1/42
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Psychological explanations: Schizophrenogenic mothers (Reichman 1948)
referred to a woman who was blamed by psychiatrists for her Childs Schizophrenia due to her being cold, rejecting and controlling towards the child
this created tension and secrecy which lead to distrust
eventually leading to the child developing paranoid delusions
why does this lack temporal validity?
created at the time of the ‘nuclear family’
at the time the mother was the one at home looking after the kids and so were then viewed as the case if the illness due to their ‘poor parenting skills’
3 characteristics of dysfunctional family (child parent rs)
high levels of interpersonal conflict
difficulty communicating with each other
being excessively critical and controlling of their children
what is Double-bind (Bateson et al 1972)
symptoms of SZ are an expression of contradictory patterns of interaction in the family
the developing child finds themself where they fear doing the wrong thing but receive mixed messages about what the “wrong thing” is and feel unable to comment on the unfairness of the situation
if they were to get it wrong the child would be punished by withdrawal of love (conditional love)
this can lead to symptoms such as?
disordered thinking
paranoid delusions
flat effect (lack of emotional expression)
delusions of persecution: statements make patients doubt what people really think of them, leading to the delusions + avolition
what are expressed emotions within a family?
its the level of emotion, in particular negative emotion, expressed towards a patient by their family/carers
verbal criticism
hostility towards patient
emotional over involvement in patients life (needless self sacrifice)
why might this lead top relapse for SZ patients?
when returning to their families upon recovering, the hostile environment can cause stress and trigger them to relapse and experience severe positive symptoms
limitation of SZ mother
it lacks temporal validity, it was developed in 1948 and does not stand the test of time. developed in the time of the ‘nucleus family’, a family with one boy one girl, a bread winner working father and a housewife. Due to the mother being the one at home at the time, she was blames by psychiatrists for her Childs SZ or any other poor wellbeing. these findings do not accurately reflect the experience of modern day families, these roles rarely exist now and the mother and father are both able to work, while both simultaneously looking after the children, the oncoming of SZ could be a result of other parent, not just mother
Psychological treatments: CBT, what is it based on
the cognitive approach, which suggests that the abnormal behaviour seen in schizophrenics is a result of underlying cognitive deficits and abnormal/irrational belief systems
what is the aim of CBT
to identify a schizophrenics irrational beliefs, demonstrate that they are in fact irrational and then help them restructure their belief systems into something more rational, it helps the patients understand their symptoms
what should this lead to and why?
effective behaviour change
CBT includes a behavioural element
a therapist teaches a client behaviours which can be used in the real world should they experience SZ symptoms in the future
this should be effective at treating the symptoms immediately and also prevent relapse long term
stage 1 of CBT
identification of irrational beliefs
what does this include?
first client works with therapist to establish therapeutic alliance, this is key of the client will not accept that their beliefs are irrational, not accepting suggestions \
therapist will help identify irrational thoughts and link these to abnormal behaviour
therapist may ask client too keep diary in which they identify situations when their symptoms appear
they also records their thoughts and beliefs at the time of the symptoms
helps a client identify irrational beliefs and highlighting how they led to the irrational behaviours
stage 2 of CBT
disputing and challenging beliefs
what does this include?
disputing irrational beliefs: the therapist challenges thoughts by asking questions, like “where is the evidence that you have to be good a everything?” this encourages clients to think more rationally
challenging beliefs logically: the therapists helps the client realise that their beliefs may be illogical or unrealistic. e.g that making a mistake does not mean they are a failure
stage 3 of CBT
restructuring beliefs and development of behavioural skills
what does this include
client and the therapist work together to restructure their beliefs into a more rational form
the client should take ownership of this stage this will ensure they feel confident using their new belief system in the future
behavioural skills?
Coping strategies: A patient who hears voices learns to distract themselves by listening to music or talking to someone, helping them cope with auditory hallucinations.
Reality testing: A patient who believes they are being watched is encouraged to examine evidence for and against this belief, helping them question their delusions.
Stress management: A patient learns relaxation techniques to manage stress, as stress can worsen symptoms of schizophrenia.
Social skills training: A patient practises starting conversations and maintaining eye contact to improve social functioning and reduce isolation.
Relapse prevention: A patient learns to recognise early warning signs, such as disturbed sleep or increased suspiciousness, and seeks help before symptoms worsen.
stage 4 of CBT
application
what does this include
client practises applying their new belief system and any behavioural strategies they have been offered
initially done through role play within therapeutic environment
once the client os comfortable with their new beliefs and behaviours they will be set homework to apply these in the real world
strength of CBT - more effective long term
could be more effective long term because it arguably deals with the psychological root cause of schizophrenia. unlike anti-psychotics, which control symptoms but does not treat the root cause of SZ, CBT targets the root cause of the disorder, resulting in sustained symptom reduction and lower long term relapse rates compares to drug therapy alone. this means that CBT is likely to more effective in the long term.
limitation of CBT - ethical grounds
can be argued it is not an appropriate treatment for SZ because it is very confrontational. this may cause distress and resistance. in addition identifying the root cause of clients irrational thoughts may be traumatic for the client as it may bring back stressful memories. pushing these vulnerable patients to engage in intense testing when they lack emotional stability raises ethical concerns to do with protection from psychological harm and informed consent.
Another strength - range of evidence that it is effective for SZ
range of evidence which demonstrates that CBT is an effective treatment for SZ. Pilling (2002) compared standard care and CBT as treatments for SZ. he found clients who were on CBT showed significantly better improvement compared to those on standard care and also that clients on CBT demonstrated lower relapse rates. this suggests that CBT is an effective treatment for SZ compared to standard psychological care.
another weakness - cannot be used for all patients of SZ
some individuals have such severe symptoms, that they cannot engage in therapy. CBT requires active reflection, motivation and concentration. patients with severe symptoms are usually too disoriented to engage with therapeutic techniques. this suggests that CBT may not be appropriate for all SZ patients, which means maybe antipsychotics would be more effective.
CSE - form of CBT
coping strategy enhancement
what are the two types?
cognitive strategies
behavioural strategies
what are cognitive strategies?
distractions from intrusive thoughts, challenging the meaning of them and positive self talk
what are behavioural strategies?
relaxation techniques, increasing/decreasing social activity to distract from low moods
who devised this and what did it focus on?
tarrier et al 2000, it focuses on building SZ patients existing coping strategies and the corresponding stress from the symptoms
what did he note that strengthened the explanation of CBT?
that patients were able to identify triggers for SZ episodes and devised their own coping strategies
Family Therapy
psychological therapy which involves all or some members of a family with the aim of improving their communication and reducing the stress of living as a family
how and what do they aim to do?
they want to alter the relationship and communication patterns, especially levels of expressed emotion to help the SZ patient recover
increase tolerance level/decrease criticism
improve positive form of communication
decrease feelings of guilt + responsibility for causing the illness
what is it based on the idea of?
that family dysfunction can play a role in the development of SZ
limitation of family therapy - environmental determinism (biological factors)
it assumes SZ is mainly caused by family dysfunction, as seen in really work in Turkington (1985). This explanation ignores strong empirical evidence for biological mechanisms, such as polygenic genetic vulnerability, dopamine, and structural neural correlates, rendering the approach environmentally reductionist and incomplete. therefore family therapy cannot fully explain or treat SZ when biological causes play a major role
strength - evidence supporting effectiveness (Pharoah)
Evidence supporting effectiveness
Pharoah et al. (2010) conducted a Cochrane review of family intervention for schizophrenia.
They found that family intervention reduced relapse rates and hospital admissions compared with standard care.
This is a strength because it suggests family therapy is an effective treatment for schizophrenia, helping patients maintain their recovery and reducing the burden on mental health services.
interactionist approach: diathesis-stress model
broad way of looking at behaviour, acknowledges range of factors involved in the onset of SZ including biological, psychological and societal factors
background of the model and Meehls original model (1962)
entirely genetic, result of a single schizogeny, extremely sensitive to stress
chronic stress in someone with the gene could lead to the development of the disorder (nature + nurture)
led to a biologically based SZ personality
claimed that no amount of stress would lead to SZ if the gene wasn’t present
modern diathesis + understanding
no longer thought to be a single gene, its polygenic (ripke et al 2014)
factors beyond genetics (psychological trauma, effects development of brain + becomes trauma)
Read et al (2001) proposed a neuro developmental model in which early trauma alters the developing brain, making an individual more venerable to stress later on
modern stress + understanding
anything that risks triggering SZ (rather than just psychological effects from poor parenting)
stress from sources like drugs (cannabis interferes with the dopamine system)
research to support: cannon et al (2002) - birth complications
found a positive correlation between birth complications and a later vulnerability to developing SZ
biological vulnerabilities interact with later stresses, that may trigger the disorder
Barlow + Durand (2009) - family history
reported that family history of SZ indicating a genetic link coupled with being part of a dysfunctional stressor elevated the risk of SZ
supports the diathesis stress model with the diathesis being the genetic tendency and the stress being the dysfunctional family
walker (1997) - cortisol
reported that SZ’s have higher levels of cortisol, related to severity of their symptoms
stress related: increases in cortisol level heighten genetically influenced abnormalities in dopamine transmission that underpin vulnerability to SZ
strength of interactionist approach using research (Barlow and Durand)
one strength of the interactionist approach and the diathesis model is the research support. Barlow and Durand (2009) reported that a family history of SZ indicates a genetic link coupled with being part of a dysfunctional stressor elevated the risk of developing SZ. this shows the interaction between nature and nurture and supports the diathesis stress model. this backs up the model showing us that SZ is interactionist.