1/29
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Donoghue v stevenson
Tort law case that establishes the existence of common duty of care. Duty that exists to anyone anticipated to be affected.
Caparo v dickman
Established the three part test to prove if there is a duty of care due.
Foreseeability
Proximity
Reasonable
Robinson v CC of West Yorkshire police [2018]
No "Blanket Immunity": Dispelled the myth that police are immune from negligence claims. They are liable if their positive acts directly cause foreseeable physical harm to bystanders.
Equality Principle: Police are subject to the same ordinary laws of negligence as private (members of the public+private businesses) citizens.( Public would be government and its agencies.)
Caparo Clarified: The Caparo 3-stage test ("fair, just, and reasonable") should ONLY be used in novel situations, not automatically applied to every negligence case.
Montgomery v Lanarkshire 2015
The ruling that transferred power of medical choice away from doctors to patients. The test now being, would the specific risk actually matter to the patient when making their choice?
Vicarious liability
when the employer is legally liable over the employees fault.
Distinction between “unauthorized mode”
And a “frolic of ones own”
An employer IS liable if an employee performs an authorized
task in a forbidden or negligent manner (unauthorized mode),
but NOT liable if the employee acts completely outside their job scope (a frolic).
Employers right to indemnity
An employer held vicariously liable has a legal right under contract to claim a 100% indemnity (reimbursement) from the negligent employee who breached their implied duty of care.
Bolam test
Outdated medical negligence test changed in 2015
Page v smith 1996
Primary victim test (case) for psychiatric injury that proved if there can be an established duty of care it does not matter if the injury is physical or psychiatric, as long as physical injury was foreseeable, defendant remains liable.
Alcock v chief constable of south yorkshire
Test (case) for proximity element secondary victims of psychiatric injury.
Football stadium incident.
Established a three part test
1.proximity of relationship
Proximity in time and space
Proximity of perception
What is the sudden ‘shock’ requirement?
There must be a sudden assault on the nervous system and then develop into a sustained mental issue. Cannot start developing ages after the incident. (Not 100% necessary but the general rule)
Immediate aftermath
Witnessing the incident or visiting loved one in hospital is enough to constitute psychiatric injury.
Proximity of perception
Claimant must have witnessed incident with owns unaided senses.
Proximity in time and space
Proximity in time and space requires a claimant suffering psychiatric harm as a secondary victim to be physically present at the scene of the negligent incident or witness its immediate aftermath close in time to when it occurred.
Proximity of relationship
Claimant needs to show close ties of love and affection. This is a sliding scale some relationships are near automatic others require a-lot of evidence.
Pure economic loss
Loss that is purely financial not stemming from personal injury or damage to property. Essentially money that is yet to be made.
Spartan steel v martin
Claimant wanted money for the raw material lost, the profit of the material if it was sold, and lastly general business downtime losses (pure economic loss)
Courts decided that pure economic loss cannot be recoverable as a general rule because it is too remote and imposes crushing liability on defendants.
Hedley byrne v heller
(To note: unfair contract terms section 11 would now favour the claimaint because writing a disclaimer would be ineffective)
Chaudhry v prabhakar
Gratuitous advice + claimed skill = duty owed. Even without payment, a friend professing specialist expertise owes a duty of care when giving advice they know will be relied upon in a serious purchase (e.g., buying a car).
Smith v Bush
Duty owed to ordinary homebuyers. A mortgage lender's surveyor owes a duty of care to a residential buyer where it is highly likely the buyer will rely on the valuation without getting an independent survey (and blanket disclaimers fail UCTA 1977).
White v jones
A solicitor preparing a will owes a duty of care to the intended beneficiaries—if the solicitor's delay stops the will being signed before the client dies, the beneficiaries can sue for their lost inheritance.
Caparo v dickman in relation to pure economic loss
No duty for general-purpose statements. For negligent misstatements, proximity requires that the defendant knew the statement would reach the claimant (or an identifiable class) for a specific transaction and be relied upon. Statutory audits are for shareholder governance, not individual takeover bids.
Playboy v bnl
No duty to an undisclosed principal. A bank giving a credit reference strictly to an intermediary company owes no duty to the hidden principal behind it—you cannot assume responsibility to someone whose existence you do not know.
Barry congregation v BXB
Restated the two-stage test for vicarious liability and held that mere opportunity to commit a tort (access gained through a role) is not enough—the wrongful act must be closely tied to the person's authorised duties, not a personal friendship, ie the wrongdoing had to be purely because of the immediate connection from work.
Strict liability
Legal liability imposed on a defendant for harm or damage without needing to prove fault, negligence, or intention—even if they took all reasonable care.
Barclays v various claimants
Armes c Nottinghamshire county council
Mersey docks v coggins
Viasystems v thermal transfer
Lister v hesley hall