1/17
Flashcards covering trustee powers of maintenance (income, TA 1925 s 31) and advancement (capital, TA 1925 s 32), statutory vs. express powers, and key application rules.
What is the primary starting point when assessing trustee powers of maintenance and advancement?
Check the declaration of trust first, as express provisions prevail and the settlor can modify or exclude statutory powers.
As a general starting rule, are trustee powers of maintenance and advancement considered powers or duties?
Both are powers, not duties; trustees have discretion and beneficiaries cannot compel them (subject to the duty under TA 1925 s 31 for adult contingent interests).
Which statutory provision governs the maintenance of beneficiaries out of trust income?
TA 1925 s 31.
Under TA 1925 s 31, what power do trustees have regarding income for minor beneficiaries (under 18)?
Trustees may apply income for maintenance, education, or benefit if the beneficiary has an interest in income (vested or contingent) and there is no prior interest (e.g., a life tenant).
Why must trustees pay a third party (such as a parent or school) rather than the minor beneficiary when applying income under s 31?
Because a minor cannot give a good receipt.
What happens to trust income for a minor if it is not applied for maintenance under TA 1925 s 31?
The income is accumulated and goes with the capital when the beneficiary becomes entitled.
How does the trustees' obligation regarding income under TA 1925 s 31 change when a contingent beneficiary turns 18?
Trustees must pay income as it arises until the interest vests; it becomes a duty rather than a discretion (e.g., in Ulrika's case, a power until 18, and a duty from 18 to 25).
If an adult beneficiary with a contingent interest dies before the condition is met, what happens to the trust capital and prior income paid?
The estate receives nothing (no capital and no accumulations), and income already paid cannot be reclaimed.
Which statutory provision governs the advancement of trust capital?
TA 1925 s 32.
What type of interest must a beneficiary hold to be eligible for advancement under TA 1925 s 32?
An interest in capital (vested or contingent); a life tenant has none.
What constitutes an advancement or benefit under TA 1925 s 32, and what restriction was highlighted in Re Pauling?
It must improve the beneficiary's material situation, not leisure or hobbies (e.g., a jet ski is not allowed), and under Re Pauling, it must not solely benefit someone else.
What is the maximum statutory capital advancement permitted for trusts created before 1 Oct 2014 compared to those created on or after 1 Oct 2014?
For trusts from 1 Oct 2014, up to the full presumptive share; for trusts before that date, up to half of the presumptive share.
From what event is the date of a will trust calculated for the 1 Oct 2014 advancement threshold?
A will trust counts from the date of death, not the date of signing.
What does bringing an advance into account (hotchpot) mean under TA 1925 s 32, and what happens if the beneficiary dies early?
The advance is brought into account against the beneficiary's share later, and it is not repaid if the beneficiary dies early.
Whose consent is required for an advancement under TA 1925 s 32 if there is a prior interest, such as a life tenant?
The prior interest holder's written consent is needed, and that person must be an adult.
Do beneficiaries with equal-ranking interests (such as Dianne and Elma) need consent from each other for an advancement?
No, equal-ranking interests need no consent from each other.
If a beneficiary requests an advancement of £80,000 from a £100,000 presumptive share under a pre-2014 trust, what is the maximum amount the trustees can advance?
Max £50,000 (up to half the presumptive share).
In exam scenarios asking 'Must the trustees pay?' regarding maintenance or advancement, what is the general answer?
It is almost always no, with the exception of an adult beneficiary with a contingent interest entitled to income as it arises under TA 1925 s 31.