader the point the analysis will prove.
Compare facts to establish a similarity to or a distinction from a prior case.
No new legal information or cases.
Describe the relevant facts of your case in concrete detail.
Decide which trigger facts from the prior case illustration to restate.
When constructing sentences, compare facts to facts, cases to cases, parties to parties, etc.
Use buzz words
Comparison buzz words: Like, similarly, as in, here, so too here
Distinction buzz words: Unlike, although, whereas, by contrast, but, despite, instead, yet
Don’t fixate on isolated facts; compare totalities instead (i.e., how all the facts in your case measure up to all the facts in a prior case). If your case is stronger, say so.
Explain legal consequence of similarity or distinction (i.e., why comparison matters).
Sources of counteranalysis
Facts → Is there a plausible argument that my client’s case is factually more similar than I thought to one of my disanalogous authorities?
Law → Could a court plausibly read the law differently than I have?
Might a court conclude a case stands for a different proposition than the one I have stated?
Might a court rely on a different line of authority?
Might a court choose the other side in a split of authority?
Unknowns → Are there outstanding questions or follow-up items that could affect the strength of my prediction?
When should I use rule-based reasoning?
The rule is crystal clear.
There is no authority you can use to illustrate the rule.
Which cases should I illustrate?
Only illustrate cases that analyze the issue in question
Cases from the governing jurisdiction
Factually analogous and meaningfully distinguishable cases
Choose a “yes” case (i.e., element/factor/other standard was satisfied)
Choose a “no” case (i.e., element/factor/other standard was satisfied)
Punctuation rules for quotes
Periods and commas go inside
Semicolons and colons go outside
Question marks and exclamation marks go inside only if they are part of the quoted matter
Mark all textual alterations and omissions with brackets or ellipses.
When to capitalize court
When referring to SCOTUS
When referring to the highest court in the jurisdiction (e.g., SCOTX)
When referring to the court you’re currently in
When stating a court’s full name