1/46
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Greenhouse effect
Greenhouse gases absorb and re-emit infrared radiation, trapping energy within the Earth system
Climate forcing
A change in the Earth’s energy balance, such as the warming effect of increasing atmospheric greenhouse gas concentrations
Climate sensitivity
How much global temperature is expected to rise in response to a sustained increase in atmospheric carbon dioxide
Externality and negative externality
Externality: a cost or benefit of an activity experiences by people who are not fully represented in the transaction
Negative externality: a cost imposed on others, such as climate change damage caused by greenhouse gas emissions
Carbon pricing
Charging for greenhouse gas emissions through a carbon tax or an emissions-trading system
Distributional effects
The unequal allocation of a policy’s costs and benefits across households, workers, industries, and regions.
Why markets alone may not solve climate change
Social cost = private cost + external cost
They receive revenue from selling electricity, so the company has an incentive to emit more than socially desirable
Climate feedback
A process that amplifies or reduces an initial climate change, positive feedback is a process where it only amplifies an initial change
Climate inertia
The delay between changes in forcing and the full response of the climate system
How can feedbacks amplify warming?
Consider the ice-albedo feedback:
Global temperatures rise.
Snow and ice melt.
The Earth's surface becomes darker.
Darker surfaces absorb more solar energy.
Additional warming promotes further melting.
This is an example of a positive feedback loop.
Tragedy of he commons
When individuals exploit a shared, limited resource for their personal benefit, resulting in resource depletion.
Free riding
Receiving benefits from a collective effort without contributing a proportionate share of its costs
Potential response: rules, enforcement, and coordination
Collective action problem
A situation in which individually rational choices do not produce a collectively desirable result
Common-pool resource
A resource from which it is difficult to exclude users and where one person’s use can reduce what it available to others. The central problem is that actors want to collective benefit of emission reductions but want others to pay for them.
Distributive conflict
Conflict over who bears the costs of climate policy and who receives the benefits, and ultimately who should change their behavior. It matters because climate policy creates winners and losers.
Winning coalition
A set of political and economic actors whose combined support is sufficient to enact and sustain a policy
Industrial policy
Government action designed to shape industrial development, innovation, investment, or production.
Durable climate policy (think of the domino effect) may require building an economic constituency for decarbonization, not merely persuading opponents to accept environmental goals.
Mildenberger critiques the dominance of Hardin's framework in climate politics, why?
The commons framework can imply that everyone contributes to the problem in roughly the same way and that everyone would prefer to cooperate if only coordination were possible.
Experience-based learning
Updating beliefs based on personal observations and experiences
Local climate perception: an individuals interpretation of climate change based on experiences in their own region
Availability heuristic: judging the importance or likelihood of something partly by how easily examples come to mind
How do political identities affect climate attitudes?
Partisan polarization: increasing differences between political parties or their supporters
Political predispositions: existing beliefs, identities, and values that shape how new information is interpreted
Partisan cue: a signal from a political party, leader, or aligned organization that helps people interpret an issue
Issue salience: the importance or priority individuals assign to an issue
Opinion-policy gap: the difference between what people say they believe or support and what governments actually enact
Is weather the same as climate?
Personal experiences may affect concern, but they do not necessarily produce stable or durable changes in beliefs.
Conspiracy thinking and belief
Conspiracy thinking: a general tendency to interpret events as the products of hidden, coordinated plans
Conspiracy belief: acceptance of a particular claim that a covert group is responsible for an event
Epistemic trust: the degree to which a person trusts particular sources or institutions as producers of knowledge
Climate science relies on complex evidence, scientific institutions, and expert consensus. People who distrust these institutions may be more receptive to claims that climate science is fabricated, exaggerated, or politically manipulated.
Conditional effect
An effect whose magnitude or direction depends on another variable or context
What are psychological processes that obstruct bipartisan support for climate policy?
Social identity: the part of an individuals self-concept derived from group membership
Identity-protective cognition: processing information in ways that protect one’s social identity and group commitments
Bipartisan support: support that extends across major political parties
Partisan polarization: increasing political division in attitudes, identities, or behavior
Psychological reactance: resistance to a perceived attempt to control one’s beliefs or choices
Superordinate identity: a broader shared identity that can create common ground across narrower group divisions
Feedback loop when climate policy associated strongly with one party
People identify the policy with that party.
Supporting the policy may appear to signal allegiance to an opposing group.
Individuals may resist the policy partly to maintain their own group identity.
Policy disagreement becomes socially and emotionally charged.
Compromise becomes harder, even when individuals share some underlying concerns.
political elites communicate partisan positions, voters interpret those positions through group identities, and the resulting polarization makes future compromise more difficult.
What do policy outcomes reflect?
Interest groups: an organized group that seeks to influence public policy
Lobbying: attempts to influence policy makers through information, advocacy, relationships, and political pressure
Policy feedback: the way existing policies create opponents, resources, and incentives that shape future politics
How can policy be strengthened or undermined?
Enacting policy: building enough support to pass a measure
Implementing a policy: translating the measure into administrative practice and real changes
Defending a policy: maintaining support against efforts to weaken or repeal it
Expanding a policy: creating the political and economic conditions for further reform
Climate misinformation
False or misleading claims about climate science, its causes, consequences, or policy implications
Manufactured doubt
Strategic efforts to make an established body of evidence appear more uncertain or contested than it is
Disinformation: false or misleading information disseminated deliberately to deceive
Astroturfing
Presenting an organized campaign as if it were spontaneous grassroots public sentiment
Collective efficacy
The belief that a group can achieve a shared objective through coordinated action
Framing and reframing
Framing: emphasizing particular aspects of an issue to shape how people interpret it
Reframing: presenting the same underlying issue through a different interpretive lens
Message effect
A change in attitudes attributable to how information is communicated
Heterogeneous response
Different people responding differently to the same message
Descriptive social norm vs. Injunctive social norm
Descriptive: a belief about what other people actually do or believe
Injunctive: a belief about what other people approve or disapprove of
A descriptive norm can be inaccurate. People may underestimate public concern about climate change or overestimate how many others reject mitigation.
Norm perception
An individual’s understanding of the prevalence or acceptability of a behavior
Social proof
Using the behavior of others as evidence about what action is appropriate or sensible
Descriptive norms vs. elite cues
Social information: Do other people support this policy? Are people around me adopting cleaner technologies?
Political information: Do leaders or political figures I trust endorse the policy?
Social norm vs. Dynamic norm
Social norm: a shared expectation concerning how people behave or should behave
Social diffusion: the spread of a behavior, idea, or innovation through a population
Dynamic norm: information that a behavior is becoming more or less common over time
Pluralistic ignorance
A situation in which individuals privately disagree with a perceived norm but believe others support it
Default option
The outcome that occurs when a person does not actively select an alternative
Green default
An environmentally preferable option that is automatically selected unless a consumer opts out
Solves inertia in consumer choices
Nudge
A change in choice architecture that predictably influences behavior while preserving meaningful freedom to choose
An intervention that influences choices without eliminating meaningful freedom of choice
Components or randomized control trials
Meta-analysis: a statistical method for synthesizing results across multiple studies. Meta-analysis provides stronger overall evidence than relying on one experiment
Treatment group: participants who receive the intervention being tested
Control group: participants who do not receive the intervention or receive a comparison condition
Effect size: the standardized or otherwise quantifies measure of the magnitude of an interventions effect
Behavioral determinant and intervention
Determinant: a factor influencing whether an individual adopts or maintains a behavior
Intervention: a targeted attempt to change a decision or action
Effectiveness: the degree to which an intervention achieves its outcome
Limited household action is an example of targeted behavioral interventions
Moral licensing and self licensing
Moral licensing: a psychological process through which a prior morally positive action can make a person feel licensed to perform subsequent less desirable action
Self-licensing: using previous good behavior as a reason to feel less constrained in a later decision
Moral self-image: a person’s perception of themselves as a morally good person
Behavioral, positive, and negative spillovers
Behavioral spillover: the effect of one action on subsequent behavior
Positive spillover: one environmentally friendly action encourages additional environmentally friendly behavior
Negative spillover: one environmentally friendly action is followd by less environmentally friendly behavior
Potential response: evaluate subsequent behavior, not just initial actions