1/24
Looks like no tags are added yet.
UCC: three causes of action
express warranty
implied warranty of merchantability
implied warranty of fitness for particular purpose
express warranty
this is printed, written, or verbal
elements:
affirmation of fact made, and is not a puff (an opinion)
the more specific, the better distinguished from opinion/puff, unless there’s an expert (then the more likely there will be an affirmation of fact vs. “best” or “guaranteed”)
basis of the bargain
reliance (the person to whom the statement was made relied on it); reliance is NOT third parties, there is no basis of the bargain
express warranty: who can be the defendant?
seller
retailer
manufacturer
can also be a garage salesperson
or service provider (like a dentist)
Implied warranty of fitness for particular purpose
elements:
seller knows or has reason to know of the buyer’s particular purpose/for wanting the good
buyer usually communicates to the seller or does something for the seller to know (likely a quote shows this)
and the buyer relies on the seller’s skill or judgment when buying it
can be the salesperson/don’t need the merchant itself/can be the garage salesperson
implied warranty of merchantability
elements:
sale of good: only question is if there’s a sale of goods
gifts/free stuff are not applicable here
there is a merchant: someone who regularly deals with goods of those kind
would not be a garage salesperson or service provider here
then merchantable: fit for ordinary purposes
it has to be safe and do what it’s supposed to; if party is injured by the product then not fit for ordinary purposes
IWM: Who can be the plaintiff?
The UCC provides three alternatives. This can favor the plaintiffs to protect people or reinforce the distribution of goods, and expands to other people who may be affected/injured by the product.
alternative A: most narrow
alternative B: broad
alternative C; most broad
IWM: Who can be the plaintiff?: Alternative A
Alternative A: most narrow
it’s any person, purchaser included
family members or household member that live with the purchaser
or house guest in the house where it’s reasonable to expect they would use the product or be affected by the goods
NOTE: must be personally injured somehow, not just property
IWM: Who can be the plaintiff?: Alternative B
Alternative B: broad
all foreseeable users or those reasonably affected by the product
NOTE: must be personally injured somehow, not just property
IWM: Who can be the plaintiff?: Alternative C
Alternative C: most broad
any foreseeable users or consumers of the good
that sustain personal injury or property damages
NOTE: ok if only property damage, and can also recover for personal injury in addition here
IWM: who can be the defendant?
anyone in the chain of distribution: whoever is selling it
manufacturer—> wholesaler—>retailer
IWM: Defenses
disclaimers on the products
“As is”: buying the product as is/no warranties attached or no implied warranties given are enough
excludes merchantability
Torts: two causes of action
negligence
strict liability
strict liability
the court only looks to the product and its defect
elements:
seller: someone engaged in the business of selling that product
places into stream of commerce: broader than a sale of goods (covers more than the same of goods, such as a rental or perfume spray)
defective good: manufacturing defect, design defect, or warning defect
that causes harm
strict liability: manufacturing defect
one unit of the products is defective
strict liability: design defect
definition: all the products were designed that way
tests:
consumer expectations test: a reasonable consumer would not expect the good to do whatever bad thing it did
risk utility test: balancing test
risk/likelihood of harm
societal benefit
extent of harm
cost
SL: who can be a plaintiff?
foreseeable people
SL: who can be a defendant?
anyone in the distribution chain
SL: defenses
assumption of risk
plaintiff knows of the specific risk
AND disregards it (then barred for recovery)
product misuse:
product is designed for one purpose
but is not used for intended purpose
torts: negligence
duty
breach
causation
damages
negligence: duty
manufacturer: duty to prevent foreseeable harms in design, manufacturing, and inspection and warning of product
wholesaler: duty to prevent foreseeable harm in inspection of the product
retailer: duty to prevent foreseeable harm in inspection of the prodcut
negligence: breach
Standard of care: industry custom
use facts from fact patter of how defendant fell below industry standards
ex: “most of them do this” or “a lot of them do this”
negligence: who is the plaintiff?
foreseeable plaintiffs
negligence: causation/damages
not as concerned with this—use the facts
negligence: defenses
assumption of risk
P knew of the risk
and disregards it
comparative negligence (ONLY negligence)
P also acts negligently in causing damage
negligence: food (all causes of action apply here)
foreign: this cannot be anticipated by a reasonable consumer
natural: expected by a reasonable consumer and the consumer will be able to reasonably guard against the object