1/173
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Physician-patient contractual relationship
What constitutes the fundamental legal and ethical anchor of medical practice under Philippine jurisprudence?
Article 1305 of the New Civil Code
Which legal provision defines a contract as a meeting of the minds between two persons whereby one binds himself to give something or render a service?
When the patient solicits medical evaluation or treatment and the physician agrees to render healthcare services
Under Article 1305, when is a physician-patient contract formed in clinical practice?
Consensual
Which legal attribute of the physician-patient relationship indicates that it is perfected by mere consent?
Article 1319 of the New Civil Code
Which article establishes that a contract is perfected by mere consent (consensus ad idem)?
At the exact moment there is a concurrence of offer and acceptance regarding the object and the cause or consideration
Under Article 1319, when does contractual perfection occur in medicine?
Medical service
What serves as the object or subject matter in the perfection of a physician-patient contract?
Professional fee or act of liberality
What serves as the cause or consideration in the perfection of a physician-patient contract?
Fiduciary
Which legal attribute of the physician-patient relationship is derived from the Latin word meaning trust or confidence?
Mutual trust
In what principle is the fiduciary nature of the physician-patient relationship anchored?
Preserving confidentiality
What strict legal and ethical duty is imposed on a physician because accurate diagnosis requires disclosure of sensitive information?
Rule 130, Section 24(c) of the Revised Rules on Evidence / Rules of Court
Which statutory rule protects the physician-patient relationship under the rule on privileged communication?
Hippocratic Oath
Which ethical document reinforces confidentiality by declaring that whatever is seen or heard in connection with professional practice which ought not to be spoken abroad shall not be divulged?
Garcia-Rueda vs. Pascasio
Which Supreme Court case established that a physician impliedly represents possessing extraordinary diligence, training, and skill when accepting a case?
Extraordinary diligence, training, and skill ordinarily possessed by physicians practicing in the same field
Under Garcia-Rueda vs. Pascasio, what degree of skill and care does a physician impliedly represent possessing?
Employ at least the same level of care that any reasonably competent physician would use under identical circumstances
What legal duty does a physician assume regarding standard of care upon accepting a patient?
Expert testimony
According to Garcia-Rueda vs. Pascasio, what is indispensable to establish the standard of care and causation in medical malpractice actions?
Onus probandi
What legal term refers to the burden of proof in medical malpractice actions?
Reyes vs. Sisters of Mercy Hospital
Which Supreme Court case reaffirmed that the existence of a physician-patient relationship is the threshold requisite creating the duty of care?
Actionable medical malpractice
What legal claim arises strictly from a breach of the physician's duty of care?
Expert scientific testimony
Under Reyes vs. Sisters of Mercy Hospital, how must a breach of the reasonable standard of care and causation generally be established?
Enriquez vs. Sun Life Assurance Co.
Which foundational Supreme Court case applied the Doctrine of Cognition governing civil contracts in the Philippines?
Doctrine of Cognition
Which doctrine dictates that acceptance must come to the knowledge of the offeror while living for a contract to be perfected?
Death of Mr. Herrer one day prior to the arrival and reading of the notice of acceptance
In Enriquez vs. Sun Life Assurance Co., what event prevented the perfection of the life annuity contract?
Full refund of the P6,000 paid
What remedy was granted to the legal heirs in Enriquez vs. Sun Life Assurance Co. because no contract was perfected prior to death?
Acceptance must come to the knowledge of the patient during life
What principle regarding contractual creation does Enriquez vs. Sun Life Assurance Co. illustrate for medical jurisprudence?
Physician
Who is defined as the licensed health professional who agrees to render medical services in exchange for consideration or out of pure beneficence?
Gratis et amore
What Latin phrase describes medical services rendered out of pure beneficence or love?
Patient
Who is defined as the individual who solicits, receives, and benefits from medical care and assumes the primary legal obligation to pay fees?
Spouse
Who holds the highest legal priority among authorized representatives to grant consent for an incapacitated patient?
Children of legal age
Who holds the second legal priority among authorized representatives to grant consent for an incapacitated patient?
Parents
Who holds the third legal priority among authorized representatives to grant consent for an incapacitated patient?
Court-appointed Legal Guardians
Who holds the fourth legal priority among authorized representatives to grant consent for an incapacitated patient?
Hospital Administrators, Medical Directors, or Chiefs of Clinics
Who is authorized to intervene or consult when immediate family members or legal guardians are unavailable during emergency clinical scenarios?
Article 1318 of the New Civil Code
Which article enumerates the three essential requisites of a valid contract?
Consent, Object or Subject Matter, and Cause or Consideration
What are the three essential requisites of a contract under Article 1318 of the New Civil Code?
Meeting of the offer and the acceptance
How is consent legally defined under contract law?
Intelligently, freely, spontaneously, and real
What four qualities must characterize consent for it to be legally valid?
Republic Act No. 6809
Which law amended Article 234 of the Family Code to lower the age of majority?
18 years
Under RA 6809, at what age is full legal capacity attained through the age of majority?
Parent or legal guardian
Through whom must unemancipated minors act when entering into binding contracts?
21 years
Under Section 3 of RA 6809 amending Article 236 of the Family Code, up to what age does contracting marriage require parental consent?
Article 2180 of the New Civil Code
Which Civil Code article governs the vicarious civil responsibility of parents and guardians for children and wards below 21 years of age?
Article 1327 of the New Civil Code
Which article disqualifies unemancipated minors, insane persons, and illiterate deaf-mutes from giving valid contractual consent?
Unemancipated minors
Which group of young individuals is disqualified by law from giving valid contractual consent under Article 1327?
Insane or demented persons
Which group of mentally impaired individuals is disqualified from giving valid consent under Article 1327?
Deaf-mutes who do not know how to read and write
Which specific group of deaf-mutes is disqualified from giving contractual consent under Article 1327?
They retain full legal capacity to contract
What is the legal capacity status of deaf-mutes who are literate under Article 1327?
Article 1328 of the New Civil Code
Which Civil Code article specifies that contracts entered into by insane or demented persons during a lucid interval are valid?
Valid
What is the legal status of a contract entered into by an insane person during a lucid interval under Article 1328?
Obtaining concurrent written consent from a court-appointed guardian or immediate family member
What risk-mitigation standard should physicians observe when treating a patient during a lucid interval?
Article 1330 of the New Civil Code
Which article governs vices of consent that render a contract voidable?
Mistake, violence, intimidation, undue influence, or fraud
What are the five vices of consent enumerated in Article 1330?
Voidable
What is the legal status of a contract where consent was obtained through mistake, violence, intimidation, undue influence, or fraud?
Informed consent
What serves as the legal gold standard of consent in medical jurisprudence?
Unauthorized medical intervention, battery, and actionable malpractice
To what legal claims does operating without valid informed consent expose a physician?
Medical service
What is the specific object or subject matter of a physician-patient contract?
Lawful (licit) and strictly within the commerce of man
What two legal criteria must the object of a physician-patient contract satisfy?
Cadaver
Which post-mortem biological entity cannot be the object of a physician-patient contract because it is no longer a legal person?
Guarantee a cure or specific outcome
What promise regarding biological outcomes can a physician never contractually make?
Article 1322 of the New Civil Code
Which Civil Code article categorizes the cause or consideration of obligations?
Onerous, Remuneratory, and Gratuitous
What are the three legal forms of cause or consideration under Philippine civil law?
Onerous
Which form of cause imposes an obligation on the patient to pay for medical services rendered?
Payment in kind
What customary non-monetary form of payment (such as farm produce or livestock) is recognized as valid onerous consideration?
Remuneratory
Which form of cause represents compensation to the physician for professional skill and labor expended?
Gratuitous (Gratis et Amore)
Which form of cause involves services rendered out of pure beneficence, love, affection, professional courtesy, consanguinity, or affinity?
Professional courtesy
What principle governs rendering gratuitous medical services to colleague physicians or their immediate families?
It does not exempt the physician from legal duty, standard of care, or civil liability for negligence
What is the effect of the total absence of a professional fee on a physician's legal liability?
Existence of the consensual contractual relationship itself
What is the sole primordial basis for legal duty and malpractice liability in medical practice?
Exact same standard of extraordinary care required for high-paying private patients
What standard of care is required when treating patients in charity wards or free medical outreach missions?
Express contract
Which form of contract is created through explicit, direct written or oral statements manifesting mutual agreement?
Implied contract
Which form of contract is formed entirely by conduct, actions, or clinical circumstances without written or spoken words?
Signing an explicit written surgical agreement prior to an elective procedure
What is a practical clinical example of an express medical contract?
Sitting on an examination table and silently yielding to physical palpation
What is a practical clinical example of an implied medical contract?
Article 1306 of the New Civil Code
Which Civil Code article establishes that contracting parties may establish stipulations provided they are not contrary to law, morals, good customs, public order, or public policy?
Void ab initio
What is the legal status of contractual stipulations between a physician and patient that violate public policy boundaries?
Law, Morals, Good Customs, Public Order, and Public Policy
What are the five statutory boundaries limiting the freedom to contract under Article 1306?
Article 259 of the Revised Penal Code
Which law penalizes physicians or midwives who use scientific knowledge or skill to cause or assist in an abortion?
Prision mayor and prision correccional in their maximum periods
What penalty is imposed on a physician who performs an illegal abortion under Article 259 RPC?
Arresto mayor and a fine not exceeding 1,000 pesos
What penalty is imposed on a pharmacist who dispenses an abortive without a prescription under Article 259 RPC?
Morals
Which statutory boundary invalidates a contract agreeing to perform euthanasia or mercy killing?
Article 253 of the Revised Penal Code
Which penal provision governs Giving Assistance to Suicide?
Prision mayor
What is the penalty under Article 253 RPC for assisting another to commit suicide?
Reclusion temporal
What is the penalty under Article 253 RPC if the physician lends assistance to the extent of directly executing the killing?
Arresto mayor in its medium and maximum periods
What is the penalty under Article 253 RPC if the assisted suicide is not consummated?
Good customs
Which boundary makes a contract executed by a mother for female genital mutilation on her daughter void?
Accepted localized cultural custom
How is elective male circumcision categorized under Philippine customs?
Public order
Which boundary invalidates an agreement where an HIV-positive patient contracts to donate blood for a commercial blood bank?
Public policy
Which statutory boundary invalidates a contract to commercially purchase a kidney from a living donor in financial distress?
Organ Donation Act
Which statute permits altruistic organ transplantation but prohibits commercial organ trading?
When the patient requests service, the physician agrees, and acceptance comes to the patient's cognition
Under the Doctrine of Cognition, when does the physician-patient relationship commence?
Marks the inception of legal duty of care, adherence to professional standards, and prospective civil liability
What is the legal significance of determining the exact instant of contract commencement?
Legally perfects a physician-patient contractual relationship
What is the legal impact of a doctor giving specific diagnostic and therapeutic advice at a private dinner party to a guest who relies on it?
It does not insulate the physician from civil malpractice liability
How does the gratuitous nature of informal advice at a social gathering affect a physician's civil liability?
Creates a binding relationship at the moment medical advice is communicated and understood over the wire
What is the legal impact of answering an unsolicited telephone call from a non-patient of record and prescribing Mefenamic acid and dressing changes?
No
Is formally opening a physical chart or collecting a fee required for legal duty to attach during a telephone consultation?
Render competent medical care
What is a contract for medical services legally defined as, rather than a contract guaranteeing outcomes?
Solis (1988)
Which medical jurisprudence authority outlines the terms excluded from a medical contract and non-relationship scenarios?
Guarantee of cure or successful treatment
Which guarantee regarding treatment outcome is excluded from a physician-patient contract?
Guarantee that treatment will benefit the patient
Which guarantee regarding patient benefit is excluded from a physician-patient contract?